登陆注册
5381100000006

第6章

so that if you deny spirit, because, included in none of the categories of time, space, motion, solidity, etc., it seems deprived of all the attributes which constitute reality, I in my turn will deny matter, which, presenting nothing appreciable but its inertia, nothing intelligible but its forms, manifests itself nowhere as cause (voluntary and free), and disappears from view entirely as substance; and we arrive at pure idealism, that is, nihility.But nihility is inconsistent with the existence of living, reasoning -- I know not what to call them -- uniting in themselves, in a state of commenced synthesis or imminent dissolution, all the antagonistic attributes of being.We are compelled, then, to end in a dualism whose terms we know perfectly well to be false, but which, being for us the condition of the truth, forces itself irresistibly upon us; we are compelled, in short, to commence, like Descartes and the human race, with the me; that is, with spirit.

But, since religions and philosophies, dissolved by analysis, have disappeared in the theory of the absolute, we know no better than before what spirit is, and in this differ from the ancients only in the wealth of language with which we adorn the darkness that envelops us.With this exception, however; that while, to the ancients, order revealed intelligence outside of the world, to the people of today it seems to reveal it rather within the world.Now, whether we place it within or without, from the moment we affirm it on the ground of order, we must admit it wherever order is manifested, or deny it altogether.There is no more reason for attributing intelligence to the head which produced the "Iliad" than to a mass of matter which crystallizes in octahedrons; and, reciprocally, it is as absurd to refer the system of the world to physical laws, leaving out an ordaining ME, as to attribute the victory of Marengo to strategic combinations, leaving out the first consul.The only distinction that can be made is that, in the latter case, the thinking ME is located in the brain of a Bonaparte, while, in the case of the universe, the ME has no special location, but extends everywhere.

The materialists think that they have easily disposed of their opponents by saying that man, having likened the universe to his body, finishes the comparison by presuming the existence in the universe of a soul similar to that which he supposes to be the principle of his own life and thought;

that thus all the arguments in support of the existence of God are reducible to an analogy all the more false because the term of comparison is itself hypothetical.

It is certainly not my intention to defend the old syllogism: Every arrangement implies an ordaining intelligence; there is wonderful order in the world; then the world is the work of an intelligence.This syllogism, discussed so widely since the days of Job and Moses, very far from being a solution, is but the statement of the problem which it assumes to solve.

We know perfectly well what order is, but we are absolutely ignorant of the meaning of the words Soul, Spirit, Intelligence: how, then, can we logically reason from the presence of the one to the existence of the other?

I reject, then, even when advanced by the most thoroughly informed, the pretended proof of the existence of God drawn from the presence of order in the world; I see in it at most only an equation offered to philosophy.

Between the conception of order and the affirmation of spirit there is a deep gulf of metaphysics to be filled up; I am unwilling, I repeat, to take the problem for the demonstration.

But this is not the point which we are now considering.I have tried to show that the human mind was inevitably and irresistibly led to the distinction of being into me and not-me, spirit and matter, soul and body.

Now, who does not see that the objection of the materialists proves the very thing it is intended to deny? Man distinguishing within himself a spiritual principle and a material principle, -- what is this but Nature herself, proclaiming by turns her double essence, and bearing testimony to her own laws? And notice the inconsistency of materialism: it denies, and has to deny, that man is free; now, the less liberty man has, the more weight is to be attached to his words, and the greater their claim to be regarded as the expression of truth.When I hear this machine say to me, "I am soul and I am body," though such a revelation astonishes and confounds me, it is invested in my eyes with an authority incomparably greater than that of the materialist who, correcting conscience and Nature, undertakes to make them say, "I am matter and only matter, and intelligence is but the material faculty of knowing."

What would become of this assertion, if, assuming in my turn the offensive, I should demonstrate that belief in the existence of bodies, or, in other words, in the reality of a purely corporeal nature, is untenable? Matter, they say, is impenetrable.-- Impenetrable by what? I ask.Itself, undoubtedly;

for they would not dare to say spirit, since they would therein admit what they wish to set aside.Whereupon I raise this double question: What do you know about it, and what does it signify?

同类推荐
  • 四十二章经注

    四十二章经注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 象台首末

    象台首末

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 度曲须知

    度曲须知

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 道德真经注

    道德真经注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 石关禅师语录

    石关禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 我的诗意生活

    我的诗意生活

    感谢生活赐予的一切,我会用真心记住每一个瞬间……
  • 独家沦陷:老公大人请止步

    独家沦陷:老公大人请止步

    “想逃?窗都没有。”雷少气息清洌,手臂猝然收紧,叶晓雾为了帮朋友误惹京城第一名少雷克已,生来就站在世界之巅的王者。她转身想逃,却被雷少撒下天罗地网困在怀中,她笑颜如花,挑衅的迎战,“怎么,你一个大男人,玩不起吗?”豪门暗斗,偷天换日,小孤女的她屡招暗算,举步为艰,一朝凤凰涅盘,浴火重生,真正身世之迷浮出水面,原来她竟然是……
  • 糖果的子弹

    糖果的子弹

    本书是奉献给爱情和成长,奉献给每一个在成长中经历过疼痛和磨难的少年。小说的主要人物是2个女孩和3个男孩。在十年的时间里,社会背景转变等影响下的情绪与心理的成长。
  • 你的素质决定你的年薪

    你的素质决定你的年薪

    越来越多的管理者意识到,员工的素质才是真正制约企业生存和发展的瓶颈。可以说,企业的核心竞争就是员工素质的竞争,企业要想在竞争中立于不败之地,必须把提升员工的素质作为当务之急。在企业中,员工能否获得较高的薪酬,获得企业的青睐,取得事业上的成功,不仅受能力、机遇、人际、环境等因素的影响,更重要的是受员工自身素质的制约.员工只有修炼自己,完善自己的职业素养,努力把自己打造成高素质的员工,才能获得自己理想的薪资待遇。每个员工都要记住:工作掌握在你自己的手中,年薪也掌握在你自己的手中。
  • 小时代琉光时代

    小时代琉光时代

    那场大火,剥夺了她一切;多年后的聚会,似乎回到了原点......林萧你还是原来的那个你么?他们都回来了,却不再是他们.....
  • 健康早餐

    健康早餐

    《妈咪私房菜丛书》根据家庭一日三餐的营养需求,精选了一千三百多道营养食谱,食物搭配具有较强的针对性,富含营养,有益身心,让你吃得美味,吃出健康。《妈咪私房菜丛书》内容丰富,实用性强,通俗易懂,是家庭主妇的有益参考书。
  • 李希凡现代文艺论著选编(中国艺术研究院学术文库)

    李希凡现代文艺论著选编(中国艺术研究院学术文库)

    《中国艺术研究院学术文库:李希凡现代文艺论著选编》共选取了作者在不同的历史时期所发表的相关学术论文及讲话稿计50篇。《中国艺术研究院学术文库:李希凡现代文艺论著选编》共分为四个篇章。第一部分主要展示的是作者对高扬社会主义文艺方向,坚持“二为”方针的理论阐述;第二部分是作者对高昂时代主题的主旋律作品的评析,再现了时代精神;第三部分主要摘录的是作者主编《中华艺术通史》的历次讲话,重温了各位艺术家的艺术涵养和道德品质;第四部分则体现了作者对艺术推陈出新,继承发展的孜孜追求。
  • Rosmersholm

    Rosmersholm

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 好友陆世

    好友陆世

    朋友的“朋”字,是两个月亮所组成,其意必须光明磊落,相互光照。人的一生中,真正的好朋友是不可多得的,但我肯定的说:陆世便是我人生中这不可多得的好朋友中的一个。——摘自时光里的日记。近日在朋友的微信圈里疯转着一篇题为《陋石铭》的短文,说是写得有味,也蛮深刻。那夜在楼下的湘水畔乘凉,时光里突然又想起这件事情来,忙打开手机从微信里找出一读,便觉得此文风很是熟悉,“譬如奇石,深埋甚久。自暴自弃,自惭丑陋……”还只读了一节,他就忍不住与陆世通了电话,一问,果然是出自他的手笔。
  • 刺客列传 秦乱纪

    刺客列传 秦乱纪

    《刺客列传》讲的是三个刺客的故事,分别是曹沫、专诸、荆轲。曾经有人说过:如果让他选择一个理想的生活时代,他就选择春秋战国。因为那是一个个性突出、充满浪漫色彩的时代。浪漫的时代,一切事情都会变得很有情调,很有戏剧性。这三个刺客都很有名,如果说到刺客就不能不提到他们。尽管这三个刺客出身不同,动机不同,手法不同,甚至结局也不同,但他们都是刺客中的典型人物,连太史公都在《史记》中为之立传,就算是刺客中的三个代表吧!《秦乱纪》讲的是秦二世即位后,赵高掌实权,实行残暴的统治,终于激起了陈胜、吴广起义,天下混战的故事,揭示了封建社会的内在矛盾。