登陆注册
4705400000419

第419章

The greater part of the two volumes before us is merely an amplification of these paragraphs. What does Mr. Southey mean by saying that religion is demonstrably the basis of civil government? He cannot surely mean that men have no motives except those derived from religion for establishing and supporting civil government, that no temporal advantage is derived from civil government, that men would experience no temporal inconvenience from living in a state of anarchy? If he allows, as we think he must allow, that it is for the good of mankind in this world to have civil government, and that the great majority of mankind have always thought it for their good in this world to have civil government, we then have a basis for government quite distinct from religion. It is true that the Christian religion sanctions government, as it sanctions everything which promotes the happiness and virtue of our species. But we are at a loss to conceive in what sense religion can be said to be the basis of government, in which religion is not also the basis of the practices of eating, drinking, and lighting fires in cold weather. Nothing in history is more certain than that government has existed, has received some obedience, and has given some protection, in times in which it derived no support from religion, in times in which there was no religion that influenced the hearts and lives of men. It was not from dread of Tartarus, or from belief in the Elysian fields, that an Athenian wished to have some institutions which might keep Orestes from filching his cloak, or Midias from breaking his head. "It is from religion," says Mr. Southey, "that power derives its authority, and laws their efficacy." From what religion does our power over the Hindoos derive its authority, or the law in virtue of which we hang Brahmins its efficacy? For thousands of years civil government has existed in almost every corner of the world, in ages of priestcraft, in ages of fanaticism, in ages of Epicurean indifference, in ages of enlightened piety. However pure or impure the faith of the people might be, whether they adored a beneficent or a malignant power, whether they thought the soul mortal or immortal, they have, as soon as they ceased to be absolute savages, found out their need of civil government, and instituted it accordingly. It is as universal as the practice of cookery. Yet, it is as certain, says Mr. Southey, as anything in abstract science, that government is founded on religion. We should like to know what notion Mr. Southey has of the demonstrations of abstract science. A very vague one, we suspect.

The proof proceeds. As religion is the basis of government, and as the State is secure in proportion as the people are attached to public institutions, it is therefore, says Mr. Southey, the first rule of policy, that the government should train the people in the way in which they should go; and it is plain that those who train them in any other way are undermining the State.

Now it does not appear to us to be the first object that people should always believe in the established religion and be attached to the established government. A religion may be false. A government may be oppressive. And whatever support government gives to false religions, or religion to oppressive governments, we consider as a clear evil.

The maxim, that governments ought to train the people in the way in which they should go, sounds well. But is there any reason for believing that a government is more likely to lead the people in the right way than the people to fall into the right way of themselves? Have there not been governments which were blind leaders of the blind? Are there not still such governments? Can it be laid down as a general rule that the movement of political and religious truth is rather downwards from the government to the people than upwards from the people to the government? These are questions which it is of importance to have clearly resolved.

Mr. Southey declaims against public opinion, which is now, he tells us, usurping supreme power. Formerly, according to him, the laws governed; now public opinion governs. What are laws but expressions of the opinion of some class which has power over the rest of the community? By what was the world ever governed but by the opinion of some person or persons? By what else can it ever be governed? What are all systems, religious, political, or scientific, but opinions resting on evidence more or less satisfactory? The question is not between human opinion and some higher and more certain mode of arriving at truth, but between opinion and opinion, between the opinions of one man and another, or of one class and another, or of one generation and another.

Public opinion is not infallible; but can Mr. Southey construct any institutions which shall secure to us the guidance of an infallible opinion? Can Mr. Southey select any family, any profession, any class, in short, distinguished by any plain badge from the rest of the community, whose opinion is more likely to be just than this much abused public opinion? Would he choose the peers, for example? Or the two hundred tallest men in the country? Or the poor Knights of Windsor? Or children who are born with cauls? Or the seventh sons of seventh sons?

We cannot suppose that he would recommend popular election; for that is merely an appeal to public opinion. And to say that society ought to be governed by the opinion of the wisest and best, though true, is useless. Whose opinion is to decide who are the wisest and best?

同类推荐
  • 尸穸

    尸穸

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上混元真录

    太上混元真录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Formation of Vegetable Mould

    The Formation of Vegetable Mould

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 云南志蛮书

    云南志蛮书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说无希望经

    佛说无希望经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 最让你释放情感的心灵故事(智慧背囊16本)

    最让你释放情感的心灵故事(智慧背囊16本)

    俄国诗人普希金说:“假如生活欺骗了你,不要忧郁,也不要愤慨!不顺心的时候暂且容忍。相信吧,快乐的日子就会到来。”生活中,会经历喜怒哀乐各种复杂的情感。如果以积极的心态去面对,雨季会变为晴天;如果以消极的心态去面对,晴天会变为雨季。但是,任何的人,无论雨季或者晴天,心中的情感都需要最真实的释放、解脱。本书汇集了最感人至深的几百个情感故事,以引人共鸣的心灵物语来进行点拨,使广大读者在故事中得到释放、领悟、受益,更加以积极、乐观的心态去面对生活、开创生活。
  • 青春·哲理卷(散文精品)

    青春·哲理卷(散文精品)

    一段爱情的重生是要等待一个人的死亡,同时也可能让死亡毁掉一切。以青春换明天的爱情,从来凄怆。爱是难分彼此——彼此的优点和缺点。我以为这是我的优点,你却说是缺点。你的缺点太多,我却喜欢你,这是我的优点。爱就是难分彼此。理想,在实现以前,有很多名字,它们是:幻想、妄想、白日梦,和不可能。可是,就是它,使得一个只能爬行的看鸭子的小男孩,变成了受众人崇敬的学者与勇者。
  • 月光漫过珍珠夏

    月光漫过珍珠夏

    十六岁的一场游戏,让秦漫月结识了大自己十岁的青年才俊谭展飞,却因她的背叛让他摧毁了她的幸福。十八岁的她结束了噩梦来到另一座城市开始大学生活,富二代公子陆均璨闯入她的生活。正当二人爱情升温之际,从香港经商归来的谭展飞再度出现在她面前,他们互相折磨,互相伤害,却痛苦地相爱。当阴谋,算计,折磨,痛苦席卷而来,这个局到底谁是幕后黑手?陆均璨又为何来到她的身边?小七死亡的真相是什么?他们的爱,是一场惊天动地的报复?还是一场山崩地裂的爱情迷雾……
  • 血色码头

    血色码头

    本书以抗日战争时期的水旱码头--古镇碛口为背景,讲述了当地盛、程两大家族,八路军,晋绥军的10个主要人物的爱恨情仇与可歌可泣的故事。作者以风土人情的笔风描写各位主人公的传奇故事,为读者重现了一个存在于过去的碛口,同时用朴实的带有山西风味的语言,把一个个活生生的碛口人带到读者面前。
  • 茶鸡蛋(外一篇)

    茶鸡蛋(外一篇)

    一个茶鸡蛋值一千块钱?何幺婆简直不敢相信自己的耳朵。但这是蒋婆亲口告诉她的。昨儿上午,何幺婆到车站门口的摆摊点,刚把煤炉子、盛满卤汤的铁锅和茶鸡蛋及那些杂七八拉的零食一五一十地摆出来,就注意到紧挨着她旁边的蒋婆神色有些异样,她像吃多了人参燕窝那样两眼放光、满脸喜色不说,还不时扎下脑袋咯儿咯儿笑几声,像一只吃了隔壁家白食的老母鸡。何幺婆寻思,蒋婆八成碰到什么喜事了,不是她那个在武汉汉正街做生意的幺女儿给她生了个外孙,就是蒋婆自己买的彩票中奖了。
  • 我与幽灵少女

    我与幽灵少女

    有一天,我做了一场梦。梦见我同一个叫千里的女孩相遇,并且走过了一段虽然忙碌但快乐的日子。她彻底,打乱了我的生活。把原本不属于我的快乐塞进了我的世界。这是一段属于御宅青年与一群少女的欢乐欢乐校园探险,这是一段清纯唯美经久难忘的青涩情怀~
  • 等心孤独者

    等心孤独者

    我们之间的距离是时针与秒针转动的距离,既使在同一平面内,心与心的距离也是遥远的地平线,而我是望曾经你的影子的孤独者,再近时针与秒针却只能等心停才能与你重合。
  • 湘村诡事

    湘村诡事

    人留鞋送行,鬼留鞋送终。因为捡到一双乞丐的草鞋,我爷爷半夜吊死在了竹林……
  • 思考世界的100部学术名著(上)(世界历史回眸经典文库)

    思考世界的100部学术名著(上)(世界历史回眸经典文库)

    从古至今,学术论著不知有多少华章,然思考的世界的且影响今日的又有多少呢?本书收集了中外一百篇思考世界的学术论著,百家齐鸣,百花齐放的壮景,让我们可以站在前人的肩膀上瞻望未来的辉煌!
  • 雪中悍刀行12:百年问一剑

    雪中悍刀行12:百年问一剑

    烽火戏诸侯开创奇幻武侠新世界,持续热销,再创高峰!北凉草包世子横空逆袭,一刀将这世俗捅了个透!奇异人物,奇幻场景,颠覆传统,荡气回肠,组成不一样的鲜活历史,不一样的瑰丽江湖!妖刀烽火颠覆传统用鬼斧般的文字创造了一个奇特而神秘的世界。这里有牵瘦马缺门牙见着歹人跑得比主子还快却是传说中的高手的老黄,有整日摇摇晃晃不求道却能一剑开天门,倒骑青牛的年轻道士,有刚出世便跌入武评第八,一声剑响成了陆地神仙敢叫天下第二劈海相送的断臂抠脚的老剑神,还有骑熊猫扛向日葵不太冷的少女杀手……