登陆注册
5406800000176

第176章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(2)

Mr.Gladstone seems to us to be, in many respects, exceedingly well qualified for philosophical investigation.His mind is of large grasp; nor is he deficient in dialectical skill.But he does not give his intellect fair play.There is no want of light, but a great want of what Bacon would have called dry light.

Whatever Mr.Gladstone sees is refracted and distorted by a false medium of passions and prejudices.His style bears a remarkable analogy to his mode of thinking, and indeed exercises great influence on his mode of thinking.His rhetoric, though often good of its kind, darkens and perplexes the logic which it should illustrate.Half his acuteness and diligence, with a barren imagination and a scanty vocabulary, would have saved him from almost all his mistakes.He has one gift most dangerous to a speculator, a vast command of a kind of language, grave and majestic, but of vague and uncertain import; of a kind of language which affects us much in the same way in which the lofty diction of the Chorus of Clouds affected the simple-hearted Athenian:

O ge ton phthegmatos os ieron, kai semnon, kai teratodes.

When propositions have been established, and nothing remains but to amplify and decorate them, this dim magnificence may be in place.But if it is admitted into a demonstration, it is very much worse than absolute nonsense; just as that transparent haze, through which the sailor sees capes and mountains of false sizes and in false bearings, is more dangerous than utter darkness.

Now, Mr.Gladstone is fond of employing the phraseology of which we speak in those parts of his works which require the utmost perspicuity and precision of which human language is capable; and in this way he deludes first himself, and then his readers.The foundations of his theory, which ought to be buttresses of adamant, are made out of the flimsy materials which are fit only for perorations.This fault is one which no subsequent care or industry can correct.The more strictly Mr.Gladstone reasons on his premises, the more absurd are the conclusions which he brings out; and, when at last his good sense and good nature recoil from the horrible practical inferences to which this theory leads, he is reduced sometimes to take refuge in arguments inconsistent with his fundamental doctrines, and sometimes to escape from the legitimate consequences of his false principles, under cover of equally false history.

It would be unjust not to say that this book, though not a good book, shows more talent than many good books.It abounds with eloquent and ingenious passages.It bears the signs of much patient thought.It is written throughout with excellent taste and excellent temper; nor does it, so far as we have observed, contain one expression unworthy of a gentleman, a scholar, or a Christian.But the doctrines which are put forth in it appear to us, after full and calm consideration, to be false, to be in the highest degree pernicious, and to be such as, if followed out in practice to their legitimate consequences, would inevitably produce the dissolution of society; and for this opinion we shall proceed to give our reasons with that freedom which the importance of the subject requires, and which Mr.Gladstone, both by precept and by example, invites us to use, but, we hope, without rudeness, and, we are sure, without malevolence.

Before we enter on an examination of this theory, we wish to guard ourselves against one misconception.It is possible that some persons who have read Mr.Gladstone's book carelessly, and others who have merely heard in conversation, or seen in a newspaper, that the member for Newark has written in defence of the Church of England against the supporters of the voluntary system, may imagine that we are writing in defence of the voluntary system, and that we desire the abolition of the Established Church.This is not the case.It would be as unjust to accuse us of attacking the Church, because we attack Mr.

Gladstone's doctrines, as it would be to accuse Locke of wishing for anarchy, because he refuted Filmer's patriarchal theory of government, or to accuse Blackstone of recommending the confiscation of ecclesiastical property, because he denied that the right of the rector to tithe was derived from the Levitical law.It is to be observed, that Mr.Gladstone rests his case on entirely new grounds, and does not differ more widely from us than from some of those who have hitherto been considered as the most illustrious champions of the Church.He is not content with the Ecclesiastical Polity, and rejoices that the latter part of that celebrated work "does not carry with it the weight of Hooker's plenary authority." He is not content with Bishop Warburton's Alliance of Church and State."The propositions of that work generally," he says, "are to be received with qualification"; and he agrees with Bolingbroke in thinking that Warburton's whole theory rests on a fiction.He is still less satisfied with Paley's defence of the Church, which he pronounces to be "tainted by the original vice of false ethical principles, and full of the seeds of evil." He conceives that Dr.Chalmers has taken a partial view of the subject, and "put forth much questionable matter." In truth, on almost every point on which we are opposed to Mr.Gladstone, we have on our side the authority of some divine, eminent as a defender of existing establishments.

Mr.Gladstone's whole theory rests on this great fundamental proposition, that the propagation of religious truth is one of the principal ends of government, as government.If Mr.Gladstone has not proved this proposition, his system vanishes at once.

同类推荐
  • 毛诗故训传

    毛诗故训传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 抱真堂诗话

    抱真堂诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 萃善录

    萃善录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • T064

    T064

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大慧普觉禅师语录

    大慧普觉禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 极品女将

    极品女将

    【女强文,一文包揽现代版古代版的女强,兼具古装言情和现代言情!】她,本是现代的一名杀手,因右眼眉侧一枚莲形胎记,她代号:莲一次泰国的任务之中,被同门师姐设计害她。一个降头,让她从变为莲晟家的新生女婴一个降头,让她一半的容颜尽毁,丑胜无盐。莲晟未央,她新生之名。莲晟家族,西夏国的将门之族,家族中所有子女,保卫疆土。莲晟未央,家族此辈中唯一的女子,纵使丑胜无盐,却可坐拥天下女子最羡之位。一个建朝史上,最丑的皇后,嫔妃不服,又如何?她依旧可以顶着后冠,霸坐凤位,冷眼相看,后宫之争的一场场闹剧!一个莲晟族史上,最强的将领她干戈铁马,驰骋沙场。雪虎为宠,惯看生死。战场上,人说:宁去阎罗殿,但求不见未央令。冷酷如她,只要泛着她底线的人,管你是谁,都要承受她的怒气!护短如她,只要是她所在意的,即使是一只畜生,亦是珍宝!淡漠如她,有着属于自己的情感表达方式……一张丑颜,一身风华,一抹淡笑,一世逍遥!尘埃落尽之时,她却消失得无影无踪……“莲晟未央,上穷碧落下黄泉,我也要将你找回!”他双拳握紧,俊颜满是神伤,少了她的相陪,这帝君之位有何乐趣可言!于是,天地色变,风云骤起,她的穿越,他的反穿越……------------------------------------------------------------------------------------推荐好文【名门呆女】她,是道上赫赫有名的“阴将军”,统领麾下鬼将鬼兵,叱咤妖鬼魔道。奉家百年奇才,却敌不过“阴将军”的宿命——短命。英年早逝,遗愿未了,死不瞑目。这一世,她叫奉绯,是太和国古传世家奉家的小女儿。天生呆子。十七年来,呆得没心没肺,呆得无情无欲,呆得不喜不怒。十七年来,奉家呆女顽固地坚持着如出生时的最高静默状态。十七年来,惜字如金,一句话都未说过。(丫的,体内只有一个魂让她想不呆点也不可能啊!)当其余六魂六魄,六情六欲再度归来,“阴将军”觉醒,必将风华万丈。很好,很劲,很强大!于是乎——啥?奉家呆女笑了?一笑倾人城,再笑倾人国,笑得死人诈尸,葬礼都举行不下去了。啥?奉家呆女哭了?梨花带雨惹人怜,玉容挂泪让人惜,哭得鸡飞狗跳,哭得鬼泣神愁,这喜宴……看来是举行不下去了。
  • 观自在菩萨说普贤陀罗尼经

    观自在菩萨说普贤陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 杀手异世:腹黑女傲逆天下

    杀手异世:腹黑女傲逆天下

    她,夜紫辰,21世纪古武世家掌权大小姐,她,亦是杀手排行榜上得第一人“魅”,因未婚夫背叛而亡她,夜紫辰,夜家直系三小姐,没有半分灵力,夜家的耻辱,她懦弱,她无助,她善良……却被姐姐残忍害死当她变成了她,不再无助,不再懦弱,她嫉恶如仇,她心很手辣她护短,她冷清,她腹黑,时常都是一副笑脸,可谁知道在那张笑脸背后是背叛的伤……她成为人们眼中的“花花小姐”可为什么这样的“花花小姐”成了“香饽饽”呢?她偶然得到神秘戒指,逆天修炼功法,炼丹药,契魔兽,炼神器……身怀逆天宝贝的她又会在玄灵大陆上掀起怎样的惊天骇浪?她笑得无害单纯,可在同时弹指间取人性命……她带着满脸的笑,说“我很善良的,我蚂蚁都舍不得杀”,可转身却一招毙命,她说“我真的从来都不杀蚂蚁,因为我只杀人”她男装行走大陆,结交无数美男,使无数美男为之倾心,相伴左右。可有了前车之鉴,谁能打开她那冰封的心……
  • 系统重生之国民男神

    系统重生之国民男神

    【正文完结番外中】重生不可怕,就怕重生妖孽化,舒澄就是这个妖孽化的典范。【叮——系统发现病毒,正在清理病毒......】【叮——病毒清理失败......】【警报!警报!绑定宿主失败,穿越功能出现故障……】舒澄曾经是一个系统,上知天文下知地理无所不能,再世为人,她许誓必要活得璀璨夺目!网文至高、科幻大神、武侠皇帝、国际影后乃至灵魂乐者……女扮男装女强男强一对一男女主身心干净男主颜值高,“能力”强,性格高冷,喜欢赚钱和宠老婆,赚到钱后把钱都给老婆花掉。欢迎加入九苑,群聊号码:906141003
  • 实用工商文书写作大全

    实用工商文书写作大全

    本书详细介绍了实用工商文书的写作方法及类型,按其文体格式划分,有表格式文书、申请报告类文书、章程及合同类文书、申诉答辩类文书四大类。打开此书,找到你想要的文体,按图索骥,轻松搞定!
  • 魔尊归

    魔尊归

    《三界风云录》有言:血月夜,魔尊归。相爱相杀了几万年的天尊顾辰风和魔尊苏星月相约于昆仑山巅一决生死!这一战,究竟会是谁胜谁败?这一战过后,三界风云又将如何变幻?魔界众人不服:“那个只想过清闲日子的魔尊哪里是天尊的对手?”天界众人更是不服:“什么相爱相杀?向来只是那女魔头杀我们天尊啊!”
  • 沉默都市

    沉默都市

    你见过草原吗?朝每一个方向看去,都是一望无边的绿色。到了夏天,马兰花缀在长长的茅草间,风卷过草原,呜呜低鸣着,无数细碎的声响像音符一样远远飘来,汇成一支草原的歌。我、芷兰和子扬就在草原上长大。芷兰是我们三人中唯一的女孩,她在阳光下的样子很好看。一直以来,同龄的孩子就只有我们三个,大概生在草原长在草原是件很稀奇的事情吧。
  • Emile Zola

    Emile Zola

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 降伏万兽:诛天九夫人

    降伏万兽:诛天九夫人

    让世界黯然失色的霸王花凌霜,一朝穿越成废物小姐的奴婢,废物小姐的日子已经很不好过了,她更是受尽凌辱。不曾想,她因胆识过人巧结仙缘,得天河图、割天匕、驭兽牌、青皇令、诛天镜等法宝,从此回眸浅笑,万兽臣服,亿木膜拜,玉指轻扬,风云大变,日月无光,敌军灰飞烟灭。只是,山有木兮木有枝,心悦君兮君不知,但终有一日,与君携手摘星辰,茫茫天地任我行。
  • 长安我许你一世长安

    长安我许你一世长安

    在这几年里,她总要独自前行,谁都不知道她真正的伤口。直到那天,他像一束暖阳照进她的心房。当她爱上他时,现实是多么的苍白。我们在青春得到爱,又在成长中失去爱。butlalwaysloveyouasbefore———我爱你,天知地知你知我知。———拼我性命,护你周全。———长安啊,我许你一世长安·····我不是喜欢你,我只是无法失去你。林长安啊,我想许你一世,安然无恙。