登陆注册
5370400000057

第57章 Appendix: On What Can Be Done To Make Metaphysics

Accordingly it has been translated "physical." -- Ed.] 14 The three following paragraphs will hardly be understood unless reference be made to what the Citique itself says on the subject of the Principles; they will, however, be of service in giving a general view of the Principles, and in fixing the attention of the main points. 15 [Kant uses here the equivocal term Wechsetwirkung. --Ed.] 16 Heat and light are in a small space just as large as to degree as in a large one; in like manner the internal representations, pain, consciousness in general, whether they last a short or a long time, need not vary as to the degree. Hence the quantity is here in a point and in a moment just as great as in any space or time however great. Degrees are therefore capable of increase, but not in intuition, rather in mere sensation (or the quantity of the degree of an intuition). Hence they can only be estimated quantitatively by the relation of 1 to 0, viz, by their capability of decreasing by infinite intermediate degrees to disappearance, or of increasing from naught through infinite gradations to a determinate sensation in a certain time. Quantitas qualitatis est gradus [i.e., the degrees of quality must be measured by equality.] 17 We speak of the "intelligible world," not (as the usual expression is) "intellectual world." For cognitions are intellectual through the understanding, and refer to our world of sense also; but objects, so far as they can be represented merely by the understanding, and to which none of our sensible intuitions can refer, are termed " intelligible." But as some possible intuition must correspond to every object, we would have to assume an understanding that intuits things immediately; but of such we have not the least notion, nor have we of the things of the understanding [Verstandes wasen], to which it should be applied. 18 Crusius alone thought of a compromise: that a Spirit, who can neither err nor deceive, implanted these laws in us originally. But since false principles often intrude themselves, as indeed the very system of this man shows in not a few examples, we are involved ill difficulties as to the use of such a principle in the absence of sure criteria to distinguish the genuine origin from the spurious as we never can know certainly what the Spirit of truth or the father of lies may have instilled into us. 19 The definition of nature is given in the beginning of the Second Part of the " Transcendental Problem," in Sect. 14. 20 1. Substantia, 2. Qualitas 3, Quamtitas, 4. Relatio, 5. Actio, 6. Passio, 7. Quando, 8. Ubi, 9. Situs, 10. Habitus. 21 Oppositum, Prius, Simul, Motus, Habere. 22 See the two tables in the chapters Von den Paralogismen der reinen Verunft and the first division of the Antinomy of Pure Reason, System der kosmologischen Ideen. 23 On the table of the categories many neat observations may be made, for instance (1) that the third arises from the first and the second joined in one concept (2) that in those of Quantity and of Quality there is merely a progress from unity to totality or from something to nothing (for this purpose the categories of Quality must stand thus: reality, limitation, total negation), without correlata or opposita, whereas those of Relation and of Modality have them; (3) that, as in Logic categorical judgments are the basis of all others, so the category of Substance is the basis of all concepts of actual things; (4) that as Modality in the judgment is not a particular predicate, so by the modal concepts a determination is not superadded to things, etc., etc. Such observations are of great use. If we besides enumerate all the predicables, which we can find pretty completely in any good ontology (for example, Baumgarten's), and arrange them in classes under the categories, in which operation we must not neglect to add as complete a dissection of all these concepts as possible, there will then arise a merely analytical part of metaphysics, which does not contain a single synthetical proposition. which might precede the second (the synthetical), and would by its precision and completeness be not only useful, but, in virtue of its system, be even to some extent elegant. 24 See Critique of Pure Reason, Von der Amphibolie der Reflexbergriffe. 25 If we can say, that a science is actual at least in the idea of all men, as soon as it appears that the problems which lead to it are proposed to everybody by the nature of human reason, and that therefore many (though faulty) endeavors are unavoidably made in its behalf, then we are bound to Fay that metaphysics is subjectively (and indeed necessarily) actual, and therefore we justly ask, how is it (objectively) possible. 26 In disjunctive judgments we consider all possibility as divided in respect to a particular concept. By the ontological principle of the universal determination of a thing in general, I understand the principle that either the one or the other of all possible contradictory predicates must be assigned to any object. This is at the same time the principle of all disjunctive judgments, constituting the foundation of our conception of possibility, and in it the possibility of every object in general is considered as determined. This may serve as a slight explanation of the above proposition: that the activity of reason in disjunctive syllogisms is formally the same as that by which it fashions the idea of a universal conception of all reality, containing in itself that which is positive in all contradictory predicates. 27 See Critique of Pure Reason, Von ded Paralogismen der reinen Verunft. 28 Were the representation of the apperception (the Ego) a concept, by which anything could be thought, it could be used as a predicate 'of other things or contain predicates in itself. But it is nothing more than the feeling of an existence without the least definite conception and is only the representation of that to which all thinking stands in relation (relative accidentis). 29 Cf. Critique, Von den Analogien der Erfahrung. 30 It is indeed very remarkable how carelessly metaphysicians have always passed over the principle of the permanents of substances without ever attempting a proof of it; doubtless because they found themselves abandoned by all proofs as soon as they began to deal with the concept of substance. Common sense, which felt distinctly that without this presupposition no union of perceptions in experience is possible, supplied the want by a postulate. From experience itself it never could derive such a principle, partly because substances cannot be so traced in all their alterations and dissolutions, that the matter can always be found undiminished, partly because the principle contains Necessity. which is always the sign of an a priori principle. People then boldly applied this postulate to the concept of soul as a substance, and concluded a necessary continuance of the soul after the death of man (especially as the simplicity of this substance, which is interred from the indivisibility of consciousness, secured it from destruction by dissolution). Had they found the genuine source of this principles discovery which requires deeper researches than they were ever inclined to make -- they would have seen, that the law of the permanence of substances has place for the purposes of experience only, and hence can hold good of things so far as they are to be known and conjoined with others in experience, but never independently of all possible experience, and consequently cannot hold good of the soul after death. 31 Cf. Critique, Die antinomie der reinen Vernunft. 32 I therefore would be pleased to have the critical reader to devote to this antinomy of pure reason his chief attention, because nature itself seems to have established it with a view to stagger reason in its daring pretensions, and to force it to self-examination. For every proof, which I have given, as well of the thesis as of the antithesis, I undertake to be responsible, and thereby to show the certainty of the inevitable antinomy of reason. When the reader is brought by this curious phenomenon to fall back upon the proof of the presumption upon which it rests, he will feet himself obliged to investigate the ultimate foundation of all the cognition of pure reason with me more thoroughly. 33 The idea of freedom occurs only in the relation of the intellectual, as cause, to the appearance, as effect. Hence we cannot attribute freedom to matter in regard to the incessant action by which it fills its space. though this action takes place from an internal principle. We dan likewise find no notion of freedom suitable to purely rational beings, for instance, to God, so far as his action is immanent. For his action, though independent of external determining causes, is determined in his eternal reason, that is, in the divine nature. It is only, if something, is to start by an action, and so the effect occurs in the sequence of time, or in the world of sense (e.g., the beginning of the world), that we can put the question, whether the causality of the cause must in its turn have been started, or whether the cause can originate an effect without its causality itself beginning.

同类推荐
  • Greville Fane

    Greville Fane

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 赌棋山庄词话

    赌棋山庄词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Ancient Law

    Ancient Law

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Black Robe

    The Black Robe

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 菩萨十住行道品

    菩萨十住行道品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 毛詩古樂音

    毛詩古樂音

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 清穿之四福晋的修行日常

    清穿之四福晋的修行日常

    容曦愕然地望着正盘膝而坐,赤着上身,吞吐月华的四阿哥,大脑果断下线。这是什么套路?时空拐了弯,历史错乱了!容曦穿越大清朝,却悲催地发现这不是她熟悉的大清朝。人人可修行,飞天遁地,白日飞升,长生可期。太子?储君?皇位?谁在乎?连康熙都在闭关修炼……这样的大清,她要怎么活?在线等,十万火急!
  • 清明雨

    清明雨

    自从我俩登上开往大西南的列车,在云贵川三省交界处的大山深处,我们还是最近的老乡!尽管在同事们眼里,我们就是完美的一对,可在我的心里,却拿她一直当小妹妹看待。的确,岁月的风雨,虽能使沧海变桑田,却很难抚平人们心灵的伤痕。因为我的爱情世界,仍被绣春牢牢地占领着——尽管她已成了郝运的老婆。然而,她对我纯洁无瑕的爱,她在生活上对我无微不至的关怀和体贴,就像早春的阳光与和煦的东风,渐渐融化了我冰封的爱情世界!在参加工作的两年后,我俩终于走进了婚姻的殿堂!
  • 上庄记

    上庄记

    喜鹊拉水的时候,骡子惊了,车子从小腿上轧过去轧断了小腿。上庄使唤的牲口多是驴和骡子,尤以骡子为主。骡子没有生育功能,犁地、拉车、驮粮食十分有劲。但骡子有一毛病,性子多疑,常常受惊,一旦受惊便是不顾一切狂奔,不像驴那么稳重。
  • 无赖王妃:放倒腹黑王爷

    无赖王妃:放倒腹黑王爷

    【痞子无赖王妃,大战闷骚腹黑王爷】吃得饱,睡的香;逛妓院,开银行;我是宇宙超萌霹雳无敌小色娘;辣椒随身装,暗器衣里藏,捣蛋整蛊我最强;将军和王爷,土匪和大王,保驾护航在身旁,各路美男齐登场!看现代女穿越在古代,如何混的风生水起?天若灭我我灭天,我命由我不由天!“这……你端的是什么东西?!”看着眼前脸色发青的某王,史琳笑得一脸无害,“嘿嘿~王爷,这是我特别给您熬的大补汤,超级营养,唇齿留香,一碗只要五千两……”
  • 茅山女道士

    茅山女道士

    白家家训——路见不平一声吼。白小西就这么无意中吼了两次,就给自己吼来了个两个男人。偏偏这两个甩都甩不掉的男人,身后还跟着一大批的魑魅魍魉,山精鬼怪...
  • 本命缺水

    本命缺水

    一个叫做徐沝(zhǔi)淼(miǎo)的男孩,误入修行之道,但是由于其五行缺水,原本只要有一点点的水属性,他就是修行届万年难得一遇的天才,但是苦逼的他因为这一个缺点变成了废材,且看沝淼怎么艰难曲折的修行吧!
  • 你情我愿

    你情我愿

    本书已出版上市,出版名《我也可以变成你喜欢的样子》,当当,淘宝等均有售!年少的同桌时光,让她对他信任有加。男友出国深造,嘱咐他代为照顾她。他会对她冷言冷语,也会在得知她生病的时候心急如焚。一个猝不及防的吻,打破了他们之间纯净的“友谊”。之后他步步紧逼,她节节败退。她以为他只是一念成了魔,殊不知,他却早已情根深种。八年来,细细绵绵的时光里,她已成为他最缠绵的伤口。……三个月后,她“男友”归来,分明是同一张脸,却有着不同的温柔。当她渐渐的迷失,才发现这份温柔的背后,竟藏着不可告人的秘密。于是仓皇而逃,而他,却拦住她的去路,微笑着说:“你看,其实我也可以变成他,变成你喜欢的样子……”
  • 续医说

    续医说

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 雍正墓陵

    雍正墓陵

    1915年间,军阀混战,为了补充军队军饷,军阀张作甫命令营长李强到民间偷盗陵墓,而吴江正好是李强营里的参谋长便跟随李强来到了金阳山。李强拿着一本不知名的册子在命人潜入金阳山上的墨湖,自己带一部分人去了金阳山深处,吴江在上山路上正好拉肚子和部队走散。吴江花了一天一夜的时间找到部队,部队里所有人都倒在血泊中,全身被高度啃咬,死因不明,吴江在尸体上仅仅发现了掉落的虫子,吴京把虫子抓在布袋里,又拿走那本不知名的册子就去墨湖那找下水的人。