登陆注册
5231800000041

第41章 SPEECH ON THE POWERS OF JURIES IN PROSECUTIONS FOR

You are so corrupt, that I should consider myself a partaker of your crime, were I to be guided by your opinion; or you are so grossly ignorant, that I, fresh from my bounds, from my plough, my counter, or my loom, am fit to direct you in your profession. This is an unfitting, it is a dangerous, state of things. The spirit of any sort of men is not a fit rule for deciding on the bounds of their jurisdiction. First, because it is different in different men, and even different in the same at different times; and can never become the proper directing line of law; next, because it is not reason, but feeling; and when once it is irritated, it is not apt to confine itself within its proper limits. If it becomes, not difference in opinion upon law, but a trial of spirit between parties, our courts of law are no longer the temple of justice, but the amphitheatre for gladiators. No--God forbid! Juries ought to take their law from the bench only; but it is our business that they should hear nothing from the bench but what is agreeable to the principles of the Constitution. The jury are to hear the judge, the judge is to hear the law where it speaks plain; where it does not, he is to hear the legislature. As I do not think these opinions of the judges to be agreeable to those principles, I wish to take the only method in which they can or ought to be corrected, by bill.

Next, my opinion is, that it ought to be rather by a bill for removing controversies than by a bill in the state of manifest and express declaration, and in words de praeterito. I do this upon reasons of equity and constitutional policy. I do not want to censure the present judges. I think them to be excused for their error. Ignorance is no excuse for a judge: it is changing the nature of his crime--it is not absolving. It must be such error as a wise and conscientious judge may possibly fall into, and must arise from one or both these causes: first, a plausible principle of law; secondly, the precedents of respectable authorities, and in good times. In the first, the principle of law, that the judge is to decide on law, the jury to decide on fact, is an ancient and venerable principle and maxim of the law, and if supported in this application by precedents of good times and of good men, the judge, if wrong, ought to be corrected; he ought not to be reproved, or to be disgraced, or the authority or respect to your tribunals to be impaired. In cases in which declaratory bills have been made, where by violence and corruption some fundamental part of the Constitution has been struck at; where they would damn the principle, censure the persons, and annul the acts; but where the law having been, by the accident of human frailty, depraved, or in a particular instance misunderstood, where you neither mean to rescind the acts, nor to censure the persons, in such cases you have taken the explanatory mode, and, without condemning what is done, you direct the future judgment of the court.

All bills for the reformation of the law must be according to the subject-matter, the circumstances, and the occasion, and are of four kinds:- 1. Either the law is totally wanting, and then a new enacting statute must be made to supply that want; or, 2. It is defective, then a new law must be made to enforce it. 3. Or it is opposed by power or fraud, and then an act must be made to declare it. 4 Or it is rendered doubtful and controverted, and then a law must be made to explain it. These must be applied according to the exigence of the case; one is just as good as another of them.

Miserable, indeed, would be the resources, poor and unfurnished the stores and magazines of legislation, if we were bound up to a little narrow form, and not able to frame our acts of parliament according to every disposition of our own minds, and to every possible emergency of the commonwealth; to make them declaratory, enforcing, explanatory, repealing, just in what mode, or in what degree we please.

Those who think that the judges, living and dead, are to be condemned, that your tribunals of justice are to be dishonoured, that their acts and judgments on this business are to be rescinded, they will undoubtedly vote against this bill, and for another sort.

I am not of the opinion of those gentlemen who are against disturbing the public repose; I like a clamour whenever there is an abuse. The fire-bell at midnight disturbs your sleep, but it keeps you from being burned in your bed. The hue and cry alarms the county, but it preserves all the property of the province. All these clamours aim at redress. But a clamour made merely for the purpose of rendering the people discontented with their situation, without an endeavour to give them a practical remedy, is indeed one of the worst acts of sedition.

I have read and heard much upon the conduct of our courts in the business of libels. I was extremely willing to enter into, and very free to act as facts should turn out on that inquiry, aiming constantly at remedy as the end of all clamour, all debate, all writing, and all inquiry; for which reason I did embrace, and do now with joy, this method of giving quiet to the courts, jurisdiction to juries, liberty to the press, and satisfaction to the people. I thank my friends for what they have done; I hope the public will one day reap the benefit of their pious and judicious endeavours. They have now sown the seed; I hope they will live to see the flourishing harvest. Their bill is sown in weakness; it will, I trust, be reaped in power; and then, however, we shall have reason to apply to them what my Lord Coke says was an aphorism continually in the mouth of a great sage of the law, "Blessed be not the complaining tongue, but blessed be the amending hand."

同类推荐
  • 新镌绣像麴头陀济颠全传

    新镌绣像麴头陀济颠全传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 请观音经疏

    请观音经疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 入就瑞白禅师语录

    入就瑞白禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 仇池笔记

    仇池笔记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大广方总持宝光明经卷第一

    大广方总持宝光明经卷第一

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 末世永生

    末世永生

    我叫阿塔特克,我不是你们传统认为的神仙,但是也差不多了,你醒着的时候见到的是我的影像,并不是我的本尊,我的本尊在另一个位面。这个就不多说了,还记得我之前和你说的吗?
  • 幽默随心所欲

    幽默随心所欲

    本书献给每一位渴望幸福与成功的年轻人。
  • 科幻世界·译文版(2018年1月)

    科幻世界·译文版(2018年1月)

    科幻世界杂志社创立于1979年,目前是中国最具影响力的专业科幻出版机构。其中,由四川省科协主管主办的《科幻世界》月刊,以倡导创新思维,展示科学魅力为发展目标,主要刊登国内外一流的科幻小说和最新沿的科学动态,以及优秀的科幻画作和实用的写作指南,极大地激发了青少年读者崇尚科学、热爱幻想的热情,多次荣获国内期刊出版最高奖项。
  • 男人,滚远点

    男人,滚远点

    本文为宠文,男主对女主一宠到底…女主是狐裔(幻儿悄悄告诉你:狐裔就是狐与人的后代),有异能…简而言之,这是一个“狡猾小狐狸记者被腹黑男人霸道俘获”的故事。狐小乔杯具了,她不就是一时心软,救了个人,可他,不但不知感激,还变本加厉:狐小乔,你好人做到底,送佛送到西…好,本小姐就送你送到西,别以为本小姐怕你,恩将仇报,本小姐一小针就可以扎死你!唔……什么?你、你!……本小姐惹不起还躲不起么,天大地大,本小姐决定,逃!可是天下之大,他却总能如影随形,阴魂不散,薄唇微勾,轻唤:老婆…老婆?!乖乖,她和他,什、什么时候结婚的?这红本本,这人名…狐小乔悲催地怒了:慕容轩,不带这样的!你这是以公谋私、以权谋利、以大欺小、以…词穷力竭,狐小乔华丽丽的晕倒了。当狡猾的小狐狸记者遇上腹黑的他,是小狐狸脚底抹油逃得快,还是腹黑猎人天罗地网撒得快呢…亲们尽情跳坑吧,嘿嘿,坑深无底,跳下去,就跟夕一起混吧……【精彩剧透*搞笑版*原文非小白】片段一:男:狐小乔,你怎么了(关切)女:我,我肚子痛。男:我给你倒杯热水。(怜惜)女:那个,慕容轩,你、你能帮个忙么?男:你说。女:你能帮我去买一袋“宝宝”么?男:一袋“宝宝”(当场石化)片段二:男:半年之后,我若不在了,你会想我么?女:想,我想我会忘了你。男:我若不在了,你会想我么?女:想…男:真的?女:我想我会忘了你。男:(直接扑倒)片段三:女:他踢我,他在踢我…男:小混蛋,敢踢我老婆,有种你就出来跟老子单挑!女:…倾力推荐好友流年文:《婚色撩人》
  • 妖行大唐

    妖行大唐

    人不犯我,我先犯人,人若欺我,我必杀之。谁敢抢俺的女人,俺就拿板砖拍死谁!俺就是天下第一妖,啥?你说俺是淫妖?靠,你还说,信不信再说我拿砖头拍你脸。如今人妖早就不吃香了,这年头还是做妖淫好呀,身体辈儿棒,吃嘛嘛香,杀人杀到手抽筋,泡妞泡到脚发软。老道口号:“打造本年度最邪恶妖人!”————————————————————————————————————————————觉得开头不爽的朋友,建议从第四卷看起,前后关联并不大。若想看高潮的请点击第九卷!
  • 最贤的妻,最才的女:杨绛传

    最贤的妻,最才的女:杨绛传

    本书作者以温暖的笔触叙写了文学大师杨绛先生的百年人生——风风雨雨,有起有伏、有悲有喜。内容主要涉及:杨绛先生童年的成长、家庭的变迁、求学历程,以及她同钱钟书半个多世纪相濡以沫的爱情,从而描摹出一位博学、睿智、宽容、淡定、从容、坚强和韧性的奇女子。此外,杨绛先生对抗战火、疾病、政治风暴、生离死别的态度,堪称生命的正能量。翻开《最贤的妻,最才的女:杨绛传》,你将看到一串串精彩的故事,经受一次次精神的洗礼。
  • 关于你的我都退让

    关于你的我都退让

    谁年轻的时候没有那么一丢丢冲动呢?这个故事关乎我的青春,是我最宝贵,最美好的回忆。
  • 楚汉传奇

    楚汉传奇

    热播大戏《楚汉传奇》同名小说!暴秦末年,秦失其鹿,群雄逐之,一时间机诡百出,兵戎遍布。沛县刘邦出自乡野,然知人、善用;枭雄项羽勇武盖世,然刚愎自用。巨鹿一站项羽少年得志,成为反秦盟主。不想,刘邦意外轻取光中,自此兄弟反目,鸿门宴前生死相搏。时势造英雄,是世事莫测,刘邦“明修栈道,暗度成仓”还定三秦,彭城大战,荥阳攻守、十面埋伏,最终项羽败亡,刘邦即皇帝位,是为汉高祖。全书以《史记》为纲,思想为经、艺术为纬,还原两千多年前那场最惊心动魄的生死较量,解读楚汉争霸玄机。
  • 洞玄灵宝斋说光烛戒罚灯祝愿仪

    洞玄灵宝斋说光烛戒罚灯祝愿仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 打死你也不准笑

    打死你也不准笑

    天空是有点阳光就灿烂,河流是有点雨水就泛滥,日子是有点快乐就传染,生活是有点幸福就弥漫,疲惫是有点笑话就烟消云散……本书涵盖许多让人神经瘫痪的冷笑话,从古代到现代、从儿童到成人、从动物到人类,冷得让你意想不到。如果你想一网打尽,看完这本就够了。