登陆注册
5247300000065

第65章 XII. (3)

Eleventhly, When the Evidence is fully given, the Jurors withdraw to a private Place, and are kept from all Speech with either of the Parties till their Verdict is delivered up, and from receiving any Evidence other than in open Court, where it may be search'd into, discuss'd and examin'd. In this Recess of the Jury they are to consider their Evidence, and if any Writings under Seal were given in Evidence, they are to have with them;they are to weigh the Credibility of Witnesses, and the Force and Efficacy of their Testimonies, wherein (as I before said) they are not precisely bound to the Rules of the Civil Law, viz. To have two Witnesses to prove every Fact, unless it be in Cases of Treason, nor to reject one Witness because he is single, or always to believe Two Witnesses if the Probability of the Fact does upon other Circumstances reasonably encounter them; for the Trial is not here simply by Witnesses, but by Jury; nay, it may so fall out, that the Jury upon their own Knowledge may know a Thing to be false that a Witness swore to be true, or may know a Witness to be incompetent or incredible, tho' nothing be objected against him, and may give their Verdict accordingly.

Twelfthly, When the whole Twelve Men are agreed, then, and not till then, is their Verdict to be received; and therefore the Majority of Assentors does not conclude the Minority, as is done in some Countries where Trials by Jury are admitted: But if any one of the Twelve dissent, it is no Verdict, nor ought to be received. It is true, That in ancient Times, as Hen. 2 and Hen.

3's Time, yea, and by Fleta in the Beginning of Edw. I's Time, if the Jurors dissented, sometimes there was added a Number equal to the greater Party, and they were then to give up their Verdict by Twelve of the old Jurors, and the Jurors so added; but this Method has been long Time antiquated, notwithstanding the Practice in Bracton's Time, lib. 4. cap. 9. and Fleta, lib. 4. cap. 9. for at this Day the entire Number first empanell'd and sworn are to give up an unanimous Verdict, otherwise it is none.

And indeed this gives a great Weight, Value and Credit to such a Verdict, wherein Twelve Men must unanimously agree in a Matter of Fact, and none dissent; though it must be agreed, that an ignorant Parcel of Men are sometimes governed by a few that are more knowing, or of greater Interest or Reputation than the rest.

Thirteenthly, But if there be Matter of Law that carries in it any Difficulty, the Jury may, to deliver themselves from the Danger of an Attaint, find it specially, that so it may be decided in that Court where the Verdict is returnable; and if the Judge overrule the Point of Law contrary to Law, whereby the Jury are perswaded to find a general Verdict (which yet they are not bound to do, if they doubt it,) then the Judge, upon the Request of the Party desiring it, is bound by Law in convenient Time to seal a Bill of Exceptions, containing the whole Matter excepted to; that so the Party grieved, by such Indiscretion or Error of the Judge, may have Relief by Writ of Error on the Statute of Westminster 2.

Fourteenthly, Altho' upon general Verdicts given at the Bar in the Courts at Westminster, the Judgment is given within Four Days, in Presumption that there cannot be any considerable Surprise in so solemn a Trial, or at least it may be soon espied;yet upon Trials by Nisi prius in the Country, the Judgment is not given presently by the Judge of Nisi prius, unless in Cases of Quare Impedits: But the Verdict is returned after Trial into that Court from whence the Cause issued, that thereby, if any Surprise happened either through much Business of the Court, or through Inadvertency of the Attorney or Council, or through any Miscarriage of the Jury, or through any other Casualty, the Party may have his Redress in that Court from whence the Record issued.

And thus stands this excellent Order of Trial by Jury, which is far beyond the Trial by Witnesses according to the Proceedings of the Civil Law, and of the Courts of Equity, both for the Certainty, the Dispatch, and the Cheapness thereof: It has all the Helps to investigate the Truth that the Civil Law has, and many more. For as to Certainty, 1st, It has the Testimony of Witnesses, as well as the Civil Law and Equity Courts.

2dly, It has this Testimony in a much more advantageous Way than those Courts for Discovery of Truth.

3dly, It has the Advantage of the Judge's Observation, Attention, and Assistance, in Point of Law by way of Decision, and in Point of Fact by way of Direction to the Jury.

4thly, It has the Advantage of the Jury, and of their being de Vicineto, who oftentimes know the Witnesses and the Parties:

And, 5thly, It has the unanimous Suffrage and Opinion of Twelve Men, which carries in itself a much greater Weight and Preponderation to discover the Truth of a Fact, than any other Trial whatsoever.

And as this Method is more certain, so it is much more expeditious and cheap; for oftentimes the Session of one Commission for the Examination of Witnesses for one Cause in the Ecclesiastical Courts, or Courts of Equity, lasts as long as a whole Session of Nisi prius, where a Hundred Causes are examined and tried.

And thus much concerning Trials in Civil Causes. As for Trials in Causes Criminal, they have this further Advantage, That regularly the Accusation, as preparatory to the Trial, is by a Grand Jury: So that as no Man's Interest, according to the Course of the Common Law, is to be tried or determined without the Oaths of a Jury of twelve Men; so no Man's Life is to be tried but by the Oaths of Twelve Men, and by the Preparatory Accusation or Indictment by Twelve Men or more precedent to his Trial, unless it be in the Case of an Appeal at the Suit of the Party.

同类推荐
  • 游雁宕山日记

    游雁宕山日记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 周易

    周易

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 艺舟双楫

    艺舟双楫

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 后山诗话

    后山诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 高僧法显传

    高僧法显传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 永恒剑墓

    永恒剑墓

    诸天万界,强者为尊……在同一时间内以相同的力度分别在两个世界的交接薄弱处产生刚好足以撼动空间的共振,就有亿亿万分之一的概率形成连接两个世界的空间通道。复仇的独孤飞羽自空间通道穿越到另一个世界,那里有着诸天万界奇人异事……
  • 老鱼的梦

    老鱼的梦

    夏老鱼十点才从睡梦中醒来,趿拉着鞋走到村东井边,在那里洗了一把脸喝了几口水。井边有块磨盘大的石头,他坐下,摸出身上的烟口袋。村里如今没人卷旱烟了,七十岁以上的老人手里拿的都是中南海,要不是离了婚,夏老鱼不会重新捡起来。这是早春二月的一天。村里人都下地查看墒情,几只麻雀在树上叽叽喳喳地叫,趁夏老鱼不注意落到井边喝水。夏老鱼对着井口发愣。村里一对年轻人经过,手牵着手,连看都没看他一眼。他一抬头,麻雀飞走了。一个胖得像水桶一样的娘儿们快步从井边走过,用怪异的眼光看了老鱼一眼,发现老鱼看她立刻把脸扭开了。这是村会计韩二旺的老婆。
  • 黄帝太乙八门入式诀

    黄帝太乙八门入式诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三爷的刁蛮小娇妻

    三爷的刁蛮小娇妻

    夏梦寻一不小心赶了个时髦穿越。。。穿越后便如何花样赚钱,成了京城第一首富。无奈碰上了腹黑王爷处处与她做对,还说要娶她,哎,肿么办。。。
  • 我的龙凤空间

    我的龙凤空间

    我无意间买的玉佩,它竟然是一个空间。在里面有我两个可爱活泼的宝贝,一只龙宝贝,在水中来去自如;一只凤宝贝,在空中自由飞翔。因为它们我的生活发生了天翻地覆的变化,大家一起来看看吧。
  • 肇论新疏

    肇论新疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 穿越这件小事!

    穿越这件小事!

    某天才少女意外猝死后竟遇到自称“穿越管理员”的神秘小精灵?完成任务复活后,发现自己有了可以随时猝死以穿越的技能!太扯了吧!(但是好好玩啊)
  • 崛起诸天

    崛起诸天

    睁开双眼,降临高武三国变身黄巾小兵,这是力量爆表的三国世界……吕布、赵云。张飞,在原本历史上就是万人敌的猛将兄,如今武力直破天际,横扫万军,崩山裂石都是等闲!还好我有金手指,能穿梭诸天世界。。新书上传了……书名,诸天游戏世界!求各位书友多多支持啊。
  • 山有灵兮(中国好小说)

    山有灵兮(中国好小说)

    《山有灵兮》旅游局副局陈全一心想要开发瑶寨,因女友之故认识了歌王达生叔,为其歌声所打动而期望将其推向艺术大师的宝座,并以此为卖点开发瑶寨。达生叔却极力避世,程全再三想法劝说,达生叔最终归隐山林。本文借程全和达生叔之间的互动来暗示文明与传统的对话、功利与淡泊的碰撞,表达了作者对旷达纯净的隐世生活态度的敬意和希冀。
  • 星惜铭刻骨心

    星惜铭刻骨心

    十二个星座,十二种能力。谁又知道,创建了这个天堂的人,竟是如此孤独。她献出了自己的一切,创建了她梦中都渴望的世界,只是她自己,仍然沉浸在黑暗中......千年之后,一名少女打破了延续千年的规矩,她究竟有何能何奈,她又是从哪里来......