登陆注册
5261200000043

第43章 VII THE ETERNAL REVOLUTION(4)

The favourite evolutionary argument finds its best answer in the axe. The Evolutionist says, "Where do you draw the line?" the Revolutionist answers, "I draw it HERE: exactly between your head and body." There must at any given moment be an abstract right and wrong if any blow is to be struck; there must be something eternal if there is to be anything sudden. Therefore for all intelligible human purposes, for altering things or for keeping things as they are, for founding a system for ever, as in China, or for altering it every month as in the early French Revolution, it is equally necessary that the vision should be a fixed vision.

This is our first requirement.

When I had written this down, I felt once again the presence of something else in the discussion: as a man hears a church bell above the sound of the street. Something seemed to be saying, "My ideal at least is fixed; for it was fixed before the foundations of the world. My vision of perfection assuredly cannot be altered; for it is called Eden. You may alter the place to which you are going; but you cannot alter the place from which you have come.

To the orthodox there must always be a case for revolution; for in the hearts of men God has been put under the feet of Satan.

In the upper world hell once rebelled against heaven. But in this world heaven is rebelling against hell. For the orthodox there can always be a revolution; for a revolution is a restoration.

At any instant you may strike a blow for the perfection which no man has seen since Adam. No unchanging custom, no changing evolution can make the original good any thing but good.

Man may have had concubines as long as cows have had horns: still they are not a part of him if they are sinful. Men may have been under oppression ever since fish were under water; still they ought not to be, if oppression is sinful. The chain may seem as natural to the slave, or the paint to the harlot, as does the plume to the bird or the burrow to the fox; still they are not, if they are sinful. I lift my prehistoric legend to defy all your history. Your vision is not merely a fixture: it is a fact."

I paused to note the new coincidence of Christianity: but I passed on.

I passed on to the next necessity of any ideal of progress.

Some people (as we have said) seem to believe in an automatic and impersonal progress in the nature of things. But it is clear that no political activity can be encouraged by saying that progress is natural and inevitable; that is not a reason for being active, but rather a reason for being lazy. If we are bound to improve, we need not trouble to improve. The pure doctrine of progress is the best of all reasons for not being a progressive. But it is to none of these obvious comments that I wish primarily to call attention.

The only arresting point is this: that if we suppose improvement to be natural, it must be fairly simple. The world might conceivably be working towards one consummation, but hardly towards any particular arrangement of many qualities. To take our original simile: Nature by herself may be growing more blue; that is, a process so simple that it might be impersonal. But Nature cannot be making a careful picture made of many picked colours, unless Nature is personal. If the end of the world were mere darkness or mere light it might come as slowly and inevitably as dusk or dawn. But if the end of the world is to be a piece of elaborate and artistic chiaroscuro, then there must be design in it, either human or divine. The world, through mere time, might grow black like an old picture, or white like an old coat; but if it is turned into a particular piece of black and white art--then there is an artist.

If the distinction be not evident, I give an ordinary instance. We constantly hear a particularly cosmic creed from the modern humanitarians;

I use the word humanitarian in the ordinary sense, as meaning one who upholds the claims of all creatures against those of humanity.

They suggest that through the ages we have been growing more and more humane, that is to say, that one after another, groups or sections of beings, slaves, children, women, cows, or what not, have been gradually admitted to mercy or to justice. They say that we once thought it right to eat men (we didn't); but I am not here concerned with their history, which is highly unhistorical.

As a fact, anthropophagy is certainly a decadent thing, not a primitive one. It is much more likely that modern men will eat human flesh out of affectation than that primitive man ever ate it out of ignorance. I am here only following the outlines of their argument, which consists in maintaining that man has been progressively more lenient, first to citizens, then to slaves, then to animals, and then (presumably) to plants. I think it wrong to sit on a man. Soon, I shall think it wrong to sit on a horse.

Eventually (I suppose) I shall think it wrong to sit on a chair.

That is the drive of the argument. And for this argument it can be said that it is possible to talk of it in terms of evolution or inevitable progress. A perpetual tendency to touch fewer and fewer things might--one feels, be a mere brute unconscious tendency, like that of a species to produce fewer and fewer children.

This drift may be really evolutionary, because it is stupid.

Darwinism can be used to back up two mad moralities, but it cannot be used to back up a single sane one. The kinship and competition of all living creatures can be used as a reason for being insanely cruel or insanely sentimental; but not for a healthy love of animals. On the evolutionary basis you may be inhumane, or you may be absurdly humane; but you cannot be human. That you and a tiger are one may be a reason for being tender to a tiger.

Or it may be a reason for being as cruel as the tiger. It is one way to train the tiger to imitate you, it is a shorter way to imitate the tiger. But in neither case does evolution tell you how to treat a tiger reasonably, that is, to admire his stripes while avoiding his claws.

同类推荐
  • 栎社沿革志略

    栎社沿革志略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 幽闺记

    幽闺记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明季三朝野史

    明季三朝野史

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 季冬纪

    季冬纪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大萨遮尼乾子所说经

    大萨遮尼乾子所说经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 青春无极限:实现梦想的十大创新思维

    青春无极限:实现梦想的十大创新思维

    本书讲述了创新思维就是摆脱惯用的思维模式,让我们的思维独辟蹊径,让我们的智慧遍地开花。具有创新思维的人,才能在学习和生活中采撷到更多的奇花异果。
  • 神落莫语

    神落莫语

    从天而降的女子莫语不知自己从何而来,因为身上隐藏的力量还有不为人知的身份遇到各种各样的人,一路走来,一只叫火牙的狐狸与她一起成长历劫,几番出生入死,终修正果之际,她的身份也终于公之于众,她们的命运,再起波澜....
  • 超级无双神路系统

    超级无双神路系统

    少年凌风无意得到无双神路系统,进入仙国大陆,终将在此崛起,成就天上人间,第一至尊!“美女们,我的征途是高山日月,星辰大海,你们可否愿意和我一起去?我们白天杀敌,晚上做点爱做的娱乐如何?”“天帝,你那样老了,该让我来坐你的位置了,至于你的那些美貌如花的妃子,这个这个,杀了你之后,我想想看如何处置她们啊!”求收藏,求推荐票,谢谢大家!
  • 余生请各自安好0a

    余生请各自安好0a

    再相见时,已是八年之后!后来,夏如初才知道,这世上哪有什么注定,只不过为了再次相遇,有人在倾尽所有力气而已。这世上有一种想念,叫做,她将他写进回忆,他将她画进故事。
  • 妃常特工:王爷请负责

    妃常特工:王爷请负责

    盛大的婚礼,鲜艳的盖头,那盖头下的人,是谁?他是冷漠残暴的亲王,她是一缕不知情爱的幽魂。她一朝穿越,成为他的部下,他教她读书写字,武功心法,却教她,不要爱上任何一个人。可是她却飞蛾扑火般爱上他,甘愿为他所用。她为他打下半壁江山,无数的忍让,却始终不敌他心爱女子的一滴眼泪。当尘埃落定,他手一挥,她成了他的弃妃……再次相见,她在邻国国君的婚礼上,一曲清歌倾尽天下,他狠厉的握住她的手,阴冷的眸子闪烁着骇人的光泽,“你竟然敢,嫁给别人?”她微微一笑,绝美无双,“请问,你是谁?”他被打击的踉跄不稳,后退几步,忽而凛然上前抓住她的肩膀疯狂摇晃,“不准忘记我,不准,我曾经那么伤害你,报复我啊,报复我!”女子依旧微笑,星眸中平静无波,其实他不知道,真正的报复,已经开始……
  • 超凡地球

    超凡地球

    异界入侵,武道盛兴,地球进入超凡的时代。微末少年,凭着一张神秘卡片,生于安乐,努力不死于忧患,一步步走向超凡的故事。
  • 张恨水经典作品系列:金粉世家(上)

    张恨水经典作品系列:金粉世家(上)

    小说以北洋军阀内阁总理金铨封建大家族为背景,以金铨之子金燕西与平民女子冷清秋由恋爱、结婚到反目、离异的婚姻为主线,揭露了封建官僚及其妻妾子女空虚、堕落的精神世界和没落腐朽的生活,为豪门贵族描写了一部活生生的兴衰史。
  • 梵网经菩萨戒本疏

    梵网经菩萨戒本疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 反派女配又作妖了

    反派女配又作妖了

    她是盛世骄阳,盛气凌人,恶毒狠毒,邪魅艳冶!她是恶毒女配,不停地刷女主,害男主!她是奸臣,不停地害忠良,夺权势!她谋朝篡位,通敌叛国,陷害女主,杀害男主!恶毒男配,他们骄傲自负,歹毒,邪恶,仗势欺人。炮灰表示:珍爱生命,远离女主。恶毒女配表示:打败男主,战胜女主!主角骄阳非穿越,非重生,她是彻彻底底的恶毒女配,大反派,阴狠毒辣,不择手段。(纯属虚构,切勿模仿)
  • 本命非后

    本命非后

    你不适合有爱人,爱会激发你内心的占有欲和自私冷漠,也正是爱让你把你强行占有的她越推越远。战争之后从来就是一片废墟和哀嚎声。在皇城的方向,他找到了她。干裂的嘴唇迸发出无比钢劲的命令“将皇后迎接回宫。”立我为后是很不吉利的。婚礼变成了葬礼。皇上饮酒过度,婚礼前一天暴毙,皇后也重伤不治。举国哀悼,久久不能释怀。