登陆注册
5376900000038

第38章 GOVERNMENT AND LAW(4)

1.Theft.--It is true that in an Anarchist world there will be no destitution, and therefore no thefts motivated by starvation.But such thefts are at present by no means the most considerable or the most harmful.The system of rationing, which is to be applied to luxuries, will leave many men with fewer luxuries than they might desire.It will give opportunities for peculation by those who are in control of the public stores, and it will leave the possibility of appropriating such valuable objects of art as would naturally be preserved in public museums.It may be contended that such forms of theft would be prevented by public opinion.But public opinion is not greatly operative upon an individual unless it is the opinion of his own group.A group of men combined for purposes of theft might readily defy the public opinion of the majority unless that public opinion made itself effective by the use of force against them.Probably, in fact, such forcewould be applied through popular indignation, but in that case we should revive the evils of the criminal law with the added evils of uncertainty, haste and passion, which are inseparable from the practice of lynching.If, as we have suggested, it were found necessary to provide an economic stimulus to work by allowing fewer luxuries to idlers, this would afford a new motive for theft on their part and a new necessity for some form of criminal law.

2.Crimes of Violence.--Cruelty to children, crimes of jealousy, rape, and so forth, are almost certain to occur in any society to some extent.The prevention of such acts is essential to the existence of freedom for the weak.If nothing were done to hinder them, it is to be feared that the customs of a society would gradually become rougher, and that acts which are now rare would cease to be so.If Anarchists are right in maintaining that the existence of such an economic system as they desire would prevent the commission of crimes of this kind, the laws forbidding them would no longer come into operation, and would do no harm to liberty.If, on the other hand, the impulse to such actions persisted, it would be necessary that steps should be taken to restrain men from indulging it.

3.The third class of difficulties is much the most serious and involves much the most drastic interference with liberty.I do not see how a private army could be tolerated within an Anarchist community, and I do not see how it could be prevented except by a general prohibition of carrying arms.If there were no such prohibition, rival parties would organize rival forces, and civil war would result.Yet, if there is such a prohibition, it cannot well be carried out without a very considerable interference with individual liberty.No doubt, after a time, the idea of using violence to achieve a political object might die down, as the practice of duelling has done.But such changes of habit and outlook are facilitated by legal prohibition, and would hardly come about without it.I shall not speak yet of the international aspect of this same problem, for I propose to deal with that in the next chapter, but it is clear that the same considerations apply with even greater force to the relations between nations.

If we admit, however reluctantly, that a criminal law is necessary and that the force of the community must be brought to bear to prevent certainkinds of actions, a further question arises: How is crime to be treated? What is the greatest measure of humanity and respect for freedom that is compatible with the recognition of such a thing as crime? The first thing to recognize is that the whole conception of guilt or sin should be utterly swept away.At present, the criminal is visited with the displeasure of the community: the sole method applied to prevent the occurrence of crime is the infliction of pain upon the criminal.Everything possible is done to break his spirit and destroy his self-respect.Even those pleasures which would be most likely to have a civilizing effect are forbidden to him, merely on the ground that they are pleasures, while much of the suffering inflicted is of a kind which can only brutalize and degrade still further.I am not speaking, of course, of those few penal institutions which have made a serious study of reforming the criminal.Such institutions, especially in America, have been proved capable of achieving the most remarkable results, but they remain everywhere exceptional.The broad rule is still that the criminal is made to feel the displeasure of society.He must emerge from such a treatment either defiant and hostile, or submissive and cringing, with a broken spirit and a loss of self-respect.Neither of these results is anything but evil.Nor can any good result be achieved by a method of treatment which embodies reprobation.

When a man is suffering from an infectious disease he is a danger to the community, and it is necessary to restrict his liberty of movement.But no one associates any idea of guilt with such a situation.On the contrary, he is an object of commiseration to his friends.Such steps as science recommends are taken to cure him of his disease, and he submits as a rule without reluctance to the curtailment of liberty involved meanwhile.The same method in spirit ought to be shown in the treatment of what is called``crime.'' It is supposed, of course, that the criminal is actuated by calculations of self-interest, and that the fear of punishment, by supplying a contrary motive of self-interest affords the best deterrent, The dog, to gain some private end, Went mad and bit the man.

同类推荐
  • 雪关禅师语录

    雪关禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 瓮中人语

    瓮中人语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四部正讹

    四部正讹

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Hippolytus

    Hippolytus

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大毗卢遮那成佛神变加持经

    大毗卢遮那成佛神变加持经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 马克思主义研究资料:经典作家著作研究Ⅳ(第14卷)

    马克思主义研究资料:经典作家著作研究Ⅳ(第14卷)

    本卷是经典著作研究第IV卷,收录关于经典作家民族学笔记以及相关著作的研究文章,展示了马克思和恩格斯晚年对唯物史观思想的进一步发展。本卷分为两个部分,第一部分是对民族学笔记和相关著作本身的研究,第二部分是对民族学笔记和相关著作中包含的理论和观点进行的专题性研究。
  • 末世之阴阳法师

    末世之阴阳法师

    秦逍本是一个在工地上打工的屌丝大学生,不料天降巨塔,晕了过去,等再次苏醒时,末世却来临了,没关系,咱有神器在手,怕个毛阿!丧尸?自己过来把灵晶抠出来!哦,好像丧尸听不懂还是自己的话。算了,还是自己来把!人类?把粮食留下就滚蛋吧!什么?不给,那就和粮食一起留下来把!你喜欢女的?我他妈还喜欢男的吗?看屌丝如何逆天成为主角。
  • 安知囚归鸟

    安知囚归鸟

    繁华世道,人心叵测……她来到本该熟悉却无比陌生的城市四年,千方百计要找的人却与命中的他息息相关。爱一个人已是不易,为他甘愿放下武器披荆斩棘更是难事。商业的战场上本就步步为营,她却在叫做爱情的城池里防不胜防。为了他,她甘愿放下恩怨。可他呢?她说:“我不后悔遇见你,但和你在一起的每一天我都心如刀绞。”他说:“但放弃你我做不到……”
  • 最强训犬员

    最强训犬员

    想过么?当有一天灾难来临,能发现你的,不一定是生命探测仪,而是救援犬;试过么?当你身处险境,能找到你的,不一定是卫星,而是救援犬;它们不被人熟知,但却一直无言战斗。它们是萌物,但它们也是战士!没错,这是一个关于无言战士的故事……
  • 谋杀植物(悬念大师希区柯克经典故事集)

    谋杀植物(悬念大师希区柯克经典故事集)

    悬疑之父,大师之中的大师,只可模仿,不可超越的巅峰,直逼理性与疯狂、压制与抗争的心理极限,你永远都猜不到故事的结局,你也无法预想故事情节的发展!精品、经典、精装、超值价蕾遇生与死、罪与罚的灵魂拷问。
  • 聪明女人情绪操控术

    聪明女人情绪操控术

    情绪无时不有,无处不在。情绪的好坏直接影响着我们的生活质量。情绪的好坏,关系到女人的生活质量、身体健康和职场发展。因此,学会控制好自己的情绪,是每个女性一生中都必须学习的重要一课。作为一个聪明的女人,不让自己永远处于不良情绪的包围之中,要懂得给心情换“跑道”。掌控和调节我们的情绪,能使女性愉快和轻松地学会管理自己的情绪,获得幸福、圆满的人生。
  • 狠人石铁

    狠人石铁

    石铁,人狠话不多,冷静如屠夫,一步步缔造无敌传奇!
  • 从诸天万界归来

    从诸天万界归来

    诸天万界,唯我独尊。一人独闯天下,挡我路者斩。另有400万字老书持续更新中,坑品有保证,大家放心入坑。新书《仙武之万界帝皇》连载中,欢迎大家围观。
  • 魔劫灭

    魔劫灭

    传说洪荒世界每过万年,必有一劫。大劫之下,便是天地圣人也难免身死道消。然而大道五十,天衍四九。每到此时,又有无数应劫而生之人在这乱世大放异彩。天帝、佛陀、妖皇、魔祖……各路大能接连走出幕后。李玄,原本只是太白剑宗的普通弟子,却一步步被迫卷入这纷扰大势之中。一个崭新的时代就此拉开序幕。
  • 王者荣耀之佛祖的爱情

    王者荣耀之佛祖的爱情

    【2018王者荣耀文学大赛·征文参赛作品】佛祖觉醒大乔的时候,看有红色锦鲤出水,野趣横生。佛祖觉醒刘禅的时候,坐骑是机关熊猫,不过就是在施展暴走熊猫转圈圈的时候,佛祖有点受不了,转的头晕想吐。还有蔡文姬的蔷薇王座,坐在王座里,真的感觉自己已经掌控整个世界,天上地下,唯我独尊。哪吒的风火轮就是一个代步工具,双轮转动间有风从雷行。庄周的坐骑很确定是星云海豚,海豚皮肤上是一副浩瀚的星图。娜可露露的玛玛哈哈是一只雄鹰,气息暴戾,自己瞪它一眼,它竟然动嘴朝脖子上啄了一下,害得佛祖人生中脖子上的第一棵草莓让一只鹰给种了……