登陆注册
5590800000088

第88章 Psychology(2)

The pamphlet was rewritten and enlarged,and a third edition of 1818gives a full exposition of his theory.Brown had meanwhile become Stewart's leading disciple,and in 1810was elected to be his colleague,Brown held the position,doing all the active duties,until his premature death in 1820.Brown,according to his biographer,wrote his lectures immediately before delivery,and completed them during his first two years of office.His theories,as well as his words,were often,acceding to the same authority,extemporised.

Brown found that he could not improve what he had written under 'very powerful excitement.'Moreover,he had an unlucky belief that he was a poet.From 1814till 1819he brought out yearly what he supposed to be a poem,these productions,the Paradise of Coquets and the rest,are in the old-fashioned taste,and have long passed into oblivion.

The lectures,published posthumously,became a textbook for students,and reached a nineteenth edition in 1851.

Their faults,considered as philosophical treatises,are palpable,they have the wordiness of hasty composition,and the discursive rhetoric intended to catch the attention of an indolent audience.Brown does not see that he is insulting his hearers when he apologises for introducing logic into lectures upon metaphysics,and indemnifies them by quotations from Akenside and the Essay on Man .Brown,however,showed great acuteness and originality.He made deviations,and took pains to mark his deviations,from Reid,though he spoke more guardedly of his own friend,Stewart,Stewart,who had strongly supported Brown's election,was shocked when,on the publication of the lectures,he came to discover that his colleague had been preaching heresy,and wrote with obvious annoyance of Brown's hastiness and dangerous concessions to the enemy.5Brown,however,impressed his contemporaries by his ability.Sydney Smith is probably reporting the current judgment of his own circle when he says 6that in metaphysics Stewart was a 'humbug'compared with Brown,I certainly think that Stewart,whom I should be sorry to call a humbug,shows less vigour and subtlety.Brown,at any rate,impressed both the Mills,and his relation to them is significant.

Brown's Essay upon Causation indicates this relation.In this,indeed,there is little,if any,divergence from Stewart,though he attacks Reid with considerable asperity.He urges that Reid,while really agreeing with Hume,affected to answer him under cover of merely verbal distinctions.7The main point is simple.

Hume had asserted that all events seem to be 'entirely loose and separate,'or,in other words,'conjoined but never connected.'Yet he points out that,in fact,when we have found two events to be 'conjoined,'we call one cause and the other effect,and assume a 'necessary connection'between them.He then asks,What is the origin of this belief,and what,therefore,is the logical warrant for its validity?Brown entirely accepts Hume's statement of the facts.The real meaning of our statements is evaded by appealing to the conception of 'power.'When the loadstone (in his favourite illustration)attracts the iron,we say it has a 'power'of attracting iron.But to speak thus of a power is simply to describe the same facts in other words.We assert this,and nothing more than this,that when the loadstone comes near the iron,each moves towards the other.'Power'is a word which only covers a statement of 'invariable antecedence.'Brown traces the various confusions which have obscured the true nature of this belief.He insists especially that we can no more discover power in mental than in physical sequences.The will had been supposed to be the type of causal power;but volition,according to Brown,reveals simply another succession of desires and bodily actions.The hypothesis of 'power'has been really the source of 'illusion.'The tendency to personify leads us to convert metaphor into fact,to invent a subject of this imaginary 'power,'and thus to create a mythology of beings to carry on the processes of nature.

In other words,Brown here follows Hume or even anticipates Comte.As J.S.Mill remarks,8this erroneous identification of 'power'with 'will'gives the 'psychological rationale of Comte's great historical generalisation';and,so far,Brown,as a follower of Hume,is clearly on the way to positivism.

The world,then,is a vast aggregate of 'loose'phenomena.A contemplation of things reveals no reason for one order rather than another.You may look at your loadstone as long as you please,but you will find no reason for its attracting iron.You may indeed interpolate a number of minute intervening sequences,and the process often suggests a vague something more than sequence;but this is a mere illusion.9Could we,in fact,see all the minute changes in bodies we should actually perceive that cause means nothing but 'the immediate invariable antecedence of an event.'10Brown especially argues against the attempts of d'Alembert and Euler to deduce the first laws of motion from the principle of 'sufficient reason.'11That,as he argues in detail,is merely begging the question,by introducing the principle of causation under an alias.

What,then,is the principle?

We believe,he says,12that 'every event must have a cause,'and that circumstances exactly 'similar must have results exactly similar.'

This belief,though applicable to all events,does not give us the 'slightest aid'to determining,independently of experience,any particular event.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 马上天下

    马上天下

    一个乡村学子成为驾驭战场的风云人物:一对父子由精神背叛到心心相印:一组师生分道扬镳数年后殊途同归,一群新的战争人物从历史隐秘处向我们走来……
  • 我不是奸臣

    我不是奸臣

    我有一书,记载天下大道。我有一剑,斩尽宇内之敌。赵晨穿越高武位面,左手持书,右手握剑,从微末中崛起,于困境中走出,振臂一呼三千甲士可篡国!但,我绝对不是什么奸臣,那只是你们世人对我的误会。赵晨如是说。
  • 神医仙妻:邪王夫君,宠上天!

    神医仙妻:邪王夫君,宠上天!

    “我家王妃虽乡下来的,但胆敢对她不敬者,杀!”“我家王妃虽不会说话,但不准与她计较!”“我家王妃虽性格柔弱,但肆意欺辱她者,杀!”众人泪奔,爷,您家王妃什么样,您自己心里没数么?脸呢?脸呢!情商堪忧的齐淑宁过劳死了,一朝穿越,发现有了父母双亲的疼爱,还有兄弟姐们娇惯,这美好的生活让她只想安稳平淡生活,种种田,卖卖药,做做饭,溜溜鸟,可是身怀异能的她,却注定与腹黑邪魅的他牵扯不清,纠缠不休了。一个是惊世的医学天才,却呆呆萌萌,一个是嗜血的王爷,却宠妻无度。她屡次助他渡过难关,他一心想将她占为己有……
  • 德高望重的我谁也打不过

    德高望重的我谁也打不过

    本座诛邪道人,修真界最大组织浣世盟盟主,修真界十大门派听我调遣;十七岁入元婴,十八岁是以元婴中期修为跨阶怒斩合体期魔修,十九岁渡劫,如今已是地仙,当世修为最高之人;那边那个筑基弟子,你拔剑做什么?冷静下来!我不接受你的挑战!救命!救命!救驾啊!护法呢?老婆救我!————修真界五好少年宇程墨,身怀天道功法诛邪决传承,从此斩杀魔修如砍瓜切菜毫无难度,砍怪升级好似火箭一日千里,但是正道修士砍他……似乎也是砍瓜切菜啊!于是宇程墨唯一擅长的事情,似乎只有把自己装的德高望重一点……折纸星人第二本书,已有一部成绩不错的完结作品,质量、更新和完结均有保证。
  • 重生:青葱岁月

    重生:青葱岁月

    如果能够回到那段青葱岁月,你会干什么?是好好放肆一回,不再辜负曾经逝去的青春,还是努力学习,好好的做一个学霸千金?重活一世,原本受尽欺辱,性格懦弱的季小北决定不再顺从,不再随波逐流。既然来了,那么便好好的疯狂一回吧!江別月,顾凉薄,前世你们所带给我的痛苦,今生我必然加倍还来。不管别人,这是季小北内心最真实的想法。这一世,她不再懦弱,不再受人欺压了!
  • 呐喊(中小学生必读丛书)

    呐喊(中小学生必读丛书)

    鲁迅是中国文化革命的主将,他不但是伟大的文学家,而且是伟大的思想家和伟大的革命家。鲁迅的骨头是最硬的,他没有丝毫的奴颜和媚骨,这是殖民地和半殖民地人民最可宝贵的性格。鲁迅是在文化战线上,代表全民族的大多数,鲁迅的方向,就是中华新文化的方向。
  • 桃花扇

    桃花扇

    梅老太爷的宅子在东城,梅家原本是保定府最著名的大户,梅老太爷的父亲曾在晚清著名红顶商人盛宣怀手下做事,在扳倒胡雪岩的商战中出了大力,有这般能人先辈,梅老太爷自然在保定府一带呼风唤雨。但民国建立至今,时代发生了巨变,梅老太爷却固守祖规,食古不化,终于弄得家道中落。
  • 倾城恋之儒女冠华

    倾城恋之儒女冠华

    外界传言洛家的十三少自大病痊愈后便从第一纨绔转为清冷的翩翩公子,高岭之花,孤傲不可亵渎……“小洛洛,听说你清冷?”某帝邪魅一笑。洛羽:“这只是个传说!”“听说你孤傲?”洛羽:“这只是个不靠谱的传说!”“听说你是高岭之花不可亵渎?”洛羽:“这真只是个极不靠谱的传说!”某帝:“既然如此,本帝就不客气了!说吧,生一个还是两个?”“本少是男的,咋生?”“呵呵,总要试试嘛!”女扮男装,文可甩笔控美女,武能提刀弑神佛,却偏偏被一个邪魅狂狷的魔帝死死吃掉。从此,上至黄泉,下穷碧落,总有他的生死相随!
  • The Blithedale Romance

    The Blithedale Romance

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 青少年爱玩的魔术全集:科学魔术

    青少年爱玩的魔术全集:科学魔术

    本书是专为青少年和魔术初级爱好者量身打造的魔术全集。通过轻松活泼的语言,图文并茂的方式,将一个个奇妙、有趣的科学魔术展现在青少年面前。本书采用循序渐进的方法,选取了生活中简单易学的小魔术,通过直观的图解和明白简洁的语言,让人一看就懂,一学就会;更能让你在不知不觉中成为魔术高手,成为朋友中最受欢迎的开心果。