登陆注册
5589700000051

第51章 PHILOSOPHY(5)

But a difficulty arises when a similar method is applied to a doctrine sincerely disputed.To the statement,'this is a necessary belief,'it is a sufficient answer to reply,'I don't believe it.'In that case,an intuition merely amounts to a dogmatic assumption that I am infallible,and must be supported by showing its connection with beliefs really universal and admittedly necessary.

Dugald Stewart followed Reid upon this main question,and with less force and originality represents the same point of view.He accepts Reid's view of the two co-ordinate departments of knowledge;the science of which mind,and the science of which body,is the object.Philosophy is not a 'theory of knowledge'or of the universe;but,as it was then called,'a philosophy of the human mind.''Philosophy'is founded upon inductive psychology;and it only becomes philosophy in a wider sense in so far as we discover that as a fact we have certain fundamental beliefs,which are thus given by experience,though they take us in a sense beyond experience.Jeffrey,reviewing Stewart's life of Reid,in the Edinburgh Review of 1804,makes a significant inference from this.Bacon's method,he said,had succeeded in the physical sciences,because there we could apply experiment.But experiment is impossible in the science of mind;and therefore philosophy will never be anything but a plaything or a useful variety of gymnastic.Stewart replied at some length in his Essays,(25)fully accepting the general conception,but arguing that the experimental method was applicable to the science of mind.Jeffrey observes that it was now admitted that the 'profoundest reasonings'had brought us back to the view of the vulgar,and this,too,is admitted by Stewart so far as the cardinal doctrine of 'the common sense'philosophy,the theory of perception,is admitted.

From this,again,it follows that the 'notions we annex to the words Matter and Mind are merely relative.'(26)We know that mind exists as we know that matter exists;or,if anything,we know the existence of mind more certainly because more directly.The mind is suggested by 'the subjects of our consciousness';the body by the objects 'of our perception.'But,on the other hand,we are totally 'ignorant of the essence of either.'(27)We can discover the laws either of mental or moral phenomena;but a law,as he explains,means in strictness nothing but a 'general fact.'(28)It is idle,therefore,to explain the nature of the union between the two unknowable substances;we can only discover that they are united and observe the laws according to which one set of phenomena corresponds to the other.From a misunderstanding of this arise all the fallacies of scholastic ontology,'the most idle and absurd speculation that ever employed the human faculties.'(29)The destruction of that pseudo-science was the great glory of Bacon and Locke;and Reid has now discovered the method by which we may advance to the establishment of a truly inductive 'philosophy of mind.'

It is not surprising that Stewart approximates in various directions to the doctrines of the empirical school.He leans towards them whenever he do es not see the results to which he is tending.Thus,for example,he is a thorough-going nominalist;(30)and on this point he deserts the teaching of Reid.He defends against Reid the attack made by Berkeley and Hume upon 'abstract ideas.'Rosmini,(31)in an elaborate criticism,complains that Stewart did not perceive the inevitable tendency of nominalism to materialism.(32)Stewart,in fact,accepts a good deal of Horne Tooke's doctrine,(33)though calling Tooke an 'ingenious grammarian,not a very profound philosopher,'but holds,as we shall see,that the materialistic tendency can be avoided.

As becomes a nominalist,he attacks the syllogism upon grounds more fully brought out by J.S.Mill.Upon another essential point,he agrees with the pure empiricists.He accepts Hume's view of causation in all questions of physical science.In natural philosophy,he declares causation means only conjunction.The senses can never give us the 'efficient'cause of any phenomenon.

In other words,we can never see a 'necessary connection'between any two events.He collects passages from earlier writers to show how Hume had been anticipated;and holds that Bacon's inadequate view of this truth was a main defect in his theories.(34)Hence we have a characteristic conclusion.He says,when discussing the proofs of the existence of God,(35)that we have an 'irresistible conviction of the necessity of a cause'for every change.

Hume,however,has shown that this can never be a logical necessity.It must then,argues Stewart,be either a 'prejudice'or an 'intuitive judgment.'

Since it is shown by 'universal consent'not to be a prejudice,it must be an intuitive judgment.Thus Hume's facts are accepted;but his inference denied.The actual causal nexus is inscrutable.The conviction that there must be a connection between events attributed by Hume to 'custom'is attributed by Stewart to intuitive belief.Stewart infers that Hume's doctrine is really favourable to theology.It implies that God gives us the conviction,and perhaps,as Malebranche held,that God is 'the constantly operating efficient Cause in the material world.'(36)Stewart's successor,Thomas Brown,took up this argument on occasion of the once famous 'Leslie controversy';and Brown's teaching was endorsed by James Mill and by John Stuart Mill.

同类推荐
  • 广异记

    广异记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 慧命经

    慧命经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说阿惟越致遮经

    佛说阿惟越致遮经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 台湾采访册

    台湾采访册

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上灵宝天尊说禳灾度厄经

    太上灵宝天尊说禳灾度厄经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 锐读(第6期·悬疑新主张)

    锐读(第6期·悬疑新主张)

    《惊奇档案》专栏编辑,觅骨寻踪,亲历惊奇与惊险,探寻神秘的不可思议,用科学的态度解读怪谈与诡闻。
  • 我把地球变值钱了

    我把地球变值钱了

    我的外号很多,独裁者,进化之神,地球管理员,计划破坏者,每个人心中的我都不相同。可其实,我只是有钱罢了。
  • 沟通无极限

    沟通无极限

    本书避免了一般口才读物中常见的那些枯燥的理论教条,也没有罗列那些可望而不可及的口才奇迹,而是从大家日常生活和工作的实际需要出发,深入浅出地探讨了“沟通无极限”这个口才理念,将一系列提高口才的方法清晰地展现在您的面前。这一过程遵循了“了解-学习-实践-应用”的科学学习步骤,并且力图让每一位读者将本书提出的106个智慧运用到自己的实际生活中去,为每一位读者切实提高自己的口才提供了有益的借鉴,并且有助于读者从中有所感悟,提高锻练口才的积极性。
  • 谷山笔麈

    谷山笔麈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 相之忘笑之落

    相之忘笑之落

    一切的一切皆是一个缘字,你我皆是缘,初相见,莫回首,注孤独。
  • 妃你莫属呢

    妃你莫属呢

    世人都说,无情皆是帝王家。从她入宫开始,她便深受宠爱。她愿也怒,可也无可奈何。身为帝王家,他的心思只是在这个女人的身上,除了这个女人之外,他从未爱上过任何的人。悄悄的呆在她的身边,默默的守候着这个女人。深宫之中,帝王独爱唯此一人。谁都不会明白,在他的心里,这个女人到底是有多重要,也没有谁知道,在这个女人的心里,这个男人到底是又有多重要。缘深缘浅,深宫独爱。
  • 天启人形

    天启人形

    有一天,有一位下位神问我,我的成神经历。好烦恼,并不是不想告诉他,毕竟我的经历具有不可复制的特点,关于他好奇的理由也是显而易见的——毕竟我是少数的初入议会就是上位神的家伙呢。但是,不想说话,啊好烦,要不写下来?就这样吧!写下来。「那是一个濒临毁灭的世界呢……」
  • 绝对狂神

    绝对狂神

    在武者的世界,拳头大就是老大,夜飞羽不甘平凡,自从获得一枚龙形琥珀后,快速崛起为一代狂神。
  • 陪伴是最长情的告白2

    陪伴是最长情的告白2

    这本《陪伴是最长情的告白2》里的文字,有一部分就是当年行走在路上时写的,也有最近给韩寒的ONE写的《别怕有我》《光头女友》及一些未发表过的新文章。对于我来说,无论行走的梦想还是写作的梦想都还没有完成,在完成写作梦的时候虽然耽误了行走梦,但因为写作这个梦想,行走的梦想也变得更有意义了。
  • 我的王妃太有肉

    我的王妃太有肉

    推荐水儿新文《黑道“傻”后》《朕的皇后太爱钱》轻松搞笑文:+++++++++++++++++++爆笑贪吃小肥女,一张吃嘴闯古代萧纤柔——一个身材惹火的女孩子,舞蹈界新升起的一颗明日之星。在外人眼中,她光鲜亮丽,充满活力。殊不知真正的她最大的愿望则是做一枚坐吃等死的懒女。(米虫)为此还特地给自己定了一个懒人十大梦想,每晚睡觉前都会默念几遍。话说人倒霉,那是接二连三的,一个重要的舞蹈大赛前,一不小心感冒了,真的很倒霉。她自认了。比赛时一个喷嚏,害得她与冠军失之交臂,真的很惨,她也接受了。害得被父母惩罚,逼着每天加紧练习舞蹈,她也服了。可为什么倒霉的事还没有结束呢?练舞练累了,本想偷个懒,却没想到喝口饮料被呛到,居然穿越了?穿就穿了呗!接受现实,可却倒霉的穿越到了一个体态臃肿,超级肥胖的女子身上。但既然命运如此,她也欣然接受了,好歹人家的父母也蛮有钱的,只要能在这个朝代实现她坐吃等死的十大梦想,她也就觉得值了。可万万没想到的是,霉运居然也跟着她穿越了——刚穿来,衣来伸手饭来张口的懒女生活没过几天,皇帝就给她来了个什么赐婚?听说还是个冰冷的王爷?唉!既然这是上天的安排,行,她接受了,只要依旧能让她做米虫,让她坐吃等死,她嫁就是了。毕竟人家也是位大帅哥,有权有势,拒绝了多伤人家的面子啊!调戏美男,是她做懒女以外的另一个梦想,既然上天让她实现这个梦想,她就美美的享受吧!这也算是不幸中的万幸了。可是——没想到这个王爷夫君有些太不识抬举!本姑娘不嫌他冷,愿意下嫁。他居然不知好歹的嫌自己肥,还给自己起了个很吉祥的外号“福娃”唉!要不是知道他是土生土长的傲天国人,还以为他也是穿来的呢!精彩一:“女儿啊!快进来!看你的未来夫君来看你了。”“真的吗爹爹?”屋内的三个俊美男子,听到外面这声娇柔的声音,便猜测起这人定是如声音一样的美丽动人——随后三人就觉得地晃动的厉害,地动山摇的,好似地震却又不像——好似有什么东西快速的朝他们移来——片刻后,只见一肥的像球一样的女子。拽着肥肥的身子,气喘吁吁的跑了进来,定眼扫了屋内三个俊美男子一眼,脸一红,扭捏了下肥胖的身子,故作一脸害羞状的亮起娇柔柔的声音道:“爹爹,那位是我的未来夫君啊?”