登陆注册
4705400000445

第445章

But Mr. Gladstone has other arguments against persecution, arguments which are of so much weight, that they are decisive not only against persecution but against his whole theory. "The Government," he says, "is incompetent to exercise minute and constant supervision over religious opinion." And hence he infers, that "a Government exceeds its province when it comes to adapt a scale of punishments to variations in religious opinion, according to their respective degrees of variation from the established creed. To decline affording countenance to sects is a single and simple rule. To punish their professors, according to their several errors, even were there no other objection, is one for which the State must assume functions wholly ecclesiastical, and for which it is not intrinsically fitted."

This is, in our opinion, quite true. But how does it agree with Mr. Gladstone's theory? What! the Government incompetent to exercise even such a degree of supervision over religious opinion as is implied by the punishment of the most deadly heresy! The Government incompetent to measure even the grossest deviations from the standard of truth! The Government not intrinsically qualified to judge of the comparative enormity of any theological errors! The Government so ignorant on these subjects that it is compelled to leave, not merely subtle heresies, discernible only by the eye of a Cyril or a Bucer, but Socinianism, Deism, Mahometanism, Idolatry, Atheism, unpunished! To whom does Mr. Gladstone assign the office of selecting a religion for the State, from among hundreds of religions, every one of which lays claim to truth? Even to this same Government, which is now pronounced to be so unfit for theological investigations that it cannot venture to punish a man for worshipping a lump of stone with a score of heads and hands. We do not remember ever to have fallen in with a more extraordinary instance of inconsistency.

When Mr. Gladstone wishes to prove that the Government ought to establish and endow a religion, and to fence it with a Test Act, Government is _to pan_ in the moral world. Those who would confine it to secular ends take a low view of its nature. A religion must be attached to its agency; and this religion must be that of the conscience of the governor, or none. It is for the Governor to decide between Papists and Protestants, Jansenists and Molinists, Arminians and Calvinists, Episcopalians and Presbyterians, Sabellians and Tritheists, Homoousians and Homoiousians, Nestorians and Eutychians, Monothelites and Monophysites, Paedobaptists and Anabaptists. It is for him to rejudge the Acts of Nice and Rimini, of Ephesus and Chalcedon, of Constantinople and St. John Lateran, of Trent and Dort. It is for him to arbitrate between the Greek and the Latin procession, and to determine whether that mysterious filioque shall or shall not have a place in the national creed. When he has made up his mind, he is to tax the whole community in order to pay people to teach his opinion, what ever it may be. He is to rely on his own judgment, though it may be opposed to that of nine-tenths of the society. He is to act on his own judgment, at the risk of exciting the most formidable discontents. He is to inflict, perhaps on a great majority of the population, what, whether we choose to call it persecution or not, will always be felt as persecution by those who suffer it. He is, on account of differences often too slight for vulgar comprehension, to deprive the State of the services of the ablest men. He is to debase and enfeeble the community which he governs, from a nation into a sect. In our own country, for example, millions of Catholics, millions of Protestant Dissenters, are to be excluded from all power and honours. A great hostile fleet is on the sea; but Nelson is not to command in the Channel if in the mystery of the Trinity he confounds the persons. An invading army has landed in Kent; but the Duke of Wellington is not to be at the head of our forces if he divides the substance. And after all this, Mr. Gladstone tells us, that it would be wrong to imprison a Jew, a Mussulman, or a Buddhist, for a day; because really a Government cannot understand these matters, and ought not to meddle with questions which belong to the Church. A singular theologian, indeed, this Government! So learned, that it is competent to exclude Grotius from office for being a Semi-Pelagian, so unlearned that it is incompetent to fine a Hindoo peasant a rupee for going on a pilgrimage to Juggernaut.

"To solicit and persuade one another," says Mr. Gladstone, "are privileges which belong to us all; and the wiser and better man is bound to advise the less wise and good; but he is not only not bound, he is not allowed, speaking generally, to coerce him. It is untrue, then, that the same considerations which bind a Government to submit a religion to the free choice of the people would therefore justify their enforcing its adoption."

同类推荐
  • 黄箓救苦十念仪

    黄箓救苦十念仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Evolution of Modern Medicine

    The Evolution of Modern Medicine

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说魔逆经

    佛说魔逆经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宋徽宗御解道德真经

    宋徽宗御解道德真经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 吴地记

    吴地记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 我变成了鲲

    我变成了鲲

    这是灵气复苏的故事。噬人的鬼怪,妖魔在昏暗的路灯下悄然来到你的身后,噬人的大口轻易将你吞噬。神话因灵气而复苏,东西方神话争锋,踏碎凌霄的猴王在天国肆掠。太阳神的传承者被后羿传承者一箭爆了菊花。面对这大争之世,李松偶获神鲲传承,走上了一条吞噬升级的道路。吞噬鬼气,领悟神通【幽冥鬼火】
  • 艾泽拉斯之第六位上古之神

    艾泽拉斯之第六位上古之神

    萨拉艾尔:“我的目标只有一个——扭曲这个世界!”【随缘更新了解一下】
  • 时光悠悠与岁月浅浅

    时光悠悠与岁月浅浅

    女:“你从来都是原来那样,未曾明白过我的心意。”男子没有理会,转身要走,而另一位男子拉起女子的手说:“不管过去的你怎么样,从现在开始,你就是我的唯一”
  • 世上最美的感悟

    世上最美的感悟

    父母的爱,如山如川;父母的爱,血浓于水;父母的爱,刻骨铭心;父母爱,净化灵魂;父母陪伴我们走过人生的颠簸之路,父母呵护我们应对人生的喜怒哀愁,从这一刻开始收拾情怀,用心感悟无声无形的爱!
  • 百年北大给青少年的人生哲理

    百年北大给青少年的人生哲理

    走成功之路,读成功之书。胸怀梦想,执著地走向远方;笑对挫折,锻造强者的品质;挖掘潜力,创造丰富的人生;荡涤心扉,用沉静过滤浮躁;热爱真知,用智慧照耀人生;空杯心态,卸掉负担和羁绊;懂得感恩,对世界一往情深;享受生活,呵护纯粹的心灵。
  • 老舍经典

    老舍经典

    本书精选了著名作家老舍的经典篇目50篇,涵盖作者自述、散文以及小说,作为新版部编教材的补充,有利于青少年读者进一步深入理解名家名篇,激发课外阅读的兴趣。老舍的作品多从普通人的视角出发,用亲切的口头语言传达普通人的喜怒哀乐。
  • 急急如律令

    急急如律令

    故事从我在算命瞎子那里拿了五十块钱说起,到了半夜,我身后竟然多了个女人的声音······
  • 法度:依法治国方略

    法度:依法治国方略

    春秋战国是我国历史的上古时期。此时期的诸侯争霸、百家争鸣和各国变法图强,促成了一个前所未有的动荡与变革局面。在这个破旧立新的变革时期,法家思想家管仲、李悝、商鞅等人提出了“依法治国”主张,在实践中积极变法,建立法制,制定法令条例,树立规范,规定法则。通过立法和执法,依法治国,实现了由“刑”到“法”再到“律”的演进,其中包含有法律概念的逐渐清晰以及人们认识水平的发展,对后世封建法律的制定和实施意义深远。
  • 体系的力量:从体系看德国经济的成功

    体系的力量:从体系看德国经济的成功

    中国的政策制定者们正在世界范围内不断寻求可供参考的发展样本。罗兰贝格管理咨询公司认为,德国恰可为中国的下一步发展提供颇具价值的借鉴。
  • 腹黑少的小甜心

    腹黑少的小甜心

    本想借着离家出走逃婚,没有想到却撞到一个腹黑闷骚的男人,被他囚在身边,还霸道宣布让自己做他女人,有没有搞错?当“订婚对象”浮出水面,居然会是那个闷骚男,当她想再次逃走的时候,发现自己居然在他的身边失了心,怎么也逃不出他世界.........