登陆注册
4611700000006

第6章

The first is evidently the composition of a warm adherent of the theory in question; the writer overlooks all the real difficulties in the way of accepting it, and, caught by the obvious truth of much that Darwin says, has rushed to the conclusion that all is equally true. He writes with the tone of a partisan, of one deficient in scientific caution, and from the frequent repetition of the same ideas manifest in his dialogue one would be led to suspect that he was but little versed in habits of literary composition and philosophical argument. Yet he may fairly claim the merit of having written in earnest. He has treated a serious subject seriously according to his lights; and though his lights are not brilliant ones, yet he has apparently done his best to show the theory on which he is writing in its most favourable aspect. He is rash, evidently well satisfied with himself, very possibly mistaken, and just one of those persons who (without intending it) are more apt to mislead than to lead the few people that put their trust in them. A few will always follow them, for a strong faith is always more or less impressive upon persons who are too weak to have any definite and original faith of their own. The second writer, however, assumes a very different tone. His arguments to all practical intents and purposes run as follows:-Old fallacies are constantly recurring. Therefore Darwin's theory is a fallacy.

They come again and again, like tunes in a barrel-organ. Therefore Darwin's theory is a fallacy.

Hallam made a mistake, and in his History of the Middle Ages, p. 398, he corrects himself. Therefore Darwin's theory is wrong.

Dr. Darwin in the last century said the same thing as his son or grandson says now--will the writer of the article refer to anything bearing on natural selection and the struggle for existence in Dr.

Darwin's work?--and a foolish nobleman said something foolish about monkey's tails. Therefore Darwin's theory is wrong.

Giordano Bruno was burnt in the year 1600 A.D.; he was a Pantheist;therefore Darwin's theory is wrong.

And finally, as a clinching argument, in one of the neighbouring settlements there is a barrel-organ which plays its psalm tunes in the middle of its jigs and waltzes. After this all lingering doubts concerning the falsehood of Darwin's theory must be at an end, and any person of ordinary common sense must admit that the theory of development by natural selection is unwarranted by experience and reason.

The articles conclude with an implied statement that Darwin supposes the Polar bear to swim about catching flies for so long a period that at last it gets the fins it wishes for.

Now, however sceptical I may yet feel about the truth of all Darwin's theory, I cannot sit quietly by and see him misrepresented in such a scandalously slovenly manner. What Darwin does say is that sometimes diversified and changed habits may be observed in individuals of the same species; that is that there are eccentric animals just as there are eccentric men. He adduces a few instances and winds up by saying that "in North America the black bear was seen by Hearne swimming for hours with widely open mouth, thus catching--almost like a whale--insects in the water." This and nothing more. (See pp. 201 and 202.)Because Darwin says that a bear of rather eccentric habits happened to be seen by Hearne swimming for hours and catching insects almost like a whale, your writer (with a carelessness hardly to be reprehended in sufficiently strong terms) asserts by implication that Darwin supposes the whale to be developed from the bear by the latter having had a strong desire to possess fins. This is disgraceful.

I can hardly be mistaken in supposing that I have quoted the passage your writer alludes to. Should I be in error, I trust he will give the reference to the place in which Darwin is guilty of the nonsense that is fathered upon him in your article.

It must be remembered that there have been few great inventions in physics or discoveries in science which have not been foreshadowed to a certain extent by speculators who were indeed mistaken, but were yet more or less on the right scent. Day is heralded by dawn, Apollo by Aurora, and thus it often happens that a real discovery may wear to the careless observer much the same appearance as an exploded fallacy, whereas in fact it is widely different. As much caution is due in the rejection of a theory as in the acceptation of it. The first of your writers is too hasty in accepting, the second in refusing even a candid examination.

Now, when the Saturday Review, the Cornhill Magazine, Once a Week, and Macmillan's Magazine, not to mention other periodicals, have either actually and completely as in the case of the first two, provisionally as in the last mentioned, given their adherence to the theory in question, it may be taken for granted that the arguments in its favour are sufficiently specious to have attracted the attention and approbation of a considerable number of well-educated men in England. Three months ago the theory of development by natural selection was openly supported by Professor Huxley before the British Association at Cambridge. I am not adducing Professor Huxley's advocacy as a proof that Darwin is right (indeed, Owen opposed him tooth and nail), but as a proof that there is sufficient to be said on Darwin's side to demand more respectful attention than your last writer has thought it worth while to give it. A theory which the British Association is discussing with great care in England is not to be set down by off-hand nicknames in Canterbury.

同类推荐
  • 奉和元承杪秋忆终南

    奉和元承杪秋忆终南

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太和正音谱

    太和正音谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天目明本禅师杂录

    天目明本禅师杂录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说金光王童子经

    佛说金光王童子经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东西晋演义

    东西晋演义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • The Choir Invisible

    The Choir Invisible

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 圣序之神

    圣序之神

    一个阴暗的世界,一个已经濒临绝望的自己,被这个世界欺骗无数次后,他已经不会再相信世界了。既然这样的话,那就创造一个让自己相信的世界…………
  • 痴儿夫君

    痴儿夫君

    她本无意入宫,却在父亲所谓的责任和荣光下,不得不选择承受。宫门似海,她早已有了觉悟,无心争斗,皇后或宫女,对她来说并无太多区别。不曾料到的是,自己也是宫中重重秘密的牺牲者,她竟是嫁给了一个痴儿,然而是痴儿便是不懂了感情了吗?“我叫洛琪,你呢?”她好像显得有点兴奋。然而,面对洛琪的热情,白衣男子却只是怔怔地站在那边,不吭声也不说话,只是嘴角挂着淡淡的弧度。她想,她无法忘记他的笛声,无法忘记他模糊带着笑意的脸庞,无法忘记他的眼神,无法忘记关于这个叫东方遥的少年的故事。是投入了情感,放入了真心,然而事实却残酷地让她发现,一切并不像表面所看到的那般。心痛的背后,更有欺骗和背叛。而最后的事实,竟是谁都不曾预料到的不是结局的结局。。。。。。
  • 谢女士 谢女士

    谢女士 谢女士

    《谢女士谢女士》是作者谢舒以自己在纽约的生活见闻为内容所写的一本散文集,从20世纪80年代入美国陪读,到现在定居在美国,主要包括初入美国时打工的经历、在美国的中国人的传奇或生活、西方人的生活状态等,文笔老练,表达出对祖国诚挚的感情,也表达出了作者对时代的反思。她写纽约江湖的镇江老板仍然惦记深埋故里的金子,她写国内屈辱国外风光最后死于骨癌的“小曹”,写靠经营饭店而去做收藏的邓先生,写少女时代为红军送信年老后在美国治病的周老太……
  • 冥主有命

    冥主有命

    校草陈默出车祸死了,苏小木跟同学一起参加他的葬礼。瞻仰遗容的时候,她一弯腰,脖子上的钻石坠子竟然好死不死地掉进了棺材里,落到了对方的两腿之间……苏小木咬着牙去捡,不料对方竟然醒来了!第二天,学校里就传遍已经挂了的校草陈莫,被苏小木摸醒的消息。
  • 念念都是你

    念念都是你

    他是热血军人,保家卫国是他的使命,她是支教老师,教书育人是她的职业,铁血柔情的甜蜜恋人,和歹徒斗智斗勇的故事。九月的QQ群301898222
  • 王者荣耀:大神,带飞可好

    王者荣耀:大神,带飞可好

    王者荣耀冠军杯比赛之后,她捧着奖杯走到了他面前,一脸严肃:“嗯……我琢磨了下,咱俩现在的关系不太合适……”“你说什么?”“嗯,我说……”她将奖杯塞进了他的怀里,笑的眉眼弯弯,“顾寒,做我未婚夫吧,能领证的那种。”“嗯?”“呐,聘礼你都收了,可不能反悔!”然后,她被强吻了,当着全国玩者的面。大神,咱说好的高冷呢?
  • 道安法师念佛赞文

    道安法师念佛赞文

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 豪门重生:首席娇妻别想逃

    豪门重生:首席娇妻别想逃

    【耳边是惑人心神的情话,掌下是猛烈跳动的心脏,背后是僵硬冰冷的墙壁,面前是自己一直深爱的男人,她怔怔地听见他说,“我心疼你。”】上一世被小白花妹妹抓住机会毁得一无所有,身死绝爱。重来一世,她不再懦弱,用心努力地成就自己的梦,打压不长眼的人,安静地写故事,没想到,却遇见了一直暗恋的他……他一直喜欢她,前世一直在寻找,却频频错过,这一世,他不在寻找,而是主动出击,果然,萌妹纸哪里跑!抓!新人新书求支持!我是浅浅,大家好!打滚卖萌!
  • 大唐公主之古鱼梦

    大唐公主之古鱼梦

    (本文架空,轻松不虐)刁蛮任性连皇上都要担忧其婚事的大唐公主居然穿越到了一千年前的西周,邂逅了一个地方小国的鱼国国君。这个鱼国国君很小气啊,动不动就生气,学学她大唐公主如何美丽大方、清新脱俗、思想开明吧。还是老顽固一个,浪费了一副好皮囊,看她盛世大唐的思宁公主如何对付他,等着接招!