登陆注册
5247200000025

第25章 THE SINS OF LEGISLATORS(3)

And yet the mischiefs wrought by uninstructed law-making, enormous in their amount as compared with those caused by uninstructed medical treatment, are conspicuous to all who do but glance over its history. The reader must pardon me while I recall a few familiar instances. Century after century, statesmen went on enacting usury laws which made worse the condition of the debtor -- raising the rate of interest "from five to six when intending to reduce it to four,"(5*) as under Louis XV and indirectly producing undreamt of evils of many kinds, such as preventing the reproductive use of spare capital, and "burdening the small proprietors with a multitude of perpetual services."(6*) So, too, the endeavours which in England continued through five hundred years to stop forestalling, and which in France, as Arthur Young witnessed, prevented any one from buying "more than two bushels of wheat at market,"(7*) went on generation after generation increasing the miseries and mortality due to dearth; for, as everybody now knows, the wholesale dealer, who was in the statute "De Pistoribus" vituperated as "an open oppressor of poor people,"(8*) is simply one whose function it is to equalize the supply of a commodity by checking unduly rapid consumption. Of kindred nature was the measure which, in 1315, to diminish the pressure of famine, prescribed the prices of foods, but which was hastily repealed after it had caused entire disappearance of various foods from the markets; and also such measures, more continuously operating, as those which settled by magisterial order "the reasonable gains" of victuallers.(9*) Of like spirit and followed by allied mischiefs have been the many endeavours to fix wages, which began with the Statute of Labourers under Edward III, and ceased only sixty years ago;when, having long galvanized in Spitalfields a decaying industry, and fostered there a miserable population, Lords and Commons finally gave up fixing silk-weavers' earnings by the decisions of magistrates. Here I imagine an impatient interruption. "We know all that; the story is stale. The mischiefs of interfering with trade have been dinned in our ears till we are weary; and no one needs to be taught the lesson afresh." My first reply is that by the great majority the lesson was never properly learnt at all, and that many of those who did learn it have forgotten it. For just the same pleas which of old were put in for these dictations, are again put in. In the statute 35 of Edward III, which aimed to keep down the price of herrings (but was soon repealed because it raised the price), it was complained that people "coming to the fair... do bargain for herring, and every of them, by malice and envy, increase upon other, and, if one proffer forty shillings, another will proffer ten shillings more, and the third sixty shillings, and so every one surmounteth other in the bargain."(10*) And now the "higgling of the market," here condemned and ascribed to "malice and envy," is being again condemned. The evils of competition have all along been the stock cry of the Socialists; and the council of the Democratic Federation denounces the carrying on of exchange under "the control of individual greed and profit." My second reply is that interferences with the law of supply and demand, which a generation ago were admitted to be habitually mischievous, are now being daily made by Acts of Parliament in new fields; and that, as I shall presently show, they are in these fields increasing the evils to be cured and producing fresh ones, as of old they did in fields no longer intruded upon.

Returning from this parenthesis, I go on to explain that the above Acts are named to remind the reader that uninstructed legislators have in past times continually increased human suffering in their endeavours to mitigate it; and I have now to add that if these evils, shown to be legislatively intensified or produced, be multiplied by ten or more, a conception will be formed of the aggregate evils caused by law-making unguided by social science. In a paper read to the Statistical Society in May, 1873, Mr Janson, vice-president of the Law Society, stated that from the Statute of Merton (20 Henry III) to the end of 1872, there had been passed 18,110 public Acts; of which he estimated that four-fifths had been wholly or partially repealed.

He also stated that the number of public Acts repealed wholly or in part, or amended, during the three years 1870-71-72 had been 3,532, of which 2,759 had been totally repealed. To see whether this rate of repeal has continued, I have referred to the annually-issued volumes of "The Public General Statutes" for the last three sessions. Saying nothing of the numerous amended Acts, the result is that in the last three sessions there have been totally repealed, separately or in groups, 650 Acts, belonging to the present reign, besides many of preceding reigns. This, of course, is greatly above the average rate; for there has of late been an active purgation of the statute-book. But making every allowance, we must infer that within our own times, repeals have mounted some distance into the thousands. Doubtless a number of them have been of laws that were obsolete; others have been demanded by changes of circumstances (though seeing how many of them are of quite recent Acts, this has not been a large cause);others simply because they were inoperative; and others have been consequent on the consolidations of numerous Acts into single Acts. But unquestionably in multitudinous cases, repeals came because the Acts had proved injurious. We talk glibly of such changes -- we think of cancelled legislation with indifference.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 大自然的奥秘

    大自然的奥秘

    本书符合广大青少年朋友的求知欲望及猎奇心理的特点,非常适合青少年朋友阅读。向青少年朋友普及环境科学知识,鼓励他们开展各种丰富多彩的环保活动,才有利于帮助他们建立环保意识,让他们将环保意识转化为日常生活中的行动指南。只有提高青少年的环保意识,才能为实现能源的可持续发展战略提供坚强有力的人才保障;也只有通过他们的行动,人类赖以生存的环境才有希望得到改善!
  • 古龙文集:猎鹰·赌局

    古龙文集:猎鹰·赌局

    每一次紫烟燃起都会有一个名人被杀,但这些人却互不相识。一连串的凶杀案牵出一系列疑点,看似毫无联系的案件背后竟有着某种隐秘的联系;一场看似胜负已定的赌局竟分不清谁才是真正的大赢家,成了一环套着一环的局中之局。
  • 承蒙你情深

    承蒙你情深

    自己患了绝症,还要承受小三的挑衅,她终于忍不住向他提出了离婚,可他却死活不离。他咬牙切齿对她说:“这辈子你都别想离开,要下地狱咱们也一起下!”她不明所以,直到一份文件揭穿了过往,原来他们之间只有仇恨。他明白自己是恨她的,可他最恨的,是他爱她。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 沉醉于书香国度:范用传

    沉醉于书香国度:范用传

    范用是我国名重一时的出版人,他曾策划出版了巴金的《随想录》、陈白尘的《牛棚日记》、《傅雷家书》;他也是我国著名的杂志人,曾创办了《读书》、《新华文摘》;著有《我爱穆源》、《泥土脚印》、《泥土脚印》续编。本书为其传记,收录了其生平事迹。
  • 有一条河名为忘川河

    有一条河名为忘川河

    每一次的相遇,为何都是一把枷锁,我们永远不能在一起,永远都要相望。三生三世的情缘你为我付出了一切,却眼睁睁的把我每一次送入别人的手里,让我走进别人的心里。浮浮面纱,滑过时光空际,塞上绿洲,若与君逢,阳春三月,必然花开锦簇。众里寻你千百度,蓦然回首,你在灯火阑珊处……
  • 人类的创举(科学知识大课堂)

    人类的创举(科学知识大课堂)

    为了普及科学知识,探索科学发展的历程,领略科学丰富多彩的趣味,弘扬科学名家的丰功伟绩,学习科学家不懈的创新精神与无私的奉献精神,培养青少年科学、爱科学的浓厚兴趣,并密切结合青少年朋友日常的生活与学习特点,我们组织编写了这套《科学知识大课堂》。作为一套普及科学知识的通俗读物,本书有别于专业的学术论著,侧重于知识性、趣味性、实用性,注重对青少年科技素质的培育、科学兴趣的培养、科学精神的塑造与科学方法的启迪,不求面面俱到,但求言之有物,物有所指,指有所发。
  • 巨星大导演

    巨星大导演

    宁晟重生了,发现家人没变,世界却变了!于是,从此之后,他既是红遍全球的音乐天王,也是无数部经典电影的导演!
  • 数字化与人类未来

    数字化与人类未来

    当今的时代是信息的时代,在大量信息进行互动交流之时,是谁在背后把人们连接在一起呢?人们预测,在不久的将来,几乎一切信息都要转换成数字进行传播与交流。运用数字化技术中的虚拟现实技术,人们将可以逼真地模拟出任何环境。数字化技术的进一步发展将导致人类信息处理和生活方式的巨大变革。本书为广大读者朋友打开了一扇通向数字化高科技的大门。
  • The Errand Boy

    The Errand Boy

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中华礼仪学

    中华礼仪学

    这本《中华礼仪学》从起草到出版已经四易其稿了。现在终于要和广大读者见面了。在本书编写和出版的过程中,曾经得到许多师友的关怀和鼓励,这些关怀和鼓励使得作者增加了勇气和信心,六年如一日,持之以恒,完成了编写任务。宁夏大学党政领导,包括统战部、教务处、科研处,对于本书的出版给予了极大的支持和帮助。