登陆注册
4282200000004

第4章

If we were asked to say, in the fewest possible words, what we conceive to be Bentham's place among these great intellectual benefactors of humanity; what he was, and what he was not; what kind of service he did and did not render to truth; we should say he was not a great philosopher, but he was a great reformer in philosophy. He brought into philosophy something which it greatly needed, and for want of which it was at a stand. It was not his doctrines which did this, it was his mode of arriving at them. He introduced into morals and politics those habits of thought and modes of investigation, which are essential to the idea of science; and the absence of which made those departments of inquiry, as physics had been before Bacon, a field of interminable discussion, leading to no result. It was not his opinions, in short, but his method, that constituted the novelty and the value of what he did; a value beyond all price, even though we should reject the whole, as we unquestionably must a large part, of the opinions themselves.

Bentham's method may be shortly described as the method of detail; of treating wholes by separating them into their parts, abstractions by resolving them into Things, classes and generalities by distinguishing them into the individuals of which they are made up; and breaking every question into pieces before attempting to solve it. The precise amount of originality of this process, considered as a logical conception -- its degree of connexion with the methods of physical science, or with the previous labours of Bacon, Hobbes or Locke -- is not an essential consideration in this pace. Whatever originality there was in the method -- in the subjects he applied it to, and in the rigidity with which he adhered to it, there was the greatest. Hence his interminable classifications. Hence his elaborate demonstrations of the most acknowledged truths. That murder, incendiarism, robbery, are mischievous actions, he will not take for granted without proof; let the thing appear ever so self-evident, he will know the why and the how of it with the last degree of precision;he will distinguish all the different mischiefs of a crime, whether of the first, the second or the third order, namely, 1.

the evil to the sufferer, and to his personal connexions; 2. the danger from example, and the alarm or painful feeling of insecurity; and 3. the discouragement to industry and useful pursuits arising from the alarm, and the trouble and resources which must be expended in warding off the danger. After this enumeration, he will prove from the laws of human feeling, that even the first of these evils, the sufferings of the immediate victim, will on the average greatly outweigh the pleasure reaped by the offender; much more when all the other evils are taken into account. Unless this could be proved, he would account the infliction of punishment unwarrantable; and for taking the trouble to prove it formally, his defence is, 'there are truths which it is necessary to prove, not for their own sakes, because they are acknowledged, but that an opening may be made for the reception of other truths which depend upon them. It is in this manner we provide for the reception of first principles, which, once received, prepare the way for admission of all other truths.' To which may be added, that in this manner also we discipline the mind for practising the same sort of dissection upon questions more complicated and of more doubtful issue.

It is a sound maxim, and one which all close thinkers have felt, but which no one before Bentham ever so consistently applied, that error lurks in generalities: that the human mind is not capable of embracing a complex whole, until it has surveyed and catalogued the parts of which that whole is made up; that abstractions are not realities per se, but an abridged mode of expressing facts, and that the only practical mode of dealing with them is to trace them back to the facts (whether of experience or of consciousness) of which they are the expression.

Proceeding on this principle, Bentham makes short work with the ordinary modes of moral and political reasoning. These, it appeared to him, when hunted to their source, for the most part terminated in phrases. In politics, liberty, social order, constitution, law of nature, social compact, etc., were the catchwords: ethics had its analogous ones. Such were the arguments on which the gravest questions of morality and policy were made to turn; not reasons, but allusions to reasons;sacramental expressions, by which a summary appeal was made to some general sentiment of mankind, or to some maxim in familiar use, which might be true or not, but the limitations of which no one had ever critically examined. And this satisfied other people; but not Bentham. He required something more than opinion as a reason for opinion. Whenever he found a phrase used as an argument for or against anything, he insisted upon knowing what it meant; whether it appealed to any standard, or gave intimation of any matter of fact relevant to the question; and if he could not find that it did either, he treated it as an attempt on the part of the disputant to impose his own individual sentiment on other people, without giving them a reason for it; a '

contrivance for avoiding the obligation of appealing to any external standard, and for prevailing upon the reader to accept of the author's sentiment and opinion as a reason, and that a sufficient one, for itself. Bentham shall speak for himself on this subject: the passage is from his first systematic work, 'Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation', and we could scarcely quote anything more strongly exemplifying both the strength and weakness of his mode of philosophizing.

同类推荐
  • 持斋念佛忏悔礼文

    持斋念佛忏悔礼文

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 所知录

    所知录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 彦周诗话

    彦周诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 土司灯仪

    土司灯仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 增订医方歌诀

    增订医方歌诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 猜谜俱乐部

    猜谜俱乐部

    著名科学家霍金说过:“有一个聪明的大脑,你就会比别人更接近成功。”思维能力在人的成功过程中起着举足轻重的作用,青少年无论将来从事什么职业,处于什么岗位,面对什么问题,拥有活跃的思维,都是你能否快速走向成功的最关健因素。全面开发青少年的思维能力,其重要性远排在教授具体知识技能之上。本选题的内容都是为全方位训练学生思维专门设计的,涵盖了逻辑学、心理学、概率论和博弈论等多种知识,本丛书极具代表性和独创性,内容丰富,难易有度,形式活泼,能帮助青少年快速掌握提高思维能力的有效方法,让你越玩越聪明,越玩越成功。
  • 最美的流年里

    最美的流年里

    在那些最美的年华里,我们经历过,得到过,失去过,回忆起来,却都是无比的美好。不求永远,只求曾经拥有。有些温柔,只要一瞬间,就足够化解所有的凄风苦雨冰冻容颜。
  • 总裁的傻妻

    总裁的傻妻

    《总裁的小前妻》“拓,我怀孕了,宝宝是你的,我想请问?”缠绵过后,她将自己有身孕的事情告诉他,以为他会高兴?“去医院把孩子打掉,你不配生我的孩子。”一张支票,狠狠摔在她的脸上,他无情下完命令转身离开…の四年后の“宝宝,今天你生日哦,想要什么礼物呢?”年轻女子温柔看着怀中的小帅哥,今天是小帅哥三岁生日。“妈咪,亲亲,妈咪,宝宝想要有个妹妹。”小男孩搂着女子亲下她脸颊,小脸上满脸期待的说着心愿。“我替她答应你,你很快就会有可爱妹妹。”男子的出现,令女子心头一震,她吓得慌忙抱着儿子离开。“帅锅叔叔,你耐我妈咪吗?我们拉勾勾。”小男孩竟躲开女子,跑去与男子拉勾勾,似乎很喜欢男子?四年之后,他忽然出现,强行霸入她家,夜夜霸上她的床…《总裁的‘傻’妻》“哥哥,别脱我衣衣,我不要,呜呜会痛痛…”娇美人儿缩在床上咬着唇瓣,小手紧紧抱着自己,缩在床角她怕怕…“女人,乖乖的躺着,嫁给我,就得陪我睡…”俊脸一沉,他上床将女子压在身下撕掉她的婚纱,该死的企业联姻…“哥哥,你的嘴嘴看起来好好吃哦。”她笑眯眯的抱着他的脖子,强吻了男人的嘴,把他的嘴当成了好吃的…“朵儿,你是不是经常这样亲男人?”俊眸紧盯着她的娇美脸庞,一想到她可能亲过别的男人他就超级不爽…
  • 重生八零小财妻

    重生八零小财妻

    预收文《八零大佬的掌心娇》八零发家致富文,请大家多多收藏。“哼,男人都是大猪蹄子。”小媳妇儿甜软的声音音。重生前她被闺蜜设计卖进了深山老林里面,父母意外死亡,弟弟赌瘾缠身。临死前才知道这个男人为自己付出了这么多。重生回来,她最想要做的事情就是嫁给这个男人,然后宠他宠他再宠他,最后再为他生一大堆的小萝卜头。
  • 许你情深不许爱

    许你情深不许爱

    "“孩子?我出差两个月,碰都没碰你一下,你孩子都给我搞出来了!”“林眠,你就是个贱人。”三年婚姻生活,两个未出生的孩子,幸运被上天眷顾,她再次怀孕,他却铁了心要扼杀那个来历不明的孩子。为了孩子,她拼命逃跑,数次以死相逼,终于离开。再次归来,她已经不在是那个唯唯诺诺的家庭主妇。她与他强强相遇,谁也不逊色与谁。孩子重病,绝望中的她拨打了前夫的号码:“我答应复婚,求你为我女儿捐献骨髓。”他愿意给她默默地情深,却一分爱也不想给她。"--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 生命的自我调适:体育百科

    生命的自我调适:体育百科

    体育,顾名思义,是指利用身体活动来进行教育,以达到增强体质、提高运动技术水平、丰富社会文化生活的目的,它是一种有目的、有意识、有组织的社会活动。一个国家体育活动的发达与否,已经成为衡量一个国家社会发展水平的一项重要指标。体育还可以培养竞争意识。一个人,必须有一种动力,一种不愿落后的信念,方能取胜。本书以通俗易懂、简洁明了的语言,对体育常识、体坛轶闻等作了一些详尽的描述,对各项影响较大的体育盛会、全民热衷的体育运动作了深入浅出的介绍,从而让读者对体育事业有一个全面的认识与了解。
  • 梦魇中的棋子

    梦魇中的棋子

    林子在床上翻了个身,右手向左边抱过去,但抱了个空,才明白妻子已经不在了。三个月前的一场车祸,让一个实实在在的肉体,变成墙上的一张带黑框的照片。林子很长时间都不能适应这样的现实,觉得妻子还是活着的。林子有点凄惶,他看了看对面墙上的那面挂钟,凌晨三点一刻了。林子想:还是睡去吧,明天还要上班呢。次日早上,林子吃完早餐到派出所签了个到。前几天五里亭村的村书记给林子打来电话,说村里两户人家为门口道路争吵了好几次了,双方扬言准备叫人来“开打”,让林子有时间去看一下,林子答应他今天过去。
  • 小地球大迷宫(科学知识游览车)

    小地球大迷宫(科学知识游览车)

    《小地球大迷宫》本书为你讲述地球上发生的各种科普知识。本书知识全面、内容精炼、通俗易懂,能够培养读者的科学兴趣和爱好,达到普及科学知识的目的,具有很强的可读性、启发性和知识性,是广大读者了解科技、增长知识、开阔视野、提高素质、激发探索和启迪智慧的良好科普读物。
  • 鬼王爷的呆萌妃

    鬼王爷的呆萌妃

    【本文属于男强女强!一对一!,绝对宠文!】古武世家夜月舞在接任掌门之位的短短几天时间内竟然穿越到一个不受宠,而且还痴傻的小姐身上,本身有着倾国倾城的容颜却被人陷害成为丑陋不堪,武学奇才被人说成废柴,看一个废柴如何在以武为尊的大陆崛起。契神兽,炼元丹,欠我的统统还回来。腹黑狡诈的鬼王轩辕绝一生只痴缠于她,为她受伤,为她送命,在一次次的危险中不知是谁折服了谁。风云变化的大陆,两者携手走向大陆的顶端,为彼此创造自由的天空。精彩片段你在干嘛,某男愤愤的看着夜月舞说,亲你,走开啦,没看见我在喂奶啊,我也要吃,滚,否则今晚没得吃,某男灰溜溜的走了。……………………………………………………………爹,娘把你的南海大珍珠磨碎了,说要美容,某小男孩眨着两个大眼睛说道。随她,某男头都没抬一下。爹,娘把那株千年结一次果的树烧掉炼丹了。随她。爹,妹妹说想跟哥哥一样出去玩。派人暗中保护。爹,娘说宫内太无聊了,出去走一走。某男嗖的一下就不见了。小男孩对着旁边的一个长得跟自己一模一样的小女孩说道,“跟你说了在爹心里,娘是最重要的,你还不信!”然后就看见小男孩从窗户内飞了出来,这次比之前的几次好像飞的更高,更远了。少宫主的武功又长进了,不知道这次多长时间回来,路人甲暗自叹息!他身边有青龙呢,放心好了。可怜的少宫主啊路人乙感叹道!
  • 胶东半岛鸟文化

    胶东半岛鸟文化

    城市,可以被称为是一本“可读”的历史。一个城市的文化个性,只能从地域文化的亮点中寻找。胶东文化有着自己的特性和独立性,是一支原生态独立起源的文化,胶东文化偏重于齐文化,在之后的发展过程中,与传统文化、红色文化结合得非常紧密。