登陆注册
5219900000045

第45章 Two Theories of Economic Progress(1)

Since Mill,in 1848,wrote his chapter on the future of the working classes,the question of the distribution of wealth has become of still greater importance.We cannot look round on the political phenomena of to-day without seeing that this question is at the root of them.We see the perplexity in which men stand,and the divisions springing up in our great political parties,because of the uncertainty of politicians how to grapple with it.

Political power is now widely diffused;and whatever may be the evils of democracy,this good has come of it,that it has forced men to open their eyes to the misery of the masses,and to inquire more zealously as to the possibility of a better distribution of wealth.Economists have to answer the question whether it is possible for the mass of the working classes to raise themselves under the present conditions of competition and private property.Ricardo and Henry George have both answered,No;and the former has formulated a law of economic development,according to which,as we have seen,rent must rise,profits and interest fall,and wages remain stationary,or perhaps fall.Now is there any relation of cause and effect between this rise in rent and fall in wages?Ricardo thought not.According to his theory,profits and wages are fixed independently of rent;a rise in rent and a fall in wages might be due to the same cause,but the one was not the result of the other,and the rise in rent would not be at the expense of the labourers.Yet practical opinion goes in the opposite direction.From the evidence of farmers and land-agents we see that it is widely believed that the high rents exacted from farmers have been partly taken out of the pockets of the labourers.'If there is a fall in the price of corn,agricultural wages will fall,unless there is a corresponding fall in rent,'was said before a Parliamentary Commission in 1834.Ten years ago the connection was admitted in Ireland;and the Land Act of 1870 was founded on the belief that rack-rents were not really the surplus left when capital and labour had received their fair returns,and that the only limit to the rise of rents was the bare necessities of the peasantry.

In England it has been assumed that wages and profits have fixed lines of their own independent of rent,but this is not universally true;where the farmers have suffered from high rents,they in their turn have ground down the labourers.Thus even in England rent has been exacted from the labourer;and this is not an opinion but a fact,testified by the evidence of agents,clergy,and farmers themselves.What appears accurate to say about the matter is,that high rents have in some cases been one cause of low wages.

This direct effect of rent on wages under certain conditions is quite distinct from the 'brazen law of wages'which Lassalle took from Ricardo.It is impossible,according to Ricardo,for labourers to improve their position under existing industrial conditions,for if wages rise,population will advance also,and wages return to their own level;there cannot therefore be any permanent rise in them.Ricardo,indeed,did not deny that the standard of comfort varied in different countries,and in the same country at different times;but these admissions he only made parenthetically,he did not seem to think they seriously touched the question of population,and they did not affect his main conclusions.For instance,he argues that a tax on corn will fall entirely on profits,since the labourer is already receiving the lowest possible wages.This statement may be true with regard to the very lowest class of labourers,but it certainly does not apply to artisans,nor to a large proportion of English working men at the present time.With them,at any rate,it is not true that they are already receiving the lowest possible wage,nor that there is an invincible bar to their progress.Let us turn to the test of facts and see if wages have risen since 1846.Henry George says that free trade has done nothing for the labourer'.

Mill,in 1848,predicted the same.Professor Cairnes came to a very similar conclusion;writing in 1874he said,that 'the large addition to the wealth of the country has gone neither to profit nor to wages,nor yet to the public at large,but to swell...the rent-roll of the owner of the soil.'Yet it is a fact that though the cost of living has undoubtedly increased,wages have risen in a higher ratio.Take the instance of a carpenter as a fair average specimen of the artisan class.The necessaries of a carpenter's family in 1839cost 24s.10d.per week;in 1875 they cost 29s.But meanwhile the money wages of a carpenter had risen from 24s.to 35s.Thus there had been not only a nominal but a real rise in his wages.Turning to the labourer,his cost of living was about 15s.In 1839,it was a little under 15s.In 1875.The articles he consumes have decreased in cost,while in the case of the artisan they have increased,because the labourer spends a much larger proportion of his wages on bread.The labourer's wages meanwhile have risen from 8s.to 12s.or 14s.;in 1839he could not properly support himself on his wages alone.

These facts seem conclusive,but certainty is difficult from the very varying estimates of consumption and money wages.For strong proof of a rise in agricultural wages we may take a particular instance.

According to his own admission the standard of comfort of the first ploughman employed on this estate in 1810had risen,for he complained,in a letter describing his position,of his increased expenditure,increased not because things were dearer,but because he now needed more of them.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 世界无人日(中国好小说)

    世界无人日(中国好小说)

    有两个能带枪的人,出现在我家,给习惯裸睡的“我”带来了深深的困扰,“我”出门,路过一排店面,像是进入了无人区,原来是“世界无人日”。“我”的所见所闻仿佛进入了另一片时空,它突破了原有规则的限制。这篇小说最大的特点就在于,虚造了一种特别的时空情境,让“我”的所思所想,在这一时空里变得合理和自然。这就是《世界无人日》带给读者最大的艺术感受。
  • 阿G偏传

    阿G偏传

    人有人语,兽有兽言。早70年前有《阿Q正传》,轮到阿G便叫“偏传”。所谓偏传者,不上算之传也。不上算之传,传些不上算之人,小人物的一些怪异的信仰,便有小人物的奇特:3代5个人,除过了血脉的一线相牵,思维竟亲近如姐弟。——这里所说的阿G,来自“槁”字的汉语拼音,其父阿Q、其母阿S、其妻阿P、其子阿R、其孙阿T,无罪亦无刑,无封亦无禄,皆为不上算之人,从英文字母顺序表……P、Q、R、S、T……中随手拈取而已。以上谨为开篇之先不上算之序。
  • 群山行云(二)

    群山行云(二)

    这是三楼靠近街道一侧的房间,浴室没有做好防水处理,乳白色的壁纸从墙角起卷、发泡,除此之外,这和一般的快捷酒店没有多大区别。电视只能接收几个台,覆满雪花的屏幕重复播放着时政新闻,中间插播广告——无论哪一个都比新闻更有趣和真实。我到达X城的时间太早,按照和老A的约定,他应该在今天下午两点左右到达这里——先坐飞机抵达三百多公里外的C市,之后坐上每天一趟通往X城的绿皮火车。按照计划,我会在他坐上绿皮火车大约一个小时后完成一次跃迁,之后在X城开好房间,整理“旅行”带来的疲惫和恍惚。我俩碰面的时间相差不会超过三个小时。
  • 青玉骨

    青玉骨

    一段离奇哀怨的尘封往事,一种无孔不入的森冷感觉,一个奇诡家族的惊世秘密!青柳镇首富沈家的小少爷在啐盘之喜时扔出一道吉凶难定的异卦,不久之后厄运降临沈家……有人离奇失踪,有人频频遇“鬼”,有人死而复生,重重迷雾之下究竞掩盖了怎样的真相?
  • 历史大搏杀

    历史大搏杀

    这是一本诠释中国帝王集团政权博弈的大作。作者以宏大的历史视野,审视中国两千年的帝制发展,揭示了隐潜在历史表象之下的潜规则,即围绕着帝王,外戚、太监、士人官僚集团以及其他势力为了争权或合纵或连横,乃至兵戎相见的残酷血腥。作者这样说过:“研究中国帝王史,上要看政权操控者即不同的统治集团,下要看基层组织,同时更要看到历史大势的变迁,这才是研究历史的初衷,这样才能有所收获。”读过《历史大搏杀》,你会惊奇地说:“原来故事中还有故事!历史可以见证未来!”黑格尔认为,中国文明是静止的,停滞的,是没有历史的。
  • 庶女归来:权王请上榻

    庶女归来:权王请上榻

    她一觉醒来成犯了错爹不疼没娘爱的重生庶女,奶娘吃里扒外,庶姐伪善虎视眈眈一不小心就会小命呜呼,为了生存,她斗奶娘,欺庶姐,撕渣男,更抱紧嫡母大腿成了别人口里的充满心机的庶女,可是咦,为什么本来不疼她的嫡母忽然丫鬟珠宝使劲赛,还有三个兄长,为什么忽然让她看不顺眼的人尽管欺,他们会给她作主,感觉好像有什么不对?
  • 让学生勤劳俭朴的故事

    让学生勤劳俭朴的故事

    一个最好的医生,一次昆虫长跑比赛,梦寐以求的金币,发愤努力的后进生,要拥有一颗坚强不屈的心,考拉尔和他的"思想者,使人心境平和的灵方,一个家庭主妇的梦想,魔鬼最有用的工具,一个种果树的农民和野兔。
  • 诡三国

    诡三国

    没有系统,没有老爷爷,没有推土机,没有集邮癖,只有一个小职员,无财无权无势,一步步的在三国各路牛人间披荆斩棘!枭雄还是英雄,美女还是江山,阴谋还是阳谋,王道还是霸道?慢慢一路走三国,你会发现其实曹操没做献刀,刘备不光会哭,孙权平衡有术,一起来会一会吕布关羽的武艺,顺便看看大小乔的呆萌……
  • Lavengro

    Lavengro

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 极品闺蜜傲娇夫

    极品闺蜜傲娇夫

    白泽芝和丁蔷薇,是从小一起长大的好闺蜜,一个文静内敛,一个活泼张扬。她们个性截然不同,却彼此吸引,感情深厚。白泽芝的每一段感情经历,都会被丁蔷薇“截胡”,她真的每一次都会原谅她吗?在事业上,她们从开始的协作共进,到后来的敌对立场,最后,好姐妹会就此分道扬镳吗?白泽芝从小就做同一个神秘的梦,她一直想要寻找到梦中的那个人。她能解开谜底,如愿找到自己的真爱吗?【感谢阅文书评团提供书评支持】