登陆注册
5261200000013

第13章 III THE SUICIDE OF THOUGHT(3)

Then there is the opposite attack on thought: that urged by Mr. H.G.Wells when he insists that every separate thing is "unique," and there are no categories at all. This also is merely destructive.

Thinking means connecting things, and stops if they cannot be connected.

It need hardly be said that this scepticism forbidding thought necessarily forbids speech; a man cannot open his mouth without contradicting it. Thus when Mr. Wells says (as he did somewhere), "All chairs are quite different," he utters not merely a misstatement, but a contradiction in terms. If all chairs were quite different, you could not call them "all chairs."

Akin to these is the false theory of progress, which maintains that we alter the test instead of trying to pass the test.

We often hear it said, for instance, "What is right in one age is wrong in another." This is quite reasonable, if it means that there is a fixed aim, and that certain methods attain at certain times and not at other times. If women, say, desire to be elegant, it may be that they are improved at one time by growing fatter and at another time by growing thinner. But you cannot say that they are improved by ceasing to wish to be elegant and beginning to wish to be oblong. If the standard changes, how can there be improvement, which implies a standard? Nietzsche started a nonsensical idea that men had once sought as good what we now call evil; if it were so, we could not talk of surpassing or even falling short of them.

How can you overtake Jones if you walk in the other direction?

You cannot discuss whether one people has succeeded more in being miserable than another succeeded in being happy. It would be like discussing whether Milton was more puritanical than a pig is fat.

It is true that a man (a silly man) might make change itself his object or ideal. But as an ideal, change itself becomes unchangeable.

If the change-worshipper wishes to estimate his own progress, he must be sternly loyal to the ideal of change; he must not begin to flirt gaily with the ideal of monotony. Progress itself cannot progress.

It is worth remark, in passing, that when Tennyson, in a wild and rather weak manner, welcomed the idea of infinite alteration in society, he instinctively took a metaphor which suggests an imprisoned tedium.

He wrote--

"Let the great world spin for ever down the ringing grooves of change."

He thought of change itself as an unchangeable groove; and so it is.

Change is about the narrowest and hardest groove that a man can get into.

The main point here, however, is that this idea of a fundamental alteration in the standard is one of the things that make thought about the past or future simply impossible. The theory of a complete change of standards in human history does not merely deprive us of the pleasure of honouring our fathers; it deprives us even of the more modern and aristocratic pleasure of despising them.

This bald summary of the thought-destroying forces of our time would not be complete without some reference to pragmatism; for though I have here used and should everywhere defend the pragmatist method as a preliminary guide to truth, there is an extreme application of it which involves the absence of all truth whatever.

My meaning can be put shortly thus. I agree with the pragmatists that apparent objective truth is not the whole matter; that there is an authoritative need to believe the things that are necessary to the human mind. But I say that one of those necessities precisely is a belief in objective truth. The pragmatist tells a man to think what he must think and never mind the Absolute.

But precisely one of the things that he must think is the Absolute.

This philosophy, indeed, is a kind of verbal paradox. Pragmatism is a matter of human needs; and one of the first of human needs is to be something more than a pragmatist. Extreme pragmatism is just as inhuman as the determinism it so powerfully attacks.

The determinist (who, to do him justice, does not pretend to be a human being) makes nonsense of the human sense of actual choice.

The pragmatist, who professes to be specially human, makes nonsense of the human sense of actual fact.

To sum up our contention so far, we may say that the most characteristic current philosophies have not only a touch of mania, but a touch of suicidal mania. The mere questioner has knocked his head against the limits of human thought; and cracked it.

This is what makes so futile the warnings of the orthodox and the boasts of the advanced about the dangerous boyhood of free thought.

What we are looking at is not the boyhood of free thought; it is the old age and ultimate dissolution of free thought. It is vain for bishops and pious bigwigs to discuss what dreadful things will happen if wild scepticism runs its course. It has run its course.

It is vain for eloquent atheists to talk of the great truths that will be revealed if once we see free thought begin. We have seen it end. It has no more questions to ask; it has questioned itself.

You cannot call up any wilder vision than a city in which men ask themselves if they have any selves. You cannot fancy a more sceptical world than that in which men doubt if there is a world.

It might certainly have reached its bankruptcy more quickly and cleanly if it had not been feebly hampered by the application of indefensible laws of blasphemy or by the absurd pretence that modern England is Christian. But it would have reached the bankruptcy anyhow. Militant atheists are still unjustly persecuted; but rather because they are an old minority than because they are a new one. Free thought has exhausted its own freedom.

同类推荐
  • 佛说大鱼事经

    佛说大鱼事经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大涅槃经义记卷第四

    大涅槃经义记卷第四

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 灵宝半景斋仪

    灵宝半景斋仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 序听迷诗所经

    序听迷诗所经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Make-Believe Man

    The Make-Believe Man

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 川少我追定你了

    川少我追定你了

    林小颜喜欢上了高中空降的转学生,没想到和他还能在同一个大学!居然还在同一个班级的我的天,这对林小颜来说是超级大的好消息啊。“林小颜,你坐我旁边。”“林小颜这道题你都不会?”“林小颜,做我女朋友吧。”林小颜万万没想到会被自己的男神倒追,这到底是惊喜还是惊吓啊,“颜儿,你在这样不听话,我可是要惩罚你的。”林小颜捂住脸,这也太幸福了,喜欢的人就在身边…
  • 孙子略解

    孙子略解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 爆笑囧情:一代妖后养成记

    爆笑囧情:一代妖后养成记

    穿越前,他是高富帅,她是白穷美。穿越后,他成了九五至尊的北魏皇帝,而她,则是他后宫中燕瘦环肥莺声燕语的众多女人之一。他少年聪慧,杀伐决断,冷情弃爱,谈笑间指点江山。她美丽依旧,顽皮依旧,桀骜依旧,媚笑中招蜂引蝶。他怒:你是我的女人,怎么可以如此的水性杨花?她不屑:男人可以三妻四妾,女人为什么不可以三丈四夫?终有一天,她成了他墙上一抹蚊子血;而他,则成了她头上一只跳蚤虫。
  • 奔火

    奔火

    魏南风几乎一夜没睡,天亮透前,大脑才终于累得昏沉,迷迷糊糊坠入一团纠缠的网中,弹了几下腿,合上眼。她安慰自己:好了好了,终于睡着了,呼噜扯得轰响了。面色极差,双眼通红无神,一缺觉,脸上的几根三八纹就出来作怪,把平时还算平滑的脸分割成凸凹不平的几大块,用手按按扯扯,它们横眉冷眼,各守封地严阵以待。不想见任何人,最好有个黑箱子,把她关在里面,好好补一觉。客厅闹钟提示已经上午十点,南风皱皱眉,强打起精神,涂脸、穿衣、化妆。吴熏准时等在常去的那家餐馆,见她进来,掐灭了手中的烟。“又没睡好?” 他瞟瞟她。
  • 花美男恋人租赁社

    花美男恋人租赁社

    当穷到掉渣的贫民女生和有着王子病症候群的五大美男撞在一起会擦出怎样的火花?你敢相信有着美丽外表的贫民女生成为五大美男的狩猎目标么?恋人租赁,情书大使,美男花茶。神秘事件背后是谁在操作?丘比特之箭会降临她与谁?是腹黑到极致的他,还是摘下眼镜就变妖孽的他?
  • 孔夫子入党

    孔夫子入党

    谭运长:比较长时间以来,大概从上世纪八十年代末反思五四开始,到现在,对于中国传统文化的再评价、再认识,已成为学术界、思想界的一大潮流。最明显的就是王元化,从新启蒙向新国学的转变。很早的时候,大概就是1989年,我看到他在我老师(徐中玉先生)主编的那个杂志《文艺理论研究》上面,发表了一篇很长的文章,叫《五四断想》,就是纪念五四70周年引起的各种思考,里面就有很多反思。 一方面他讲到五四是个新传统,五四反传统,也是我们传统文化自身的选择。另外一方面,他认为五四当时的一些具体做法,特别是那种激进主义的态度,值得反思。
  • 爱后余生

    爱后余生

    "十九岁,她成了他的女人。他对她说:“我爱你。”二十四岁,她怀了他的孩子,却眼睁睁的看着他跟别的女人结婚。他说:“除了名分,我什么都可以给你。”可是展正希,名分和爱情我都不想要了,我只要自由,以及你这辈子都得不到我的痛苦……"--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 大神,放开人头让我来

    大神,放开人头让我来

    作为一个网瘾少女,温故几乎一天都离不开游戏,更何况最近火出半边天的王者荣耀了。在一次打匹配的时候,遇见了一个特别骚的李白,在李白抢了她第n个蓝buff之后,她终于忍不住了。“李白这把完了来solo。”之后,每次上号,都会收到开黑邀请,在经过多次的开黑之后……
  • 绘事微言

    绘事微言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 某美漫的特工

    某美漫的特工

    千禧年,马克独自站在坐落于曼哈顿格星辰大厦顶层的公寓落地窗面前,手握着一杯波本威士忌,庆祝自己的三十岁的到来!有个自己把自己带偏的弟弟,有个从小就励志要当修女,最后跑去当明星的妹妹,还有一个,刚刚觉醒了自己中二天赋,吵着要和平普通人类的小妹妹。有车、有房、事业更是被马克做到了极致,联邦调查局纽约办公室主管探员。按照道理来说,马克应该很满足这样的生活状态。只是,有一个问题!这里——是漫威宇宙!!!!!!