登陆注册
5211100000010

第10章

Let us say a word on the moral question set in action by Bayle, to know "if a society of atheists could exist?" Let us mark first of all in this matter what is the enormous contradiction of men in this dispute;those who have risen against Bayle's opinion with the greatest ardour;those who have denied with the greatest insults the possibility of a society of atheists, have since maintained with the same intrepidity that atheism is the religion of the government of China.

Assuredly they are quite mistaken about the Chinese government; they had but to read the edicts of the emperors of this vast country to have seen that these edicts are sermons, and that everywhere there is mention of the Supreme Being, ruler, revenger, rewarder.

But at the same time they are not less mistaken on the impossibility of a society of atheists; and I do not know how Mr.Bayle can have forgotten one striking example which was capable of making his cause victorious.

In what does a society of atheists appear impossible? It is that one judges that men who had no check could never live together; that laws can do nothing against secret crimes; that a revengeful God who punishes in this world or the other the wicked who have escaped human justice is necessary.

The laws of Moses, it is true, did not teach a life to come, did not threaten punishments after death, did not teach the first Jews the immortality of the soul; but the Jews, far from being atheists, far from believing in avoiding divine vengeance, were the most religious of all men.Not only did they believe in the existence of an eternal God, but they believed Him always present among them; they trembled lest they be punished in themselves, in their wives, in their children, in their posterity, even unto the fourth generation; this curb was very potent.

But, among the Gentiles, many sects had no curb; the sceptics doubted everything: the academicians suspended judgment on everything; the Epicureans were persuaded that the Deity could not mix Himself in the affairs of men;and at bottom, they admitted no Deity.They were convinced that the soul is not a substance, but a faculty which is born and which perishes with the body; consequently they had no yoke other than morality and honour.

The Roman senators and knights were veritable atheists, for the gods did not exist for men who neither feared nor hoped anything from them.The Roman senate in the time of Caesar and Cicero, was therefore really an assembly of atheists.

That great orator, in his harangue for Cluentius, says to the whole senate in assembly: "What ill does death do him? we reject all the inept fables of the nether regions: of what then has death deprived him? of nothing but the consciousness of suffering."Does not Caesar, the friend of Cataline, wishing to save his friend's life against this same Cicero, object to him that to make a criminal die is not to punish him at all, that death is nothing , that it is merely the end of our ills, that it is a moment more happy than calamitous? And do not Cicero and the whole senate surrender to these reasons? The conquerors and the legislators of the known universe formed visibly therefore a society of men who feared nothing from the gods, who were real atheists.

Further on Bayle examines whether idolatry is more dangerous than atheism, if it is a greater crime not to believe in the Deity than to have unworthy opinions thereof: in that he is of Plutarch's opinion; he believes it is better to have no opinion than to have a bad opinion; but with all deference to Plutarch, it was clearly infinitely better for the Greeks to fear Ceres, Neptune and Jupiter, than to fear nothing at all.The sanctity of oaths is clearly necessary, and one should have more confidence in those who believe that a false oath will be punished, than in those who think they can make a false oath with impunity.It is indubitable that in a civilized town, it is infinitely more useful to have a religion, even a bad one, than to have none at all.

It looks, therefore, that Bayle should have examined rather which is the more dangerous, fanaticism or atheism.Fanaticism is certainly a thousand times more deadly; for atheism inspires no bloody passion, whereas fanaticism does: atheism is not opposed to crime, but fanaticism causes crimes to be committed.Fanatics committed the massacres of St.Bartholomew.Hobbes passed for an atheist; he led a tranquil and innocent life.The fanatics of his time deluged England, Scotland and Ireland with blood.Spinoza was not only atheist, but he taught atheism; it was not he assuredly who took part in the judicial assassination of Barneveldt; it was not he who tore the brothers De Wit in pieces, and who ate them grilled.

The atheists are for the most part impudent and misguided scholars who reason badly, and who not being able to understand the creation, the origin of evil, and other difficulties, have recourse to the hypothesis of the eternity of things and of inevitability.

The ambitious, the sensual, have hardly time for reasoning, and for embracing a bad system; they have other things to do than comparing Lucretius with Socrates.That is how things go among us.

That was not how things went with the Roman senate which was almost entirely composed of atheists in theory and in practice, that is to say, who believed in neither a Providence nor a future life; this senate was an assembly of philosophers, of sensualists and ambitious men, all very dangerous, who ruined the republic.Epicureanism existed under the emperors:

the atheists of the senate had been rebels in the time of Sylla and Caesar:

under Augustus and Tiberius they were atheist slaves.

同类推荐
  • A Group of Noble Dames

    A Group of Noble Dames

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 仿指南录

    仿指南录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 五虎平南

    五虎平南

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Spanish Prisoners of War

    Spanish Prisoners of War

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 悟道录

    悟道录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 雨(人文阅读与收藏·良友文学丛书)

    雨(人文阅读与收藏·良友文学丛书)

    两年后的上海,吴仁民的妻子已经病死,陈真被汽车撞死。此时张若兰已经嫁给一个大学教授,周如水又爱上了另一个被称为小资产阶级女性的李佩珠。吴仁民对周冷嘲热讽,但自己很快也坠入情网。恋上他从前帮助过的女学生熊智君。但吴仁民很快发现熊智君的好友就是自己从前的恋人玉雯,她因为爱慕荣华富贵而抛弃过他,现在又因为孤独想与他重续旧好,吴仁民痛苦地拒绝了她。
  • 英国王室之子·译言古登堡计划

    英国王室之子·译言古登堡计划

    《英国王室之子》是一本讲给孩子们听的历史。内斯比特用讲童话故事的方式,将阿尔弗烈德大帝、亨利五世、“黑太子”爱德华……这些历史上赫赫有名的英国国王、王子们的儿时轶事娓娓道来。在这本书里,除了历史故事,还有适合孩子听的莎士比亚的历史剧、英国诗人迈克尔·德雷顿的战争诗。王室之子不再是单薄的符号,而是活生生的人;历史不再枯燥无聊,而是如此真实有趣。让我们以英国王室之子为典范,了解历史的同时,学习勇气、智慧与道德情操吧!
  • 溺宠天师大人

    溺宠天师大人

    一个是令六界闻风丧胆的妖之尊者,一个是与妖永处对立面的天师。可当彼此动情之时,纵然违背道义,掀起血雨腥风那又如何?只因你是你,不关乎身份、地位、荣耀!放眼六界,那个执子之手,与子偕老之人只有你,也只能是你……
  • 万古帝尊

    万古帝尊

    天地之间,灵者为帝,体者为尊。灵之极者,可破九天,体之极者,可碎十地。九天十地,唯我帝尊!三界之内,唯我独尊!
  • 意外看风味:奢华酒店

    意外看风味:奢华酒店

    《意外看风味:奢华酒店》以世界最热门旅游地点伦敦、东京、夏威夷、葡萄牙、希腊小岛、越南会安等地方为背景,从当地的世界著名奢华酒店落笔,以亲身体验的方式推荐去当地作深度旅游的线索,文字细腻,推荐理由实用而独到。书中附有酒店名称原文、地址、预定电话、网址等实用资讯。
  • 世界最具智慧性的哲理故事(2)

    世界最具智慧性的哲理故事(2)

    我的课外第一本书——震撼心灵阅读之旅经典文库,《阅读文库》编委会编。通过各种形式的故事和语言,讲述我们在成长中需要的知识。
  • 以婚为名

    以婚为名

    夏草曾经以为,与陈慕云的相遇就是一出灰姑娘与王子的童话,却没有想到,自己其实只是一个配角和炮灰。“陈先生。”夏草说,“既然以前我的爱,我的孩子与你无关,那么现在,你爱我,又与我何干?”
  • 重生之锦绣嫡女

    重生之锦绣嫡女

    当表姐出现在眼前,巧笑嫣然的告诉她:“你不是说绝不为妾么,现在跪在这里,不是还得叫我一声主母!”——宁为寒门妻,不做高门妾!云卿怎么都没有想到,只为这一句话,引来表姐处心积虑的谋害,联合他人灭她满门,夺她正室之位。当父母被斩,家门被灭之时,她才知道,这世人眼中美好的姻缘,不过是一片假象,他们心心念念的都是她沈家巨富的家产。再次睁眼,却回到父母皆在的十三岁,她还是沈府千金嫡女,一切都还没有发生。护父母,保家业。为了不重蹈覆辙,她开始步步算计。为了家人的安危,她开始狠下心肠。这一世她一定要不枉此生,斗姨娘,斗姐妹,斗舅母,誓将一切牛鬼蛇神全部打倒,活出一个锦绣人生。【推荐本人完结文】《浴火王妃》女强,一对一P:本文,一对一,宅斗,重生,宠文
  • 终极圣灵

    终极圣灵

    一位孤儿出身的平凡人,在购买彩票之时,一次意外的相遇,被卷入一个善意的圈套。误入圣龙,却意外成为了亿中无一的亡灵法师,身为亡灵法师,除了亡灵属性,自身竟然还拥有神圣属性!两种矛盾的属性,如何结合?为了生存,他决定通过当职业玩家来获取收入。他凭借着自己的能力与智慧,在众多职业玩家的尔虞我诈中一次次地脱险,探索游戏更多的潜在玩法。通过不懈努力,最终在圣龙里打出了一片属于自己的天下。终极圣灵,不仅仅是拥有神圣属性的亡灵法师,有了合体技能,他就是一名在各大职业中不断变幻角色的全职业玩家。且看他如何立足圣龙吧!面对无尽敌人,他轻轻地说,“请记住我的名字,我叫林豪。终极圣灵,林豪。”(本书一号QQ群已经创建,群号:280420691。目前还有大量空位。欢迎大家前来与天玄进行互动!)
  • 希拉里、密和、我

    希拉里、密和、我

    一个行踪诡异的西方女人,一个身世神秘的东方女人,一个因妻“离”子散而濒临崩溃的中国男人,在天寒地冻的皇家山上的奇遇,将一段梦幻般的“三角关系”带进了阅读的视野,三个生命的“真相”与中国最沉重的历史和现实纠结,三种激情的碰撞与人类最古老的喜悦和悲伤交织,这是一个冬天的童话,这更是一个时代的神话……