登陆注册
5217300000176

第176章 Chapter VI(40)

When Newman was invited by innocent people to appear as the champion of faith against science,he refused,for the reason (among others)that he could not tell what was the position to be assailed.He would not deny that 'science grew,but it grew by fits and Starts,'and threw out hypotheses which 'rose and fell.'(266)He supposes science to represent a fluctuating set of guesses.Even if it appeared to contradict revelation,the contradiction could be evaded by an easy device.Science and Scripture contradict each other as to the motion of the earth.We cannot decide till we know what motion is,and then it may turn out that science is false or reconcilable to Scripture.(267)This saying alienated Froude and Kingsley,and,I fancy,with good reason;but we can see how Newman came to it.Theology,he thought,rested on a deeper foundation than science.It represented a single body of deductive truth;while science represented a set of detached conclusions formed upon particular facts.

This appears to reverse the truth.'The scientific principle,in the first place,is at issue with the theology not upon this or that point,not on the conflict between particular statements,but all along the line.Two differing conceptions of the universe are at issue,and one must be accepted.Newman substantially replies that science has its own --a lower --sphere.(268)In the Idea of a University he argues that theology must be admitted into the course,because it deals with the realities underlying phenomena,and is therefore the rightful queen of sciences.The history of the actual relations of science and theology would supply a curious commentary upon this opinion.Newman meanwhile holds that the conflict arises from a scientific misconception.

The latest infidel device,he says,is to leave theology alone.

The man of science trusts to the interest of his own pursuits to distract the mind from theology,which then perishes by inanition.(269)His error consists in leaving the higher study out of sight,or applying methods legitimate in one sphere to those of the other sphere.Science,then,does not give certainty,or gives certainty which has no bearing upon the higher orders of truth.

The reply is obvious.The physical sciences,in the first place,give a body of consistent and verifiable truth,and the only such body of truth.In the next place,it is impossible to assign science and philosophy to two different provinces.The scientific doctrines must lay down the base to which all other truth,so far as it is discoverable,must conform.The essential feature of contemporary thought was just this:that science was passing from purely physical questions to historical,ethical,and social problems.The dogmatist objects to private judgment or free thought on the ground that,as it gives no criterion,it cannot lead to certainty.His real danger was precisely that it leads irresistibly to certainty.The scientific method shows how such certainty as is possible must be obtained.The man of science advocates free inquiry precisely because it is the way to truth,and the only way,though a way which leads through many errors.His test is that which so impressed Newman himself,Securus judicat orbis terrarum;only orbis terrarum must not be translated one European Church during a few centuries.The man of science fully agrees with Newman that there is a true 'illative sense';that men can reason implicitly before they can reason in logical form,and make approximately true formulae though involved in innumerable superstitions and errors.The ultimate criterion is the power of verifying conclusions,of testing truth by its capacity to explain phenomena,and by its conformity to the scientific truth already established beyond dispute.But there is no royal road to truth in philosophy any more than in science;or,rather,it must be far longer and more difficult to reach it.Therefore we must not lay down rules as absolutely certain,but subject them to perpetual examination,to what Newman calls 'the all-corroding force'of the intellect,in the conviction that by that process we are slowly approximating to sounder belief.The errors have to be 'corroded.'This is admittedly true of all the natural sciences;we have to puzzle out the truth in every development of thought,from astronomy to physiology,by a slow and painful process.Moreover,it is true of all the religions of the world except,as Newman would say,the Catholic.Why is that to be an exception?Newman candidly admits a difficulty.The suggestion that a religion to be universally accepted should be universally revealed,as though written 'on the sun,'is,he admits,plausible.(270)He urges that there always was a revelation somewhere,though a revelation in Jerusalem was not of much use in Peking.Yet the admitted fact seems to be a fatal objection to the a priori probability which he assumes of a revelation.To nine-tenths of the world there has been only a 'virtual,'that is to say,no revelation.How,then,does he try to make room for the one exceptional case?The secret is to keep to the geocentric point of view.Shut yourself up within the Church,interpret the world by reference to it,instead of interpreting it by its place in the world;pronounce the instincts by which it has been supported to be ultimate and infallible,instead of listening to the obvious explanation,and you can certainly escape self-contradiction --as it is still always possible on the same terms to hold to the Ptolemaic astronomy.You have only to assume as a first principle that the earth does not move,and the facts can always be forced into conformity.To outsiders this is to confuse the causes with the reasons of belief.So Newman in his famous development theory provides a kind of parallel to the scientific theory.He shows with the greatest clearness how a certain body works out the properties implied in the type,and so obeys an implicit logic.

同类推荐
  • 词综

    词综

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 光赞经

    光赞经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 壶关录

    壶关录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 精忠旗

    精忠旗

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上正一朝天三八谢罪法忏

    太上正一朝天三八谢罪法忏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 食仙

    食仙

    庖刀司命,剁妖断鬼。瓮中奥妙,亦能证道。掌中乾坤,两般天地。财侣法地,诸般皆得。千年传承的金牌厨师苏择,是一个现代的修真者。在一次网友聚会时,他居然捡到一个异界?!从此修真不用愁,一界在手,天下我有。修真境界:炼精化气——练气化神——炼神返虚——体虚合道PS:已完本《卑鄙在汉末》,《天国降临》。读者群:《东厨居》:20722203二群【食仙居处】:124386998
  • 桂花树

    桂花树

    李东文, 70后。1999年开始学习写作,以小说及情感专栏为主,曾在《天涯》《长城》《十月》《西湖》《长江文艺》等杂志发表小说,作品多次被《小说选刊》《中篇小说选刊》《读者》等转载。
  • A Narrative of the Expedition to Botany Bay

    A Narrative of the Expedition to Botany Bay

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 紫星花之诗2

    紫星花之诗2

    卡亚特大陆是一片临海大陆,越往西越荒凉,最远是人类没有到过的神秘之地。大陆上的人们信仰着光明之神,却饱受妖魔的威胁。在几万年前,光明之神将危害人类安全的黑暗妖魔封印到了地底深处被称为“第九层圣殿”的地方。克里欧找到妖魔解禁的端倪,组成小队深入第九层圣殿。在这里,克里欧终于明白了妖魔王的诡计……
  • 不顾此生遇见你

    不顾此生遇见你

    叶璟应闺蜜之邀前往夏威夷度假却意外遇见了顾安远,两人历经了一周的远洋之旅并且结识了心理专家上野千雪,在上野千雪的帮助下叶璟终于身心痊愈,和顾安远破镜重圆,直到婚礼现场叶璟才知道,这一切都是顾安远的精心安排,她以为自己是付出最多的那一个,却不想顾安远爱她更多,相爱的两个人最后一定会在一起。
  • 人生哲理枕边书2

    人生哲理枕边书2

    书中充满了智慧、温暖人心和震撼心灵的故事和哲理。能够激发我们的灵感,涤荡我们的心灵,丰富我们的经验,升华我们的人生。 谨以本书献给各行各业、不同年龄、愿意通过学习和自己的努力迅速改善人生境遇的人。 要想让人生充实一点,让生活质量高一点,让职场生活丰富一点,为人处世潇洒一点,就要时刻把本书放在枕边,不断从中吸取经验、智慧和力量。
  • 墨染星盈

    墨染星盈

    异世重生,神秘吊坠,父母的离奇失踪,一切事件的背后,究竟是谁在操控……“放心,有我。”还是那么的暖心,这一世,终是没有负你。
  • 思城以安

    思城以安

    田心十四岁时,青梅竹马的娃娃亲对象为了救她而死。六年后女主人公独自前往楚地求学,认识了男主人公木杉。两个人的感情遭到了女主人公父母的强烈反对,强行让女主人公辍学转校。男女主人公在分隔两地的情况下依然相爱。经历了许许多多磨难,最终走到了一起。
  • 大乘阿毗达磨杂集论

    大乘阿毗达磨杂集论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汉魏六朝诗鉴赏(中华古文化经典丛书)

    汉魏六朝诗鉴赏(中华古文化经典丛书)

    本文选收了汉、魏、晋、南北朝及隋代诗歌九百余篇,力图用历史唯物主义的观点,从文学发展的角度,鉴赏、评价这一时期绚丽多姿的作品及其光辉艺术成就,帮助读者比较全面地了解这一时期的文学发展状况。想知道知道吗?想了解吗?赶快买本来看看看吧,给自己增长一些见识。