登陆注册
4810700000012

第12章 The Idol of the Bardolaters

There is even an advantage in having a book on Shakespear with the Shakespearian irony left out of account. I do not say that the missing chapter should not be added in the next edition: the hiatus is too great: it leaves the reader too uneasy before this touching picture of a writhing worm substituted for the invulnerable giant. But it is none the less probable that in no other way could Mr Harris have got at his man as he has. For, after all, what is the secret of the hopeless failure of the academic Bardolaters to give us a credible or even interesting Shakespear, and the easy triumph of Mr Harris in giving us both? Simply that Mr Harris has assumed that he was dealing with a man, whilst the others have assumed that they were writing about a god, and have therefore rejected every consideration of fact, tradition, or interpretation, that pointed to any human imperfection in their hero. They thus leave themselves with so little material that they are forced to begin by saying that we know very little about Shakespear. As a matter of fact, with the plays and sonnets in our hands, we know much more about Shakespear than we know about Dickens or Thackeray: the only difficulty is that we deliberately suppress it because it proves that Shakespear was not only very unlike the conception of a god current in Clapham, but was not, according to the same reckoning, even a respectable man.The academic view starts with a Shakespear who was not scurrilous; therefore the verses about "lousy Lucy" cannot have been written by him, and the cognate passages in the plays are either strokes of character-drawing or gags interpolated by the actors. This ideal Shakespear was too well behaved to get drunk; therefore the tradition that his death was hastened by a drinking bout with Jonson and Drayton must be rejected, and the remorse of Cassio treated as a thing observed, not experienced: nay, the disgust of Hamlet at the drinking customs of Denmark is taken to establish Shakespear as the superior of Alexander in self-control, and the greatest of teetotallers.

Now this system of inventing your great man to start with, and then rejecting all the materials that do not fit him, with the ridiculous result that you have to declare that there are no materials at all (with your waste-paper basket full of them), ends in leaving Shakespear with a much worse character than he deserves. For though it does not greatly matter whether he wrote the lousy Lucy lines or not, and does not really matter at all whether he got drunk when he made a night of it with Jonson and Drayton, the sonnets raise an unpleasant question which does matter a good deal; and the refusal of the academic Bardolaters to discuss or even mention this question has had the effect of producing a silent verdict against Shakespear. Mr Harris tackles the question openly, and has no difficulty whatever in convincing us that Shakespear was a man of normal constitution sexually, and was not the victim of that most cruel and pitiable of all the freaks of nature: the freak which transposes the normal aim of the affections. Silence on this point means condemnation; and the condemnation has been general throughout the present generation, though it only needed Mr Harris's fearless handling of the matter to sweep away what is nothing but a morbid and very disagreeable modern fashion. There is always some stock accusation brought against eminent persons. When I was a boy every well-known man was accused of beating his wife. Later on, for some unexplained reason, he was accused of psychopathic derangement. And this fashion is retrospective. The cases of Shakespear and Michel Angelo are cited as proving that every genius of the first magnitude was a sufferer; and both here and in Germany there are circles in which such derangement is grotesquely reverenced as part of the stigmata of heroic powers. All of which is gross nonsense. Unfortunately, in Shakespear's case, prudery, which cannot prevent the accusation from being whispered, does prevent the refutation from being shouted. Mr Harris, the deep-voiced, refuses to be silenced. He dismisses with proper contempt the stupidity which places an outrageous construction on Shakespear's apologies in the sonnets for neglecting that "perfect ceremony" of love which consists in returning calls and making protestations and giving presents and paying the trumpery attentions which men of genius always refuse to bother about, and to which touchy people who have no genius attach so much importance. No leader who had not been tampered with by the psychopathic monomaniacs could ever put any construction but the obvious and innocent one on these passages.

But the general vocabulary of the sonnets to Pembroke (or whoever "MrW. H." really was) is so overcharged according to modern ideas that a reply on the general case is necessary.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 媒体领导力:领导干部如何与媒体打交道

    媒体领导力:领导干部如何与媒体打交道

    《媒体领导力:领导干部如何与媒体打交道》对领导干部与媒体打交道的各个方面作了全面的阐述,既包括宏观层面的基本知识,又包括微观层面的具体方法,可以帮助领导干部从思想意识和具体技巧上提高与媒体打交道的水平。涉及的主要内容有:媒体新时代的到来;领导干部与“无冕之王”;让自己的媒体形象亮起来;领导口才与演讲艺术;关注基于民意的舆情;运用媒体作宣传;直面虚假负面报道;接受采访的技巧;做成功的新闻发言人;突发事件中的媒体管理:学会运用和引导网络;自觉接受媒体监督等。书中精心穿插了许多资料链接,这些资料或知识,或案例,或图表,方便阅读时从不同角度加深对正文的理解。在每章的最后还附上了……
  • 隋唐历史人物狄仁杰评传

    隋唐历史人物狄仁杰评传

    本书从思想、信仰、品格、心理、君臣关系、同僚关系等方面,对狄仁杰进行了研究和评价。全面客观地写出了狄仁杰曲折坎坷又富有传奇色彩的一生。
  • 格言寄语篇(名人佳作)

    格言寄语篇(名人佳作)

    本书共有七辑,主要收入人生与命运、理想与追求、学习与求知、爱情与婚姻、道德与品格、交际与处世、生活与娱乐等方面格言。
  • 皇家六少恋上千金女

    皇家六少恋上千金女

    一个微带嚣张气息的拽丫头——宫希然;一个只会死读书的书呆子——玉兮寒;一个美国回归的野蛮女生——莫薰;一个文静内敛的上流淑女——蓝紫昕。四个别致不一样的女生,会在伯莱亚皇家贵族学院掀起一阵怎么样的巨浪?六个男生对上四个女生,他们会擦出怎么样的火花呢?
  • 抚州曹山本寂禅师语录

    抚州曹山本寂禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天圣广灯录

    天圣广灯录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南窗一梦春入画

    南窗一梦春入画

    穿越?而且还是个七岁黄毛丫头身上?没劲,天天吃喝玩乐像变个人似的,开心到飞起!可是已经玩了七八年了,什么事情都没有发生,最起码告诉我怎么回到属于我的世界吧!突然父亲大人说我有婚约?还是个将军?满心期待他归来能带给我乐趣,不曾想他竟然带回西域女子要娶她为妻?作为新时代女性我怎么能容忍三妻四妾?坚决不同意,不是你休我,是我要休了你!
  • 咸也好,淡也好

    咸也好,淡也好

    本书以“小故事”(或精品美文或寓言说理)+“咸淡指数”+“咸言淡语”的形式,演绎生活中的咸与淡,而在这咸与淡中你还可以品尝出种种不同的滋味,它们就是每天与我们常见却往往又擦肩而过的种种生活哲理。它们始终高扬着人性的温情,同时又带给我们最为睿智的思考。
  • 佛说金耀童子经

    佛说金耀童子经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 归来之脱团团长

    归来之脱团团长

    这个世界上真有长得一模一样的人?古易表示不信,为了查明她的真身,他放弃基业,开始另一段传奇人生。