登陆注册
4282200000020

第20章

But towards poetry in the narrower sense, that which employs the language of words, he entertained no favour. Words, he thought, were perverted from their proper office when they were employed in uttering anything but precise logical truth. He says, somewhere in his works, that, 'quantity of pleasure being equal, push-pin is as good as poetry' -- but this is only a paradoxical way of stating what he would equally have said of the things which he most valued and admired. Another aphorism is attributed to him, which is much more characteristic of his view of this subject: 'All poetry is misrepresentation'. Poetry, he thought, consisted essentially in exaggeration for effect: in proclaiming some one view of a thing very emphatically, and suppressing all the limitations and qualifications. This trait of character seems to us a curious example of what Mr Carlyle strikingly calls 'the completeness of limited men'. Here is a philosopher who is happy within his narrow boundary as no man of indefinite range ever was: who flatters himself that he is so completely emancipated from the essential law of poor human intellect, by which it can only see one thing at a time well, that he can even turn round upon the imperfection and lay a solemn interdict upon it. Did Bentham really suppose that it is in poetry only that propositions cannot be exactly true, cannot contain in themselves all the limitations and qualifications with which they require to be taken when applied to practice? We have seen how far his own prose propositions are from realizing this Utopia: and even the attempt to approach it would be incompatible not with poetry merely, but with oratory, and popular writing of every kind.

Bentham's charge is true to the fullest extent; all writing which undertakes to make men feel truths as well as see them, does take up one point at a time, does seek to impress that, to drive that home, to make it sink into and colour the whole mind of the reader or hearer. It is justified in doing so, if the portion of truth which it thus enforces be that which is called for by the occasion. All writing addressed to the feelings has a natural tendency to exaggeration; but Bentham should have remembered that in this, as in many things, we must aim at too much, to be assured of doing enough.

From the same principle in Bentham came the intricate and involved style, which makes his later writings books for the student only, not the general reader. It was from his perpetually aiming at impracticable precision. Nearly all his earlier and many parts of his later writings, are models, as we have already observed, of light, playful and popular style: a Benthamiana might be made of passages worthy of Addison or Goldsmith. But in his later years and more advanced studies, he fell into a Latin or German structure of sentence, foreign to the genius of the English language. He could not bear, for the sake of clearness and the reader's ease, to say, as ordinary men are content to do, a little more than the truth in one sentence, and correct it in the next. The whole of the qualifying remarks which he intended to make, he insisted upon imbedding as parentheses in the very middle of the sentence itself. And thus the sense being so long suspended, and attention being required to the accessory ideas before the principal idea had been properly seized, it became difficult, without some practice, to make out the train of thought. It is fortunate that so many of the most important parts of his writings are free from this defect. We regard it as a reductio ad absurdum of his objection to poetry. In trying to write in a manner against which the same objection should not lie, he could stop nowhere short of utter unreadableness, and after all attained no more accuracy than is compatible with opinions as imperfect and one-sided as those of any poet or sentimentalist breathing. Judge then in what state literature and philosophy would be, and what chance they would have of influencing the multitude, if his objection were allowed, and all styles of writing banished which would not stand his test.

We must here close this brief and imperfect view of Bentham and his doctrines; in which many parts of the subject have been entirely untouched, and no part done justice to, but which at least proceeds from an intimate familiarity with his writings, and is nearly the first attempt at an impartial estimate of his character as a philosopher, and of the result of his labours to the world.

After every abatement, and it has been seen whether we have made our abatements sparingly -- there remains to Bentham an indisputable place among the great intellectual benefactors of mankind. His writings will long form an indispensable part of the education of the highest order of practical thinkers; and the collected edition of them ought to be in the hands of everyone who would either understand his age, or take any beneficial part in the great business of it.

NOTE:

1. See the 'Principles of Civil Law' contained in Part II of his collected works.

the End

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 五灯严统

    五灯严统

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 医方论

    医方论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 美国:从殖民地到惟一超级大国

    美国:从殖民地到惟一超级大国

    本书探讨了美国如何在两百多年中获得迅速发展,成为世界头号经济、军事强国的原因。
  • 最强军医

    最强军医

    新书《我老婆一夜成名》已在起点发布。 它很短,但会旋转。入得浅,却能泛滥!它是最强军医的手术刀,刀转一寸救红颜!刀旋一寸……杀人泛滥!鼻子一闻,能闻出病情轻重;伸手一摸,便能消炎止痛;一把上古医刀,能起死回生,也能断人性命!他是上古医术的唯一继承者,也是兵王谱里排名第一的巅峰兵王。带着娶妻的重任,重返都市江湖。娇妻似水,江湖如梦,一场腥风血雨,已悄然拉开序幕……铁血枭雄出我辈,深入江湖岁月催。血影刀光谈笑间,匹马西风人憔悴。血染一生终不悔,红尘逍遥我独醉。深入江湖生死非,只为一人笑一回!
  • 求知与奋进(漫漫求知路)

    求知与奋进(漫漫求知路)

    从我国古代“天人合一”的思想传统到当代世界倡导的“环境保护”和“可持续发展”,无不指明了学会与自然“共处”的重要性。这种学习,像其他学习一样,也包括了知识、技能和态度、价值观念的习和和养成。知识经济的时代,人人需要终身学习。学什么?怎么学?学会求知、学会做事、学会共处、学会做人。从本质上来说,成人一生的发展模式和对待新事物与旧事物的兴趣模式都与三个月的孩子几乎相同。本选题献给想把孩子培养成才的父母们,献给看不懂孩子为什么越来越不按成人的想法生活和学习的父母们,献给不想让孩子变成冤家的父母们,本丛书是帮助父母从本质上认识自己的孩子,了解孩子成长规律,把握系统爱育方法的通俗读物。
  • 闪婚总裁别太坏

    闪婚总裁别太坏

    他,多金,霸道,行事阴狠,又极爱面子,在他眼中没有用钱解决不了的事情,如果有,那就是钱还不够多。她,性格独立大方,又要强精干,知世故而不世故,可是却被赌棍父亲连累,走投无路下只得向他低头。他在鄙视她的同时,却不由自主深陷爱情的漩涡。
  • 思考的力量

    思考的力量

    人和人本质的区别是思考的区别。面对同样的事物,不同的人的思考大相径庭,从而导致他们的行动和结果也千差万别。乔布斯预料到了个人电脑的繁盛前景,从而创立了苹果公司;马云判断电子商务将成为不可阻挡的趋势,从而创立了阿里巴巴;马斯克预见了电动汽车的趋势,从而投资了特斯拉公司……
  • 读史剩言

    读史剩言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 冒牌太子妃

    冒牌太子妃

    人生三大悲剧是:久旱遇甘霖——一滴。他乡遇故知——债主。洞房花烛夜——麻婆。而越清河人生三大悲剧是:穿越得公主——冒牌。先嫁得丞相——死了。再嫁得太子——是gay?!她真的不想嫁人啊!无奈某正牌公主以美男美食并身家性命威逼利诱.尊严诚可贵,零食价更高,若为小命故,两者皆可拋!为了保住小命,越清河咬牙披嫁衣!晋太子!你的冒牌太子妃来也!【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 谁家天下

    谁家天下

    如今这年代,灵魂转世都不叫投胎了,那叫穿越时空!这可是现在最时髦的事了,谁都巴望着能穿上那么一回,好好过把瘾!可是,这穿一次是赶时髦,穿两次可就是活受罪了。她就是这样一个不幸地穿了又穿的倒楣孩子,回回等到她以为从此以后就可以过上幸福的生活的时候,就会被逼无奈地穿那么一回!唉!这样的日子什么时候才算是个头啊?咦?!这次不是说会让她转生到太平盛世过安稳日子吗?这该死的六殿阎君怎么一脚把她踹到了隋朝?!老天爷啊!在这乱世之中,这日子可让她怎么过啊?