登陆注册
5391900000014

第14章 THE VOTER AND THE TWO VOICES(2)

Nearly all the great newspapers,both pompous and frivolous,will declare dogmatically day after day,until every one half believes it,that red and green are the only two colours in the paint-box.THE OBSERVER will say:"No one who knows the solid framework of politics or the emphatic first principles of an Imperial people can suppose for a moment that there is any possible compromise to be made in such a matter;we must either fulfil our manifest racial destiny and crown the edifice of ages with the august figure of a Green Premier,or we must abandon our heritage,break our promise to the Empire,fling ourselves into final anarchy,and allow the flaming and demoniac image of a Red Premier to hover over our dissolution and our doom."The DAILY MAIL would say:

"There is no halfway house in this matter;it must be green or red.We wish to see every honest Englishman one colour or the other."And then some funny man in the popular Press would star the sentence with a pun,and say that the DAILY MAIL liked its readers to be green and its paper to be read.But no one would even dare to whisper that there is such a thing as yellow.

For the purposes of pure logic it is clearer to argue with silly examples than with sensible ones:because silly examples are simple.But I could give many grave and concrete cases of the kind of thing to which I refer.

In the later part of the Boer War both parties perpetually insisted in every speech and pamphlet that annexation was inevitable and that it was only a question whether Liberals or Tories should do it.It was not inevitable in the least;it would have been perfectly easy to make peace with the Boers as Christian nations commonly make peace with their conquered enemies.Personally I think that it would have been better for us in the most selfish sense,better for our pocket and prestige,if we had never effected the annexation at all;but that is a matter of opinion.

What is plain is that it was not inevitable;it was not,as was said,the only possible course;there were plenty of other courses;there were plenty of other colours in the box.Again,in the discussion about Socialism,it is repeatedly rubbed into the public mind that we must choose between Socialism and some horrible thing that they call Individualism.I don't know what it means,but it seems to mean that anybody who happens to pull out a plum is to adopt the moral philosophy of the young Horner--and say what a good boy he is for helping himself.

It is calmly assumed that the only two possible types of society are a Collectivist type of society and the present society that exists at this moment and is rather like an animated muck-heap.It is quite unnecessary to say that I should prefer Socialism to the present state of things.Ishould prefer anarchism to the present state of things.But it is simply not the fact that Collectivism is the only other scheme for a more equal order.A Collectivist has a perfect right to think it the only sound scheme;but it is not the only plausible or possible scheme.We might have peasant proprietorship;we might have the compromise of Henry George;we might have a number of tiny communes;we might have co-operation;we might have Anarchist Communism;we might have a hundred things.I am not saying that any of these are right,though I cannot imagine that any of them could be worse than the present social madhouse,with its top-heavy rich and its tortured poor;but I say that it is an evidence of the stiff and narrow alternative offered to the civic mind,that the civic mind is not,generally speaking,conscious of these other possibilities.The civic mind is not free or alert enough to feel how much it has the world before it.There are at least ten solutions of the Education question,and no one knows which Englishmen really want.For Englishmen are only allowed to vote about the two which are at that moment offered by the Premier and the Leader of the Opposition.There are ten solutions of the drink question;and no one knows which the democracy wants;for the democracy is only allowed to fight about one Licensing Bill at a time.

So that the situation comes to this:The democracy has a right to answer questions,but it has no right to ask them.It is still the political aristocracy that asks the questions.And we shall not be unreasonably cynical if we suppose that the political aristocracy will always be rather careful what questions it asks.And if the dangerous comfort and self-flattery of modern England continues much longer there will be less democratic value in an English election than in a Roman saturnalia of slaves.For the powerful class will choose two courses of action,both of them safe for itself,and then give the democracy the gratification of taking one course or the other.The lord will take two things so much alike that he would not mind choosing from them blindfold--and then for a great jest he will allow the slaves to choose.

同类推荐
  • 佛说优婆塞五戒相经

    佛说优婆塞五戒相经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 老子道德经校释

    老子道德经校释

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 教童子法

    教童子法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 庚申君遗事

    庚申君遗事

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 君臣上

    君臣上

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 学霸自学学习法

    学霸自学学习法

    怎样学习才能达到最好的效果?学习是一个循序渐进的过程,在这个过程中,只有注意自己的学习方法,才能收到事半功倍的效果。学习方法并没有统一的标准和规定,因个人条件的不同,选取的方法效果也有一定的差别。我们编辑的这套“学霸学习法”作品可供学者参考,从中获取最适合自己的高效学习方法,但要说明的是:“学习有法,但无定法,贵在得法”。《学霸自学学习法》对学生如何提高自学能力做出了理论指导,并推荐了部分有利于学生提高自学能力的故事,可供练习掌握该学习方法。
  • 陌上何杳杳

    陌上何杳杳

    “小狐狸,你给我站住!”“死山鸡,你别过来,你再过来,我就……我就……”“你就……你就……你就干什么?”“我就把你吃了,我可是狐狸,最爱的便是山鸡了!”“老子是凤凰,最擅长吃狐狸了!”“禽兽授受不亲,你们鸟族都这般轻浮放荡吗?”“别的鸟大抵如此,天可见怜,只余下我这么一个痴情种……”“我说了不喜欢你就是不喜欢!”“无妨,路遥知马力,日久见人心!”陌上花开,星河光转,我终是等到你了——小狐狸!这一次,你休想丢下我!
  • 悬疑故事

    悬疑故事

    无数事实、经验和理性已经证明:好故事可以影响人的一生。而以我们之见,所谓好故事,在内容上讲述的应是做人与处世的道理,在形式上也应听得进、记得住、讲得出、传得开,而且不会因时代的变迁而失去她的本质特征和艺术光彩。为了让更多的读者走进好故事,阅读好故事,欣赏好故事,珍藏好故事,传播好故事,我们特编选了一套“故事会5元精品系列”以飨之。其选择标准主要有以下三点:一、在《故事会》杂志上发表的作品。二、有过目不忘的艺术感染力。三、有恒久的趣味,对今天的读者仍有启迪作用。愿好故事伴随你的一生!
  • 重回九四好种田

    重回九四好种田

    方明湘的观念一直是:这个世界上,没有什么坏人是拳头解决不了的。如果有,那说明你拳头不够硬。重生后,她突然醒悟了。这辈子她要做个顾家的好女人,赚钱养家讨爸妈开心,给家里造房子,给哥哥娶老婆。————食用指南:这是一篇慢节奏种田文,主角极其护短,为家人和朋友,会一言不合就开打。故事略狗血,作者玻璃心,求轻喷。
  • 江西诗社宗派图录

    江西诗社宗派图录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宠婚入骨:总裁前夫温柔点

    宠婚入骨:总裁前夫温柔点

    费云夕实在受不了杜珣这所为的宠爱,这白天宠,晚上宠,床上宠,地上宠的滋味太不好过,所以,她费劲儿心思的想离婚。协议书往办公桌上一拍:“杜珣,我离婚。”杜珣给她一个白眼:“老婆,我不同意。“费云夕闻言,双手环胸冷声道:“那好,不离婚可以,我给你个特权,你去找个小三儿回来使劲儿宠,我绝对不干涉。”杜珣一听赶紧合上电脑,解释:“老婆大人,国家婚姻法明文规定,一男多妻不合法,所以,为了能做个合格好公民,我累死累活只宠你。”费云夕一听,只想赶紧晕过去。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 花箭情缘

    花箭情缘

    从来没谈过恋爱的木晓玫意外地穿越到了女子为尊的凤仪国,不仅成了民族英雄,当上了地位尊贵的封主,还一下子有了七个夫君!小心翼翼地和陌生的皇权周旋之余,她邂逅了各种美色,却对一个脾气“最差”的男人朝思暮想,到底该怎么办啊!!
  • 语文新课标课外必读第十辑:彼得·潘

    语文新课标课外必读第十辑:彼得·潘

    国家教育部颁布了最新《语文课程标准》,统称新课标,对中、小学语文教学指定了阅读书目,对阅读的数量、内容、质量以及速度都提出了明确的要求,这对于提高学生的阅读能力,培养语文素养,陶冶情操,促进学生终身学习和终身可持续发展,对于提高广大人民的文学素养具有极大的意义。
  • 北大人的社交课

    北大人的社交课

    《北大人的社交课》就是一部帮人成长、助人成功的实用交际学,它摆脱了冗长的理论带来的无益的教条和说教,也避免了因过于实际而产生的人情冷漠、“厚黑”当先的消极影响,着重于与人交往的思路和方法,是一本有样可学的社会实用手册。
  • 智慧变通术(现代人智慧全书)

    智慧变通术(现代人智慧全书)

    《智慧变通术》全面、系统、分门别类地将现代人生存立世必须具备的智慧告诉您。指导您做适者生存、永立人上的强者。本书分为5章,包括了“做人的智慧”,“挺起胸膛做人”,“踏踏实实做人”,“做人要善于言谈”,“做人要豁达”等章节。