登陆注册
5376900000040

第40章 GOVERNMENT AND LAW(6)

Those who accept the orthodox doctrine of democracy contend that, if ever the power of capital were removed, representative institutions would suffice to undo the evils threatened by bureaucracy.Against this view, Anarchists and Syndicalists have directed a merciless criticism.French Syndicalists especially, living, as they do, in a highly democratized country, have had bitter experience of the way in which the power of the State can be employed against a progressive minority.This experience has led them to abandon altogether the belief in the divine right of majorities.The Constitution that they would desire would be one which allowed scope for vigorous minorities, conscious of their aims and prepared to work for them.It is undeniable that, to all who care for progress, actual experience of democratic representative Government is very disillusioning.Admitting-- as I think we must--that it is preferable to any PREVIOUS form of Government, we must yet acknowledge that much of the criticism directed against it by Anarchists and Syndicalists is thoroughly justified.

Such criticism would have had more influence if any clear idea of an alternative to parliamentary democracy had been generally apprehended.But it must be confessed that Syndicalists have not presented their case in a way which is likely to attract the average citizen.Much of what they say amounts to this: that a minority, consisting of skilled workers in vital industries, can, by a strike, make the economic life of the whole community impossible, and can in this way force their will upon the nation.The action aimed at is compared to the seizure of a power station, by which a whole vast system can be paralyzed.Such a doctrine is an appeal to force, and is naturally met by an appeal to force on the other side.

It is useless for the Syndicalists to protest that they only desire power in order to promote liberty: the world which they are seeking to establish does not, as yet, appeal to the effective will of the community, and cannot be stably inaugurated until it does do so.Persuasion is a slow process, and may sometimes be accelerated by violent methods; to this extent such methods may be justified.But the ultimate goal of any reformer who aims at liberty can only be reached through persuasion.The attempt to thrust liberty by force upon those who do not desire what we consider liberty must always prove a failure; and Syndicalists, like other reformers, must ultimately rely upon persuasion for success.

But it would be a mistake to confuse aims with methods: however little we may agree with the proposal to force the millennium on a reluctant community by starvation, we may yet agree that much of what the Syndicalists desire to achieve is desirable.

Let us dismiss from our minds such criticisms of parliamentary government as are bound up with the present system of private property, and consider only those which would remain true in a collectivist community.Certain defects seem inherent in the very nature of representative institutions.There is a sense of self-importance, inseparable from success in a contest for popular favor.There is an all-but unavoidable habit of hypocrisy, since experience shows that the democracy does not detect insincerity in an orator, and will, on the other hand, be shocked by things which even the most sincere men may think necessary.Hence arises a tone of cynicism among elected representatives, and a feeling that no man can retain his position in politics without deceit.This is as much the fault of the democracy as of the representatives, but it seems unavoidable so long as the main thing that all bodies of men demand of their champions is flattery.However the blame may be apportioned, the evil must be recognized as one which is bound to occur in the existing forms of democracy.Another evil, which is especially noticeable in large States, is the remoteness of the seat of government from many of the constituencies--a remoteness which is psychological even more than geographical.The legislators live in comfort, protected by thick walls and innumerable policemen from the voice of the mob; as time goes on they remember onlydimly the passions and promises of their electoral campaign; they come to feel it an essential part of statesmanship to consider what are called the interests of the community as a whole, rather than those of some discontented group; but the interests of the community as a whole are sufficiently vague to be easily seen to coincide with self-interest.All these causes lead Parliaments to betray the people, consciously or unconsciously; and it is no wonder if they have produced a certain aloofness from democratic theory in the more vigorous champions of labor.

同类推荐
  • 佛说造塔功德经

    佛说造塔功德经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东周列国志上

    东周列国志上

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 半九亭集

    半九亭集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 海上和柴军使清明书

    海上和柴军使清明书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Congo & Other Poems

    The Congo & Other Poems

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 皇明纪略

    皇明纪略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 女尊之朕很中意:陛下不要跑

    女尊之朕很中意:陛下不要跑

    二十一世纪的新新人类---时薰彦,一个双子座的大龄剩女,闲着没事干去给自己造墓,本想着几十年后用,得,刚刚挖好就被一道雷劈中,这个墓不用等到几十年后了,现在就可以用了。可谁知道,她不但没有死,还变成了皇位继承人,从此桃花朵朵开。可是某人身在福中不知福,偏偏要逃跑,要去江湖飘,吃遍天下美食,阅遍天下美男。众男妃:“陛下天亮了。”不要做梦了。时薰彦:“人生必须有点追求。”脚步悄悄往着墙边挪。可是为什么她的夫君们一个个都是这么666的人?一个个身怀异术,穿越时空什么的,根本就不在话下,而且,她还发现,原来自己的重生是有预谋的。
  • 知识名言(现代名言妙语全集)

    知识名言(现代名言妙语全集)

    这些名言警句句句经典,字字珠玑,精辟睿智,闪耀着智慧的光芒和精神的力量,具有很强的鼓舞性、哲理性和启迪性。具有成功心理暗示和潜在力量开发的功能,不仅可以成为我们的座右铭,还能增进自律的能力。
  • 重生之直播小农女

    重生之直播小农女

    上一世,秦珍珠遭亲人陷害,错过心爱之人,受尽折磨。重生一世,喜获直播系统,抓住上一世错过的良人,把日子过的有声有色,顺便发家致富,没事的时候虐虐渣渣,日子过的别太逍遥自在。
  • 黎影暗主

    黎影暗主

    只有在深渊中才知道光明的可贵笑话,身在黑暗,为什么不可以下坠?这本书算是我自己的一个新手,尝试自己试着一个写一个新的力量体系,但看来我写的很烂,如果有书荒的朋友,或者是有自己想看的书,全部都看完了,而且找不到其他书的朋友,可以过来看一下,打发一下时间,有意见的也可以说一下。
  • 旗袍旗袍

    旗袍旗袍

    1931年,民国第一杀手、“斧头帮”帮主王九洲不满国民党的抗日态度,决定刺杀蒋介石。不巧情报泄露,在生死关头,王九洲被爱国青年梅月堇、岱春风、孟惜之所救。梅月堇崇拜英雄,王九洲爱慕美女,两人暗生情愫。梅月堇出身官宦家庭,父亲是蒋介石身边的红人梅默庵,在父亲的反对声中,她毅然选择了跟随王九洲。但她始终无法摆脱跟父亲血肉相连的亲情,如同她无法割舍对王九洲的恋情一样。暗恋、嫉妒、色诱、纵欲、恩爱情仇,她究竟何去何从?岱春风和孟惜之加入了王九洲的劳工会馆,三人结拜为兄弟,一起杀汉奸,也一起爱上了梅月堇。
  • 施食通览

    施食通览

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 净土生无生论注

    净土生无生论注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 威尼斯商人

    威尼斯商人

    《威尼斯商人》是莎士比亚四大喜剧之一。约写于1596年。剧中描写威尼斯一位身无分文的贵族青年巴萨尼奥,为向富家嗣女鲍西娅求婚,向好友安东尼奥借钱。安东尼因货船尚未到港,只好向犹太高利贷者夏洛克借债,并被迫立约:如不按期偿还,就让夏洛克从安东尼奥身上割一磅肉。巴萨尼奥与鲍西娅一见钟情,但安东尼奥的货船却遇险未归,债务到期他将被罚割下一磅肉。鲍西娅毅然扮作律师,去威尼斯营救安东尼奥。在法庭上,鲍西以惊人的才智,驳倒夏洛克,打赢了官司。
  • 终身的事

    终身的事

    我要讲的就是婚姻这一件终身大事,这么大的事却叫几个年轻人拿来随意玩耍,幸好容应鱼是个守规矩的女孩,在父母与朋友的帮助下,让这段契约婚姻一一礼成,最后高冷的岳律师也只是说:“没有亏损就好!”