登陆注册
4811800000031

第31章 (4)

[NOTE by Engels to 1885 German edition: This was perfectly correct for the year 1847 [when Marx wrote these lines]. At that time the world trade of the United State was limited mainly to import of immigrants and industrial products, and export of cotton and tobacco, i.e., of the products of southern slave labor. The Northern States produced mainly corn and meat for the slave states. It was only when the North produced corn and meat for export and also became an industrial country, and when the American cotton monopoly had to face powerful competition, in India, Egypt, Brazil, etc., that the abolition of slavery became possible. And even then this led to the ruin of the South, which did not succeed in replacing the open Negro slavery by the disguised slavery is Indian and Chinese coolies. ]

Thus slavery, because it is an economic category, has always existed among the institutions of the peoples. Modern nations have been able only to disguise slavery in their own countries, but they have imposed it without disguise upon the New World.

What would M. Proudhon do to save slavery? He would formulate the problem thus: preserve the good side of this economic category, eliminate the bad.

Hegel has no problems to formulate. He has only dialectics. M.

Proudhon has nothing of Hegel's dialectics but the language. for him the dialectic movement is the dogmatic distinction between good and bad.

Let us for a moment consider M. Proudhon himself as a category.

Let us examine his good and bad side, his advantages and his drawbacks.

If he has the advantage over Hegel of setting problems which he reserves the right of solving for the greater good of humanity, he has the drawback of being stricken with sterility when it is a question of engendering a new category by dialectical birth-throes. What constitutes dialectical movement is the coexistence of two contradictory sides, their conflict and their fusion into a new category. The very setting of the problem of eliminating the bad side cuts short the dialectic movement.

It is not the category which is posed and opposed to itself, by its contradictory nature, it is M. Proudhon who gets excited, perplexed and frets and fumes between the two sides of the category.

Caught thus in a blind alley, from which it is difficult to escape by legal means, M. Proudhon takes a real flying leap which transports him at one bound into a new category. Then it is that, to his astonished gaze, is revealed the serial relation in the understanding .

He takes the first category that comes handy and attributes to it arbitrarily the quality of supplying a remedy for the drawbacks of the category to be purified. Thus, if we are to believe M. Proudhon, taxes remedy the drawbacks of monopoly; the balance of trade, the drawbacks of taxes; landed property, the drawbacks of credit.

By taking the economic categories thus successively, one by one, and making one the antidote to the other, M. Proudhon manages to make with this mixture of contradictions and antidotes to contradictions, two volumes of contradictions, which he rightly entitles: The System of Economic Contradictions .

Fifth Observation "In the absolute reason all these ideas... are equally simple, and general.... In fact, we attain knowledge only by a sort of scaffolding of our ideas. But truth in itself is independent of these dialectical symbols and freed from the combinations of our minds."(Proudhon, Vol.II, p.97)

Here all of a sudden, by a kind of switch-over of which we now know the secret, the metaphysics of political economy has become an illusion! Never has M. Proudhon spoken more truly. Indeed, from the moment the process of the dialectic movement is reduced to the simple process of opposing good to bad, and of administering one category as an antidote to another, the categories are deprived of all spontaneity; the idea "ceases to function";there is no life left in it. It is no longer posed or decomposed into categories.

The sequence of categories has become a sort of scaffolding. Dialectics has ceased to be the movement of absolute reason. There is no longer any dialectics but only, at the most, absolutely pure morality.

When M. Proudhon spoke of the series in the understanding, of the logical sequence of categories, he declared positively that he did not want to give history according to the order in time, that is, in M.

Proudhon's view, the historical sequence in which the categories have manifested themselves. Thus for him everything happened in the pure ether of reason.

Everything was to be derived from this ether by means of dialectics. Now that he has to put this dialectics into practice, his reason is in default.

M. Proudhon's dialectics runs counter to Hegel's dialectics, and now we have M. Proudhon reduced to saying that the order in which he gives the economic categories is no longer the order in which they engender on e another. Economic evolutions are no longer the evolutions of reason itself.

What then does M. Proudhon give us? Real history, which is, according to M. Proudhon's understanding, the sequence in which the categories have manifested themselves in order of time? No! History as it take place in the idea itself? Still less! That is, neither the profane history of categories, nor their sacred history! What history does he give us then? The history of his own contradictions. Let us see how they go, and how they drag M.

Proudhon in their train.

Before entering upon this examination, which gives rise to the sixth important observation, we have yet another, less important observation to make.

Let us admit with M. Proudhon that real history, history according to the order in time, is the historical sequence in which ideas, categories and principles have manifested themselves.

Each principle has had its own century in which to manifest itself.

同类推荐
  • 警世

    警世

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 十六大罗汉因果识见颂

    十六大罗汉因果识见颂

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 钟吕传道集

    钟吕传道集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 读史抄

    读史抄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 老子想尔注

    老子想尔注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 重生之鸢归君心

    重生之鸢归君心

    高洁党可入!!! 在叶千鸢眼里:小时候君墨倾是那个单纯可爱得小萌娃。只是这小萌娃为啥时不时脸红结巴,还一脸霸道的让她等他呢十几岁时君墨倾在外臭名昭著,确是那个永远对她傻傻的笑着,把所有好东西都孝敬给她的好弟弟只是这好弟弟为啥依旧时不时脸红结巴,还外加时不时笑得像个傻子,脑子有病还是用坑,能治吗十五岁时君墨倾啥都好,除了二点,傻点,脑子有坑点,脾气差点,其他还是勉强可以的。未来的弟媳妇不好找啊只是为啥,这二货一脸视死如归强吻了后,开始明坑暗夺软硬兼施,誓要把自己拐回去这画风真的不对哈本文男主重生,女主穿越,男主女主身心干净
  • 校草

    校草

    作品简介:一个老套的灰姑娘与王子现代版。头脑顶级的男人婆尹萱草为好友陷害,误考入贵族学院圣德。不起眼的她突然身价倍增不过也因为如此,她倒霉地成了女生公敌……
  • 话题写作指导与好词好句好段(上)

    话题写作指导与好词好句好段(上)

    “话题”,就是指谈话的中心;以所给的话题为中心,并围绕这个中心内容而进行选材写出的文章就是“话题”作文。话题文章写作是考验一个作者逻辑思维能力的一个重要方面,通过此训练。能极大的提高人的思辨能力,使人处事交流条理分明。
  • 天剑邪尊

    天剑邪尊

    顺为仙,逆为魔,亘古匆匆皆弹指。血染红尘踏轮回,苍茫道上破生死。葬爱颠倒黄泉路,剑气凌霄震九宇。误我今生成永劫,舍我其谁念红烛。
  • 佛说转有经

    佛说转有经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中学生必知的名胜古迹(下)

    中学生必知的名胜古迹(下)

    名胜古迹,是指风景优美和有古代遗迹的著名地方。漫步在这些名山胜水之中,一方面可以领略自然的大好风光,另一方面也从中感悟博大精深的历史文化。对于了解一个国家,一个地区,一个民族的地理文化,也有着十分重要的帮助。
  • 七夜

    七夜

    十三年前,因为一场追杀,林源等七个人被困在一个只有黑白两色的地方,几人耗费了七夜才得以离开,但是脱困后每人对此只有一天的记忆。十三年后,一段摩斯电码预示着间隔十三年的杀人游戏又将继续。十三年后的七天时间里,林源先后见证了当年七人里有人自杀、有人精神病发、有人被害身亡。人人互相怀疑。林源通过对十三年前七个夜晚的各自回忆,以及十三年后七天内发生的一系列诡怪事情,终于找到掩藏在所谓“真相”后面的真相,然而最终的结果却让他骇然。
  • 第一至尊

    第一至尊

    星域苍穹,十方世界。有通神神通,修炼可天地同存,永生不灭。有武魂万千,‘至强武魂’镇压万古时空。’至强武魂‘拥有者天耀武帝凌耀阳,因修炼绝世神通‘至尊诀’,在突破星位时陨落重生为青龙宗弟子叶无生。从此十万年千载浩劫解开面纱,一步一步解开重生之谜,成就武道至尊。
  • 流年易逝之寻爱

    流年易逝之寻爱

    片段一:“我想和你一起,看尽这繁华的流年”这是我儿时多年来的梦,但梦就是梦,终究会支离破碎。片段二:“喂!我今天忘带历史书了,借你的给我用用呗,下课就还你。”“那个……我……”那时的自己,每天用这种很难令他相信的理由见他,却终有一天,我再也没有去借过他的东西,只因……片段三:……片段四:多年之后,我带着我心爱的人来到这里,望着这里的一切,总觉得一切有些不可思议,流年易逝,我终寻到了我这一生中的——最爱。
  • 家庭教育与儿童智商情商开发

    家庭教育与儿童智商情商开发

    本书吸收了近年来心理学在家庭教育方面的科研成果,以让孩子学会学习、开发儿童的智商和情商为主线,详细地介绍了家庭教育的方法和家庭教育中应注意的问题等。