登陆注册
5590800000085

第85章 Economic Heretics(9)

Perhaps,however,it is fairer to notice in how many points there was unconscious agreement;and how by converting very excellent maxims into absolute dogmas,from which a whole system was deducible,the theories appeared to be mutually contradictory,and,taken separately,became absurd.The palpable and admitted evil was the growth of pauperism and demoralisation of the labourer.The remedy,according to the Utilitarians,is to raise the sense of individual responsibility,to make a man dependent upon his own exertions,and to give him security that he will enjoy their fruit.Let government give education on one hand and security on the other,and equality will follow in due time.The sentimental Radical naturally replies that leaving a man to starve does not necessarily make him industrious;that,in point of fact,great and growing inequality of wealth has resulted;and that the rights of man should be applied not only to political privilege,but to the possession of property.The Utilitarians have left out justice by putting equality in the background.Justice,as Bentham replied,has no meaning till you have settled by experience what laws will produce happiness;and your absolute equality would destroy the very mainspring of social improvement.Meanwhile the Conservative thinks that both parties are really fostering the evils by making individualism supreme,and that organisation is necessary to improvement;while one set of Radicals would perpetuate a mere blind struggle for existence,and the other enable the lowest class to enforce a dead level of ignorance and stupidity.They therefore call upon government to become paternal and active,and to teach not only morality but religion;and upon the aristocracy to discharge its functions worthily,in order to stamp out social evils and prevent a servile insurrection.But how was the actual government of George IV and Sidmouth and Eldon to be converted to a sense of its duties?On each side appeal is made to a sweeping and absolute principle,and amazingly complex and difficult questions of fact are taken for granted.The Utilitarians were so far right that they appealed to experience,as,in fact,such questions have to be settled by the slow co-operation of many minds in many generations.

Unfortunately the Utilitarians had,as we have seen,a very inadequate conception of what experience really meant,and were fully as rash and dogmatic as their opponents.I must now try to consider what were the intellectual conceptions implied by their mode of treating these problems.

Notes:

1.The discussions of population most frequently mentioned are:-W.Godwin,Thoughts occasioned by Dr Parr's Spital Sermon ,etc.1801;R.Southey,in (Aikin;'s)Annual Review for 1803,pp.292-301;Thomas Jarrold,Dissertations on Man ,etc.1806;James Grahame,Inquiry into the Principle of Population ,1816;George Ensor,Inquiry concerning the Population of Nations ,1818;W.Godwin,On Population ,1820;Francis Place,Principles of Population ,1822;David Booth,Letter to the Rev.T.R.Malthus ,1823;M.T.Sadler,Law of Population ,1830;A.Alison,Principles of Population ,1840;T.Doubleday,True Laws of Population ,1842.

2.Quarterly Review ,Dec.1812(reprinted in Southey's Moral and Political Essays ,1832),3.Quarterly Review ,July 1827,by (Archbishop)Sumner,Malthus's commentator in the Records of Creation .Ricardo's Letters to Trower ,p.47.

同类推荐
  • 金液大丹口诀

    金液大丹口诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中国古代传奇小说选

    中国古代传奇小说选

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 幻士仁贤经

    幻士仁贤经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 女开科传

    女开科传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 异辞录

    异辞录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 月光与玫瑰

    月光与玫瑰

    这个甜蜜的当代中篇小说是《阳光明媚,皓月皎洁》的前传。讲述了这样一个故事:卡洛琳·戴维斯拿到了硕士学位后,回到纽约和她的母亲住在一起。琳达·戴维斯知道她总有一天会离开,决意确保自己的女儿拥有一个安稳的未来。卡洛琳有她自己的打算。尽管母女两人时不时会起争执,她们都深爱对方。卡洛琳是一位美丽的女子,也是一位成功的艺术家。她一直敷衍地配合着母亲的计划,直到遇见了布拉德利·瑞沃丹·怀特,这个男人颠覆了她的世界。
  • 傲娇甜心:腹黑大神,宠上瘾

    傲娇甜心:腹黑大神,宠上瘾

    某天,顾大小姐终于忍不下去了。他顾家就只有他哥一根独苗,不能让基情满满的断送了顾家的血脉,下定决心曲线救兄。美人让他随便挑,美男她也随便送,可某人只是挑眉,兴趣缺缺。“开个价,怎么样才能离开我哥?”某男轻挑唇角,“如果是歌儿你舍身救兄,或许可以考虑。”顾清歌咬牙切齿,“你想的美。”某男欺身反压,挑起她的下巴,“歌儿,不如以胸换兄,等价交换,童叟无欺呢。”以胸换兄!秦混蛋!炸了毛的顾清歌指着门外,“你给我滚!”某人却借机蹭了蹭她的脸,“歌儿,地球是圆的呢。”“所以呢?”“滚完一圈,还是会回到原点的。”
  • 会驯兽的召唤师

    会驯兽的召唤师

    都市青年被车撞死因祸得福,受父母遗物的吊坠上的传承重生在异界贵族获得同万物交谈的能力和强化魔兽的能力。看龙岚如何以召唤师,驯兽师的双身份成为君主,成为帝王。
  • 娇妻引入怀

    娇妻引入怀

    陈姿之所以答应和司煜谦假结婚,就是因为司煜谦向她保证会让她的家人一生平安。只要他有了心上人,她会立刻消失。但陈姿怎么也没想到这个男人竟然会言而无信!“司煜谦,我们分开吧。”“证都领了,还想去哪儿?”“胡说!那是假的!”“假的?”男人甩出来两本印着钢印的红本本,“老婆,真证都有了,怎么还留着假证纪念我们美好的爱情?”“司煜谦,我们的合作已经到期了!”“还没有,我给我的户口本交了一辈子的房租,所以你的名字印在上面,一辈子也不会到期。”【支持新书《傲娇席少,我超甜》】
  • 金箓午朝仪

    金箓午朝仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Native's Return, 1945-1988

    A Native's Return, 1945-1988

    The third in a three-volume series, this edition chronicles the life of noted journalist, historian, and author William Shirer-a witness to the rise of the Third Reich. Here, Shirer recounts his return to Berlin after its defeat, his shocking firing by CBS News, and his final visit to Paris sixty years after he first lived there as a cub reporter in the 1920s. It paints a bittersweet picture of his final decades, friends lost to old age, and a changing world.More personal than the first two volumes, this final installment takes an unflinching look at the author's own struggles after World War II-and his vindication after the publication of The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, his most acclaimed work. It also provides intimate details of his often-troubled marriage. This book gives readers a surprising and moving account of the last years of a true historian-and an important witness to history.
  • 辣妻好萌:总裁宠的好棒棒

    辣妻好萌:总裁宠的好棒棒

    美好的故事总有个开始,杨娇娇做一个名敬业的花边杂志社成员,因为师傅的委派,只身进入欧阳皓郊外别墅找取微型录像机,不想被欧了皓打了个回马枪,当场捉住了她。本想死不承认,就此跑路,结果惨遭师傅的出卖。诶,这就是她狗血新生活的开端吗。
  • 明伦汇编闺媛典闺义部

    明伦汇编闺媛典闺义部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编人事典形影部

    明伦汇编人事典形影部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 考鬼专家

    考鬼专家

    父亲考古,岳父古董商,而我却是稀里糊涂的成了“考鬼专家”。对,你们没看错,也没听错,我就是一个“考鬼专家”。古往今来第一位考鬼专家。