Mackenzie knew that the closest FBI field office to Bent Creek was in Omaha, Nebraska. The thought of returning to Nebraska in an official capacity was intimidating, yet at the same time, almost fitting. Still, she was beyond relieved when Heideman called them to let them know that the current base of operations for the case was in the Bent Creek police department.
She and Ellington arrived there just after six that evening. As she walked toward the front doors of the station with Ellington, feelings of working as a woman in law enforcement in the Midwest came creeping back in. It was in the nearly misogynistic way some of the men in uniform looked at her. The change of clothes and title had apparently done nothing. Men were still going to see her as second class.
The only difference now was that she didn't give a shit if she offended anyone or hurt their feelings. She was here on bureau business to help a small and fledgling police force figure out who was kidnapping women from their back roads. She was not going to be treated the same way she had been the last time she worked in the Midwest as a detective for the Nebraska State Police.
She quickly discovered that part of her assumptions upon entering the station were wrong. Maybe the change of title and stature did mean something. When they were escorted back to the primary conference room, she saw that the local PD had ordered Chinese food for them. It was spread out on a small coffee bar in the back of the room, along with a few two-liter bottles of drinks and snacks.
Thorsson and Heideman were already enjoying the comped dinner, shoveling portions of lo mein noodles and orange chicken onto their plates. Ellington gave her a what are ya gonna do? sort of shrug and headed for the table as well. She did the same as a few other people filtered in and out of the room. While she was sitting down at the conference table with a portion of sesame chicken and a crab rangoon, one of the officers she had seen on the side of State Route 14 approached her and extended his hand. Again, she saw his badge and recognized him as the sheriff.
"Agent White, right?" he asked.
"I am."
"Good to meet you. I'm Sheriff Bateman. I hear you and your partner went up near Sigourney to talk to the mother of the most recent victim. No results?"
"Nothing. Just a potential source of information to cross off the list. And a pretty good confirmation that we're not dealing with a case of a daughter that simply decided not to call her mother when plans changed."
Clearly disappointed by this, Bateman nodded and turned back for the front of the room where two other officers were in conversation.
As Ellington took a seat beside Mackenzie, they both looked to the front of the room. A man who had earlier introduced himself as Deputy Wickline was placing pictures and printouts on a dry erase board with magnets. Another officer-the only other female in the room-was writing a series of notes along the other side of the board.
"Looks like they run a tight ship around here," Ellington said.
She had been thinking the same thing. She had come in assuming this would be something of a sloppily put together circus as it had been with the Nebraska State PD when she had worked there. But so far, she was impressed with how the Bent Creek PD was organizing things.
Several minutes later, Sheriff Bateman checked in with the officers at the board and ushered the two male officers out. The female stayed behind and took a seat at the table. Bateman closed the door and went to the front of the room. He glanced around at the four FBI agents and three remaining officers in the room.
"We got dinner because I have no idea how long we'll be here," he said. "We don't generally get a lot of bureau presence in Bent Creek so this is new to me. So please, Agents, let me know if there is anything we can do to make things smoother. For now, I'll turn this over to you agents."
He took a seat, leaving Ellington and Thorsson to give one another a quick confused look. Thorsson grinned and gestured to the front of the room, giving the responsibility to the agents from DC.
Ellington nudged Mackenzie lightly under the table as he said: "Yes, so Agent White will walk us through the information we have so far, as well as any current theories we have."
She knew he was trying to rib her by throwing her under the bus in such a way, but she didn't mind. In fact, a small selfish part of her wanted to be in front of the room. Maybe it was some girlish revenge fantasy to come back to this area of the country and run a conference room in a way she had never been allowed to do in Nebraska. Whatever the reason, she went to the front of the room and took a quick look at the dry erase board that had been put together.
"The work your officers did here," she said, pointing to the board, "pretty much spells the story out for me. The first victim is a resident of Bent Creek. Naomi Nyles, forty-seven years of age. She was reported missing by her daughter and was last seen two weeks ago. Her car was found on the side of the road in no apparent state of disrepair. I believe officers within this very building were able to crank the car just fine and bring it back here."
"That's correct," Deputy Wickline said. "The car is still in the impound lot, as a matter of fact."
"The second missing person was twenty-six-year-old Crystal Hall. Her employer is Wrangler Beef in Des Moines and they have confirmed that she was sent to a cattle farm just outside of Bent Creek. The owner of the farm confirms that Crystal did show up for a planned meeting and left the property shortly after five in the afternoon. Her credit card history shows that she grabbed dinner at the Bent Creek Subway at five fifty-two." She pointed to where one of the helpful officers had already jotted this information down on the board.
"The question that raises," Bateman said, "is when she was abducted. Her car was not discovered until around one thirty in the morning. For someone to not notice her car or at least report it, even on State Route 14, means that there's a good chance she was elsewhere in town before heading back home. I seriously doubt someone would have been bold enough to nab her between six thirty and seven thirty. And if they were that bold…"
He trailed off here, as if not liking how he needed to end the comment. So Mackenzie took the liberty and finished for him.
"Then it means it would be someone familiar with the area," she said. "Particularly with the traffic patterns on State Route 14. However, the profile for this type of guy doesn't line up with being so bold. He lurks in darkness. He sneaks up on them. There's nothing at all overt about this guy."
Bateman nodded at this, his eyes wide and a smile on his face. She'd seen the look before. It was the look of a man who was not only impressed by the way she thought, but appreciated it. She saw the same look on the face of the female officer and an overweight man at the end of the table, still enjoying the free dinner. Deputy Wickline was nodding at her comment, scribbling notes down in a legal pad.
"Sheriff," Ellington said, "do we have any idea the average amount of traffic that goes through that route at that time of day?"
"A state-sanctioned traffic monitor and report from 2012 estimates that between six in the afternoon and midnight, there's an average of about eighty vehicles that will pass through State Route 14. It really isn't a very busy road. But keep in mind, it's just been the author and Crystal Hall that were taken from 14. The first missing person, Naomi Nyles, was abducted off of County Road 664."
"And what's the traffic like there during that time of day?" Mackenzie asked.
"Almost nothing," Bateman said. "I think the number was around twenty or thirty. Deputy Wickline, do you know any different?"
"Sounds about right," Wickline said.
"And speaking of the author," Mackenzie continued. "Delores Manning, thirty-two. She lives in Buffalo but has family just outside of Sigourney. Her tires were flattened by broken glass fragments in the road. The glass is quite thick and had been painted black to prevent glare and shine from the headlights. Her agent reported her as missing about half an hour after her car was discovered by a passing truck around two in the morning. Agent Ellington and I spoke with her mother and sister today and they could provide no solid leads. As a matter of fact, there seem to be no solid leads at all to any of these disappearances. And unfortunately, that's all we have."
"Thank you, Agent White," Bateman said. "So where do we go from here?"
Mackenzie smirked a bit and nodded to the Chinese food on the back table. "Well, it's a good thing you planned ahead. I think the best place to start is to go over any unsolved disappearances within a one-hundred-mile radius over the last ten years."
No one objected but the looks on the faces of Bateman, Wickline, and the other officers said enough. The female officer shrugged in defeat and raised her hand dutifully. "I can get on records and pull all of that," she said.
"Sounds good, Roberts," Bateman said. "Can you have results for us in an hour? Get some of the desk-riders out front to help."
Roberts got up and left the conference room. Mackenzie noticed that Bateman watched her a bit longer than the other men in the room.
"Agent White," Bateman said. "Do you happen to have any ideas as to what kind of suspect we should be looking for? In a fairly small town like Bent Creek, the quicker we can rule people out, the quicker we can point you to the sort of person you're looking for."
"Without clues of any kind, it could be hard to pinpoint," Mackenzie said. "But so far, there are a few certain things we can assume. Agent Ellington, would you like to take over on this part?"
He smiled at her as he took a bite out of an egg roll. "Please, keep going. You're doing just fine."
It was an odd back-and-forth between them that she hoped wasn't too obvious to others in the room. She had been trying to show respect-to show him that she was not trying to run the show. But he, in turn, had shrugged it off. For now, it seemed that he almost appreciated the fact that she was assuming the lead.
"First of all," she said, doing her best not to be thrown off course, "the suspect is almost certainly a local. His ability to study traffic patterns along these back roads shows a rigorous kind of patience that makes him a bit easier to profile. If the suspect has gone through this much trouble to abduct these women, then past cases involving kidnapping and abduction suggest that he is not taking these women to kill them. As I said, he seems to be sneaky. Everything we know about him-attacking when they are vulnerable, in the dark, and apparently planning the act-points to a man with non-violent tendencies. After all, what's the point of painstakingly plotting an abduction only to kill the victim moments later? It indicates that he is collecting these women, for lack of a better term."
"Yes," Roberts, the female officer, said. "But collecting them for what, exactly?"
"Is it terrible to assume it's a sex thing?" Deputy Wickline asked.
"Not at all," Mackenzie said. "In fact, if our suspect is shy, that's one more check mark on the profile for us. Shy men that go after women in such a way are usually too shy or otherwise burdened socially to romance women. It's usually the case with rapists that do everything they can to not hurt the women."
She got a few more of those admiring glances from around the room. But given the topic that was being discussed, she couldn't appreciate it.
"But we can't know for sure?" Bateman asked.
"No," Mackenzie said. "And that's where the pressure is on us. This isn't just a killer that we are hoping won't strike again. This man is psychotic, and dangerous. The longer it takes to find him, the longer he has to do whatever he wants with these women."
