登陆注册
5589700000086

第86章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(8)

Bentham admits this in his own fashion.If 'motives'cannot be properly called good or bad,is there,he asks,nothing good or bad in the man who on a given occasion obeys a certain motive?'Yes,certainly,'he replies,'his disposition.'(46)The disposition,he adds,is a 'fictitious entity,and designed for the convenience of discourse in order to express what there is supposed to be permanent in a man's frame of mind.'By 'fictitious,'as we have seen,he means not 'unreal'but simply not tangible,weighable,or measurable-like sticks and stones,or like pains and pleasures.'Fictitious'as they may be,therefore,the fiction enables us to express real truths,and to state facts which are of the highest importance to the moralist and the legislator.Bentham discusses some cases of casuistry in order to show the relation between the tendency of an action and the intention and motives of the agent.Ravaillac murders a good king;Ravaillac's son enables his father to escape punishment,or conveys poison to his father to enable him to avoid torture by suicide.(47)What is the inference as to the son's disposition in either case?The solution (as he substantially and,I think,rightly suggests)will have to be reached by considering whether the facts indicate that the son's disposition was mischievous or otherwise;whether it indicates political disloyalty or filial affection,and so forth,and in what proportions.The most interesting case perhaps is that of religious persecution,where the religious motive is taken to be good,and the action to which it leads is yet admitted to be mischievous.The problem is often puzzling,but we are virtually making an inference as to the goodness or badness of the 'disposition'implied by the given action under all the supposed circumstances.This gives what Bentham calls the 'meritoriousness'(48)of the disposition.The 'intention'is caused by the 'motive.'The 'disposition'is the 'sum of the intentions';that is to say,it expresses the agent's sensibility to various classes of motives;and the merit therefore will be in proportion to the total goodness or badness of the disposition thus indicated.The question of merit leads to interesting moral problems.Bentham,however,observes that he is not here speaking from the point of view of the moralist but of the legislator.

Still,as a legislator he has to consider what is the 'depravity'of disposition indicated by different kinds of conduct.This consideration is of great importance.

The 'disposition'includes sensibility to what he calls 'tutelary motives'motives,that is,which deter a man from such conduct as generally produces mischievous consequences.No motive can be invariably,though some,especially the motive of goodwill,and in a minor degree those of 'amity'and a 'love of reputation,'are generally,on the right side.The legislator has to reinforce these 'tutelary motives'by 'artificial tutelary motives,'and mainly by appealing to the 'love of ease,'that is,by making mischievous conduct more difficult,and to 'self-preservation,'that is,by making it more dangerous.(49)He has therefore to measure the force by which these motives will be opposed;or,in other words,the 'strength of the temptation.'Now the more depraved a man's disposition,the weaker the temptation which will seduce him to crime.

Consequently if an act shows depravity,it will require a stronger counter-motive or a more severe punishment,as the disposition indicated is more mischievous.

An act,for example,which implies deliberation proves a greater insensibility to these social motives which,as Bentham remarks,(50)determine the 'general tenor of a man's life,'however depraved he may be.The legislator is guided solely by 'utility,'or aims at maximising happiness without reference to its quality.Still,so far as action implies disposition,he has to cOnsider the depravity as a source of mischief.The legislator who looks solely at the moral quality implied is wrong;and,if guided solely by his sympathies,has no measure for the amount of punishment to be inflicted.These considerations will enable us to see what is the proper measure of resentment.(51)The doctrine of the neutrality or 'unmorality'of motive is thus sufficiently clear.Bentham's whole aim is to urge that the criterion of morality is given by the consequences of actions.To say the conduct is good or bad is to say in other words that it produces a balance of pleasure or pain.To make the criterion independent,or escape the vicious circle,we must admit the pleasures and pains to be in themselves neutral;to have,that is,the same value,if equally strong,whatever their source.In our final balance-sheet we must set down pains of illwill and of goodwill,of sense and of intellect with absolute impartiality,and compare them simply in respect of intensity.We must not admit a 'conscience'or 'moral sense'which would be autocratic;nor,indeed,allow moral to have any meaning as applied to the separate passions.

But it is quite consistent with this to admit that some motives,goodwill in particular,generally tend to bring out the desirable result,that is,a balance of pleasure for the greatest number.The pains and pleasures are the ultimate facts,and the 'disposition'is a 'fictitious entity'or a name for the sum of sensibilities.It represents the fact that some men are more inclined than others to increase the total of good or bad.

同类推荐
  • 小儿疮疡门

    小儿疮疡门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Patagonia

    The Patagonia

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洞玄灵宝太上六斋十直圣纪经

    洞玄灵宝太上六斋十直圣纪经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 先识览

    先识览

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 画图缘

    画图缘

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 豹的世仇

    豹的世仇

    十八年前,狒狒杰瑞德和花豹卡罗莎是在同一片土地上长大的伙伴。长大后,狩猎的冲突使它们疏远了彼此,唯恐对方侵入自己的领地。一个旱季的夜晚,为了采摘可以救命的猴面包树叶,狒狒杰瑞德爬上了花豹卡罗莎世代居住的巨大的猴面包树,不慎撞落了卡罗莎储藏在树上的猎物……为了报复狒狒杰瑞德,卡罗莎偷袭了杰瑞德狒狒家族,却惨败而归。杰瑞德率领庞大的狒狒家族,趁机抢占了花豹卡罗莎世代居住的猴面包树。为了争夺巨大的猴面包树,花豹家族和狒狒家族爆发了一次次血战。
  • 成功创业的300个常识

    成功创业的300个常识

    创业并不是传奇!书中的内容并不会让您头脑发热、热血沸腾,反而会让您趋于理性、冷静!它没有吹嘘种种创业的“宝典”和“圣经”,而是讲述可能导致创业失败甚至让创业者破产的种种可能和潜在隐患。它解决的问题是:在当下的中国,没有资本支撑也没有强大的后台,普通人如何避开陷阱、少走弯路、修正做事方法,从而走出“我想创业”的梦想,迈向“我能创业”的征程!是企业老板、门店经营者、草根创业者和不甘于打工者不可不读的创业实践宝典。
  • 谁念庭风独飞雪

    谁念庭风独飞雪

    苏千雪以为,能够嫁给他是美好的开始。她也以为,再等等,顾廷睿对她就不会有那么多的冷漠和无情。结果,夜夜折磨,她发现他深爱的只有自己的继妹。胎死腹中,父亲身亡。她的深爱换来了刻骨铭心的痛恨,也终于决定远离顾延睿……
  • 你和我的倾城年华

    你和我的倾城年华

    她离开家乡到外地教学,后来因为闺蜜的婚贴而重新回到家乡,不料又遇上了他,她该如何选择?是默默守护的男生还是记忆中的他?青春的往事渐渐浮现在脑海里,到底谁才是那个对的人?
  • 雪夜龙藏

    雪夜龙藏

    他原本是一名孤儿,一名杀手,在异世重生重生,他如何一步一步登上巅峰?是强敌的来袭,还是亲者的背叛,亦或是命运的捉弄?是巨龙冲天,还是杀神临世。亦正亦邪,谁又能说得清、道得明。
  • 相思谋,总裁的出逃妻

    相思谋,总裁的出逃妻

    【题记——爱情再贵,也不过是你想要的,我刚好给得起!】她是G城建筑首富之女,却在幼年离家出走,浪迹于江城旧郊。苦恋十年的恋人抛弃于她,另娶之人竟然是她的继妹;洁癖到病态的男人横空出世,步步为谋,纳她入局,究竟是奇货可居还是另有隐情?当她在男人的强取豪夺之下,终于动心,陷入男人的相思之谋后,却发现,真正的悲剧刚刚开始。他的初恋回归,她是他心口的朱砂痣?还是拍干在墙上的蚊子血?她的前任后悔,他是她一场意外的真心错付?还是寂寞生命里的巧合?他和她,都经历过浓烈的爱情。原本以为,再也没有资格去爱的他,和再也没有能力来爱的她,一不小心,却将爱情开成了繁花似锦!十年一觉,原来所有的感情都是注定!幸好,她的归期,恰逢花开!……那个让你咬着牙逞强,憋着眼泪倔强的人,一定不会是良配!——【顾西陆】爱情再贵,也不过是你想要的,我刚好给得起!——【顾西陆】有欲望,是喜欢;忍住对你的欲望,是爱情!——【顾西陆】不欺骗,不背叛,不抛弃,我对爱情的要求如此简单,却一次次妥协成为弥留在心尖上的坟!爱你,从未想过是这么残酷的事!——【楚乔】你渗进我的生命时,我毫无知觉,等到发现时,已经不疯魔,不成活!——【楚乔】此文暖虐,三观正常,无狗血沸腾,纯洁一对一!【新人一枚,看文请收藏,拜谢!】
  • 做事要会算计

    做事要会算计

    做事要会算计,不是让你在做事过程中为达目的而不择手段;不是让你为了摘取成功桂冠而暗中“放箭”;更不是让你为了出人头地而不惜货地里使“阴招”。所谓算计,是做事先下手为强的胆略;是行动前深谋远虑的眼光;是让“人情”更具杀伤力的手段;是借机会之力成就辉煌的气魄;是你走向成功的巧言妙语。《做事要会算计》一书,以改变做事莽撞、毛躁、缺新少变、思维僵硬这些普遍存在的做事方式为出发点,并紧密结合当今社会的现实,谈做事的技巧和道理,语言风趣幽默、浅显易懂;知识面广而可读性强,观念新颖而人情人理。不管是创业者还是成功者,不管是领导者还是普通职员,都可以从中得到有益的启迪。
  • 神级主角光环

    神级主角光环

    一不小心,杨星穿越了,然后成为了绝对的主角,拥有了神级主角光环!神级主角光环到底有多牛X?打个架,对手能被自己绊倒摔成重伤!被高手追杀,仇人遇到仇人的仇人结果同归于尽!摔下悬崖,能够遇到逆天的传承、远古宝藏、无敌宠物!连被漂亮女杀手刺杀,最后女杀手都能够莫名其妙成为自己的女仆!……拥有神级主角光环的杨星,简直就是无敌的气运之子!美女?三宫六院?宝物?势力?装X?闷声发大财?一路横推?杨星表示,那都不是事。
  • 字母的童话

    字母的童话

    本书把26个字母的关系用爱情的方式演绎出来,环环相扣,形成一个神奇、美好、纯真的童话世界。26个字母,它们既是全文的章节名称,却又是26个故事的主人公,每个字母代表一个渴望恋爱的孩子,用自己凌厉却悲哀的眼神谱写出一曲惟有恋人才听得懂的灵魂乐。一曲惟有恋人才听得见的灵魂乐,一部26个字母荡气回肠的爱情圣经。
  • 爱情不过你有病我有药

    爱情不过你有病我有药

    【已出版上市】(全本完)我没有遇到猫在潜水,却遇到你。没有遇到狗在攀岩,却遇到你。我没有遇到夏天飘雪,却遇到你。我没有遇见所有的不平凡,却遇见了不平凡的你。刚刚好,你有病,我有药。我想,这就是爱情吧。