登陆注册
5406800000199

第199章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(25)

Again, on our principles, all civil disabilities on account of religious opinions are indefensible.For all such disabilities make Government less efficient for its main end: they limit its choice of able men for the administration and defence of the State; they alienate from it the hearts of the sufferers; they deprive it of a part of its effective strength in all contests with foreign nations.Such a course is as absurd as it would be in the governors of a hospital to reject an able surgeon because he is an Universal Restitutionist, and to send a bungler to operate because he is perfectly orthodox.

Again, on our principles, no Government ought to press on the people religious instruction, however sound, in such a manner as to excite among them discontents dangerous to public order.For here again Government would sacrifice its primary end to an end intrinsically indeed of the highest importance, but still only a secondary end of Government, as Government.This rule at once disposes of the difficulty about India, a difficulty of which Mr.

Gladstone can get rid only by putting in an imaginary discharge in order to set aside an imaginary obligation.There is assuredly no country where it is more desirable that Christianity should be propagated.But there is no country in which the Government is so completely disqualified for the task.By using our power in order to make proselytes, we should produce the dissolution of society, and bring utter ruin on all those interests for the protection of which Government exists.Here the secondary end is, at present, inconsistent with the primary end, and must therefore be abandoned.Christian instruction given by individuals and voluntary societies may do much good.Given by the Government it would do unmixed harm.At the same time, we quite agree with Mr.

Gladstone in thinking that the English authorities in India ought not to participate in any idolatrous rite; and indeed we are fully satisfied that all such participation is not only unchristian, but also unwise and most undignified.

Supposing the circumstances of a country to be such, that the Government may with propriety, on our principles, give religious instruction to a people; we have next to inquire, what religion shall be taught.Bishop Warburton answers, the religion of the majority.And we so far agree with him, that we can scarcely conceive any circumstances in which it would be proper to establish, as the one exclusive religion of the State, the religion of the minority.Such a preference could hardly be given without exciting most serious discontent, and endangering those interests, the protection of which is the first object of Government.But we never can admit that a ruler can be justified in helping to spread a system of opinions solely because that system is pleasing to the majority.On the other hand, we cannot agree with Mr.Gladstone, who would of course answer that the only religion which a ruler ought to propagate is the religion of his own conscience.In truth, this is an impossibility.And as we have shown, Mr.Gladstone himself, whenever he supports a grant of money to the Church of England, is really assisting to propagate not the precise religion of his own conscience, but some one or more, he knows not how many or which, of the innumerable religions which lie between the confines of Pelagianism and those of Antinomianism, and between the confines of Popery and those of Presbyterianism.In our opinion, that religious instruction which the ruler ought, in his public capacity, to patronise, is the instruction from which he, in his conscience, believes that the people will learn most good with the smallest mixture of evil.And thus it is not necessarily his own religion that he will select.He will, of course, believe that his own religion is unmixedly good.But the question which he has to consider is, not how much good his religion contains, but how much good the people will learn, if instruction is given them in that religion.He may prefer the doctrines and government of the Church of England to those of the Church of Scotland.But if he knows that a Scotch congregation will listen with deep attention and respect while an Erskine or a Chalmers sets before them the fundamental doctrines of Christianity, and that a glimpse of a surplice or a single line of a liturgy would be the signal for hooting and riot and would probably bring stools and brickbats about the ears of the minister, he acts wisely if he conveys religious knowledge to the Scotch rather by means of that imperfect Church, as he may think it, from which they will learn much, than by means of that perfect Church from which they will learn nothing.The only end of teaching is, that men may learn;and it is idle to talk of the duty of teaching truth in ways which only cause men to cling more firmly to falsehood.

On these principles we conceive that a statesman, who might be far indeed from regarding the Church of England with the reverence which Mr.Gladstone feels for her, might yet firmly oppose all attempts to destroy her.Such a statesman may be too well acquainted with her origin to look upon her with superstitious awe.He may know that she sprang from a compromise huddled up between the eager zeal of reformers and the selfishness of greedy, ambitious, and time-serving politicians.

He may find in every page of her annals ample cause for censure.

同类推荐
  • 天官冢宰

    天官冢宰

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Song of the Cardinal

    The Song of the Cardinal

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 慈受怀深禅师广录

    慈受怀深禅师广录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Padre Ignacio

    Padre Ignacio

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四分律删补随机羯磨

    四分律删补随机羯磨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 大侠,别怕

    大侠,别怕

    抢个大侠做压寨夫人是宝宝的毕生追求,江湖生活是她的向往。因为儿时的约定,盛宝华初入江湖寻找大侠慕容云天。生着一副天真单纯样貌的宝宝其实是个腹黑的小狐狸,闯江湖的生活也过得有滋有味。江湖险恶并不是说说而已的,宝宝其实只想拐个大侠回飞天寨成亲,但是却卷入了一场血雨腥风中,不仅丢了大侠,还差点把自己的小命也搭了进去。是天然呆少女,还是诡计多端的小狐狸?是冷峻正义的大侠,还是阴险腹黑的幕后黑手?
  • 偏执夫君的纯情娘子

    偏执夫君的纯情娘子

    大学毕业,刚找到一个博物馆的工作,没想到就遇到了博物馆连续失窃事件,搞得人心惶惶,最后馆长想出了特别坑的办法,下班以后让每个人带一件文物回家保管,但是这样漏洞还是多多呀!经过一系列的保密工作,林璃月得到一件说是千年以前的串珠项链,在她看来并不起眼的项链却让她遇到不寻常的事情! 回家的路上遇到雷雨天气,没干坏事的她,第一次被雷劈了,等到她再次醒来,却来到了一个不一样的世界,想着找工作填饱肚子,却又遇到了傲娇的主子,被逼无奈做了别人的贴身丫鬟,开始了她的悲惨人生。“月儿,打盆水来!”“是!”“月儿,给本公子宽衣!”“是!”“月儿,今晚由你侍寝!”说好的不近女色的,这是几个意思!!
  • 万界丹尊

    万界丹尊

    绝世强者,一代丹尊李通天在渡天君大劫的时候遭人围攻而陨落,岂料重回到少年时代,从此风起云涌,与无数天才争雄,重启传奇之路!书友群(554064213)万千世界,谁主沉浮?顺我者昌!逆我者亡!
  • 重生之天命嫡女

    重生之天命嫡女

    十五岁的天山圣境废材天命嫡女,一朝重生,意外获得异宝,身怀随身空间,空间自带各种异能,从此开启逆袭之路!来自现代的灵魂,生怕麻烦,只答应原主顺便的话替她报个身死之仇,然后平淡的升级打怪兽。不曾想这躯壳的原主自带招黑体质,惹上的一身债,得她来偿!渣男未婚夫来了,那就接招吧;渣堂姐来了,那就废了她修为……然,这冷面神又是什么鬼?她不曾招惹他,他却先要控制她的人生自由。士可杀不可辱!她突然想通了,强者为尊的世界,实力才是一切,她得快速变强,变强,再变强!管你什么牛神马面,从此一边站去,她没有在怕的!
  • 大唐狄公案

    大唐狄公案

    善测人心的神探狄仁杰,哪知人心似无底!这是时间长廊中最繁花似锦的一段,拥有着独一无二的帝王和她最为聪明睿智的臣子。狄仁杰,这是一个无论翻开哪一本唐代史书都会提到的名字。名留史册的人很多,但大多毁誉各掺,是非功过,各有评说。但如狄仁杰一般多是溢美之词的,并不多见。庙堂江湖,皆是上通下达;三教九流中,亦是游刃有余,他的人生与故事本身就已经是一种传奇。帷幕重重雾深深,哪知人心似无底。其实从古至今,天子黎庶、王亲贵胄、鸿儒白丁,他们的爱恨情仇、喜怒哀乐,并无不同。因为,无论哪里,有故事的都是人,而故事的最终发源地都是人的心。
  • 一品白易

    一品白易

    韩白易穿越古代成为柳家一名杂役。他绝望之时,一个神秘仓库拯救了他!韩白易已经兴奋不已,道:“柳夫人!我有一款内衣名叫比基尼!”夫人道:“拿来看看。”“不错!提拔你为管家。”“诸葛先生,我有蓝色小药丸!”诸葛先生道:“拿来,我尝尝什么味道!”“县令缺人,你去当吧。”“公主!那文胸不是戴在头上的!妳先拿下来......”公主道:“那应该戴在哪里......过来帮我。”“陛下,我愿当急先锋!率领调教好的特种小队,拿了敌将人头!”陛下激动道:“准了!册封你为天策上将!”于是在这个搞笑的,奇葩的,各方势力蠢蠢欲动的混乱时代,且看韩白易如何逆势而起!成为最大赢家!注:架空历史,轻松阅读,切勿较真^.^
  • 数学思维法训练(青少年提高逻辑思维能力训练集)

    数学思维法训练(青少年提高逻辑思维能力训练集)

    当今时代是一个知识爆炸的时代,也是一个头脑竞争的时代;在竞争日益激烈的环境下,一个人想要很好地生存,不仅需要付出勤奋,而且还必须具有智慧。随着人才竞争的日趋激烈和高智能化,越来越多的人认识到只拥有知识是远远不够的。因为知识本身并不能告诉我们如何去运用知识,如何去解决问题,如何去创新,而这一切都要靠人的智慧,也就是大脑思维来解决。认真观察周围的人我们也会发现,那些在社会上有所成就的人无不是具有卓越思维能力的人。
  • 季羡林自传(典藏本)

    季羡林自传(典藏本)

    《季羡林自传(典藏本)》畅销近10年,是季羡林生前亲自授权、审定的版本。当代中国出版社为了表达对季羡林先生的纪念,隆重推出双色精编典藏本。《季羡林自传(典藏本)》是作者季羡林先生用自己的笔,讲述了他从山东临清县一个贫苦农民家庭的孩子,一步一步成长为学贯中西、享誉海内外的学术大师的人生历程,记述了他九十多年来所遇到的人和事,见证了时代的变迁,展示了他个人的奋斗经历和情感世界。
  • 凤妃倾城

    凤妃倾城

    在这个皇权至上的朝代,沐千华韬光养晦,只求为自己求得一方宁静,却不想,最终还是沦为了他人的棋子。当那所谓的夫君一剑刺穿自己胸膛的时候,沐千华笑的妖艳,挥剑斩断一头青丝,决然转身。她不信命,也从不认命,不信这个世界上没有一个人跟自己厮守到老……愿得一人心,白首不相离!
  • 翠崖必禅师语录

    翠崖必禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。