登陆注册
5589700000090

第90章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(12)

The universe of thought is made up of a number of separate 'entities'corresponding to nouns-substantive,and when these bundles are distinctly isolated by appropriate nouns,the process of arranging and codifying according to the simple relations indicated by the copula is greatly facilitated.The ideal language would resemble algebra,in which symbols,each representing a given numerical value,are connected by the smallest possible number of symbols of operation,+,-,=,and so forth.To set two such statements side by side,or to modify them by inserting different constants,is then a comparatively easy process,capable of being regulated by simple general rules.Bentham's style becomes tiresome,and was often improperly called obscure.It requires attention,but the meaning is never doubtful --and to the end we have frequent flashes of the old vivacity.

The Rationale of Evidence,as Mill remarks,(63)is 'one of the richest in matter of all Bentham's productions.'It contains,too,many passages in Bentham's earlier style,judiciously preserved by his young editor;indeed,so many that I am tempted even to call the book amusing.In spite of the wearisome effort to say everything,and to force language into the mould presented by his theory,Bentham attracts us by his obvious sincerity.The arguments may be unsatisfactory,but they are genuine arguments.They represent cOnviction;they are given because they have convinced;and no reader can deny that they really tend to convince.We may complain that there are too many words,and that the sentences are cumbrous;but the substance is always to the point.The main purpose may be very briefly indicated.Bentham begins by general considerations upon evidence,in which he and his youthful editor indicate their general adherence to the doctrines of Hume.(64)This leads to an application of the methods expounded in the 'Introduction,'in order to show how the various motives or 'springs of action'and the 'sanctions'based upon them may affect the trustworthiness of evidence.Any motive whatever may incidentally cause 'mendacity.'The second book,therefore,considers what securities may be taken for 'securing trustworthiness.'We have,for example,a discussion of the value of oaths (he thinks them valueless),of the advantages and disadvantages of reducing evidence to writing,of interrogating witnesses,and of the publicity or privacy of evidence.Book III deals with the 'extraction of evidence.'We have to compare the relative advantages of oral and written evidence,the rules for cross-examining witnesses and for taking evidence as to their character.Book IV deals with 'pre-appointed evidence,'the cases,that is,in which events are recorded at the time of occurrenCe with a view to their subsequent use as evidence.We have under this head to consider the formalities which should be required in regard to contracts and wills;and the mode of recording judicial and other official decisions and registering births,deaths,and marriages.In Books V and VIwe consider two kinds of evidence which is in one way or other of inferior cogency,namely,'circumstantial evidence,'in which the evidence if accepted still leaves room for a process of more or less doubtful inference;and 'makeshift evidence,'such evidence as must sometimes be accepted for want of the best,of which the most conspicuous instance is 'hearsay evidence.'Book VII deals with the 'authentication'of evidence.Book viii is a consideration of the 'technical'system,that namely which was accepted by English lawyers;and finally Book IX deals with a special point,namely,the exclusion of evidence.

Bentham announces at starting(65)that he shall establish 'one theorem'and consider two problems.The problems are:'what securities can be taken for the truth of evidence?'and 'what rules can be given for estimating the value of evidence?'The 'theorem'is that no evidence should be excluded with the professed intention of obtaining a right decision;though some must be excluded to avoid expense,vexation,and delay.This,therefore,as his most distinct moral,is fully treated in the last book.

Had Bentham confined himself to a pithy statement of his leading doctrines,and confirmed them by a few typical cases,he would have been more effective in a literary sense.His passion for 'codification,'for tabulating and arranging facts in all their complexity,and for applying his doctrine at full length to every case that he can imagine,makes him terribly prolix.On the other hand,this process no doubt strengthened his own conviction and the conviction of his disciples as to the value of his process.Follow this clue of utility throughout the whole labyrinth,see what a clear answer it offers at every point,and you cannot doubt that you are in possession of the true compass for such a navigation.Indeed,it seems to be indisputable that Bentham's arguments are the really relevant and important arguments.How can we decide any of the points which come up for discussion?Should a witness be cross examined?Should his evidence be recorded?Should a wife be allowed to give evidence against her husband?or the defendant to give evidence about his own case?These and innumerable other points can only be decided by reference to what Bentham understood by 'utility.'This or that arrangement is 'useful'because it enables us to get quickly and easily at the evidence,to take effective securities for its truthfulness,to estimate its relevance and importance,to leave the decision to the most qualified persons,and so forth.

These points,again,can only be decided by a careful appeal to experience,and by endeavouring to understand the ordinary play of 'motives'and 'sanctions.'

同类推荐
  • 元代奏议集录

    元代奏议集录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 外科游风丹毒斑疹门

    外科游风丹毒斑疹门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 正学隅见述

    正学隅见述

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 重修凤山县志

    重修凤山县志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 济一子道书十七种

    济一子道书十七种

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 我的世界之创世神记

    我的世界之创世神记

    风萧萧,创世的威力再闪耀;雷闪现;昨日的风貌已重见……
  • 记忆之莲

    记忆之莲

    二零一零年一月,曼哈顿,气温在冰点上下浮动。女律师李孜正面临着婚姻和事业的抉择,一个偶然的机会,她介入了一件陷入僵局的刑事诉讼,试图为芭蕾舞演员Han洗脱谋杀罪名。在她走访证人的过程中,来自于不同的人的记忆片段逐渐拼凑出一段即将湮灭的往事,真相慢慢浮现的同时,李孜也开始思考情感、婚姻、人与人之间相爱的欲望和相守的无奈。
  • 呆侠成神记

    呆侠成神记

    人生如梦,昏昏沉沉。多少年蹉跎云烟。秋叶凋零不是昨日那青春少年。梦醒,问花开是否依然芬芳美艳?却涌流满腹深仇念。
  • 最强逍遥狂少

    最强逍遥狂少

    噬天,人欺我,我杀人。天欺我,我灭天。四海之内任我游。
  • Aladdin and the Magic Lamp

    Aladdin and the Magic Lamp

    There once lived a poor tailor, who had a son called Aladdin,a careless, idle boy who would do nothing but play all day long inthe streets with little idle boys like wkkk.net so grieved thefather that he died; yet, in spite of his mother's tears and prayers,Aladdin did not mend his ways.汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 我家苏先生很傲娇

    我家苏先生很傲娇

    (推荐新书:绯闻陆总官宣吧)“苏子墨,我要嫁给你!”都说女追男隔层纱,可沐西怎么觉得,她和他之间隔了一堵厚厚的城墙?一朝被人设计,他误会她,她含泪离去。四年后归来,他每天往她工作室送鲜花,想尽一切办法和她扯上关系,回头助理却讪讪的告诉他:“总裁,您送的花又进垃圾桶了。”某男揉着疼痛的额角,沉思一会便说:“明天改送儿子。”翌日,某小奶包站在他的面前告诉他,“爹地,妈咪和她男朋友约会去了,不在家。”于是,他幽怨地注视着眼前自己的缩小版,明明是个追妻神器,可他怎么觉得是个坑爹货?【群:138299894】
  • 你也是蘑菇吗

    你也是蘑菇吗

    《你也是蘑菇吗?》是新浪微博人气作者安定医院郝医生首部关于精神病人的脑洞故事集。38个脑洞轻奇的故事,108个让人哭笑不得的暖心细节。讲述精神病人那些不为人知的惊奇故事,呈现精神病人真实的内心世界。透过精神病人的内心世界,折射当下喧嚣、繁华大都市下正在努力奋斗的年轻人心中的脆弱与不安,如果你在其中看到了自己的影子,不要惊慌,不要气馁,不要哭泣,我们都曾经历痛苦与迷茫。愿你生命的每一段旅程,都有一朵“蘑菇”伴你共度风雨,那是每一个阶段不断强大的另一个自己,愿本书能带给你丝丝温暖,安抚你每一个黑暗的夜晚。
  • 寂寞大佬任正非

    寂寞大佬任正非

    《寂寞大佬任正非》是一本关于通信大佬任正非的传记,也是华为帝国的成长史。他从寒门学子转变为大佬,从军人转变为商人,将“山寨公司”转变为了“华为帝国”。他是一只“土狼”,没有可以大肆挥霍的资本,没有显赫的背景,便带领着华为队伍,亮相中国民营企业族群,挑战跨国巨头,仅用时23年闯入世界500强。他创造了华为“床垫文化”,发布了《华为基本法》,他的“冬天论”成为了中国企业危机最为公认的代名词。有人说,中国百年企业有几个?但如果是任正非及团队生存100年,那么华为就能生存超过100年。本书介绍的就是如此神秘的任正非和他的华为帝国。
  • 坏孩子的天空:经典青春禁忌电影大纪录

    坏孩子的天空:经典青春禁忌电影大纪录

    本书选取具有代表性的青春禁忌题材电影作品,按照时间排序,每个电影单列一章,内容包括电影基本资讯(名称、海报、演职员表、所获奖项和内容简介)和影评。并插入于该影片中影响颇广的音乐(如《加州旅馆》)、场景、演员的小链接、经典台词等,使之成为兼具欣赏性和资料性的电影艺术类图书。
  • 天之九野

    天之九野

    为了追寻心中那份莫名的感情,一名少年带着一条奇异的小白蛇离开了人迹罕至的绝地大裂谷,来到了九天之上……从此,这片古老的天地又多了一个传奇!