登陆注册
5589700000086

第86章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(8)

Bentham admits this in his own fashion.If 'motives'cannot be properly called good or bad,is there,he asks,nothing good or bad in the man who on a given occasion obeys a certain motive?'Yes,certainly,'he replies,'his disposition.'(46)The disposition,he adds,is a 'fictitious entity,and designed for the convenience of discourse in order to express what there is supposed to be permanent in a man's frame of mind.'By 'fictitious,'as we have seen,he means not 'unreal'but simply not tangible,weighable,or measurable-like sticks and stones,or like pains and pleasures.'Fictitious'as they may be,therefore,the fiction enables us to express real truths,and to state facts which are of the highest importance to the moralist and the legislator.Bentham discusses some cases of casuistry in order to show the relation between the tendency of an action and the intention and motives of the agent.Ravaillac murders a good king;Ravaillac's son enables his father to escape punishment,or conveys poison to his father to enable him to avoid torture by suicide.(47)What is the inference as to the son's disposition in either case?The solution (as he substantially and,I think,rightly suggests)will have to be reached by considering whether the facts indicate that the son's disposition was mischievous or otherwise;whether it indicates political disloyalty or filial affection,and so forth,and in what proportions.The most interesting case perhaps is that of religious persecution,where the religious motive is taken to be good,and the action to which it leads is yet admitted to be mischievous.The problem is often puzzling,but we are virtually making an inference as to the goodness or badness of the 'disposition'implied by the given action under all the supposed circumstances.This gives what Bentham calls the 'meritoriousness'(48)of the disposition.The 'intention'is caused by the 'motive.'The 'disposition'is the 'sum of the intentions';that is to say,it expresses the agent's sensibility to various classes of motives;and the merit therefore will be in proportion to the total goodness or badness of the disposition thus indicated.The question of merit leads to interesting moral problems.Bentham,however,observes that he is not here speaking from the point of view of the moralist but of the legislator.

Still,as a legislator he has to consider what is the 'depravity'of disposition indicated by different kinds of conduct.This consideration is of great importance.

The 'disposition'includes sensibility to what he calls 'tutelary motives'motives,that is,which deter a man from such conduct as generally produces mischievous consequences.No motive can be invariably,though some,especially the motive of goodwill,and in a minor degree those of 'amity'and a 'love of reputation,'are generally,on the right side.The legislator has to reinforce these 'tutelary motives'by 'artificial tutelary motives,'and mainly by appealing to the 'love of ease,'that is,by making mischievous conduct more difficult,and to 'self-preservation,'that is,by making it more dangerous.(49)He has therefore to measure the force by which these motives will be opposed;or,in other words,the 'strength of the temptation.'Now the more depraved a man's disposition,the weaker the temptation which will seduce him to crime.

Consequently if an act shows depravity,it will require a stronger counter-motive or a more severe punishment,as the disposition indicated is more mischievous.

An act,for example,which implies deliberation proves a greater insensibility to these social motives which,as Bentham remarks,(50)determine the 'general tenor of a man's life,'however depraved he may be.The legislator is guided solely by 'utility,'or aims at maximising happiness without reference to its quality.Still,so far as action implies disposition,he has to cOnsider the depravity as a source of mischief.The legislator who looks solely at the moral quality implied is wrong;and,if guided solely by his sympathies,has no measure for the amount of punishment to be inflicted.These considerations will enable us to see what is the proper measure of resentment.(51)The doctrine of the neutrality or 'unmorality'of motive is thus sufficiently clear.Bentham's whole aim is to urge that the criterion of morality is given by the consequences of actions.To say the conduct is good or bad is to say in other words that it produces a balance of pleasure or pain.To make the criterion independent,or escape the vicious circle,we must admit the pleasures and pains to be in themselves neutral;to have,that is,the same value,if equally strong,whatever their source.In our final balance-sheet we must set down pains of illwill and of goodwill,of sense and of intellect with absolute impartiality,and compare them simply in respect of intensity.We must not admit a 'conscience'or 'moral sense'which would be autocratic;nor,indeed,allow moral to have any meaning as applied to the separate passions.

But it is quite consistent with this to admit that some motives,goodwill in particular,generally tend to bring out the desirable result,that is,a balance of pleasure for the greatest number.The pains and pleasures are the ultimate facts,and the 'disposition'is a 'fictitious entity'or a name for the sum of sensibilities.It represents the fact that some men are more inclined than others to increase the total of good or bad.

同类推荐
  • 龙虚篇

    龙虚篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 李文襄公奏疏与文移

    李文襄公奏疏与文移

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • THE KREUTZER SONATA

    THE KREUTZER SONATA

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Make-Believe Man

    The Make-Believe Man

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 医学衷中参西录

    医学衷中参西录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 奔火

    奔火

    魏南风几乎一夜没睡,天亮透前,大脑才终于累得昏沉,迷迷糊糊坠入一团纠缠的网中,弹了几下腿,合上眼。她安慰自己:好了好了,终于睡着了,呼噜扯得轰响了。面色极差,双眼通红无神,一缺觉,脸上的几根三八纹就出来作怪,把平时还算平滑的脸分割成凸凹不平的几大块,用手按按扯扯,它们横眉冷眼,各守封地严阵以待。不想见任何人,最好有个黑箱子,把她关在里面,好好补一觉。客厅闹钟提示已经上午十点,南风皱皱眉,强打起精神,涂脸、穿衣、化妆。吴熏准时等在常去的那家餐馆,见她进来,掐灭了手中的烟。“又没睡好?” 他瞟瞟她。
  • 总裁要够了没

    总裁要够了没

    那一晚,从酒吧到酒店,他才知已婚的她竟还是一个女孩。从女孩到女人,她只当被蚊子咬了一口,却,从此惹上了那个男人,女人星星眼望之的小鲜肉。终于有一天,她才知她一直自以为是小生的男人竟有着无比显赫的身世,再也甩不开。
  • 惊天奇案Ⅱ:滔天大罪

    惊天奇案Ⅱ:滔天大罪

    操纵中国房地产价格的幕后黑手,美国次贷危机背后的神秘大亨,股市崩盘之后的最大赢家……神探韩峰,为您解密一个企图垄断中国甚至世界房地产的巨大阴谋!中国长江三角洲的地产大亨相继遇难,与此同时,香港、台湾,甚至中国一些偏远地区的房地产大亨也难逃死劫,接连不明死亡的背后,是谁在充当策划推手的角色?在巨额回报前,是谁犯下滔天大罪,向法律和道德宣战?在房地产暴利时代即将过去的时候,在商业地产与住宅地产的拐点时期,让我们再次跟随神探韩峰的脚步,回头去看它曾经的暴利与罪恶!
  • 落英如海

    落英如海

    白落英,很简单,很纯真,有点任性。年少时,她执意要追随小小的梦想。然而,当时光逝去,最终陪在身边的,还是那个笨笨的,执着的,一如既往深爱自己的阿宝。终于,有一天当阿宝也离开世界,她才体会到失去挚爱的痛苦,变成鬼魂的落英遇到死神。“哪里可以找到我的夫君?”她问。死神很无奈,她有不能说的秘密。但是,她还是决定帮助她。地狱中遇到的神秘人物,是否会改写落英的命运?转换身份后的她,又能否和阿宝重聚?死神的前世今生,敬请期待!
  • 绑架大主角

    绑架大主角

    人生如戏,处处惊喜。凭空落下的一个花盆没有把安生一盆带走,反而带来了一个坑爹的绑架系统,各种作死的绑架任务如约而至......神仙、鬼怪、大侠、皇帝,各个世界的主角成了他的绑架对象,最重要的是绑架任务一旦发布,那便无法停止,拒绝接受视为任务失败,各种惩罚让人蛋疼......而绑架成功之后的奖励也是让人无法抗拒。
  • 墨白风月

    墨白风月

    本不该有交集的两人,一个成就青史传奇,一个坠为野史尘埃。墨与白,既是相互对立的存在,又互相牵扯不断。再有百年,墨白均归尘土,唯史官笔上之墨,宣纸之白,可传后世。墨白为名,落笔成书。
  • 茫茫人海中你的脸

    茫茫人海中你的脸

    “我”穿越在梦与现实之中,梦是真实的,现实更是真实的……
  • 掉落漫威世界当超级英雄

    掉落漫威世界当超级英雄

    在这穿越者满天飞的时代,林锐在一次意外触电后也毫不意外的穿越了,而且还是穿越到了大洋彼岸的美国。不过,纪念馆里那个身穿蓝色战服的健美先生怎么那么眼熟?还有纽约市中心那个标志性的建筑,林锐好像也在哪里见过。重生穿越到了漫威电影世界,在一切还未开始的时候,林锐和少年蜘蛛侠还有绿魔成为了朋友。在钢铁侠还未出现的时候,林锐就已经和托尼·斯塔克搭上线。为了活下去以及内心的守护,林锐将会有一个怎样的人生呢?这是一个穿越进漫威世界却只想着安稳度日,最后却意外成为超级英雄的故事。PS:时间线以本故事为主。
  • 密室里的恶魔

    密室里的恶魔

    不管是看似光鲜亮丽的服装设计师、看似高高在上的时尚编辑,还是看似女神般的超级模特,当自己的利益和爱情受到威胁时,都会不择手段去攻击别人。可是,到底是谁触碰了人性的底线?到底是谁杀了人?谁能得到救赎?谁又能逃出生天?一切的一切,都隐藏在黑暗的密室里,由恶魔一手操纵,你想来会会它吗?
  • 末世之宇宙深渊

    末世之宇宙深渊

    浩瀚的宇宙,万年的蓝星,外星的阴谋!时空混乱:恐龙、巨蟒、剑齿虎、复合体、巨大虫出现。惨烈的生存竞赛拉开序幕、激烈的爱恨情仇上演!作者不写多余的后宫,用心写科幻的奇景。动人的生死故事,脑洞大开的情节。当外星生物降临,谜底会是什么?当蓝星生命尽头,结局会在何方?后续更多的故事,等着朋友们一起阅读……