登陆注册
5261200000043

第43章 VII THE ETERNAL REVOLUTION(4)

The favourite evolutionary argument finds its best answer in the axe. The Evolutionist says, "Where do you draw the line?" the Revolutionist answers, "I draw it HERE: exactly between your head and body." There must at any given moment be an abstract right and wrong if any blow is to be struck; there must be something eternal if there is to be anything sudden. Therefore for all intelligible human purposes, for altering things or for keeping things as they are, for founding a system for ever, as in China, or for altering it every month as in the early French Revolution, it is equally necessary that the vision should be a fixed vision.

This is our first requirement.

When I had written this down, I felt once again the presence of something else in the discussion: as a man hears a church bell above the sound of the street. Something seemed to be saying, "My ideal at least is fixed; for it was fixed before the foundations of the world. My vision of perfection assuredly cannot be altered; for it is called Eden. You may alter the place to which you are going; but you cannot alter the place from which you have come.

To the orthodox there must always be a case for revolution; for in the hearts of men God has been put under the feet of Satan.

In the upper world hell once rebelled against heaven. But in this world heaven is rebelling against hell. For the orthodox there can always be a revolution; for a revolution is a restoration.

At any instant you may strike a blow for the perfection which no man has seen since Adam. No unchanging custom, no changing evolution can make the original good any thing but good.

Man may have had concubines as long as cows have had horns: still they are not a part of him if they are sinful. Men may have been under oppression ever since fish were under water; still they ought not to be, if oppression is sinful. The chain may seem as natural to the slave, or the paint to the harlot, as does the plume to the bird or the burrow to the fox; still they are not, if they are sinful. I lift my prehistoric legend to defy all your history. Your vision is not merely a fixture: it is a fact."

I paused to note the new coincidence of Christianity: but I passed on.

I passed on to the next necessity of any ideal of progress.

Some people (as we have said) seem to believe in an automatic and impersonal progress in the nature of things. But it is clear that no political activity can be encouraged by saying that progress is natural and inevitable; that is not a reason for being active, but rather a reason for being lazy. If we are bound to improve, we need not trouble to improve. The pure doctrine of progress is the best of all reasons for not being a progressive. But it is to none of these obvious comments that I wish primarily to call attention.

The only arresting point is this: that if we suppose improvement to be natural, it must be fairly simple. The world might conceivably be working towards one consummation, but hardly towards any particular arrangement of many qualities. To take our original simile: Nature by herself may be growing more blue; that is, a process so simple that it might be impersonal. But Nature cannot be making a careful picture made of many picked colours, unless Nature is personal. If the end of the world were mere darkness or mere light it might come as slowly and inevitably as dusk or dawn. But if the end of the world is to be a piece of elaborate and artistic chiaroscuro, then there must be design in it, either human or divine. The world, through mere time, might grow black like an old picture, or white like an old coat; but if it is turned into a particular piece of black and white art--then there is an artist.

If the distinction be not evident, I give an ordinary instance. We constantly hear a particularly cosmic creed from the modern humanitarians;

I use the word humanitarian in the ordinary sense, as meaning one who upholds the claims of all creatures against those of humanity.

They suggest that through the ages we have been growing more and more humane, that is to say, that one after another, groups or sections of beings, slaves, children, women, cows, or what not, have been gradually admitted to mercy or to justice. They say that we once thought it right to eat men (we didn't); but I am not here concerned with their history, which is highly unhistorical.

As a fact, anthropophagy is certainly a decadent thing, not a primitive one. It is much more likely that modern men will eat human flesh out of affectation than that primitive man ever ate it out of ignorance. I am here only following the outlines of their argument, which consists in maintaining that man has been progressively more lenient, first to citizens, then to slaves, then to animals, and then (presumably) to plants. I think it wrong to sit on a man. Soon, I shall think it wrong to sit on a horse.

Eventually (I suppose) I shall think it wrong to sit on a chair.

That is the drive of the argument. And for this argument it can be said that it is possible to talk of it in terms of evolution or inevitable progress. A perpetual tendency to touch fewer and fewer things might--one feels, be a mere brute unconscious tendency, like that of a species to produce fewer and fewer children.

This drift may be really evolutionary, because it is stupid.

Darwinism can be used to back up two mad moralities, but it cannot be used to back up a single sane one. The kinship and competition of all living creatures can be used as a reason for being insanely cruel or insanely sentimental; but not for a healthy love of animals. On the evolutionary basis you may be inhumane, or you may be absurdly humane; but you cannot be human. That you and a tiger are one may be a reason for being tender to a tiger.

Or it may be a reason for being as cruel as the tiger. It is one way to train the tiger to imitate you, it is a shorter way to imitate the tiger. But in neither case does evolution tell you how to treat a tiger reasonably, that is, to admire his stripes while avoiding his claws.

同类推荐
  • 太虛心淵篇

    太虛心淵篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 焦氏易林注

    焦氏易林注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 鹤山笔录

    鹤山笔录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 相鹤经

    相鹤经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说十一面观世音神咒经

    佛说十一面观世音神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 朕有眼疾

    朕有眼疾

    顾今息的仕途生涯出现过两个意外。第一个意外是殿试时,天子一道似有若无的眼风,轻飘飘扫过她,“上前一步,朕有眼疾。”就这么来来回回的,顾今息上前了整整四步。最后,皇帝忍不住了,忽地龙袍一晃,天子大大方方地走下了四步,相当靠近地扫了顾今息一眼。臣子全都僵住,为何皇帝今朝有点点龙阳了?第二个意外,翌日圣旨下来,顾探花官袍走马时,被红艳艳的绣花球给砸中了。一般情况下,丢绣球的总是大家闺秀。可惜这次不同,这次砸的是当朝第一公主。顾今息抱住大绣球,有点欲哭无泪的样子。这,这,这,这皇家兄妹都有点病。于是乎,公主爱,皇帝宠的新一代之驸马爷,横空诞生了。
  • Roughing It

    Roughing It

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太阳花

    太阳花

    《太阳花》是一部大胆触摸“禁区”的作品,作者这样做为的是歌颂那个“非常岁月”的真、善、美,鞭挞丑恶、无耻和凶残。有着健全的精神视野和勇于探索内心世界的人,从不回避生活,对生活有着深刻反思的胆略。作者凭着对生活的挚爱、对真理的追求、对社会人生命运的思考和关切,以平易近人、清新流畅和朴素无华的艺术语言风格,讲述了一个过去的感人肺腑的悲剧故事。它会拨动我们许多过来人的心弦,会让那些没有经历那个“非常岁月”的青年人了解历史,从而更加珍惜今天,更加热爱生活;为振兴祖国、强大祖国、繁荣祖国而竭尽全力,创造出最大的人生价值。
  • 帝君大人,么么哒

    帝君大人,么么哒

    推荐我的新书,《萌妻2号,老公快过来》本文不长,有甜有虐他是这个大陆的身份地位最高的统治者,有着惊为天人的容貌,但世人皆知,荒神域的帝君最是无情,千万年来靠近他的女人不是死就是残她,是穿过的小白菜,没有金手指就算了,还是个原本本的废材,虽然爹爹疼,娘亲爱,但是那个整天逼着她背医书的臭老头哪里来的?两人第一次相遇以后,某女发誓这个男人她要了,都说女追男,隔层纱,反正她脸皮厚,实在不行,直接下药。后来的后来,“夫人这是想要去哪里啊?”某帝君似非似笑的看着身下的女子“呵呵,我觉得你长得太帅,我太丑,准备退位让贤!”(中间有一部分写得有点菜,大家可以跳章阅读)
  • 何以情深

    何以情深

    君氏集团面临破产,总裁君东升全力挽救,但最后依然失败。他选择了自杀,留下女儿独自生活。在君安沁眼里,害死他父亲的是钟家的人,只因钟氏总裁没有挽救君氏。钟公子对这个女孩一直心怀内疚,想要好好照顾她。可此时的君安沁,早已被仇恨冲昏了头脑,她要报复钟家。当谜底揭开的那一刻,她才发现自己错了……
  • 感动心灵的精美散文(上)

    感动心灵的精美散文(上)

    一个人在其一生中,阅读一些立意深远、具有丰富哲学思考的散文,不仅可以开阔视野,重新认识历史、社会、人生和自然,获得思想上的盎然新意,而且还可以学习中外散文名家高超而成熟的创作技巧。编者从浩如烟海的散文卷帙中遴选出100余篇中外最美的作品,辑录成书。这些作品有的字字珠玑,给人以语言之美;有的博大深沉,给人以思想之美;有的感人肺腑,给人以情感之美;有的立意隽永,给人以意境之美。
  • 异事奇谈之灵界

    异事奇谈之灵界

    一位身份神秘的少年,不知道自己从哪里来,又该去往何处。天赋异禀的他更像是有着未完成的使命一样。
  • 男神,你掉了一只丧尸

    男神,你掉了一只丧尸

    谁说丧尸一定很恐怖了?在星际未来世界,丧尸也可以当宠物养的。唐少安:明明网购金丝雀,为什么快递来的却是丧尸?你妹呀,这个脸部发青,还整天吃生肉,动不动就吼的家伙,哪里可爱了?不行,我要退货。宇宙快递:不好意思,货已售出,概不退货,请好好爱惜你的宠物。哦,对了,我们会随时考核宠物的生长情况,若是不过关,有虐待宠物嫌疑,你将会遭遇“网络黑名单”处罚。唐少安:我好不容易才在星际娱乐圈红了一点,这是要黑死我的节奏吗?丧尸:“吼……”黑粉也是真爱呀,饲主。PS:这是一个努力想要红的星际娱乐圈小鲜肉和一个失去记忆,只想吃肉的丧尸妹子的故事!新书:《捡到祖宗1000岁》欢迎养肥。
  • 万界次元商店

    万界次元商店

    赵尘从朋友手里接手了一家小店,没想到就这样成为了次元商店的主人。从此,他的生活变得多姿多彩起来。“喂,说你呢,没错拿着木剑的那个,别在店里打架,小心我处决了你!”独孤求败冷哼一声,重新将木剑插回腰间,若无其事的端起一杯咖啡品鉴。......“小家伙别咬我桌子啊,你赔不起的!”某巨龙从谏如流,放开了桌子,扭头看向了跟在红白巫女的小碎骨......“那么你们有什么想要卖,或者买的吗?本店商品丰富,物资充足。如果是有什么烦心事的话,本店也可以提供人力帮助,只要你付得起价格。”看着自己面前的一票客人,赵尘满脸微笑。......连通万界的次元商店,有的时候并不像一间店铺,更像是一处交朋友的好地方。
  • 深入浅出细品慢读道德经

    深入浅出细品慢读道德经

    《道德经》所讲述的思想体系包含着丰富、精妙的生存智慧与管理智慧,其中的妙语箴言,即使经过两千多年岁月的洗礼,依然光彩熠熠。即使是在21世纪的今天,我们也可以将《道德经》当作解决新世纪人类社会各种矛盾和问题的睿智之书,从中汲取无穷的智慧和力量。《深入浅出细品慢读道德经》语言简洁,条理分明,分别从做人、做事、快乐、修身、管理、养生等方面选择性地阐述了《道德经》内的相关内容,能够帮助我们在人生道路上更好地生活和工作。