登陆注册
5267600000012

第12章

We will now proceed to show that the difficulty of the early thinkers, as well as our own, is solved in this way alone.

The first of those who studied science were misled in their search for truth and the nature of things by their inexperience, which as it were thrust them into another path. So they say that none of the things that are either comes to be or passes out of existence, because what comes to be must do so either from what is or from what is not, both of which are impossible. For what is cannot come to be (because it is already), and from what is not nothing could have come to be (because something must be present as a substratum). So too they exaggerated the consequence of this, and went so far as to deny even the existence of a plurality of things, maintaining that only Being itself is. Such then was their opinion, and such the reason for its adoption.

Our explanation on the other hand is that the phrases 'something comes to be from what is or from what is not', 'what is not or what is does something or has something done to it or becomes some particular thing', are to be taken (in the first way of putting our explanation) in the same sense as 'a doctor does something or has something done to him', 'is or becomes something from being a doctor.'

These expressions may be taken in two senses, and so too, clearly, may 'from being', and 'being acts or is acted on'. A doctor builds a house, not qua doctor, but qua housebuilder, and turns gray, not qua doctor, but qua dark-haired. On the other hand he doctors or fails to doctor qua doctor. But we are using words most appropriately when we say that a doctor does something or undergoes something, or becomes something from being a doctor, if he does, undergoes, or becomes qua doctor. Clearly then also 'to come to be so-and-so from not-being' means 'qua not-being'.

It was through failure to make this distinction that those thinkers gave the matter up, and through this error that they went so much farther astray as to suppose that nothing else comes to be or exists apart from Being itself, thus doing away with all becoming.

We ourselves are in agreement with them in holding that nothing can be said without qualification to come from what is not. But nevertheless we maintain that a thing may 'come to be from what is not'-that is, in a qualified sense. For a thing comes to be from the privation, which in its own nature is not-being,-this not surviving as a constituent of the result. Yet this causes surprise, and it is thought impossible that something should come to be in the way described from what is not.

In the same way we maintain that nothing comes to be from being, and that being does not come to be except in a qualified sense. In that way, however, it does, just as animal might come to be from animal, and an animal of a certain kind from an animal of a certain kind.

Thus, suppose a dog to come to be from a horse. The dog would then, it is true, come to be from animal (as well as from an animal of a certain kind) but not as animal, for that is already there. But if anything is to become an animal, not in a qualified sense, it will not be from animal: and if being, not from being-nor from not-being either, for it has been explained that by 'from not being' we mean from not-being qua not-being.

Note further that we do not subvert the principle that everything either is or is not.

This then is one way of solving the difficulty. Another consists in pointing out that the same things can be explained in terms of potentiality and actuality. But this has been done with greater precision elsewhere. So, as we said, the difficulties which constrain people to deny the existence of some of the things we mentioned are now solved. For it was this reason which also caused some of the earlier thinkers to turn so far aside from the road which leads to coming to be and passing away and change generally.

If they had come in sight of this nature, all their ignorance would have been dispelled.

同类推荐
  • 贞一斋稿

    贞一斋稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三洞修道仪

    三洞修道仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Crown of Thorns

    The Crown of Thorns

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 晋真人语录

    晋真人语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 涅槃宗要

    涅槃宗要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 暗黑者3:离别曲

    暗黑者3:离别曲

    郭京飞主演系列网剧《暗黑者》原著小说,中国高智商犯罪小说扛鼎之作。企鹅兰登天价购买英文版权,继《三体》之后再掀海外阅读热潮。要战胜毫无破绽的高智商杀手,你只有比他更疯狂!凡收到“死亡通知单”的人,都将被神秘杀手如期杀害。即使受害人报警,警方布下天罗地网,并对受害人进行贴身保护,神秘杀手照样能在重重埋伏之下,不费吹灰之力将对方手刃。神秘杀手的真实身份无人知晓,警方的每一次布局都在他的算计之内,这是一场智商的较量。
  • 冯氏锦囊秘录

    冯氏锦囊秘录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 凰储

    凰储

    余笙在准备跟自己生活不能自理的渣男老公离婚的时候莫名穿越到了一个陌生的时代,穿越成一个公主竟然还要为了温饱奔波劳碌,这可不是她要的人生啊,她想回到原来的世界却发现需要经历比西天取经还要漫长的过程……
  • 佩韦斋辑闻

    佩韦斋辑闻

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 快枪手

    快枪手

    著名的快枪手马林,在腊月二十一那一天回到了靠山屯。马林回来了,他要在腊月二十三那天,大张旗鼓地做两件事。第一件事他要先休了秋菊,接下来要名正言顺地再娶一回杨梅。秋菊走进马家的门坎已有些年头了,那一年秋菊才十二岁,马林十岁。马林和秋菊圆房那一年,马林十六岁,秋菊十八岁。也就是在那一年,十六岁的马林离家,投奔了张作霖的队伍,当上了一名快枪手。
  • 狱球

    狱球

    当地球被外星人占领。人类终究是苍茫宇宙中的一个齿轮,当我们遇到比我们更强的种族,该怎么办?当你的家人被外星人奴役,你是否能拿起手里的武器!不自由,毋宁死!新人作者,求推荐,求收藏。
  • 总裁大人太傲娇之辰墨的宝贝儿

    总裁大人太傲娇之辰墨的宝贝儿

    五年前的一次错误,让他将整个山城市都掀翻了天只为找到她算账。一晃五年过去,让她和他再次相遇。她在他的眼中是个不知廉耻,私德败坏,不知检点的女人。他在她眼中是的冷漠无情,自大傲慢的异类。一切因为一个赌约开始,却赌进了一生。薛宝儿:我的真心相付,没想到又是一场笑话而已,不要再来找我……夜辰墨:你尽然有个孩子,那是谁的种?薛鸠笙:叔叔,你知道我爸爸是谁吗?我要代表月亮消灭那个渣男……夜辰墨:……
  • 六字神咒经

    六字神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 盛世娇宠:娘娘,斗上凤位!

    盛世娇宠:娘娘,斗上凤位!

    “朕的瑾言自乡野长大,不懂规矩,你们一个个的,可不要欺负了她。”那些被抢了风头,失了体面的贵妇千金们都欲哭无泪,恨的银牙咬碎腹中吞。“朕的瑾言性情平和温善,从不与人为敌,不与人斗。”那一个个被打入冷宫,下场凄凉的小姐妃子们表示,皇上您都看不到么?“朕的瑾言,温柔乖巧,懂事听话,最得朕心。”自皇后登位之日,内殿之中突然就多出了一个民间物件,名曰搓衣板,听闻乃是皇后所赠,皇上珍藏,以供闺房之乐。
  • 夜航船

    夜航船

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。