登陆注册
5382300000246

第246章 CHAPTER XXXIII(1)

THE NEW LAW COURTS

Judicial Procedure in the Olden Times--Defects and Abuses--Radical Reform--The New System--Justices of the Peace and Monthly Sessions--

The Regular Tribunals--Court of Revision--Modification of the Original Plan--How Does the System Work?--Rapid Acclimatisation--

The Bench--The Jury--Acquittal of Criminals Who Confess Their Crimes--Peasants, Merchants, and Nobles as Jurymen--Independence and Political Significance of the New Courts.

After serf-emancipation and local self-government, the subject which demanded most urgently the attention of reformers was the judicial organisation, which had sunk to a depth of inefficiency and corruption difficult to describe.

In early times the dispensation of justice in Russia, as in other States of a primitive type, had a thoroughly popular character.

The State was still in its infancy, and the duty of defending the person, the property, and the rights of individuals lay, of necessity, chiefly on the individuals themselves. Self-help formed the basis of the judicial procedure, and the State merely assisted the individual to protect his rights and to avenge himself on those who voluntarily infringed them.

By the rapid development of the Autocratic Power all this was changed. Autocracy endeavoured to drive and regulate the social machine by its own unaided force, and regarded with suspicion and jealousy all spontaneous action in the people. The dispensation of justice was accordingly appropriated by the central authority, absorbed into the Administration, and withdrawn from public control. Themis retired from the market-place, shut herself up in a dark room from which the contending parties and the public gaze were rigorously excluded, surrounded herself with secretaries and scribes who put the rights and claims of the litigants into whatever form they thought proper, weighed according to her own judgment the arguments presented to her by her own servants, and came forth from her seclusion merely to present a ready-made decision or to punish the accused whom she considered guilty.

This change, though perhaps to some extent necessary, was attended with very bad consequences. Freed from the control of the contending parties and of the public, the courts acted as uncontrolled human nature generally does. Injustice, extortion, bribery, and corruption assumed gigantic proportions, and against these evils the Government found no better remedy than a system of complicated formalities and ingenious checks. The judicial functionaries were hedged in by a multitude of regulations, so numerous and complicated that it seemed impossible for even the most unjust judge to swerve from the path of uprightness.

Explicit, minute rules were laid down for investigating facts and weighing evidence; every scrap of evidence and every legal ground on which the decision was based were committed to writing; every act in the complicated process of coming to a decision was made the subject of a formal document, and duly entered in various registers; every document and register had to be signed and countersigned by various officials who were supposed to control each other; every decision might be carried to a higher court and made to pass a second time through the bureaucratic machine. In a word, the legislature introduced a system of formal written procedure of the most complicated kind, in the belief that by this means mistakes and dishonesty would be rendered impossible.

It may be reasonably doubted whether this system of judicial administration can anywhere give satisfactory results. It is everywhere found by experience that in tribunals from which the healthy atmosphere of publicity is excluded justice languishes, and a great many ugly plants shoot up with wonderful vitality. Languid indifference, an indiscriminating spirit of routine, and unblushing dishonesty invariably creep in through the little chinks and crevices of the barrier raised against them, and no method of hermetically sealing these chinks and crevices has yet been invented. The attempt to close them up by increasing the formalities and multiplying the courts of appeal and revision merely adds to the tediousness of the procedure, and withdraws the whole process still more completely from public control. At the same time the absence of free discussion between the contending parties renders the task of the judge enormously difficult. If the system is to succeed at all, it must provide a body of able, intelligent, thoroughly-trained jurists, and must place them beyond the reach of bribery and other forms of corruption.

In Russia neither of these conditions was fulfilled. Instead of endeavouring to create a body of well-trained jurists, the Government went further and further in the direction of letting the judges be chosen for a short period by popular election from among men who had never received a juridical education, or a fair education of any kind; whilst the place of judge was so poorly paid, and stood so low in public estimation, that the temptations to dishonesty were difficult to resist.

The practice of choosing the judges by popular election was an attempt to restore to the courts something of their old popular character; but it did not succeed, for very obvious reasons.

Popular election in a judicial organisation is useful only when the courts are public and the procedure simple; on the contrary, it is positively prejudicial when the procedure is in writing and extremely complicated. And so it proved in Russia. The elected judges, unprepared for their work, and liable to be changed at short intervals, rarely acquired a knowledge of law or procedure.

同类推荐
  • 樵隐词

    樵隐词

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 山中寄诗友

    山中寄诗友

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伤科方书

    伤科方书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 揆度

    揆度

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天台八教大意

    天台八教大意

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 纸玫瑰(全集)

    纸玫瑰(全集)

    小护士白雁与青年才俊康剑闪婚,突然发现这不是一出灰姑娘与王子的剧情。他心里早有一位红颜知已,婆婆视她如眼中钉,公公与她妈妈居然有旧情,到处是迷。后来,白雁定义:如果你是只麻雀,不小心成了凤凰,别太当真,这只是个传说……康剑与白雁分手后,生活几经波折,情路漫漫不知归途,命运之手翻云覆雨,两人最终情归何处?是相忘于江湖还是相濡以沫?
  • 神玄空域

    神玄空域

    孑然一身踏白雪,诛魔焚心志更坚。万年帝夏化乌有,青云壮志苦难酬。六道轮回神魔灭,久久归臻命运劫。苦等万年人未到,白骨内含忠魂血。新书《山海诡谭》求看,求点评!
  • 总裁的狠心情人

    总裁的狠心情人

    他,成年的他是万千女人追求的目标,心中却有不为人知的伤,心中的温柔只为她而存在她,拥有不同的身份,即便自己的哥哥,也并不明晰,在扮演好每个角色的同时,还要默默保护着身边的人她最终选择离开,没有什么冠冕堂皇的理由,逝去的爱又是否会永远存在,他和她最终还能走到一起吗?
  • 轮回

    轮回

    怪物和鬼,其实都存在。它们存在于我们体内,有些时候,胜利属于它们。——TennesseeWilliams“救我!”一道微弱的声线刺透萧楚生的耳鼓,犹如一柄破空袭来的利剑,霎那间将他的防线洞穿。计算机显示器上是一篇名为《最终遗言》的帖子,从它发布到现在,短短十个小时,点击量已经上升到了20多万,萧楚生感到心跳加速,冷汗直冒,那些黑色的字体犹如凝固的血液,分外刺眼——而那些血液都是沉闷的黑色。“……游戏已经开始,你们有24个小时来享受这个愉悦的过程,胜利者将获得褒奖,失败者将永远腐朽……”帖子的附件里有一个简短的话。
  • 微生物密码(世界科技百科)

    微生物密码(世界科技百科)

    本套青少年科普知识读物综合了中外最新科技的研究成果,具有很强的科学性、知识性、前沿性、可读性和系统性,是青少年了解科技、增长知识、开阔视野、提高素质、激发探索和启迪智慧的良好科谱读物,也是各级图书馆珍藏的最佳版本。
  • 位面之主宰之王

    位面之主宰之王

    我在天龙中和乔峰喝过酒,和木婉清谈过恋爱,..在倚天中教过张三丰太极拳,邂逅过赵敏,...在僵尸道长里面和九叔学过道,...咦,怎么这是吸血鬼?
  • 大观楼捉鬼

    大观楼捉鬼

    第一回大观楼僵尸惊魂三江口王告殒命地处湘粤两省交界之地的平兰县县城北面,有一条麻卵石铺就的挑盐大道,是解放前湘南通往广东的必经之路。据史料记载,这条路始建于明朝隆庆年间,由于年代久远,路面上一个紧挨一个的麻卵石已经被行人踩得溜光。麻卵石间的缝隙里,不知渗进了多少挑夫行人的汗水,但见那饱吮了盐汗的马鞭草,从石缝间顽强地生长出来,又被路人踩倒下去。于是年复一年,在那石缝间,大路旁,竟牵连结成了一层坚韧的草网,坚韧到你要想从其间拔出一蔸草根来,都不晓得要费多大的力气。
  • 后山诗话

    后山诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 空间神医:重生最强女王

    空间神医:重生最强女王

    【新文《我的仙家农庄征服全世界》求预收,么么哒~】前世,江凝历尽艰辛走上人生巅峰,却招来古武世家的灭杀,一尸两命!重生归来,她身怀仙医空间,得到仙医传承,从此踏上修仙之路,报仇虐渣,带着家人致富,成就无上霸业,再登人生巅峰。传闻,容大少爱妻如命,宠妻无度,甜到极致!【女强爽文,一路爽到底!】……PS:推荐作者的9本完结作品,欢迎亲们移驾阅读,么么哒~《重生六零我养活了五个大佬》《重生八零我成了全能大佬》《空间神医:重生最强女王》《宠婚燃烧:媳妇太彪悍》《弃妇重生豪门:千金崛起》《宠婚烈爱:超能天后来袭》《神医下堂妃》《惊世弃后:神医小萌宝》《火爆小医女:天下第一绝宠》。
  • 仙君请留步

    仙君请留步

    前世,她是国破家亡的帝女凤凰,他是所向披靡的仙界主将。今生,她是自唱挽歌的亡国贵女,他是隐居世外的孤高谪仙。当命运让他们再次相遇,仰慕仙人的凡人女子,宁愿放下一身矜持高傲拾起杀人刀。纵然生死相隔,也不能阻止我追逐你的脚步。