登陆注册
5419400000156

第156章

It is especially remarkable that the practical conception of freedom is based upon the transcendental idea, and that the question of the possibility of the former is difficult only as it involves the consideration of the truth of the latter.Freedom, in the practical sense, is the independence of the will of coercion by sensuous impulses.A will is sensuous, in so far as it is pathologically affected (by sensuous impulses); it is termed animal (arbitrium brutum), when it is pathologically necessitated.The human will is certainly an arbitrium sensitivum, not brutum, but liberum; because sensuousness does not necessitate its action, a faculty existing in man of self-determination, independently of all sensuous coercion.

It is plain that, if all causality in the world of sense were natural- and natural only- every event would be determined by another according to necessary laws, and that, consequently, phenomena, in so far as they determine the will, must necessitate every action as a natural effect from themselves; and thus all practical freedom would fall to the ground with the transcendental idea.For the latter presupposes that although a certain thing has not happened, it ought to have happened, and that, consequently, its phenomenal cause was not so powerful and determinative as to exclude the causality of our will- a causality capable of producing effects independently of and even in opposition to the power of natural causes, and capable, consequently, of spontaneously originating a series of events.

Here, too, we find it to be the case, as we generally found in the self-contradictions and perplexities of a reason which strives to pass the bounds of possible experience, that the problem is properly not physiological, but transcendental.The question of the possibility of freedom does indeed concern psychology; but, as it rests upon dialectical arguments of pure reason, its solution must engage the attention of transcendental philosophy.Before attempting this solution, a task which transcendental philosophy cannot decline, it will be advisable to make a remark with regard to its procedure in the settlement of the question.

If phenomena were things in themselves, and time and space forms of the existence of things, condition and conditioned would always be members of the same series; and thus would arise in the present case the antinomy common to all transcendental ideas- that their series is either too great or too small for the understanding.The dynamical ideas, which we are about to discuss in this and the following section, possess the peculiarity of relating to an object, not considered as a quantity, but as an existence; and thus, in the discussion of the present question, we may make abstraction of the quantity of the series of conditions, and consider merely the dynamical relation of the condition to the conditioned.The question, then, suggests itself, whether freedom is possible; and, if it is, whether it can consist with the universality of the natural law of causality; and, consequently, whether we enounce a proper disjunctive proposition when we say: "Every effect must have its origin either in nature or in freedom," or whether both cannot exist together in the same event in different relations.The principle of an unbroken connection between all events in the phenomenal world, in accordance with the unchangeable laws of nature, is a well-established principle of transcendental analytic which admits of no exception.The question, therefore, is: "Whether an effect, determined according to the laws of nature, can at the same time be produced by a free agent, or whether freedom and nature mutually exclude each other?" And here, the common but fallacious hypothesis of the absolute reality of phenomena manifests its injurious influence in embarrassing the procedure of reason.For if phenomena are things in themselves, freedom is impossible.In this case, nature is the complete and all-sufficient cause of every event; and condition and conditioned, cause and effect are contained in the same series, and necessitated by the same law.If, on the contrary, phenomena are held to be, as they are in fact, nothing more than mere representations, connected with each other in accordance with empirical laws, they must have a ground which is not phenomenal.But the causality of such an intelligible cause is not determined or determinable by phenomena; although its effects, as phenomena, must be determined by other phenomenal existences.This cause and its causality exist therefore out of and apart from the series of phenomena; while its effects do exist and are discoverable in the series of empirical conditions.Such an effect may therefore be considered to be free in relation to its intelligible cause, and necessary in relation to the phenomena from which it is a necessary consequence- a distinction which, stated in this perfectly general and abstract manner, must appear in the highest degree subtle and obscure.

The sequel will explain.It is sufficient, at present, to remark that, as the complete and unbroken connection of phenomena is an unalterable law of nature, freedom is impossible- on the supposition that phenomena are absolutely real.Hence those philosophers who adhere to the common opinion on this subject can never succeed in reconciling the ideas of nature and freedom.

Possibility of Freedom in Harmony with the Universal Law of Natural Necessity.

同类推荐
  • 黄莲东岩禅师语录

    黄莲东岩禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 养性延命录

    养性延命录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 武当玄天上帝灵应宝卷

    武当玄天上帝灵应宝卷

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 七曜星辰别行法

    七曜星辰别行法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 无垢净光大陀罗尼经

    无垢净光大陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 不是我说,你智商真的不行

    不是我说,你智商真的不行

    “你的智商是不是下线了啊?我来教你好了。”我就喜欢用这种不同常人的思考去套路别人,你们这是有意见吗?就算你们有意见,麻烦把智商先上线吧!矮个子长相俊秀却用灵活头脑去称霸整间学校,带上他的同伙一起闯荡初高校界。搞笑的校园日常,猪一样的队友,漂亮的青梅竹马,结伴不良少年……感情纠纷这都不是事儿!
  • 灵山画师就要胡来

    灵山画师就要胡来

    景幽和这六合四海的所有生灵都是格格不入的,因为她是个人,一个普通人。
  • 加特帝国

    加特帝国

    纷乱的大陆,小人物的崛起。加特,一个卑鄙无耻的混蛋。从无到有,一步一步的往前走,从乞丐变成混混,从混混变成了走私犯,从走私犯变成了海贼,从海贼变成了商会会长,从商会会长变成了领地主,最后成为一个帝国的王。兄弟、女人、对手,都是沿途的点缀,记忆中的亮点。请各方书友品评。
  • 拯救蛮荒女神

    拯救蛮荒女神

    地球屌丝易笑意外来到蛮荒大陆,成为了剑圣的弟子,他勤奋修炼,只想找到回家的路,奈何他及身边的红颜们都卷入了惊天阴谋之中,在不断拯救身边女神的过程中,他一步步变强,成为了绝世战神。冲冠一怒为红颜!想动我的女神,没门!神来诛神!
  • 我的1979

    我的1979

    一觉醒来,回到那个年代,再次面对过往,你猜不透的结局..........
  • 教育报刊市场化的困境与突围

    教育报刊市场化的困境与突围

    本书以湖北教育报刊社为例,研究了我国大陆教育报刊市场化的问题。并全面地梳理了教育报刊市场化经营的有关研究成果,较为准确地描述了我国教育报刊市场化路线的发展历史。本选题具有极强的现实意义。亦具有较强的实践指导价值。
  • 三明地名纵横

    三明地名纵横

    市方志委编纂的“三明地情丛书”之《三明地名纵横》从行政地名、自然实体地名、人工建筑地名等方面,真实地反映出三明地名的社会性、时代性、民族性、地域性等特征。
  • 修真黑科技

    修真黑科技

    经过无尽岁月的沉淀和积累,无仙、无帝、不长生的后仙古时期,开启了一代修真大世,各种机缘与造化层出不穷。北原皇子牧天歌,以体入道,迈上了不合时代的修真之路。他凭借出众的天资,不懈的努力,和超前的思维模式,穷极所有,与天争,与地争,与人争,可终难逃宿命轮回。
  • 微型小说一千零一夜(第十卷)

    微型小说一千零一夜(第十卷)

    本书中的每一篇小说都是一个贴近生活的精彩故事,反映着当代生活的广阔图景。它们不仅能教会你如何理解生活,更能教会你如何热爱生活。开阔读者的视野、启迪读者的心智、使读者得到精神享受,是编者编选此书的最大愿望。
  • 活幼心书

    活幼心书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。