登陆注册
4704900000014

第14章

'The use of names, Socrates, is to inform, and he who knows names knows things.' Do you mean that the discovery of names is the same as the discovery of things? 'Yes.' But do you not see that there is a degree of deception about names? He who first gave names, gave them according to his conception, and that may have been erroneous. 'But then, why, Socrates, is language so consistent? all words have the same laws.' Mere consistency is no test of truth. In geometrical problems, for example, there may be a flaw at the beginning, and yet the conclusion may follow consistently.

And, therefore, a wise man will take especial care of first principles.

But are words really consistent; are there not as many terms of praise which signify rest as which signify motion? There is episteme, which is connected with stasis, as mneme is with meno. Bebaion, again, is the expression of station and position; istoria is clearly descriptive of the stopping istanai of the stream; piston indicates the cessation of motion; and there are many words having a bad sense, which are connected with ideas of motion, such as sumphora, amartia, etc.: amathia, again, might be explained, as e ama theo iontos poreia, and akolasia as e akolouthia tois pragmasin. Thus the bad names are framed on the same principle as the good, and other examples might be given, which would favour a theory of rest rather than of motion. 'Yes; but the greater number of words express motion.' Are we to count them, Cratylus; and is correctness of names to be determined by the voice of a majority?

Here is another point: we were saying that the legislator gives names; and therefore we must suppose that he knows the things which he names: but how can he have learnt things from names before there were any names? 'I believe, Socrates, that some power more than human first gave things their names, and that these were necessarily true names.' Then how came the giver of names to contradict himself, and to make some names expressive of rest, and others of motion? 'I do not suppose that he did make them both.'

Then which did he make--those which are expressive of rest, or those which are expressive of motion?...But if some names are true and others false, we can only decide between them, not by counting words, but by appealing to things. And, if so, we must allow that things may be known without names; for names, as we have several times admitted, are the images of things; and the higher knowledge is of things, and is not to be derived from names; and though I do not doubt that the inventors of language gave names, under the idea that all things are in a state of motion and flux, I believe that they were mistaken; and that having fallen into a whirlpool themselves, they are trying to drag us after them. For is there not a true beauty and a true good, which is always beautiful and always good? Can the thing beauty be vanishing away from us while the words are yet in our mouths? And they could not be known by any one if they are always passing away--for if they are always passing away, the observer has no opportunity of observing their state. Whether the doctrine of the flux or of the eternal nature be the truer, is hard to determine. But no man of sense will put himself, or the education of his mind, in the power of names: he will not condemn himself to be an unreal thing, nor will he believe that everything is in a flux like the water in a leaky vessel, or that the world is a man who has a running at the nose. This doctrine may be true, Cratylus, but is also very likely to be untrue; and therefore I would have you reflect while you are young, and find out the truth, and when you know come and tell me. 'I have thought, Socrates, and after a good deal of thinking I incline to Heracleitus.' Then another day, my friend, you shall give me a lesson.

'Very good, Socrates, and I hope that you will continue to study these things yourself.'

We may now consider (I) how far Plato in the Cratylus has discovered the true principles of language, and then (II) proceed to compare modern speculations respecting the origin and nature of language with the anticipations of his genius.

同类推荐
  • 正源略集

    正源略集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 张庄僖文集

    张庄僖文集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 药师仪轨一具

    药师仪轨一具

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 兰室秘藏

    兰室秘藏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 渚山堂词话

    渚山堂词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 二潇的撞鬼日常

    二潇的撞鬼日常

    只听说打怪能升级,就没听说过捉鬼也能升级的,而且偶尔还会掉点装备顾萧潇也是醉了,她虽然从小就喜欢听灵异故事,但也是一位好龙的叶公而已。看着房间里四处飘荡的鬼魂,还有那不同品种的妖怪,顾萧潇觉得心好累,虽然看着很热闹,但她是真的不想住在鬼屋之中啊,另外,那个被男人头所装点着的吊灯,怎么看都有些让人渗的慌。顾萧潇从来不信这个世界有鬼怪,也从来没想过能谈场惊天地泣鬼神的爱情,可是当他出现时……一切似乎都变得不那么一样了。季白,他并不是一个谁都能享用的男人,仅仅22岁的顾萧潇还没有学会如何去对待这样一个男人。
  • 正道大妖

    正道大妖

    弱小却从来不懂得认输,绝望却从来不选择放弃。烟花的绽放只是瞬间的夺目,夕阳的陶醉却不知黑夜即将来临。旭日的东升,就像那只新生的大妖,正朝着苍穹发出攻击的咆哮。
  • 别为小事生气

    别为小事生气

    “海纳百川,有容乃大;壁立千仞,无欲则刚。”尊重别人是一种美德,“敬人者,人恒敬之”,尊重别人,自然会获得别人的好感和尊重。宽容是一种高尚的人格修养,一种“宰相胸襟”,一种大将风度。一点宽容会让别人感动一生,一点爱意会让别人温暖一生,一句祝福与鼓励的话语会让别人幸福一生。关照别人就是关照自己;伤害别人就是伤害自己;宽容别人就是宽容自己。以理智和豁达去化解矛盾,我们才能赢得别人的尊敬和理解。做一个心胸开阔的人,我们将赢得美好的人生。
  • 萌宠待养成

    萌宠待养成

    这是一个萌宠的世界,修士只有与萌宠签约才能变得更加强大!萌宠大陆,自天地异象,产生无数变故,全面复苏之后,萌宠也能异变,或者进化、返祖、血脉觉醒等。这是一个关于签约萌宠,召唤萌宠的故事!
  • 恋爱不加糖

    恋爱不加糖

    慕夏首度尝试,搞怪校园爱情精彩上演,《恋爱不加糖》全新演绎最无厘头的爱情故事!有些爱情注定要相遇、要争吵、要相爱。有些缘分注定不可改变。有一种爱情叫做——冤家路窄,弄巧成拙。每个人身边,都有一些看似微小实则伟大的爱情,你看见了吗?周嘉妮是校园中一个有点迷糊有点可爱的普通女学生。而李暮是校园中出了名的问题男生,照理说毫无关系的两个人,却因为误打误撞结怨。校园里的童话正在上演,高傲王子和温柔骑士的较量过后,谁才能赢回迷糊公主的心?
  • 逆天狂妃:王爷,来一战!

    逆天狂妃:王爷,来一战!

    她,是现代顶尖杀手,却遭人怨恨,最终含恨而死,一朝穿越,便要潇洒活一世。什么?废柴!遥身一变,极品丹药一抓一大把,各种神兽争相签订契约,各路美男争相求嫁。 但是却被冰山王爷宠成了小绵羊,这怎么行! “王爷,来一战!” “好,夫人莫非欲-求不满?没关系,为夫这就履行责任。” 【虽然前两本书可能玛丽苏,但是我保证,就算我们玛丽苏,也要苏的不一样!后面的小说绝对题材新颖!】
  • 夫君,你别跑

    夫君,你别跑

    一次地震,让她狗血穿越。行,穿越就穿越吧,换种方式生活也挺好。可是这是什么?这腰上的肉,跳水都不见得能沉下去!这脸,简直比新疆的打馕都大!罢了罢了,颜值不够家世来凑,再不成来个温柔多金的好老公也成。只是,八月秋高风怒号,卷我屋上三重茅,这家底,连小偷都嫌穷。士可杀不可辱,配置再低,也不能丢了穿越女主的脸,上京逃婚吧。“秦小姐,天生聪颖与本,天生聪颖与本王着实不配,倒是这个小丫头深得我心。”后来,京城红的发紫的四王爷当众告白,随手丢给她一个天大的馅饼。
  • 大串联

    大串联

    假如没有那次大串联,我现在可能也跟很多人一样,娶妻生子,买房置地,赶上黄金周什么的还去什么地方旅旅游。老了,就打打太极拳,跳跳交际舞,或开车到水库钓钓鱼。恰恰是我十七岁的那次出行,叫我知道了人的内心深处蕴含着那么多深不可测的黑暗层面,几乎想都想不到……这一发现,居然影响了我的一生。
  • 放弃是一种拥有

    放弃是一种拥有

    在生活中,当你于突然之间失去了一些以为可以长久依靠的东西时,痛苦和伤心是难免的。但只要你换一种思维方式,从另外一个角度去看问题,就会发现,在失去的同时,你也能获得许多。虽然,在刚失去的那段日子里,你肯定会有失落感、会有迷茫,但你一定要相信,经过挫折磨难的洗礼之后,你一定能脱胎换骨,找回全新的、受人喜爱的自我。当下,“得”是很多人奋斗不止的目的,但有些东西却是我们应该学会放弃的。比如功名、利禄……
  • 实战宇宙

    实战宇宙

    新的时代来临,宣告着旧时代的结束,诸多网络游戏也面临淘汰的危机。皇宇科技创造出一款新型实战游戏,其名宇宙战纪。真实的冒险,异次元空间,游戏世界的大门开启,无数玩家纷纷前去冒险。一面之缘定羁绊,少年亚乐,少女彩悦也踏上他们的旅程,虽各有目的,但只为通关。原名《宇宙战纪》