登陆注册
5419400000132

第132章

Let it be supposed that a composite thing (as substance) consists of simple parts.Inasmuch as all external relation, consequently all composition of substances, is possible only in space; the space, occupied by that which is composite, must consist of the same number of parts as is contained in the composite.But space does not consist of simple parts, but of spaces.Therefore, every part of the composite must occupy a space.But the absolutely primary parts of what is composite are simple.It follows that what is simple occupies a space.Now, as everything real that occupies a space, contains a manifold the parts of which are external to each other, and is consequently composite- and a real composite, not of accidents (for these cannot exist external to each other apart from substance), but of substances- it follows that the simple must be a substantial composite, which is self-contradictory.

The second proposition of the antithesis- that there exists in the world nothing that is simple- is here equivalent to the following: The existence of the absolutely simple cannot be demonstrated from any experience or perception either external or internal; and the absolutely simple is a mere idea, the objective reality of which cannot be demonstrated in any possible experience; it is consequently, in the exposition of phenomena, without application and object.For, let us take for granted that an object may be found in experience for this transcendental idea; the empirical intuition of such an object must then be recognized to contain absolutely no manifold with its parts external to each other, and connected into unity.

Now, as we cannot reason from the non-consciousness of such a manifold to the impossibility of its existence in the intuition of an object, and as the proof of this impossibility is necessary for the establishment and proof of absolute simplicity; it follows that this simplicity cannot be inferred from any perception whatever.As, therefore, an absolutely simple object cannot be given in any experience, and the world of sense must be considered as the sum total of all possible experiences: nothing simple exists in the world.

This second proposition in the antithesis has a more extended aim than the first.The first merely banishes the simple from the intuition of the composite; while the second drives it entirely out of nature.Hence we were unable to demonstrate it from the conception of a given object of external intuition (of the composite), but we were obliged to prove it from the relation of a given object to a possible experience in general.

OBSERVATIONS ON THE SECOND ANTINOMY.

THESIS.

When I speak of a whole, which necessarily consists of simple parts, I understand thereby only a substantial whole, as the true composite; that is to say, I understand that contingent unity of the manifold which is given as perfectly isolated (at least in thought), placed in reciprocal connection, and thus constituted a unity.Space ought not to be called a compositum but a totum, for its parts are possible in the whole, and not the whole by means of the parts.It might perhaps be called a compositum ideale, but not a compositum reale.But this is of no importance.As space is not a composite of substances (and not even of real accidents), if I abstract all composition therein- nothing, not even a point, remains; for a point is possible only as the limit of a space- consequently of a composite.

Space and time, therefore, do not consist of simple parts.That which belongs only to the condition or state of a substance, even although it possesses a quantity (motion or change, for example), likewise does not consist of simple parts.That is to say, a certain degree of change does not originate from the addition of many simple changes.Our inference of the simple from the composite is valid only of self-subsisting things.But the accidents of a state are not self-subsistent.The proof, then, for the necessity of the simple, as the component part of all that is substantial and composite, may prove a failure, and the whole case of this thesis be lost, if we carry the proposition too far, and wish to make it valid of everything that is composite without distinction- as indeed has really now and then happened.Besides, I am here speaking only of the simple, in so far as it is necessarily given in the composite- the latter being capable of solution into the former as its component parts.The proper signification of the word monas (as employed by Leibnitz) ought to relate to the simple, given immediately as simple substance (for example, in consciousness), and not as an element of the composite.As an clement, the term atomus would be more appropriate.And as I wish to prove the existence of simple substances, only in relation to, and as the elements of, the composite, I might term the antithesis of the second Antinomy, transcendental Atomistic.But as this word has long been employed to designate a particular theory of corporeal phenomena (moleculae), and thus presupposes a basis of empirical conceptions, I prefer calling it the dialectical principle of Monadology.

ANTITHESIS.

同类推荐
  • 华严一乘法界图

    华严一乘法界图

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 刘壮肃公奏议

    刘壮肃公奏议

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上老君说天妃救苦灵验经

    太上老君说天妃救苦灵验经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三洞众戒文

    三洞众戒文

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 警世钟

    警世钟

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 萌妻难哄,首席宠婚甜蜜蜜

    萌妻难哄,首席宠婚甜蜜蜜

    她被他宠得无法无天,神鬼不怕,朋友说他太惯着了,他只道:“无妨,宠得无法无天,除了我,没人再敢要她。”她日渐爱上了这个强势霸道又不讲理的男人,以为此生幸福,却看见他颤抖着搂着另一个女人轻柔的哄着:“别怕,依依,四哥在,再也不离开你。”她才明白,所有的宠爱,都是偷来的。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 灵武

    灵武

    吞噬神鼎,可吞天下灵气,噬万物精华!山贼喽啰徐鸿偶得此鼎,从此告别了炮灰生涯,踏上逆天之路!任你高阶又如何?只要擦破点皮,吸你寿元让你立刻暴毙!以一对万又怎样?吞敌人灵气为己用,越战越勇无人可敌!小小山贼异军突起,且看徐鸿如何登临灵武巅峰!
  • 妖尾之召唤魔导士

    妖尾之召唤魔导士

    有那么一种魔法以卡牌魔法为基底,参考了星灵魔法的召唤,模仿了具现之弧的想象创造,再以附加魔法赋予各种属性,创造出各种各样拥有魔法力量的怪兽。此魔法,被称之为‘召唤之卡’作为此魔法唯一的拥有者,卡尔文·马卡罗在伊修迦尔上书写着自己的传奇。这是名为卡尔文·马卡罗的的故事。
  • 稚界

    稚界

    在虚幻与现实中徘徊,欲望伴随着力量在疯狂生长,在虚幻与现实的界限里谁是“真”,那个又是“假”谁是真谁是假或许已经不重要了吧?
  • 剑心武神

    剑心武神

    轻罗离愁犹余殇,杯酒难释敬行郎;凡春似锦遥无路,独有荆棘守寒广。飘摇垂月映如靥,蜉蝣且来斗思量;海萍微浮波轻起,西风卷帘升惆怅。人生难允柴米断,只身流落到平康;雅阁挂帘十二载,故城遥盼归行郎。
  • 欧阳修词集评

    欧阳修词集评

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洛仙

    洛仙

    人若死去,必然重坠轮回,无法超脱。传闻数百年前巫鬼道,可以借鬼道神通而成大道,但是一夜之间却烟消云散。废墟之上,一鹤西来,天师道应运而生。佛灭之日,乱相纷呈,平民百姓命如草芥。方仲的亲身父母不幸成为一对亡命冤魂,为了复生双亲,他被迫踏上了修道之路。
  • 战帝系列(四)

    战帝系列(四)

    出了残破之庙,放眼望去,果见半里之遥的地方有四个人影在奋力挥舞着兵器,向虚空狠斩力劈,呼喝声不绝于耳,状如疯狂……
  • 宣室志

    宣室志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 我把地球变值钱了

    我把地球变值钱了

    我的外号很多,独裁者,进化之神,地球管理员,计划破坏者,每个人心中的我都不相同。可其实,我只是有钱罢了。