登陆注册
5589700000051

第51章 PHILOSOPHY(5)

But a difficulty arises when a similar method is applied to a doctrine sincerely disputed.To the statement,'this is a necessary belief,'it is a sufficient answer to reply,'I don't believe it.'In that case,an intuition merely amounts to a dogmatic assumption that I am infallible,and must be supported by showing its connection with beliefs really universal and admittedly necessary.

Dugald Stewart followed Reid upon this main question,and with less force and originality represents the same point of view.He accepts Reid's view of the two co-ordinate departments of knowledge;the science of which mind,and the science of which body,is the object.Philosophy is not a 'theory of knowledge'or of the universe;but,as it was then called,'a philosophy of the human mind.''Philosophy'is founded upon inductive psychology;and it only becomes philosophy in a wider sense in so far as we discover that as a fact we have certain fundamental beliefs,which are thus given by experience,though they take us in a sense beyond experience.Jeffrey,reviewing Stewart's life of Reid,in the Edinburgh Review of 1804,makes a significant inference from this.Bacon's method,he said,had succeeded in the physical sciences,because there we could apply experiment.But experiment is impossible in the science of mind;and therefore philosophy will never be anything but a plaything or a useful variety of gymnastic.Stewart replied at some length in his Essays,(25)fully accepting the general conception,but arguing that the experimental method was applicable to the science of mind.Jeffrey observes that it was now admitted that the 'profoundest reasonings'had brought us back to the view of the vulgar,and this,too,is admitted by Stewart so far as the cardinal doctrine of 'the common sense'philosophy,the theory of perception,is admitted.

From this,again,it follows that the 'notions we annex to the words Matter and Mind are merely relative.'(26)We know that mind exists as we know that matter exists;or,if anything,we know the existence of mind more certainly because more directly.The mind is suggested by 'the subjects of our consciousness';the body by the objects 'of our perception.'But,on the other hand,we are totally 'ignorant of the essence of either.'(27)We can discover the laws either of mental or moral phenomena;but a law,as he explains,means in strictness nothing but a 'general fact.'(28)It is idle,therefore,to explain the nature of the union between the two unknowable substances;we can only discover that they are united and observe the laws according to which one set of phenomena corresponds to the other.From a misunderstanding of this arise all the fallacies of scholastic ontology,'the most idle and absurd speculation that ever employed the human faculties.'(29)The destruction of that pseudo-science was the great glory of Bacon and Locke;and Reid has now discovered the method by which we may advance to the establishment of a truly inductive 'philosophy of mind.'

It is not surprising that Stewart approximates in various directions to the doctrines of the empirical school.He leans towards them whenever he do es not see the results to which he is tending.Thus,for example,he is a thorough-going nominalist;(30)and on this point he deserts the teaching of Reid.He defends against Reid the attack made by Berkeley and Hume upon 'abstract ideas.'Rosmini,(31)in an elaborate criticism,complains that Stewart did not perceive the inevitable tendency of nominalism to materialism.(32)Stewart,in fact,accepts a good deal of Horne Tooke's doctrine,(33)though calling Tooke an 'ingenious grammarian,not a very profound philosopher,'but holds,as we shall see,that the materialistic tendency can be avoided.

As becomes a nominalist,he attacks the syllogism upon grounds more fully brought out by J.S.Mill.Upon another essential point,he agrees with the pure empiricists.He accepts Hume's view of causation in all questions of physical science.In natural philosophy,he declares causation means only conjunction.The senses can never give us the 'efficient'cause of any phenomenon.

In other words,we can never see a 'necessary connection'between any two events.He collects passages from earlier writers to show how Hume had been anticipated;and holds that Bacon's inadequate view of this truth was a main defect in his theories.(34)Hence we have a characteristic conclusion.He says,when discussing the proofs of the existence of God,(35)that we have an 'irresistible conviction of the necessity of a cause'for every change.

Hume,however,has shown that this can never be a logical necessity.It must then,argues Stewart,be either a 'prejudice'or an 'intuitive judgment.'

Since it is shown by 'universal consent'not to be a prejudice,it must be an intuitive judgment.Thus Hume's facts are accepted;but his inference denied.The actual causal nexus is inscrutable.The conviction that there must be a connection between events attributed by Hume to 'custom'is attributed by Stewart to intuitive belief.Stewart infers that Hume's doctrine is really favourable to theology.It implies that God gives us the conviction,and perhaps,as Malebranche held,that God is 'the constantly operating efficient Cause in the material world.'(36)Stewart's successor,Thomas Brown,took up this argument on occasion of the once famous 'Leslie controversy';and Brown's teaching was endorsed by James Mill and by John Stuart Mill.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 王妃倾城:王爷求放过

    王妃倾城:王爷求放过

    善良的她,为了自己爱的人,嫁入王府,在她满身伤痕的时候,才发现这都是一场阴谋,在想要离开时,他说:我爱的人是你,你逃不掉了。”
  • 青藏铁路

    青藏铁路

    我的一行行诗是一条条白云般的哈达,高高举过头,献给你,青藏铁路;献给你,青藏高原;献给你,珠穆朗玛;献给你,拉萨……我的一行行诗是一条一条有体温的枕木,向着你,匍匐匍匐,我的西藏;向着你,匍匐匍匐,我的热土;向着你,匍匐匍匐,我的拉萨,我的众神之都……我的一行行诗其实是一颗一颗铺路石,密密匝匝地,众志成城地,扛起青藏铁路,完成历史和未来的同期叮嘱……我的一行行诗其实是一只一只春蚕,浑身透亮地,吐着蚕丝地,铺设着一条前无古人的丝绸之路……
  • 天庭兵王

    天庭兵王

    新书已经上传,书名:一剑捅穿这民国,请大家继续支持。 荣嘉刚来到这个世界的时候,猴子才刚刚从石头里蹦出来,天蓬还没被封为元帅,小白龙还在四海逍遥地纨绔着,九头虫才长出两颗头,那具白骨依然被深埋在万年阴墓下,黑熊是个只知掏蜂窝的吃货,蝎子精对自己的身世懵懂不知,一切都还没开始,但高高在上的圣人们已经开始布局,只是随着荣嘉的到来,从此之后,世间再无西游
  • 三生劫难之厮守一生

    三生劫难之厮守一生

    三生三世,我都要和你厮守一生。凤景看着若离离红光近在咫尺的距离,他的脑海里飘过凤族长老的话“殿下,你用这招“凤啸”的时候一定要谨记凤啸一出,必见血光…”
  • 猎人笔记

    猎人笔记

    揭露农奴主的残忍,农奴的悲惨生活,因此被放逐。在监禁中写成短篇小说《木木》,对农奴制表示抗议。在每一个笔记故事中,除了“猎人”的形象外,还有一个特色就是对于大自然的描写,无论色彩、音响和气息,都表现出作家敏锐的洞察力、听力和细腻的感受力。无怪托尔斯泰断言,在自然景物描写上,屠格涅夫以后的作家是无人敢动笔了。
  • 乱龙篇

    乱龙篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 冲动的青春——桌球绝恋(下)

    冲动的青春——桌球绝恋(下)

    《桌球绝恋》讲述了:那些年,我们都很年轻;那些年,我们对爱情懵懵懂懂;那些年,我们分不清喜欢与爱。当感觉来临时,我们会脸红,会心跳,当看不见某个人时,会想念,会想见,当一个人的时候,会憧憬,会傻笑。那些带着青涩的味道,那些关于我们青春里羞羞答答的回忆,那些,长大的我们,总是怀念的校园时代。
  • 玉照新志

    玉照新志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 稽查之城

    稽查之城

    赵建国、吴光荣、王坚持和邱已经四个人在喜客来打麻将,被公安局给抓了。他们在8318房,正打着,有人敲门。邱已经说:“请进。没声音,门继续敲着。“进呀,邱已经说,“敲个鬼。邱已经今天火不好,老输,他以为是服务员,言语就戗。赵建国一看,房门小栓倒着,哪进得来?“谁把门反锁了。说着,赵建国起身去开门。邱已经担心他看自己的牌,啪一下把竖着的麻将子反扣在牌桌上。门刚开,呼一下进来六七个人,没服务员。有人嚷着:“公安局的,都别动。”
  • 暖婚契爱:老婆,宠入怀

    暖婚契爱:老婆,宠入怀

    “老公,该睡觉了。”“我……正在忙。”男人慌忙抓了本书一本正经地看了起来。自从结婚后,言辞就发现他们俩睡觉的姿势都有些不对。以前那个一言不合就壁咚的男人竟然变得清心寡欲起来。“老公,说实话,你是不是不行?”男人漆黑的深眸一片幽暗:“阿辞,你要知道我是个传统的男人,婚前坚决守身如玉。”嗤!四年前灌醉她占完便宜就跑的男人,还说什么守身如玉?等等,他这话是什么意思?她看到男人脸上一闪而过的心虚,登时大怒:“混蛋,你又骗我!”男人一脸坚定地把人拖上床,温柔安抚:“不,是我爱你。”于是,当她终于成为顶级设计师后,有人采访:穆总在你心中的形象是?言辞抽着嘴角非常肯定地回答:戏精。【双洁一对一宠文】