登陆注册
5381100000124

第124章

How did you fail to see that, without a guarantee of the invention, you conceded a privilege, not for a real discovery, but for a possible discovery, and that thus the field of industry was given up by you before the plough was found? Certainly, your duty bade you to be prudent; but who gave you a commission to be dupes?

Thus the patent for invention is not even the fixing of a date; it is an abandonment in anticipation.It is as if the law should say: "I assure the land to the first occupant, but without guaranteeing its quality, its location, or even its existence; not even knowing whether I ought to give it up or that it falls within the domain of appropriation!" A pretty use of the legislative power!

I know that the law had excellent reasons for abstaining; but I maintain that it also had good reasons for intervening.Proof:

"It cannot be concealed," says M.Renouard, "it cannot be prevented;

patents are and will be instruments of quackery as well as a legitimate reward of labor and genius....It is for the good sense of the public to do justice to juggleries."

As well say it is for the good sense of the public to distinguish true remedies from false, pure wine from adulterated; or, it is for the good sense of the public to distinguish in a buttonhole the decoration awarded to merit from that prostituted to mediocrity and intrigue.Why, then, do you call yourselves the State, Power, Authority, Police, if the work of Police must be performed by the good sense of the public?

As the proverb says, he who owns land must defend it; likewise, he who holds a privilege is liable to attack.

Well! how will you judge the counterfeit, if you have no guarantee?

In vain will they offer you the plea: in right first occupancy, in fact similarity.Where reality depends upon quality, not to demand a guarantee is to grant no right over anything, is to take away the means of comparing processes and identifying the counterfeit.In the matter of industrial processes success depends upon such trifles! Now, these trifles are the whole.

I infer from all this that the law regarding patents for inventions, indispensable so far as its motives are concerned, is impossible -- that is, illogical, arbitrary, disastrous -- in its economy.Under the control of certain necessities the legislator has thought best, in the general interest, to grant a privilege for a definite thing; and he finds that he has given a signature-in-blank to monopoly, that he has abandoned the chances which the public had of making the discovery or some other similar to it, that he has sacrificed the rights of competitors without compensation, and abandoned the good faith of defenceless consumers to the greed of quacks.

Then, in order that nothing might be lacking to the absurdity of the contract, he has said to those whom he ought to guarantee: "Guarantee yourselves!"

I do not believe, any more than M.Renouard, that the legislators of all ages and all countries have wilfully committed robbery in sanctioning the various monopolies which are pivotal in public economy.But M.Renouard might well also agree with me that the legislators of all ages and all countries have never understood at all their own decrees.A deaf and blind man once learned to ring the village bells and wind the village clock.

It was fortunate for him, in performing his bell-ringer's functions, that neither the noise of the bells nor the height of the bell-tower made him dizzy.The legislators of all ages and all countries, for whom I profess, with M.Renouard, the profoundest respect, resemble that blind and deaf man; they are the Jacks-in-the-clock- house of all human follies.

What a feather it would be in my cap if I should succeed in making these automata reflect! if I could make them understand that their work is a Penelope's web, which they are condemned to unravel at one end as fast as they weave at the other!

Thus, while applauding the creation of patents, on other points they demand the abolition of privileges, and always with the same pride, the same satisfaction.M.Horace Say wishes trade in meat to be free.Among other reasons he puts forward this strictly mathematical argument:

The butcher who wants to retire from business seeks a purchaser for his investment; he figures in the account his tools, his merchandise, his reputation, and his custom; but under the present system, he adds to these the value of the bare title, -- that is, the right to share in a monopoly.

Now, this supplementary capital which the purchasing butcher gives for the title bears interest; it is not a new creation; this interest must enter into the price of his meat.Hence the limitation of the number of butchers' stalls has a tendency to raise the price of meat rather than lower it.

I do not fear to affirm incidentally that what I have just said about the sale of a butcher's stall applies to every charge whatever having a salable title.

M.Horace Say's reasons for the abolition of the butcher's privilege are unanswerable; moreover, they apply to printers, notaries, attorneys, process- servers, clerks of courts, auctioneers, brokers, dealers in stocks, druggists, and others, as well as to butchers.But they do not destroy the reasons which have led to the adoption of these monopolies, and which are generally deduced from the need of security, authenticity, and regularity in business, as well as from the interests of commerce and the public health.

The object, you say, is not attained.My God! I know it: leave the butcher's trade to competition, and you will eat carrion; establish a monopoly in the butcher's trade, and you will eat carrion.That is the only fruit you can hope for from your monopoly and patent legislation.

Abuses! cry the protective economists.Establish over commerce a supervisory police, make trade-marks obligatory, punish the adulteration of products, etc.

同类推荐
  • 金刚錍论私记

    金刚錍论私记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 栎社沿革志略

    栎社沿革志略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Medea

    Medea

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说弥勒菩萨发愿王偈

    佛说弥勒菩萨发愿王偈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 琴史尽美

    琴史尽美

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 原来竹马是直男

    原来竹马是直男

    竹马竹马,脑袋门夹!明明是身娇肉贵的“太子爷”,偏偏关键时刻抽风,在老爷子定继承人的时候跑去弃商从艺,出道两年多成为红透整片天的偶像巨星。明星也是不错的,但是你绝逼不能走弯路啊!于是,在某青梅毅然而然走上了弯男掰直的征程,最后,他倒是好了,她却把自己整个儿搭进去了。
  • 修真十书黄庭内景玉经注卷

    修真十书黄庭内景玉经注卷

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 邵兰荪医案

    邵兰荪医案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 窃国枭雄的法宝

    窃国枭雄的法宝

    刺婢狎婢在京杭大运河的北端,号称运河“龙头”、“小燕京”的通州,有一座距河三百米,始建于北周的燃灯佛舍利塔。砖塔为八角形十三层密檐式,穿雾摩云,颇具冲霄之势。悬铜铃二千二百四十八枚,为世界之最,也是古通州八景之魁首。塔影倒映,微波荡漾,白帆穿梭于碧柳拂水的河面,不但如诗如画,亦为运河上端航标。因而有了“一支塔影认通州”的传世佳句。清光绪二十六年八月十二日(1900年9月5日),英、美、德、意、日、俄、奥等国的军队侵占通州。枪声、马嘶声由远而近,通州火光四起,洋兵洋马如同恶魔从天而降。
  • 复郎廷佐书

    复郎廷佐书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 财富的点滴积累

    财富的点滴积累

    人的生理和生存需要并不是致富的动力或源泉,就如在动物生活中找不到任何相同或相似的财富追逐现象,因为它不能顺应基本的目标,也不能满足根本的需求。致富的含义就是获得超过自己需要的东西。这看起来漫无目标,却是人类最强大的驱力。
  • 追你天涯到海角

    追你天涯到海角

    苦恋一个人,想拥抱她,亲吻她,和她一起生活。追你到天涯海角,直到你在我怀里。
  • 开心国学800问

    开心国学800问

    本书所选的国学知识难易适中、活泼有趣,犹如身临其境《开心辞典》,让人在一种快乐的氛围中开阔视野,提高文化修养。糕点为什么叫“点心”?“五福临门”究竟是哪“五福”?“黄花闺女”的“黄花”到底是什么花?婚礼上为什么一定要放鞭炮?
  • 妃你不可:皇家饭碗不好摔

    妃你不可:皇家饭碗不好摔

    无意中招惹了东华国最冷血无情的男人,从此方清浅的人生就像开了劣质挂一样曲折精彩……多年来她都信奉“单身好,想跟谁好跟谁好”的座右铭,可娘亲口中的“祖传单身”,到了她这一辈无论如何都不灵验了,不仅桃花三两枝,还被那个传言中不近女色的臭男人霸王硬上弓。嫁给烈王很多年后,方清浅也仍有种自己被骗的感觉。至于哪里被骗,她也说不上来,或许就是女人隐隐的第六感吧……直到某天,她借阅了东华本纪史册。“东华有女清浅,生性顽劣善妒,因缘际会遇烈王,沉溺于其英姿,纠缠不休。然其谓烈王祖传单身之诅咒,烈王遂生恻隐之心,娶其为妃,独宠余生。”方清浅忍不了了,夺过太史官的笔,去伪存真,改写历史:是烈王逼我嫁的!
  • 人生之路如何走过

    人生之路如何走过

    本书是从叔本华的诸多著作集中选取了数十篇具有代表性的文章,内容涉及人生、哲学、美学、道德等诸多方面,基本反映了叔本华人生哲学的主要思想和理论。