登陆注册
4811800000012

第12章 (4)

Everyone knows that when supply and demand are evenly balanced, the relative value of any product is accurately determined by the quantity of labor embodied in it, that is to say, that this relative value expresses the proportional relation precisely in the sense we have just attached to it. M. Proudhon inverts the order of thing. Begin, he says, by measuring the relative value of a product by the quantity of labor embodied in it, and supply and demand will infallibly balance one another. Production will correspond to consumption, the product will always be exchangeable. Its current price will express exactly its true value. Instead of saying like everyone else: when the weather is fine, a lot of people are to be seen going out for a walk. M. Proudhon makes his people go out for a walk in order to be able to ensure them fine weather.

What M. Proudhon gives as the consequence of marketable value determined a priori by labor time could be justified only by a law couched more or less in the following terms:

Products will in future be exchanged in the exact ratio of the labor time they have cost. Whatever may be the proportion of supply to demand, the exchange of commodities will always be made as if they had been produced proportionately to the demand. Let M. Proudhon take it upon himself to formulate and lay down such a law, and we shall relieve him of the necessity of giving proofs. If, on the other hand, he insists on justifying his theory, not as a legislator, but as an economist, he will have to prove that the time needed to create a commodity indicates exactly the degree of its utility and marks its proportional relation to the demand, and in consequence, to the total amount of wealth. In this case, if a product is sold at a price equal to its cost of production, supply and demand will always be evenly balanced; for the cost of production is supposed to express the true relation between supply and demand.

Actually, M. Proudhon sets out to prove that labor time needed to create a product indicates its true proportional relation to needs, so that the things whose production costs the least time are the most immediately useful, and so on, step by step. The mere production of a luxury object proves at once, according to this doctrine, that society has spare time which allows it to satisfy a need for luxury.

M. Proudhon finds the very proof of his thesis in the observation that the most useful things cost the least time to produce, that society always begins with the easiest industries and successively "starts on the production of objects which cost more labor time and which correspond to a higher order of needs."M. Proudhon borrows from M. Dunoyer the example of extractive industry -- fruit-gathering, pasturage, hunting, fishing, etc. -- which is the simplest, the least costly of industries, and the one by which man began "the first day of his second creation". The first day of his first creation is recorded in Genesis, which shows God as the world's first manufacturer.

Things happen in quite a different way from what M. Proudhon imagines.

The very moment civilization begins, production begins to be founded on the antagonism of orders, estates, classes, and finally on the antagonism of accumulated labor and actual labor. No antagonism, no progress. This is the law that civilization has followed up to our days. Till now the productive forces have been developed by virtue of this system of class antagonisms. To say now that, because all the needs of all the workers were satisfied, men could devote themselves to the creation of products of a higher order -- to more complicated industries -- would be to leave class antagonism out of account and turn all historical development upside down. It is like saying that because, under the Roman emperors, muraena were fattened in artificial fishponds, therefore there was enough to feed abundantly the whole Roman population. Actually, on the contrary, the Roman people had not enough to buy bread with, while the Roman aristocrats had slaves enough to throw as fodder to the muraena.

The price of food has almost continuously risen, while the price of manufactured and luxury goods has almost continuously fallen. Take the agricultural industry itself; the most indispensable objects, like corn, meat, etc., rise in price, while cotton, sugar, coffee, etc., fall in a surprising proportion. And even among comestibles proper, the luxury articles, like artichokes, asparagus, etc., are today relatively cheaper than foodstuffs of prime necessity. In our age, the superfluous is easier to produce than the necessary. Finally, at different historical epochs, the reciprocal price relations are not only different, but opposed to one another. In the whole of the Middle Ages, agricultural products were relatively cheaper than manufactured products; in modern times they are in inverse ratio.

Does this mean that the utility of agricultural products has diminished since the Middle Ages?

The use of products is determined by the social conditions in which the consumers find themselves placed, and these conditions themselves are based on class antagonism.

Cotton, potatoes and spirits are objects of the most common use.

Potatoes have engendered scrofula; cotton has to a great extent driven out flax and wool, although wool and flax are, in many cases, of greater utility, if only from the point of view of hygiene; finally, spirits have got the upper hand of beer and wine, although spirits used as an alimentary substance are everywhere recognized to be poison. For a whole century, governments struggled in vain against the European opium; economics prevailed, and dictated its orders to consumption.

Why are cotton, potatoes and spirits the pivots of bourgeois society?

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 御赐痞妃:邪魅王爷太勾人

    御赐痞妃:邪魅王爷太勾人

    她本是异世亡魂,机缘巧合之后遇见了他,此后便死皮赖脸的粘上了他。“夫君,一夜夫妻百日恩,你忘记妾身了吗?”某男眉头一挑,再然后……“母妃,父王他又失踪了……”某个小宝贝佯装着急的说道。
  • 总裁情深心月当空

    总裁情深心月当空

    南心月一生可以说是一路开挂,两岁时才与母亲回到了南氏,成为云城第一名媛。15岁就认命为南氏有史以来第一位女总裁,身价千亿,还拥有着公主的身份!手撕祖母,姑姑堂姐,绝美倾世容颜,头脑聪慧,颇有手段。未婚夫更是人中之龙,M国亲王,为人冷血,手段更是残忍却只宠爱她一人,经过一路过关斩将才将南心月娶回,却没有想到婚礼当天瞬间变成了葬礼!只听到天空一声巨响……直到有一天......
  • 每天读一点经济学常识

    每天读一点经济学常识

    这是一本让你生活得更睿智的经济学通俗读物,妙趣横生的经济学课堂,人人都能看懂的经济学!经济学本身就是有趣的,人类的生活同样充满神秘。在这个无孔不入的商品社会,我们无时无刻不在和经济发生关系,逃避是不可能的,只有多学习一些经济学知识,才能更好地把握经济的脉搏,让自己的生活变得更轻松!
  • 与仙君不得不说的二三事

    与仙君不得不说的二三事

    既是相逢不相识,从此天涯陌路人。“温润似玉如你,在见识了这么不堪的我后,也终究不过是转身离去了吧”“见你所见,听你所听;你依然不信我,我中意的从来都是你不曾变过;所谓陌路之人,我若不愿,那便只能是纸张上的几字罢了。”情之一字所引二三事。
  • 大秦帝国之惠夫人

    大秦帝国之惠夫人

    温柔苦命的失婚老女人重生到战国时期的秦国,带着系统平台,种田生子的故事,本来以为这辈子就是种田流,没想到男人是一国之君。
  • 全能皇妃

    全能皇妃

    十二年前她家破人亡,十二年后她更改身份回来复仇,却发现她有着更大的使命,为了集齐七颗灵珠,她不惜以身犯险,深入敌国,巧取强夺。在这场权力的游戏中,究竟谁能获得最终的胜利?
  • 百愚禅师语录

    百愚禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 当尘埃消散之时

    当尘埃消散之时

    生存还是毁灭?这是一个问题。图书馆里的一个阴暗的角落里的一本尘封已久的手稿记录了一个被习惯无视了的事实,机缘偶合之下被一个沉迷于虚拟世界的无行浪子发现。不懈的寻根问底,到底又会带来什么?
  • 长江三峡的前世今生

    长江三峡的前世今生

    课本里有许多科学知识。可是叫你天天啃干巴巴的课本,背着又大又重的书包,从早到晚啃得头昏脑涨也不行呀!丢掉大书包,从刘兴诗编著的《长江三峡的前世今生》里学科学知识吧!
  • 总裁的妻子

    总裁的妻子

    【全本完】五年后!在一场名为“m.wkkk.net”的婚纱时装秀上,她牵着三个精致绝美的小宝贝,亲密的挽着另外一个男人,出现在了电视上!而他,在电视那边,紧紧地盯着那个笑容甜美的人!******一场大火,让她家破人亡。被初恋情人出卖,她将身心都献给了一个带着半张面具的男人!为了复仇,她不惜赔上所有,包括她自己!她,是萧氏集团最底层的婚纱设计助理。他,是日日折磨她的神秘男人。他,是流连花丛,桀骜不驯的总裁少爷。一件神秘的婚纱,将他与她,她与他的命运紧紧地联系在了一起。一次意外,她凭着对时尚的嗅觉,一跃成为了婚纱设计界的新起之秀!可命运却再次的给她开了一个玩笑……当她整个人消失在了他的世界时,他跪在地上,悔恨袭上了他的心头……