登陆注册
5381100000006

第6章

so that if you deny spirit, because, included in none of the categories of time, space, motion, solidity, etc., it seems deprived of all the attributes which constitute reality, I in my turn will deny matter, which, presenting nothing appreciable but its inertia, nothing intelligible but its forms, manifests itself nowhere as cause (voluntary and free), and disappears from view entirely as substance; and we arrive at pure idealism, that is, nihility.But nihility is inconsistent with the existence of living, reasoning -- I know not what to call them -- uniting in themselves, in a state of commenced synthesis or imminent dissolution, all the antagonistic attributes of being.We are compelled, then, to end in a dualism whose terms we know perfectly well to be false, but which, being for us the condition of the truth, forces itself irresistibly upon us; we are compelled, in short, to commence, like Descartes and the human race, with the me; that is, with spirit.

But, since religions and philosophies, dissolved by analysis, have disappeared in the theory of the absolute, we know no better than before what spirit is, and in this differ from the ancients only in the wealth of language with which we adorn the darkness that envelops us.With this exception, however; that while, to the ancients, order revealed intelligence outside of the world, to the people of today it seems to reveal it rather within the world.Now, whether we place it within or without, from the moment we affirm it on the ground of order, we must admit it wherever order is manifested, or deny it altogether.There is no more reason for attributing intelligence to the head which produced the "Iliad" than to a mass of matter which crystallizes in octahedrons; and, reciprocally, it is as absurd to refer the system of the world to physical laws, leaving out an ordaining ME, as to attribute the victory of Marengo to strategic combinations, leaving out the first consul.The only distinction that can be made is that, in the latter case, the thinking ME is located in the brain of a Bonaparte, while, in the case of the universe, the ME has no special location, but extends everywhere.

The materialists think that they have easily disposed of their opponents by saying that man, having likened the universe to his body, finishes the comparison by presuming the existence in the universe of a soul similar to that which he supposes to be the principle of his own life and thought;

that thus all the arguments in support of the existence of God are reducible to an analogy all the more false because the term of comparison is itself hypothetical.

It is certainly not my intention to defend the old syllogism: Every arrangement implies an ordaining intelligence; there is wonderful order in the world; then the world is the work of an intelligence.This syllogism, discussed so widely since the days of Job and Moses, very far from being a solution, is but the statement of the problem which it assumes to solve.

We know perfectly well what order is, but we are absolutely ignorant of the meaning of the words Soul, Spirit, Intelligence: how, then, can we logically reason from the presence of the one to the existence of the other?

I reject, then, even when advanced by the most thoroughly informed, the pretended proof of the existence of God drawn from the presence of order in the world; I see in it at most only an equation offered to philosophy.

Between the conception of order and the affirmation of spirit there is a deep gulf of metaphysics to be filled up; I am unwilling, I repeat, to take the problem for the demonstration.

But this is not the point which we are now considering.I have tried to show that the human mind was inevitably and irresistibly led to the distinction of being into me and not-me, spirit and matter, soul and body.

Now, who does not see that the objection of the materialists proves the very thing it is intended to deny? Man distinguishing within himself a spiritual principle and a material principle, -- what is this but Nature herself, proclaiming by turns her double essence, and bearing testimony to her own laws? And notice the inconsistency of materialism: it denies, and has to deny, that man is free; now, the less liberty man has, the more weight is to be attached to his words, and the greater their claim to be regarded as the expression of truth.When I hear this machine say to me, "I am soul and I am body," though such a revelation astonishes and confounds me, it is invested in my eyes with an authority incomparably greater than that of the materialist who, correcting conscience and Nature, undertakes to make them say, "I am matter and only matter, and intelligence is but the material faculty of knowing."

What would become of this assertion, if, assuming in my turn the offensive, I should demonstrate that belief in the existence of bodies, or, in other words, in the reality of a purely corporeal nature, is untenable? Matter, they say, is impenetrable.-- Impenetrable by what? I ask.Itself, undoubtedly;

for they would not dare to say spirit, since they would therein admit what they wish to set aside.Whereupon I raise this double question: What do you know about it, and what does it signify?

同类推荐
  • 谦斋文录

    谦斋文录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 送刘禹锡

    送刘禹锡

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Fathers of the Constitution

    The Fathers of the Constitution

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 腰问

    腰问

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Adv,Of Wisteria Lodge

    The Adv,Of Wisteria Lodge

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 涉世之皇朝

    涉世之皇朝

    完结撒花答谢wzpyymm 欢迎加群一世安901614337来到异界如何适应环境生存下来,零卓开始了漫漫成长路。第一步先拿下人才培养摇篮,改造成现代的学府。成为天下学子之师。第二步在商业立足,然后赚银子,掌握国家经济命脉。第三步跟两大氏族的最优秀的人谈场权势纠葛又甜又虐的恋爱第四步来次江湖游,搅动一场风云,收获一只无赖。第五步奔向潇洒自由。天界,人界,妖界,玄幻就是如此精彩。认真来看。
  • 玄功邪佛

    玄功邪佛

    少年欧阳之乎,在临盆之时得到天下奇人“水火双邪”所救。十几年后,身怀“神水、圣火”双功的欧阳之乎行道武林,因经验不足误中圈套成为他人的杀人工具。巧幸得遇其母当年的二婢之一,不但灵智恢复,还巧得武学秘笈《易佛心经》的上部,便易容巧扮,混入武林邪派“残雨楼”,巧施奇计,歼灭此楼。但在凯旋而归时,却落入天下最大势力“飞魂楼”的圈套,不但损兵折将,同时自身被天下四大杀手围攻,以致功力尽废。巧幸灵智大发,终使他悟出“易佛心经”的最高心法——“空定刀诀”,功力尽复,还内劲大增,重入江湖。当年邪佛的稀世灵禽“无影鹘鹘”重现武林,少侠得其之助,不但破阵而出,还得到了“邪佛上人”所留的“千劫战笈“……
  • 乱世王者之巅峰指挥

    乱世王者之巅峰指挥

    键盘、鼠标塑造不一样的世界,神豪之间的对决,全新的SLG联赛,独特的竞技性!!(这是唯一没有俱乐部的联赛!有的只有神豪!)
  • 我们的青春有相逢

    我们的青春有相逢

    这是一部关于他们青春时期的小爱恋。希望大家多多支持。这里有酸,有甜,有涩。接受意见改进。多谢支持。“还好,我们的青春有相逢。”梁瑗对着方凛言道。方凛言笑着对着她说道:“嗯,感谢老天爷让我遇见你。”……
  • 部落冲突,我的酋长大人

    部落冲突,我的酋长大人

    科技年代穿越到了上古时期,连个吃饭的碗都没有的部落,还是一个被饿死的小女孩身上,女主大大发誓,不但要用自己的双手制作出碗,还要是金饭碗!!且看女主和她的手机,如何在土著中创造美好生活!!情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 饿魔狼君

    饿魔狼君

    认识的第一天“从今天起,你就是我的”“是…是你的?”她活像是吃了个鸭蛋卡在了喉咙。“奴隶!”他依旧冷冷的说。“为…为什么?我又不欠你!”听到这里,她十分愤愤不平。“我说你是”他转过头瞥了她一眼,那可怕的样子让她忍不住缩了缩脖子。她在心里痛骂自己‘胆小鬼,没种!’“你就是!”“是是是是…我是…”难道自己一辈子就这样了?认识的第二天“那个…主人…”主人还是只给她背影,她有点气馁。索性停下脚步不走了。什么嘛!她真可怜!“大魔头!哼,难怪人家说你是大魔头,性格孤僻,怪异,霸道,野蛮…”忽然,她觉得脖子后面冷飕飕的。“你想死吗?”冰冷寒彻骨的声音幽幽的响起~“主…主人,我…我没说你坏话哦~”认识的第三天“主人,为…为什么…有…有这么多的人要杀你?”没人理她!唉,她好像开始习惯对空气说话了~认识的第四天“你…你这个魔鬼!你…你为什么杀我娘?”魔鬼幽幽的看了她一眼,转身走了~“站住!你是个恶魔!我讨厌你!”“我饿了,你去煮饭!”“嘎?什么?你…你别想岔开话题,你为什么杀她?”“我看她不顺眼。煮饭!”“你…你看我不顺眼,是不是也要杀我?”恶魔静静的瞅了她一会,幽幽的说道:“我不会杀你。”“骗鬼去吧!我不要和一个杀人不眨眼的魔头呆在一起,我要离开你!”恶魔眼中闪过一道绿光。“如果你敢逃走,我把你爹也杀了!”“你…你…呜哇哇…你这个大魔头!”要是以后的每天都这么精彩,那可真是要命!
  • 伤寒论

    伤寒论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 忽必烈大帝(连载4)

    忽必烈大帝(连载4)

    谁也没有料到,海都之乱竟然如此旷日持久,难以解决。那木罕一筹莫展,心急如焚,恨不得一口把海都吞了。思虑良久,才说:“这样等着让海都放归安童不可能。必须派兵去打才有可能。”昔班急忙制止,说,没有大汗的命令怎么行呢?那木罕说,只管去打,打赢了大汗也不会说什么的。大军做准备,一个月后起兵讨伐海都。
  • 徐志摩文集(第二册)

    徐志摩文集(第二册)

    中国是诗的国度,历代诗人名家辈出,灿若群星。在中国现代文学史上,青年诗人徐志摩那电光火石般短促的一生,那充满浪漫激情的新体诗歌,无疑是最引人注目的。有两个方面对他生活创作影响最为深远。其一是他学养深厚,学贯中西。其二是与两位才女——林徽音和陆小曼的感情经历。《徐志摩文集》是他经典作品的精选集,是一本不可或缺的收藏本。从书中体会徐志摩在爱情的浮沉中所经历的种种心境,回味早逝青年诗人的传奇一生。
  • 驭元诀

    驭元诀

    当末日来临掉入深渊那一刻,本是必死无疑,却肉体重生,修炼元气爬出地底。当踏出深渊的那一刻,什么?现在男人以胖为美?看着那一堆肥肉,呕……滚开,老娘是女人!(正统修仙)