登陆注册
5589700000094

第94章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(16)

Wherever an aristocracy differs from the democracy,their judgment will be erroneous.(87)The people will naturally choose 'morally apt agents,'and men who wish to be chosen will desire truly to become 'morally apt,'for they can only recommend themselves by showing their desire to serve the general interest.(88)'All experience testifies to this theory,'though the evidence is 'too bulky'to be given.Other proofs,however,may at once be rendered superfluous by appealing to 'the uninterrupted and most notorious experience of the United States.'(89)To that happy country he often appeals indeed(90)as a model government.In it,there is no corruption,no useless expenditure,none of the evils illustrated by our 'matchless constitution.'

The constitution deduced from these principles has at least the merit of simplicity.We are to have universal suffrage,annual parliaments,and vote by ballot.He inclines to give a vote to women.(91)There is to be no king,no house of peers,no established church.Members of parliament are not to be re-eligible,till after an interval.Elaborate rules provide for their regular attendance and exclusive devotion to their masters'business.

They are to be simply 'deputies,'not 'representatives.'They elect a prime minister who holds office for four years.Officials are to be appointed by a complex plan of competitive examination;and they are to be invited to send in tenders for doing the work at diminished salary.When once in office,every care is taken for their continual inspection by the public and the verification of their accounts.They are never for an instant to forget that they are servants,not the masters,of the public.

Bentham,of course,is especially minute and careful in regard to the judicial organisation a subject upon which he wrote much,and much to the purpose.The functions and fees of advocates are to be narrowly restricted,and advocates to be provided gratuitously for the poor.They are not to become judges:to make a barrister a judge is as sensible as it would be to select a procuress for mistress of a girls'school.(92)Judges should be everywhere accessible:always on duty,too busy to have time for corruption,and always under public supervision.One characteristic device is his quasi-jury.The English system of requiring unanimity was equivalent to enforcing perjury by torture.Its utility as a means of resisting tyranny would disappear when tyranny had become impossible.But public opinion might be usefully represented by a 'quasi-jury'of three or five,who should not pronounce a verdict,but watch the judge,interrogate,if necessary,and in case of need demand a rehearing.Judges,of course,were no longer to make law,but to propose amendments in the 'Pannomion'or universal code,when new cases arose.

His leading principle may be described in one word as 'responsibility,'or expressed in his leading rule,'Minimise Confidence.'(93)'All government is in itself one vast evil.'(94)It consists in applying evil to exclude worse evil.Even 'to reward is to punish,'(95)when reward is given by government.

The less government,then,the better;but as governors are a necessary evil,they must be limited by every possible device to the sole legitimate aim,and watched at every turn by the all-seeing eye of public opinion.Every one must admit that this is an application of a sound principle,and that one condition of good government is the diffusion of universal responsibility.

It must be admitted,too,that Bentham's theory represents a vigorous embodiment and unflinching application of doctrines which since his time have spread and gained more general authority.Mill says that granting one assumption,the Constitutional Code is 'admirable.'(96)That assumption is that it is for the good of mankind to be under the absolute authority of a majority.

In other words,it would justify what Mill calls the 'despotism of public opinion.'To protest against that despotism was one of the main purposes of Mill's political writings.How was it that the disciple came to be in such direct opposition to his master?That question cannot be answered till we have considered Mill's own position.But I have now followed Bentham far enough to consider the more general characteristics of his doctrine.

I have tried,in the first place,to show what was the course of Bentham's own development;how his observation of certain legal abuses led him to attempt the foundation of a science of jurisprudence;how the difficulty of obtaining a hearing for his arguments led him to discover the power of 'Judge and Co.';how he found out that behind 'Judge and Co.'were George III and the base Sidmouth,and the whole band of obstructors entrenched within the 'matchless constitution';and how thus his attack upon the abuses of the penal law led him to attack the whole political framework of the country.I have also tried to show how Bentham's development coincided with that of the English reformers generally.They too began with attacking specific abuses.They were for 'reform,not revolution.'The constitution satisfied them in the main:they boasted of the palladia of their liberties,'trial by jury'and the 'Habeas Corpus'Act,and held Frenchmen to be frog-eating slaves in danger of lettres de cachet and the Bastille.English public opinion in spite of many trammels had a potent influence.Their first impulse,therefore,was simply to get rid of the trammels --the abuses which had grown up from want of a thorough application of the ancient principles in their original purity.The English Whig,even of the more radical persuasion,was profoundly convinced that the foundations were sound,however unsatisfactory might be the superstructure.

同类推荐
  • 温公琐语

    温公琐语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 易象图说外篇

    易象图说外篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说咒齿经

    佛说咒齿经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 古今笑史

    古今笑史

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编家范典妯娌部

    明伦汇编家范典妯娌部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 城市的钥匙

    城市的钥匙

    龙仁青,当代著名作家。1967年3月生于青海湖畔铁卜加草原1986年7月毕业于青海海南民族师范学校藏语言文学专业。先后从事广播、电视、报纸等媒体的新闻翻译(汉藏文)、记者、编辑、导演、制片等职,现供职于青海电视台影视部。
  • 饥饿风暴

    饥饿风暴

    这里的每个人都很能吃,有人说我们是从地狱爬出的饿鬼,多么低级的诽谤,我们只是胃口好而已,万千世界,遍地食材,我可不能亏待了我的胃!粉丝群:108898033
  • 大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大学生考证指南

    大学生考证指南

    针对大学生学习及就业的需要,汇编国家有关考试法规,英语等级考试,计算机等级考试,教师资格证,普通话水平测试,记者从业资格证,导游资格证考试,管理类证书,艺术类证书及其他类证书的相关规定。
  • 青青的穿越生活

    青青的穿越生活

    杜青青带着空间穿越到古人身上。懦弱的父亲让她进退两难。经商致富过程中,却发现堂哥对自己好到不可思议……
  • 带着英雄联盟系统回火影

    带着英雄联盟系统回火影

    方伟穿越了,穿越后的他成为了佐助的弟弟,还随身带着英雄联盟系统,”奇怪我的沙子怎么不听我的话了“我爱罗很纳闷,方伟贼笑着解锁了英雄沙漠皇帝阿兹尔,他解锁蛮王,和雾忍七刀众比刀术,解锁盲僧,与小李和凯比体术。他利用英雄联盟系统在火影世界里留下一个又一个的传说。ps,书友群:661086321,咆哮一群,欢迎大家进入聊天打屁。
  • 唤醒大脑的巨人

    唤醒大脑的巨人

    人的八种智能的潜力十分巨大,也不是一成不变的。目前在学校里常用语言智能和数学、逻辑智能考核学生。学者们对事业成功者的研究发现:事业成功者大多是右脑功能较强者,右半脑起着控制行为、产生情感、艺术欣赏的作用。是发明创造的源泉。甚至有人提出:“人脑有80%的潜能为开发.而开发的重点是右脑。”只有左右脑平衡、沟通和互补,才能最大限度地利用人脑的潜能,左右脑功能开发得都比较好的人是最聪明的人。
  • 逆天系统之人生赢家

    逆天系统之人生赢家

    左手一个聚宝盆,右手一个摇钱树,中间摆着一个大礼包~想不走上人生巅峰都难!
  • 假侦探

    假侦探

    小说以一个华裔教授在美国患病之后的悲惨经历为线索,融合了悬疑、推理、感情等调动读者兴趣的要素,深入描写了一个人处在极度绝望的环境下的所作所想,揭示了在美国许多人依然对华人抱有偏见的现实。小说是通俗小说和严肃文学的结合,语言文字富有文学性,饱含哲理,又处处设下悬念,紧抓住读者的心。
  • 圆宗文类

    圆宗文类

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。