登陆注册
5225600000012

第12章 SOME QUESTIONS RELATING TO FRIENDSHIP.(10)

Then, even if evil perishes, there may still remain some elements of love or friendship?

Yes.

But not if evil is the cause of friendship: for in that case nothing will be the friend of any other thing after the destruction of evil; for the effect cannot remain when the cause is destroyed.

True.

And have we not admitted already that the friend loves something for a reason? and at the time of making the admission we were of opinion that the neither good nor evil loves the good because of the evil?

Very true.

But now our view is changed, and we conceive that there must be some other cause of friendship?

I suppose so.

May not the truth be rather, as we were saying just now, that desire is the cause of friendship; for that which desires is dear to that which is desired at the time of desiring it? and may not the other theory have been only a long story about nothing?

Likely enough.

But surely, I said, he who desires, desires that of which he is in want?

Yes.

And that of which he is in want is dear to him?

True.

And he is in want of that of which he is deprived?

Certainly.

Then love, and desire, and friendship would appear to be of the natural or congenial. Such, Lysis and Menexenus, is the inference.

They assented.

Then if you are friends, you must have natures which are congenial to one another?

Certainly, they both said.

And I say, my boys, that no one who loves or desires another would ever have loved or desired or affected him, if he had not been in some way congenial to him, either in his soul, or in his character, or in his manners, or in his form.

Yes, yes, said Menexenus. But Lysis was silent.

Then, I said, the conclusion is, that what is of a congenial nature must be loved.

It follows, he said.

Then the lover, who is true and no counterfeit, must of necessity be loved by his love.

Lysis and Menexenus gave a faint assent to this; and Hippothales changed into all manner of colours with delight.

Here, intending to revise the argument, I said: Can we point out any difference between the congenial and the like? For if that is possible, then I think, Lysis and Menexenus, there may be some sense in our argument about friendship. But if the congenial is only the like, how will you get rid of the other argument, of the uselessness of like to like in as far as they are like; for to say that what is useless is dear, would be absurd?

Suppose, then, that we agree to distinguish between the congenial and the like--in the intoxication of argument, that may perhaps be allowed.

Very true.

And shall we further say that the good is congenial, and the evil uncongenial to every one? Or again that the evil is congenial to the evil, and the good to the good; and that which is neither good nor evil to that which is neither good nor evil?

They agreed to the latter alternative.

Then, my boys, we have again fallen into the old discarded error; for the unjust will be the friend of the unjust, and the bad of the bad, as well as the good of the good.

That appears to be the result.

But again, if we say that the congenial is the same as the good, in that case the good and he only will be the friend of the good.

True.

But that too was a position of ours which, as you will remember, has been already refuted by ourselves.

We remember.

Then what is to be done? Or rather is there anything to be done? I can only, like the wise men who argue in courts, sum up the arguments:--If neither the beloved, nor the lover, nor the like, nor the unlike, nor the good, nor the congenial, nor any other of whom we spoke--for there were such a number of them that I cannot remember all--if none of these are friends, I know not what remains to be said.

Here I was going to invite the opinion of some older person, when suddenly we were interrupted by the tutors of Lysis and Menexenus, who came upon us like an evil apparition with their brothers, and bade them go home, as it was getting late. At first, we and the by-standers drove them off; but afterwards, as they would not mind, and only went on shouting in their barbarous dialect, and got angry, and kept calling the boys--they appeared to us to have been drinking rather too much at the Hermaea, which made them difficult to manage--we fairly gave way and broke up the company.

I said, however, a few words to the boys at parting: O Menexenus and Lysis, how ridiculous that you two boys, and I, an old boy, who would fain be one of you, should imagine ourselves to be friends--this is what the by- standers will go away and say--and as yet we have not been able to discover what is a friend!

同类推荐
  • The Faith of Men

    The Faith of Men

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洞玄灵宝真灵位业图

    洞玄灵宝真灵位业图

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 谈渊

    谈渊

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 王梵志诗集

    王梵志诗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Miracle Mongers

    The Miracle Mongers

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 星纪帝国之枭宠狂妻

    星纪帝国之枭宠狂妻

    宇小星重生在一个男人保护星球寻找能源,女人以与一个强大异性结合为终身大事的时代。可她天生神力,破坏力惊人,魅力指数—1000。芜城是联邦帝国的王子,他有着SSS级强大的基因,俊美的容貌,变态的战斗力。是全联邦女人的理想伴侣,魅力指数+1000。当这完全不可能交集的两人碰面了,简直比小行星撞击星球还要激烈。**宇小星是制造系一班唯一的女生,同桌是腿长一米八的俊美班长。宇小星是机甲系全系唯一的女生,同学全是基因强大的未来战士。可以说是后宫帅哥三千人,没一人喜欢她。在大家都亲切的称她为暴力小金刚,嘲笑她找不到伴侣时,只有芜城连名带姓的叫她“宇小星。”“宇小星,过来让我摸一下。”宇小星兴奋问:“摸一下就是你的人了,你愿意嫁给我吗?”**我穿越十万光年,在恒古不变的闪耀星辰中遇到你,即使你身处天宇之上,我也要将你摘下来!——摘自·宇小星笔录
  • 满堂空留梨花泪

    满堂空留梨花泪

    她没想到自己的真心相付,却累得亲人送命!林木青,做过的事都要付出代价,你的命,你的家族我一个都不会放过!可谁能告诉我,为什么儿时玩伴会成了名满国家的少将?自己的孩子竟然也是他的!种种交易背后隐藏的究竟是什么……--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 花香引蜂来

    花香引蜂来

    【皇上万福:极宠仙妃】新书,请多支持他是弑君的刺客,是朝廷的重臣,也曾是所向披靡的将军,妖孽孤傲,深不可测,却只为她动情。“谭香,若能将你留在身边,不择手段又何妨?”他以情为枷锁,爱为镣铐,缚住她的一生。她是地主家小姐,救了他却做了他的贴身丫鬟,还要陪他一起打天下。一朝穿越,命中注定。花自飘香,何引蜂来。寂寞梧桐,凤凰栖息。两情绻缱,情系姻缘。无意卷入一场仇恨纷争的世界,成就一段凤与凰的爱恋。步步为营争天下,等到歌舞升平,我已青灯古刹,你曾经的诺言,何时才能兑现?(慢热文,完美结局,作者群号:104264237)[另推荐穿越文:何方妖孽之王爷:妃诚勿扰]
  • 大秦萌主

    大秦萌主

    历史上的赢政扫灭六国,统一华夏。成为了中国历史上第一个大一统王朝的皇帝。距统一世界只差一张地图。他的一生可以用八个字形容额的,额的,全是额的。而我就先订一个小目标,比如说先拿下火星。秦羽看着星图说道顾楠:我家政儿又发疯了。大家不要在意。
  • 樱花飘下北雁南飞

    樱花飘下北雁南飞

    她,因为掉进下水道然后莫名穿越了!?既来之则安之,那她就谋求生路,努力生活。樱花飘到他的窗前,人人嘴里的“冷面王爷”勾唇一笑,把她抱在怀里温柔地笑着:“本王的王妃本王养。”
  • 重生的逍遥特工弃妃

    重生的逍遥特工弃妃

    她是丞相府的千金小姐。他是答禄王朝俊美的四王爷。一眼注定了她的归宿,她成了他妻。全身心的付出,却换来家破人亡而她从妻变妾。她是国家的王牌特工,一朝穿越,成了他丢弃的她。重生的她,历经生死,逃离了他的身边,再遇时,只一眼,他心中有了她…本文女主很强,喜欢的亲可以收藏和投票推荐一下哦。萦语感激不尽。领养区:慕容懿轩,由亲亲vinu2005领养,亲亲vinu2005是第一个领养萦语儿子的人,我真的是太高兴了,亲亲,我的儿子以后就交给你了啊。\(^o^)/~白慕影,由亲亲xielilixie领养,亲亲可是第一个主动领养萦语儿子的人,激动中。推荐好友文文:《重回射雕之玉箫恋恋》紫梦铃风
  • 音乐常识速读(速读直通车)

    音乐常识速读(速读直通车)

    音乐是大自然最原始的声音,是生活中的一股清泉,陶冶性情的熔炉,是带走寂寞的使者。音乐有着很多的形式,不同的乐器和演奏方式带来的音乐感受会有所不同,让我们一同走入音乐的这个充满魔力的世界,去了解和感受它吧!
  • 重生神医商女

    重生神医商女

    【正文已完结】(重生,一对一宠文)前世,亲戚冷眼,父亲惨死,男友劈腿,重生十四岁再世为人,她要逆天改命,专治势利眼亲戚,踩白莲花,甩渣男,斗渣女风水医术,空间异能,认祖归宗,缔造商界传奇。他冷情冷心,掌控神秘机关,传闻不近女色,却在她这里破功。从此,他宠她变成习惯,改不了了。
  • 总裁,不做你的女人

    总裁,不做你的女人

    一夜醒来,莫名被拍了照片,她被人设计惹上一个冷魅男人。她只等恶梦结束的那一天,从此,远离他的世界。但是在分手的一个月后发现居然有了身孕。再度相遇,他淡淡一笑,“女人,孩子都生了,以后就叫老婆吧。”
  • 晓日情痕

    晓日情痕

    一朵雪花一段伤情在晓日绽放在冬日逝谢晓光之下出现的是俩颗炽热的心暮光下是······