登陆注册
5174400000048

第48章 Fallacies

Right understanding consists in the discovery and adherence to truth,and that in the perception of the visible or probable agreement or disagreement of ideas as they are affirmed and denied one of another.From whence it is evident that the right use and conduct of the understanding,w hose business is purely truth and nothing else,is that the mind should be kept in a perfect indifference,not inclining to either side any further than evidence settles it by knowledge or the over-balance of probability gives it the turn of assent and belief;but yet it is very hard to meet with any discourse wherein one may not perceive the author not only maintain (for that is reasonable and fit),but inclined and biased to one side of the question With marks of a desire that should be true.

If it be asked me how authors who have such a bias and lean to it may be discovered,I answer,by observing how in their Writings or arguings they are often led by their inclinations to change the ideas of the question,either by changing the terms or by adding and joining others to them,whereby the ideas under consideration are so varied as to be more serviceable to their purpose and to be thereby brought to an easier and nearer agreement or more visible and remoter disagreement one with another.This is plain and direct sophistry;but I am far from thinking that,wherever it is found,it is made use of with design to deceive and mislead the readers.

It is visible that men's prejudices and inclinations by this way impose often upon themselves;and their affection for truth,under their prepossession in favor of one side,is the very thing that leads them from it.Inclination suggests and slides into their discourse favorable terms which introduce favorable ideas,till at last by this means that is concluded clear and evident,thus dressed up,which taken in its native state,by making use of none but the precise determined ideas,would find no admittance at all.

The putting these glosses on what they affirm,these (as they are thought)handsome,easy and graceful explications of what they are discoursing on,is so much the character of what is called and esteemed writing well,that it is very hard to think that authors will ever be persuaded to leave what serves so well to propagate their opinions and procure themselves credit in the world for a more jejune and dry way of writing,by keeping to the same terms precisely annexed to the same ideas,a sour and blunt stiffness tolerable in mathematicians only,who force their way and make truth prevail by irresistible demonstration.

But yet,if authors cannot be prevailed with to quit the looser,though more insinuating,ways of writing,if they will not think fit to keep close to truth and instruction by unvaried terms and plain unsophisticated arguments,yet it concerns readers not to be imposed on by fallacies and the prevailing ways of insinuation.To do this,the surest and most effectual remedy is to fix in the mind the clear and distinct ideas of the question stripped of words;and so likewise in the train of argumentation,to take up the author's ideas,neglecting his words,observing how they connect or separate those in the question.He that does this will be able to cast off all that is superfluous;he will see what is pertinent,what coherent,what is direct to,what slides by the question.This will readily show him all the foreign ideas in the discourse and where they were brought in;and though they perhaps dazzled the writer,yet he will perceive that they give no light nor strength to his reasonings.

This,though it be the shortest and easiest way of reading books with profit and keeping oneself from being misled by great names or plausible discourses,yet,it being hard and tedious to those who have not accustomed themselves to it,it is not to be expected that everyone (amongst those few who really pursue truth)should this way guard his understanding from being imposed on by the willful or at least undesigned sophistry which creeps into most of the books of argument.They that write against their conviction or that,next to them,are resolved to maintain the tenets of a party they are engaged in cannot be supposed to reject any arms that may help to defend their cause,and therefore such should be read with the greatest caution.And they who write for opinions they are sincerely persuaded of and believe to be true think they may so far allow themselves to indulge their laudable affection to truth as to permit their esteem of it to give it the best colors and set it off with the best expressions and dress they can,thereby to gain it the easiest entrance into the minds of their readers and fix it deepest there.

One of those being the state of mind we may justly suppose most writers to be in,it is fit their readers,who apply to them for instruction,should not lay by that caution which becomes a sincere pursuit of truth,and should make them always watchful against whatever might conceal or misrepresent it.If they have not the skill of representing to themselves the author's sense by pure ideas separated from sounds and thereby divested of the false lights and deceitful ornaments of speech,this yet they should do:they should keep the precise question steadily in their minds,carry it along Faith them through the whole discourse,and suffer not the least alteration in the terms either by addition,subtraction or substituting any other.This everyone can do who has a mind to it;and he that has not a mind to it,it is plain makes his understanding only the warehouse of other men's lumber?Imean false and unconcluding reasonings,rather than a repository of truth for his own use,which will prove substantial and stand him in stead when he has occasion for it.And whether such a one deals fairly by his own mind and conducts his own understanding right,I leave to his own understanding to judge.

同类推荐
  • Lost Face

    Lost Face

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 比丘听施经

    比丘听施经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 和严给事闻唐昌观玉

    和严给事闻唐昌观玉

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 日本国考略

    日本国考略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 鸡峰普济方

    鸡峰普济方

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 夜色温柔

    夜色温柔

    描写的是一个出身寒微但才华出众的青年对富有梦幻色彩的理想的追求以及最终如何遭到失败、变得颓废消沉的故事。
  • 一束堇

    一束堇

    江思瑾和林一楠是从小一起长得的青梅竹马。林一楠每天都到江思瑾门口等她,以为自己的心思,她早就该知道了。谁知道,这天,她约他出去约会,却推出来个妹子,说要给他介绍女朋友?什么?他的女朋友不是她吗?--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 倾世毒医

    倾世毒医

    生来就是上一代恩怨的牺牲品,过着被死神追赶的日子,所以,水玉烟极度任性!也因此她性情淡薄疏离,相信无情不似多情苦。偏偏出现了个仓行云,愿将行云付流水。他打破了她的藩篱,为她卷入是非,甚至不惜放弃一切!偏偏她就动了心。
  • 法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读

    法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读

    法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读法律解码:101个焦点民事行为的法律关键点解读
  • 食客天子

    食客天子

    在芝罘府辖下的小小桃远镇居然有桃五爷这样一位“食客”。五爷大号连吉,连连吉利的意思。意思很是不错的。五爷双腿似有些不一般齐,行走时一拐一拐。不恭敬他的人便喊他“连吉歪子”,讥他做人做事有些不正。看,连吉一拐一拐地走来了。
  • 网游之收集大师

    网游之收集大师

    【DNF男街霸贴吧官方授权职业文】(前排提示,这是一本月更31w字的小破书)咸鱼青年秦炎,在经历了多款虚拟游戏之后,终于是在深渊游戏开启了属于自己的幸运之路。一双红色高跟鞋,来自于深渊游戏制作方的不解之迷。曾执念加入大势力,出走后迎来新生。面向世界展现自己实力的大舞台之上,秦炎和他的伙伴终会绽放......欢迎加入兰翔他哥的书友群,群号码:648283720
  • “水鬼”是这样打天下的

    “水鬼”是这样打天下的

    前两年,央视10频道连续播发将近一年的公益广告引起我们的注意:一位圆脸中年渔民对着镜头说:“生命是无价的,我能在海上救那么多人,感到很幸福。”字幕上写道:“郭文标,浙江省温岭市石塘镇小沙头村渔民。郭文标三十年如一日,守护着浙江东南温岭一带海域,不计报酬、不计得失、不顾个人安危,已在惊涛恶浪中救起了五百多条生命。”在温岭,渔民习惯称他为“标哥”,有事找“标哥”,好使;在那片海域,过往的船老大称他为“水鬼”,或在“水鬼”前加“平安”两字,即“平安水鬼”。不论谁在海上遇到麻烦,第一个想到的就是他,他的手机号码成为海上110。
  • 幸福的法则

    幸福的法则

    这是一本类似于《菜根谭》的书,书中并没有一个贯穿始终的主线,只是一则则充满哲理的小品,内容涵盖了自然、艺术、修养、生活甚至还有企业管理等各个层面。虽然它没有一个固定的主题,但是它的目标是明确的,就是告诉人们究竟如何才能幸福地生活。读这本书的感觉,有点像在看央视纪录片频道的《浮生一日》节目,时而讲迪拜,时而讲菲律宾,时讲而父子亲情,时而讲乳酪美食,看似没有丝毫联系的事物之间,却又存在着相同的感动。总之,它的重点不在于陈述,而在于感受,然后就是伦理学最重视的,也是最重要的——知而行之。
  • 状留篇

    状留篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 盛世妖娆:摄政王妃要逆天

    盛世妖娆:摄政王妃要逆天

    轮回匕首,一念入轮回一念堕地狱。传闻,只要用轮回匕首自缢,就会用一半灵魂,换一场重生。白静书,一个热爱于追狗血小说的中医院院长,一不小心穿书,成为被女主顶替身份的正主。一代权臣,相貌出众,是书里众星捧月的对象,她的存在,完完全全就是用于衬托女主后期有多么的惨。本想安安静静过完一生,却不想被他黏上。“关关雎鸠,在河之洲。首辅大人,春宵一度~”白静书:“……”她这是造了什么孽。没办法,自己选的人,跪着,也要宠!一场灵魂的互换,一次艰难的选择,等到盛世花开,来赴一场醉欢。