登陆注册
5270400000091

第91章

One should also, wherever possible, secure the universal premiss by a definition relating not to the precise terms themselves but to their co-ordinates; for people deceive themselves, whenever the definition is taken in regard to a co-ordinate, into thinking that they are not making the admission universally. An instance would be, supposing one had to secure the admission that the angry man desires vengeance on account of an apparent slight, and were to secure this, that 'anger' is a desire for vengeance on account of an apparent slight: for, clearly, if this were secured, we should have universally what we intend. If, on the other hand, people formulate propositions relating to the actual terms themselves, they often find that the answerer refuses to grant them because on the actual term itself he is readier with his objection, e.g. that the 'angry man' does not desire vengeance, because we become angry with our parents, but we do not desire vengeance on them. Very likely the objection is not valid; for upon some people it is vengeance enough to cause them pain and make them sorry; but still it gives a certain plausibility and air of reasonableness to the denial of the proposition. In the case, however, of the definition of 'anger' it is not so easy to find an objection.

Moreover, formulate your proposition as though you did so not for its own sake, but in order to get at something else: for people are shy of granting what an opponent's case really requires. Speaking generally, a questioner should leave it as far as possible doubtful whether he wishes to secure an admission of his proposition or of its opposite: for if it be uncertain what their opponent's argument requires, people are more ready to say what they themselves think.

Moreover, try to secure admissions by means of likeness: for such admissions are plausible, and the universal involved is less patent; e.g. make the other person admit that as knowledge and ignorance of contraries is the same, so too perception of contraries is the same; or vice versa, that since the perception is the same, so is the knowledge also. This argument resembles induction, but is not the same thing; for in induction it is the universal whose admission is secured from the particulars, whereas in arguments from likeness, what is secured is not the universal under which all the like cases fall.

It is a good rule also, occasionally to bring an objection against oneself: for answerers are put off their guard against those who appear to be arguing impartially. It is useful too, to add that 'So and so is generally held or commonly said'; for people are shy of upsetting the received opinion unless they have some positive objection to urge: and at the same time they are cautious about upsetting such things because they themselves too find them useful.

Moreover, do not be insistent, even though you really require the point: for insistence always arouses the more opposition. Further, formulate your premiss as though it were a mere illustration: for people admit the more readily a proposition made to serve some other purpose, and not required on its own account. Moreover, do not formulate the very proposition you need to secure, but rather something from which that necessarily follows: for people are more willing to admit the latter, because it is not so clear from this what the result will be, and if the one has been secured, the other has been secured also. Again, one should put last the point which one most wishes to have conceded; for people are specially inclined to deny the first questions put to them, because most people in asking questions put first the points which they are most eager to secure. On the other hand, in dealing with some people propositions of this sort should be put forward first: for ill-tempered men admit most readily what comes first, unless the conclusion that will result actually stares them in the face, while at the close of an argument they show their ill-temper. Likewise also with those who consider themselves smart at answering: for when they have admitted most of what you want they finally talk clap-trap to the effect that the conclusion does not follow from their admissions: yet they say 'Yes' readily, confident in their own character, and imagining that they cannot suffer any reverse. Moreover, it is well to expand the argument and insert things that it does not require at all, as do those who draw false geometrical figures: for in the multitude of details the whereabouts of the fallacy is obscured. For this reason also a questioner sometimes evades observation as he adds in a corner what, if he formulated it by itself, would not be granted.

For concealment, then, the rules which should be followed are the above. Ornament is attained by induction and distinction of things closely akin. What sort of process induction is obvious: as for distinction, an instance of the kind of thing meant is the distinction of one form of knowledge as better than another by being either more accurate, or concerned with better objects; or the distinction of sciences into speculative, practical, and productive. For everything of this kind lends additional ornament to the argument, though there is no necessity to say them, so far as the conclusion goes.

For clearness, examples and comparisons should be adduced, and let the illustrations be relevant and drawn from things that we know, as in Homer and not as in Choerilus; for then the proposition is likely to become clearer.

同类推荐
  • 虚舟禅师注八识规矩颂

    虚舟禅师注八识规矩颂

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The King of the Golden River

    The King of the Golden River

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Stories by English Authors Orient

    Stories by English Authors Orient

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 开辟演义

    开辟演义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 鹤林玉露

    鹤林玉露

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 这个皇妃有点凶

    这个皇妃有点凶

    意外穿越,居然成了皇帝了女人,身边还带了个豆丁小女儿,她不甘心,才不要服侍皇上了,就要带着女儿逃跑……--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 豪门冷少的小酷妻

    豪门冷少的小酷妻

    相处多年却从不曾看过他的真面目,等他在自己的眼前消失之后那才发现自己心底满满的都是这个男人。人生失意之时遇到的那个男人,与他很相似,可是她不确定是不是他?再次被伤害之后却有些不知所措,喜欢的人原来一直都是在欺骗自己,她就像是一个被人踢来踢去的皮球一般再也动弹不得。三年之后再次归来,此时她再也不会让自己受到伤害,即便是相遇了,也不会手软。渣男,小三,败类,曾经伤害过自己的人,统统去死,她不再饶恕。
  • 魔女夕颜

    魔女夕颜

    恶魔睁开了嗜血的双瞳,灵魂与肉体,都可以成为买卖!而她不曾对魔鬼乞讨,却莫名被迫签下黑色契约,而他正用冰冷的指尖,抚摸着她……为了让她复活,他甘愿沦入地狱,成为神秘“无间当铺”的主宰!与之纠缠,只为要回她欠下的孽,与她十世的合卺之夜,有的只是交换,没有爱?--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 冤魂别墅之镜妖

    冤魂别墅之镜妖

    男主孟寒听说Y城郊区有个冤魂别墅最近在闹鬼,便与几个朋友一同前去探探虚实,在这个过程中他们又有那些“意外”收获呢……
  • 校长记(“民国大学与大师”丛书系列)

    校长记(“民国大学与大师”丛书系列)

    民国时期,中国积贫积弱;但民国时代的大学却闻名遐迩,在东西方国际上都享有盛誉。这是为什么呢?有史家分析认为,这是因为当时的大学校长个个都很“牛气”。俗话说得好,“兵熊熊一个,将熊熊一窝”,“校长怎么样,大学就会怎么样;如果要想造就一个伟大的大学,有干练的校长还不够,还必须有卓越的校长”。
  • 王室之祭愿者

    王室之祭愿者

    比粉刑宫、焚尸炉、实验中心、饥饿、夺走初夜还要可怕的是祭灵仪式,它不是某种仪式,而是他们长达十天半个月的欢宴;在达赤王国,平民只能坐在火焰上,品尝他们送出的恐慌;平民只能以温热的鲜红色,祭奠逝去的王!他们巧言如簧:休要反抗,在坚硬的铁蹄下,只能如蚁,如退缩的群羊……祭灵仪式就要开始了,杂物镇的人们已惊恐万状!
  • 滦州万善晖州昊禅师语录

    滦州万善晖州昊禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生

    走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生

    《走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生》并非完整的人物传记,而是重在介绍可供读者借鉴的大师成才之路;《走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生》也不是普及大师们所掌握的艰深难懂的知识,而是描绘他们那令人景仰的品格风范。这是一位数学家写的一本散文集,讲述了12位科学与教育大师的真实而又鲜为人知的美丽人生。他们都是卓有贡献的出类拔萃的人才。今人正在享用他们的科学文化成果,应该认识并且走近他们。《走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生》的主人公个个光彩照人,成就非凡,却也曾经历坎坷。他们之中有作者的师长、朋友。作者对自己笔下的人物饱含深情,更兼美的文笔。文章写得感人肺腑,每篇故事都具有知识性、趣味性、启迪性与普适性,具有很强的可读性。无论为人师者或莘莘学子,都将在阅读《走近大师:12位科学家的美丽人生》时获得乐趣与激励。
  • 文案摇滚帮:让写作更简单

    文案摇滚帮:让写作更简单

    “10W+的爆文信手拈来”、“BAT、网易、360、海尔、京东都是他们的客户”、“国内唯一高质高产的原创文案类自媒体”文案摇滚帮首次发声揭秘文摇的故事大法,手把手教你写出好故事!在写故事这件事上,90%的人有这样的误区——“这是一件拼天赋或者碰运气的事”。NO!其实写作也是有套路可寻的,文案摇滚帮十年经验倾囊相授,一本书教你如何在互联网时代利用故事思维提升自己的影响力!
  • 神秘守宫砂

    神秘守宫砂

    史正万无论如何也没想到,已过知命之年的他,竟然又和一个女人有了缘分。而且,还是一个沾着晨露,山花般娇嫩漂亮的姑娘。那天上午,史正万正在屋内品着香茗,吸着水烟,镖局里的伙计林三儿进来禀报说:“镖头,门外有位先生要见您,说是有桩生意上的事,想找您商谈。”史正万眼皮都没抬一下,只是摆了摆手,照旧喝着他的茶,吸他的烟。倒不是史正万这个人傲气十足,而是他天生就沉默寡言,可要紧处说出来的话却是一诺千金。林三儿会意,抬脚走了出去。史正万是不愁没有生意做的。