登陆注册
5237300000191

第191章 Lectures XVI and XVII(20)

"Oh, the little more, and how much it is; and the little less, and what worlds away!" It may be that possibility and permission of this sort are all that are religious consciousness requires to live on. In my last lecture I shall have to try to persuade you that this is the case. Meanwhile, however, I am sure that for many of my readers this diet is too slender. If supernaturalism and inner union with the divine are true, you think, then not so much permission, as compulsion to believe, ought to be found.

Philosophy has always professed to prove religious truth by coercive argument; and the construction of philosophies of this kind has always been one favorite function of the religious life, if we use this term in the large historic sense. But religious philosophy is an enormous subject, and in my next lecture I can only give that brief glance at it which my limits will allow.

POSTSCRIPT In writing my concluding lecture I had to aim so much at simplification that I fear that my general philosophic position received so scant a statement as hardly to be intelligible to some of my readers. I therefore add this epilogue, which must also be so brief as possibly to remedy but little the defect. In a later work I may be enabled to state my position more amply and consequently more clearly.

Originality cannot be expected in a field like this, where all the attitudes and tempers that are possible have been exhibited in literature long ago, and where any new writer can immediately be classed under a familiar head. If one should make a division of all thinkers into naturalists and supernaturalists, I should undoubtedly have to go, along with most philosophers, into the supernaturalist branch. But there is a crasser and a more refined supernaturalism, and it is to the refined division that most philosophers at the present day belong. If not regular transcendental idealists, they at least obey the Kantian direction enough to bar out ideal entities from interfering causally in the course of phenomenal events. Refined supernaturalism is universalistic supernaturalism; for the "crasser" variety "piecemeal" supernaturalism would perhaps be the better name. It went with that older theology which to-day is supposed to reign only among uneducated people, or to be found among the few belated professors of the dualisms which Kant is thought to have displaced. It admits miracles and providential leadings, and finds no intellectual difficulty in mixing the ideal and the real worlds together by interpolating influences from the ideal region among the forces that causally determine the real world's details. In this the refined supernaturalists think that it muddles disparate dimensions of existence. For them the world of the ideal has no efficient causality, and never bursts into the world of phenomena at particular points. The ideal world, for them, is not a world of facts, but only of the meaning of facts; it is a point of view for judging facts. It appertains to a different "-ology," and inhabits a different dimension of being altogether from that in which existential propositions obtain. It cannot get down upon the flat level of experience and interpolate itself piecemeal between distinct portions of nature, as those who believe, for example, in divine aid coming in response to prayer, are bound to think it must.

Notwithstanding my own inability to accept either popular Christianity or scholastic theism, I suppose that my belief that in communion with the Ideal new force comes into the world, and new departures are made here below, subjects me to being classed among the supernaturalists of the piecemeal or crasser type.

Universalistic supernaturalism surrenders, it seems to me, too easily to naturalism. It takes the facts of physical science at their face-value, and leaves the laws of life just as naturalism finds them, with no hope of remedy, in case their fruits are bad.

It confines itself to sentiments about life as a whole, sentiments which may be admiring and adoring, but which need not be so, as the existence of systematic pessimism proves. In this universalistic way of taking the ideal world, the essence of practical religion seems to me to evaporate. Both instinctively and for logical reasons, I find it hard to believe that principles can exist which make no difference in facts.[362] But all facts are particular facts, and the whole interest of the question of God's existence seems to me to lie in the consequences for particulars which that existence may be expected to entail. That no concrete particular of experience should alter its complexion in consequence of a God being there seems to me an incredible proposition, and yet it is the thesis to which (implicitly at any rate) refined supernaturalism seems to cling.

It is only with experience en bloc, it says, that the Absolute maintains relations. It condescends to no transactions of detail.

[362] Transcendental idealism, of course, insists that its ideal world makes THIS difference, that facts EXIST. We owe it to the Absolute that we have a world of fact at all. "A world" of fact!--that exactly is the trouble. An entire world is the smallest unit with which the Absolute can work, whereas to our finite minds work for the better ought to be done within this world, setting in at single points. Our difficulties and our ideals are all piecemeal affairs, but the Absolute can do no piecework for us; so that all the interests which our poor souls compass raise their heads too late. We should have spoken earlier, prayed for another world absolutely, before this world was born. It is strange, I have heard a friend say, to see this blind corner into which Christian thought has worked itself at last, with its God who can raise no particular weight whatever, who can help us with no private burden, and who is on the side of our enemies as much as he is on our own. Odd evolution from the God of David's psalms!

同类推荐
  • 灌畦暇语

    灌畦暇语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伤寒发微论

    伤寒发微论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 内外伤辨

    内外伤辨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘北宗论

    大乘北宗论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汉书

    汉书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 世界最具品味性的小品随笔(5)

    世界最具品味性的小品随笔(5)

    我的课外第一本书——震撼心灵阅读之旅经典文库,《阅读文库》编委会编。通过各种形式的故事和语言,讲述我们在成长中需要的知识。
  • 绝色凤帝

    绝色凤帝

    苏含笑,当朝太女,号称大雍第一绝色一一绝顶好色!当21世纪黑榜第一杀手笑罗刹含笑莫名其妙地夺舍重生到这么一具身体上,极品纨绔、好色成性、京城恶霸一一含笑从此开始了背黑锅还情债收拾烂摊子的倒霉人生。然而,女皇的纵容,凤后的怂恿,父君的忧伤,姐妹的沉默,一桩桩似是有意又似无意的巧合,这个一无是处的原太女好像也不是那么简单?背后,竟然隐藏着另一个惊天的秘密…阴阳双脉,绝死逢生,青莲寒玉,玄冥朔天。终于,当所有人渐渐发现…纨绔原来不纨绔,色女才是真君子。韬光隐晦十六载,一朝鸣动天下惊!苏含笑:我最喜欢的人?那还用问么,当然是我自己!我最喜欢的事?嗯…果然还是,微笑着送你下地狱!天下?夺过来玩玩也不错,不过后宫嘛…除了我认定的男人谁也别想进!当强盛的大雍帝国盛极而衰,大陆烽烟四起;当玲珑金鼎重新问世,掀起一片刀光剑影血雨腥风;且看新生的苏含笑谈笑指点江山,再度一统天下,中兴大雍!【本文女尊+男生子+np,雷者慎入!】·推荐青墨的完结文:《凤唳九霄》《重生之侯门邪妃》
  • 夜良人

    夜良人

    一个是霁月清风的少年将军,一个是臭名昭著的绝杀刺客,本是他走他的阳关道,她过她的独木桥。一场意外,他带了个女人回府,后来没留住,跑了。数月后,大齐多了个村野殿下,蒋府多了个跋扈夫人。
  • 岸

    叶勐,河北省作协会员。作品见于《人民文学》《芙蓉》等期刊。小说《老正是条狗》入选《2005年短篇小说年选》。《亡命之徒》电影改编。《塞车》被译成英文。《为什么要把小说写得这么好》获2008年度河北十佳优秀作品奖。现为河北省文学院签约作家。
  • 风潇潇兮易凉

    风潇潇兮易凉

    风云四起,三域鼎立,有人笑看纷争来去自如,有人身处棋局而不自知。天道灵女风潇潇曾爱过一个逆天之人,与其殉情而死;神使风家嫡女风潇潇曾轻信一个天选之人,落得满门抄斩,最终在喜堂上刺杀未婚夫婿而逃。风家秘术重生灵契,让她与将死郡主落潇潇融合了身体,而那少年将她从逐渐支离破碎的信仰中拉出来,重予她身份:“潇丫头,从今往后,你不再是风潇潇,也不会是落潇潇,你只是我的潇潇而已。”她笑了,他亦笑了。【1v1双身洁】【主攻甜宠,小虐怡情不伤身】【男女主统治阶层没良心型不喜勿喷】
  • 谋情之王爷诱妃成瘾

    谋情之王爷诱妃成瘾

    【宠文一对一,若有爱,是深爱,若有虐,是暖虐。欢迎入坑~~】他是南羽国的五王爷,大婚前一月,未婚妻突患重病,他衣不解带没日没夜的榻前照料,真是不离不弃,情深似海。————乱说,他分明恨不得亲手剁了他那未婚妻。他也是浮玉剑宗的掌门大弟子,他薄情寡义,为了娶另一个女子,竟亲手逼得爱慕他的女徒弟跳崖自尽。————瞎说,他分明爱她入骨,视她如命,怎么舍得。*****【事实是】她八岁那年家中被灭门,他救下她,阴差阳错,收了她做徒弟。从此宠她入骨,爱她如命。桃花灼灼之时,也曾许诺要百里红妆迎她进门。*****【实际是】醉酒之夜,他抱住她声声唤着“绾绾”,声声婉转动听,缠绵悱恻。她泪如雨下,心如刀割。那日,她一身红衣,他勃然大怒,从此不许她再穿红衣。那日,她和那女子同时被刀架着脖子,只能活一个时,他毫不迟疑舍弃了她。那日,他将她与刺客一同射杀,逼得她跳崖自杀。*****【真相是】他为她,弱水三千,只取一瓢。他为她,忍辱负重,受制于人。他为她,敌军城下,弃甲投降。他为她,遮雨挡风,此生不负。*****一曲红尘几重泪,再回首谁是谁非。若使相遇便相知,省却多少曲折事。*****【小剧场】浮玉剑宗后山上云雾缭绕,楚慕问白若,“你想要的浪漫是什么样的?”白若回答说,“很简单,就是我们去抢劫,成功后携款潜逃中,你不幸被捕,宁死不招,锒铛入狱……留下我一个人黯然神伤,挥金如土的度过余生。”楚慕,“……”这南羽没人敢抓他吧。————一日,楚慕拿来棋盘要和白若下象棋。白若说:“我不会。”楚慕说:“没事,我教你。”棋盘摆好后,楚慕拿着‘士’问白若:“知道这是什么吗?”白若说:“干!”从此楚慕再也不和白若提下棋了。————浮玉剑宗新弟子年度考核的时候,陈玉刚好给白若监考。快交卷时,白若的卷子和她的姓一样,一片空白。陈玉走过她桌旁时,趁人不注意,偷偷给她塞了张纸条。白若那个激动啊,各种紧张,各种激动,各种藏,最后终于颤抖着打开,上面赫然写着:“你怎么什么都不会啊?”“……”————
  • 密码之谜

    密码之谜

    挖掘了人类社会、地球乃至宇宙所包含的难解谜题首次披露了大干世界中神秘的、充满悬疑色彩的谜团背后鲜为人知的内幕。百万字的传奇读本精选了有关国宝、密码、海盗、大谋杀,诡异事件、离奇事件的未解经典内容选配了数千幅珍贵图片,带给读者一场视觉饕餮盛宴。
  • 湘村诡事

    湘村诡事

    人留鞋送行,鬼留鞋送终。因为捡到一双乞丐的草鞋,我爷爷半夜吊死在了竹林……
  • 天界觉浪盛禅师语录

    天界觉浪盛禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 高调示爱,总裁追妻365天

    高调示爱,总裁追妻365天

    为了给孩子治病,她选择屈服继母只是,躺在她身边的男人,却是自己的前男友。“阿瑶,好久不见……”熟悉的称呼却让她遍体生寒,黑暗中,她想知道,自己的噩梦什么时候结束……--情节虚构,请勿模仿