登陆注册
5152500000020

第20章 HAROLD'S OATH TO WILLIAM--A.D.1064?(4)

The mere obligation of homage would, in the skilful hands of William and Lanfranc, be quite enough to work on men's minds, as William wished to work on them.To Harold meanwhile and to those in England who heard the story, the engagement would not seem to carry any of these consequences.The mere homage then, which Harold could hardly refuse, would answer William's purpose nearly as well as any of these fuller obligations which Harold would surely have refused.

And when a man older than William engaged to marry William's child-daughter, we must bear in mind the lightness with which such promises were made.William could not seriously expect that this engagement would be kept, if anything should lead Harold to another marriage.The promise was meant simply to add another count to the charges against Harold when the time should come.Yet on this point it is not clear that the oath was broken.Harold undoubtedly married Ealdgyth, daughter of AElfgar and widow of Gruffydd, and not any daughter of William.But in one version Harold is made to say that the daughter of William whom he had engaged to marry was dead.

And that one of William's daughters did die very early there seems little doubt.

Whatever William did Lanfranc no doubt at least helped to plan.The Norman duke was subtle, but the Italian churchman was subtler still.

In this long series of schemes and negotiations which led to the conquest of England, we are dealing with two of the greatest recorded masters of statecraft.We may call their policy dishonest and immoral, and so it was.But it was hardly more dishonest and immoral than most of the diplomacy of later times.William's object was, without any formal breach of faith on his own part, to entrap Harold into an engagement which might be understood in different senses, and which, in the sense which William chose to put upon it, Harold was sure to break.Two men, themselves of virtuous life, a rigid churchman and a layman of unusual religious strictness, do not scruple to throw temptation in the way of a fellow man in the hope that he will yield to that temptation.They exact a promise, because the promise is likely to be broken, and because its breach would suit their purposes.Through all William's policy a strong regard for formal right as he chose to understand formal right, is not only found in company with much practical wrong, but is made the direct instrument of carrying out that wrong.Never was trap more cunningly laid than that in which William now entangled Harold.

Never was greater wrong done without the breach of any formal precept of right.William and Lanfranc broke no oath themselves, and that was enough for them.But it was no sin in their eyes to beguile another into engagements which he would understand in one way and they in another; they even, as their admirers tell the story, beguile him into engagements at once unlawful and impossible, because their interests would be promoted by his breach of those engagements.William, in short, under the spiritual guidance of Lanfranc, made Harold swear because he himself would gain by being able to denounce Harold as perjured.

The moral question need not be further discussed; but we should greatly like to know how far the fact of Harold's oath, whatever its nature, was known in England? On this point we have no trustworthy authority.The English writers say nothing about the whole matter;to the Norman writers this point was of no interest.No one mentions this point, except Harold's romantic biographer at the beginning of the thirteenth century.His statements are of no value, except as showing how long Harold's memory was cherished.

According to him, Harold formally laid the matter before the Witan, and they unanimously voted that the oath--more, in his version, than a mere oath of homage--was not binding.It is not likely that such a vote was ever formally passed, but its terms would only express what every Englishman would feel.The oath, whatever its terms, had given William a great advantage; but every Englishman would argue both that the oath, whatever its terms, could not hinder the English nation from offering Harold the crown, and that it could not bind Harold to refuse the crown if it should be so offered.

同类推荐
  • 大乘阿毗达磨集论

    大乘阿毗达磨集论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说漏分布经

    佛说漏分布经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 月屋漫稿

    月屋漫稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Woman of Thirty

    A Woman of Thirty

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 瑜伽师地论释

    瑜伽师地论释

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 网游之大神姗姗来迟

    网游之大神姗姗来迟

    我爱不爱你是我的事,就像你不喜欢打王者一样。
  • 大荒神侠传

    大荒神侠传

    上古神侠,唯我独尊。八荒六合,行者无疆。东方道宗,西方佛宗,北方真宗,南方灵宗,宗脉通三界;道义,侠义,宗义,情义,四义乱洪荒。少年身负血仇,脚踏悲歌,纵是聪俊无双,神力通天,也难逃神佛之掌。愿以此身此魂,护你一世安好,百岁无忧。
  • 文化软实力与国际谈判

    文化软实力与国际谈判

    文化是国家软实力的重要内容,国际谈判深受其影响。在两国的谈判竞争中,军事等硬实力与文化软实力是很重要的两个方面。中国为什么在国际谈判桌上很多时候不占优势?我认为原因有二:一是对文化的差异性认识不够。冲突的基本根源不再是意识形态,而常常是文化方面的差异。主宰全球的将是“文明的冲突”。二是对新闻媒体的作用不够重视。在相当大的程度上,媒体已经开始主导社会舆论的话语权,特别是网络世界的兴起,舆论浪潮席卷而来。谈判是最直接的文化角力。我方人员的文化积累,对对方文化背景的熟悉与洞察,和不同文化背景人士的交流应对……小而言之,关乎在某次谈判中是否可运筹帷幄、长袖善舞;大而言之,关乎一个国家在国际交往中的外在形象,以及在国际谈判席上主动权和话语权。
  • 重生之魅惑君心

    重生之魅惑君心

    天空中飘起淅淅沥沥的细雨,在乌云的笼罩下,好像在发出一种让人窒息的痛。在马路的上走来一个身着淡紫色裙子的美丽女孩,她的脸色苍白、清澈的明眸中饱含着晶莹的泪,薄薄的嘴唇呈现着淡淡的紫色,好像在微微的颤抖着。尽管如此却丝毫不影响她的绝色容姿,但她周身散发着沉痛和绝望的气息,让人不禁猜测在她身上发生了什么事,是谁舍得伤害这样的一个女孩。那个女子拖着沉重的步伐向路边的一辆白色跑车走去,不知……
  • 主神崛起

    主神崛起

    一觉醒来穿越成反派?这剧本不对!还抢了人家的妹子?又有一个强势的姐姐?剧本更不对了!居然还有主神空间,诸天万界?我一定是在做梦!吴明淡定地木着脸,继续着征程。
  • 教诫新学比丘行护律仪

    教诫新学比丘行护律仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中国最好的小小说

    中国最好的小小说

    不可不读的“短经典”,魅力无限的“微阅读”,遴选国内外顶尖级小小说作家不可不读的百篇代表作,国内经典微阅读一网打尽!所收作品,由国内顶尖级小小说作家授权供稿。他们是中国小小说历届金麻雀奖获得者的代表作。其作品被《小说选刊》《小小说选刊》《微型小说选刊》《读者》《意林》《格言》等名刊刊载;他们的作品构成了“漓江版”、“长江文艺版”、“花城版”等重要年选版本的支柱性作品;几乎年年被各省、市“中考”、“高考”试卷选为阅读题或作为作文素材,并被译介到美国、俄国、日本、法国、新西兰、马来西亚、泰国、新加坡等国家……
  • 萌化九尾日常

    萌化九尾日常

    九尾醒来,打了个哈欠,印象中好像有一个灵魂融进了自己的身体。啊,管呢,继续睡。……然后九尾的意识就被取代。再次醒来,继承了九尾和宅男灵魂的小玖出世
  • 主权债务危机和经济可持续性

    主权债务危机和经济可持续性

    我们一直认为市场经济和资本主义理念创造了全球经济繁荣,以及提高全世界人民生活水平的奇迹,尤其是四十年代以后,西方发达国家和日本的经济发展都证明了这一点。然而,在一个全球化和商业化的时代,作者怀疑,我们是否还能继续享受这一理念所带来繁荣,特别是当债务缠身的西方国家发现维持这个繁荣假象越来越困难时。作者不仅提出了一些创新的想法,利用市场原则产生公共财政收入来维持现状,还在本书中强调,除了采取新的货币和财政政策措施以外,西方国家还应该采取一些规范市场经济的措施。
  • 海上那群男子汉

    海上那群男子汉

    本书由前远洋大副梁斌撰写,书中讲述了31个中国远洋海员在世界各地遇到的真实故事,在越军炮火中撤离的最后一艘中国船拒绝带走华裔姑娘,巴拿马圣诞夜的肚皮舞娘与中国海员的情感交流,主人公钓上一条大鲨鱼,女海员的风流事……真实地告诉你发生在远离陆地的远洋船上的事。