登陆注册
5381100000149

第149章

I affirm, then, that God, if there is a God, does not resemble the effigies which philosophers and priests have made of him; that he neither thinks nor acts according to the law of analysis, foresight, and progress, which is the distinctive characteristic of man; that, on the contrary, he seems rather to follow an inverse and retrogressive course; that intelligence, liberty, personality in God are constituted not as in us; and that this originality of nature, perfectly accounted for, makes God an essentially anti-civilizing, anti-liberal, anti-human being.

I prove my proposition by going from the negative to the positive, --

that is, by deducing the truth of my thesis from the progress of the objections to it.

1.God, say the believers, can be conceived only as infinitely good, infinitely wise, infinitely powerful, etc., -- the whole litany of the infinites.Now, infinite perfection cannot be reconciled with the datum of a will holding an indifferent or even reactionary attitude toward progress:

therefore, either God does not exist, or the objection drawn from the development of the antinomies proves only our ignorance of the mysteries of infinity.

I answer these reasoners that, if, to give legitimacy to a wholly arbitrary opinion, it suffices to fall back on the unfathomability of mysteries, I am as well satisfied with the mystery of a God without providence as with that of a Providence without efficacy.But, in view of the facts, there is no occasion to invoke such a consideration of probability; we must confine ourselves to the positive declaration of experience.Now, experience and facts prove that humanity, in its development, obeys an inflexible necessity, whose laws are made clear and whose system is realized as fast as the collective reason reveals it, without anything in society to give evidence of an external instigation, either from a providential command or from any superhuman thought.The basis of the belief in Providence is this necessity itself, which is, as it were, the foundation and essence of collective humanity.But this necessity, thoroughly systematic and progressive as it may appear, does not on that account constitute providence either in humanity or in God; to become convinced thereof it is enough to recall the endless oscillations and painful gropings by which social order is made manifest.

2.Other arguers come unexpectedly across our path, and cry: What is the use of these abstruse researches? There is no more an infinite intelligence than a Providence; there is neither me nor will in the universe outside of man.All that happens, evil as well as good, happens necessarily.An irresistible ensemble of causes and effects embraces man and nature in the same fatality; and those faculties in ourselves which we call conscience, will, judgment, etc., are only particular accidents of the eternal, immutable, and inevitable whole.

This argument is the preceding one inverted.It consists in substituting for the idea of an omnipotent and omniscient author that of a necessary and eternal, but unconscious and blind, coordination.From this opposition we can already form a presentiment that the reasoning of the materialists is no firmer than that of the believers.

Whoever says necessity or fatality says absolute and inviolable order;

whoever, on the contrary, says disturbance and disorder affirms that which is most repugnant to fatality.Now, there is disorder in the world, disorder produced by the play of spontaneous forces which no power enchains: how can that be, if everything is the result of fate?

But who does not see that this old quarrel between theism and materialism proceeds from a false notion of liberty and fatality, two terms which have been considered contradictory, though really they are not.If man is free, says the one party, all the more surely is God free too, and fatality is but a word; if everything is enchained in nature, answers the other party, there is neither liberty nor Providence: and so each party argues in its own direction till out of sight, never able to understand that this pretended opposition of liberty and fatality is only the natural, but not antithetical, distinction between the facts of activity and those of intelligence.

Fatality is the absolute order, the law, the code, fatum, of the constitution of the universe.But this code, very far from being exclusive in itself of the idea of a sovereign legislator, supposes it so naturally that all antiquity has not hesitated to admit it; and today the whole question is to find out whether, as the founders of religions have believed, the legislator preceded the law in the universe, -- that is, whether intelligence is prior to fatality, -- or whether, as the moderns claim, the law preceded the legislator, -- in other words, whether mind is born of nature.BEFORE or AFTER, this alternative sums up all philosophy.To dispute over the posteriority or priority of mind is all very well, but to deny mind in the name of fatality is an exclusion which nothing justifies.To refute it, it is sufficient to recall the very fact on which it is based, -- the existence of evil.

Given matter and attraction, the system of the world is their product:

that is fatal.Given two correlative and contradictory ideas, a composition must follow: that also is fatal.Fatality clashes, not with liberty, whose destiny, on the contrary, is to secure the accomplishment of fatality within a certain sphere, but with disorder, with everything that acts as a barrier to the execution of the law.Is there disorder in the world, yes or no?

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 大宋江山(第八卷):襄阳风雨

    大宋江山(第八卷):襄阳风雨

    蒙哥汗在忽里台大会上被立为新汗,不久开始兵分多路进攻南宋。贾似道、吕文德、吕文焕等人,靠着余玠在台州建立起的防御体系,挫败蒙古人的锋锐,并将蒙哥击毙在台州城下。大宋江山迎来了难得的数年安宁。贾似道回朝后对权力渴望日增,与吕文德等人结党,宋廷几乎成了贾似道的掌中之物。小说以大开大合的故事、人物群像的方式揭示了大宋王朝衰败的根源。
  • 焦氏喉科枕秘

    焦氏喉科枕秘

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 穿越虫洞找妈妈

    穿越虫洞找妈妈

    特色:1.是一部让成人回归童心并关爱孩子和动物的儿童文学,一部让孩子了解和走进成人世界的成人童话,一部关于寻“找”亲情爱情的言情文学。对小孩、成人的可阅读性都非常强,对老人而言也是一部回忆年轻的温情的好作品。2.在现实生活的基础上进行文学精炼和提升,有四川的风土人情、美食、民生;又兼具了科学幻想、人文幻想、童话幻想、神话幻想。3.警醒人们爱护动物、警醒成人关爱孩子、警醒人们在忙碌繁杂的红尘中药回归内心淳朴善良等......4.融入了中国国粹艺术“京剧”的元素:“生、旦、净、丑”等......5.全文共三卷三十一节,每节里都有一段唱词,或原创或引用。
  • 炮灰不在服务区

    炮灰不在服务区

    全息网游BOSS苏葭萌从游戏穿越而来,发现自己竟然从虐人的BOSS变成被虐的炮灰!前有怀着怨气重生复仇的腹黑大姐后有顶着万能玛丽苏光环的穿越二姐底下还有两只各种捣蛋坑娘的包子童鞋还让不让人好好过日子了?苏葭萌:我的目标是带着儿子征服星辰大海,拒绝宅斗宫斗……某人笑眯眯道:可以啊,小萌,你负责赚钱养家,我负责貌美如花,如何?苏葭萌:“……”(*^__^*)求粉红票票哦~~~~
  • 红颜错之妃权天下

    红颜错之妃权天下

    她是南昭国大将军的私生庶女,人人嗤之以鼻,命如蝼蚁的她却在亲眼见到母亲惨死剑下后毅然走上那条复仇之路。庭院深深,阴谋重重,她周旋其中,步步为营。他是权倾朝野的沐王——萧沐锦,俊逸的面貌下藏着深不可测的心机。她知道他有心上人,却不知死活的触碰他心里的禁地。她并非善类,却忘记“螳螂捕蝉,黄雀在后”,在他那里输掉了一切。他是她的师父——无欢,教她武功,多少年隐藏的情愫终于在得知她背叛他的那一刻爆发,猛烈与残忍。他是南昭国的天子——南宫彻,却不在乎她的过去,要她的人,也要她的心,原应神圣的爱变得扭曲和血腥。为了报复,为了毁灭,她终于登上了权力的巅峰,回首看去,却发现一切都是一种无奈。倾城如她,狠毒如她,痴情如她,可怜亦如她……【本文慢热,非喜勿进。虐恋情深,最后绝对一对一哦】
  • 殇蝶迷途

    殇蝶迷途

    “找你二十七块三毛,谢谢惠顾,欢迎再来。”宋晓的脸上挂着热情的微笑。暂时没有新的客人过来结账,她可以稍微休息一会儿了。她看了看手表,已经是晚上九点二十分了。还有不到一个小时就下班了。她的丈夫今晚不用加班,说好过来接她下班,两人一起去吃夜宵。宋晓有些期待。最近丈夫工作很忙,早出晚归,他俩已经好几天没一起吃饭了。此时,手机忽然震动起来,来电是一个陌生的手机号码。“你好。”宋晓接通了电话。“嫂子,是我!霍奇侠!”
  • 竹马快投降

    竹马快投降

    本是温柔贤淑小姑凉,奈何……一遇见他不超过三句话立马炸毛,果然讨厌他!本是温润如玉小绅士,奈何……一遇见她不超过三句话就有种想要掐死她的冲动,不过,为啥越吵心里感觉越不对,好吧,既然招惹了他,就别怪他把她吃的连骨头渣子都不剩了。程伊认为在这世上只有两个女人能让他有种掐死人的冲动,但是还不忍下手,一个是他老妈,另一个……你们慢慢品吧。
  • 重生之女学霸

    重生之女学霸

    出车祸之后醒过来的安向柔意外的发现自己居然坐在久违的初中教室中,震惊之余,安向柔接受了自己重生回初一的事实。既然上天让我重新活过,这一世那些爱我护我的人将不会再离开,那些妒我伤我的人再无任何机会。
  • 火神肆虐:火灾的防范与自救

    火神肆虐:火灾的防范与自救

    本系列主要内容包括“自然灾害”、“火场危害”、“交通事故”、“水上安全”、“中毒与突发疾病”、“突发环境污染”等,书中主要针对日常生活中遇到的各种灾害问题作了详细解答,并全面地介绍了防灾减灾的避险以及自救的知识。居安思危,有备无患。我们衷心希望本书能够帮助青少年迅速掌握各种避险自救技能。
  • 友情卷(文摘小说精品)

    友情卷(文摘小说精品)

    本书收录了一些文摘小说中的精品故事。人与人之间交往,从最简单的那份情感开始,可以演绎多少真挚情感。本卷主要以友情为选材,从不同的视角诠释作者们眼中的友情。