登陆注册
4614900000004

第4章

PANTHEISM. I

THE Rev. J. H. Blunt, in his "Dictionary of Sects, Heresies, etc.," defines Pantheists as "those who hold that God is everything, and everything is God."If it is granted that the value of words lies in the definiteness and coherency of the ideas that present themselves to us when the words are heard or spoken-then such a sentence as "God is everything and everything is God" is worthless.

For we have so long associated the word "God" with the idea of a Living Person, who can see, hear, will, feel pleasure, displeasure, etc., that we cannot think of God, and also of something which we have not been accustomed to think of as a Living Person, at one and the same time, so as to connect the two ideas and fuse them into a coherent thought. While we are thinking of the one, our minds involuntarily exclude the other, and vice versa; so that it is as impossible for us to think of anything as God, or as forming part of God, which we cannot also think of as a Person, or as a part of a Person, as it is to produce a hybrid between two widely distinct animals. If Iam not mistaken, the barrenness of inconsistent ideas, and the sterility of widely distant species or genera of plants and animals, are one in principle-sterility of hybrids being due to barrenness of ideas, and barrenness of ideas arising from inability to fuse unfamiliar thoughts into a coherent conception.

I have insisted on this at some length in "Life and Habit," but can do so no further here. (Footnote: Butler returned to this subject in "Luck, or cunning?" which was originally published in 1887.

In like manner we have so long associated the word "Person" with the idea of a substantial visible body, limited in extent, and animated by an invisible something which we call Spirit, that we can think of nothing as a person which does not also bring these ideas before us. Any attempt to make us imagine God as a Person who does not fulfil [sic] the conditions which our ideas attach to the word "person," is ipso facto atheistic, as rendering the word God without meaning, and therefore without reality, and therefore non-existent to us. Our ideas are like our organism, they will stand a vast amount of modification if it is effected slowly and without shock, but the life departs out of them, leaving the form of an idea without the power thereof, if they are jarred too rudely.

Any being, then, whom we can imagine as God, must have all the qualities, capabilities, and also all the limitations which are implied when the word "person" is used.

But, again, we cannot conceive of "everything" as a person.

"Everything" must comprehend all that is to be found on earth, or outside of it, and we know of no such persons as this. When we say "persons" we intend living people with flesh and blood;sometimes we extend our conceptions to animals and plants, but we have not hitherto done so as generally as I hope we shall some day come to do. Below animals and plants we have never in any seriousness gone. All that we have been able to regard as personal has had what we can call a living body, even though that body is vegetable only; and this body has been tangible, and has been comprised within certain definite limits, or within limits which have at any rate struck the eye as definite. And every part within these limits has been animated by an unseen something which we call soul or spirit. A person must be a persona-that is to say, the living mask and mouthpiece of an energy saturating it, and speaking through it. It must be animate in all its parts.

But "everything" is not animate. Animals and plants alone produce in us those ideas which can make reasonable people call them "persons" with consistency of intention. We can conceive of each animal and of each plant as a person; we can conceive again of a compound person like the coral polypes [sic], or like a tree which is composed of a congeries of subordinate persons, inasmuch as each bud is a separate and individual plant. We can go farther than this, and, as I shall hope to show, we ought to do so; that is to say, we shall find it easier and more agreeable with our other ideas to go farther than not; for we should see all animal and vegetable life as united by a subtle and till lately invisible ramification, so that all living things are one tree-like growth, forming a single person. But we cannot conceive of oceans, continents, and air as forming parts of a person at all; much less can we think of them as forming one person with the living forms that inhabit them.

To ask this of us is like asking us to see the bowl and the water in which three gold-fish are swimming as part of the gold-fish.

同类推荐
  • 奉和圣制送张说上集

    奉和圣制送张说上集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 讷谿奏疏

    讷谿奏疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Rowdy of the Cross L

    Rowdy of the Cross L

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 集注太玄经

    集注太玄经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 深情虐恋宝贝请原谅

    深情虐恋宝贝请原谅

    【大虐】【有心脏病者勿进】她,被他视为仇人,几年来受尽痛苦,她爱他呀,直到她不爱了,他才发现,自己已经在不知不觉中爱上她了。她恨他,怎么办?临死的关头,她终于回心转意,又给他当了一次新娘。不久之后,他为她打下了天下,他还清清楚楚的记得,那年,她对他说,她的梦想是当公主。王子为公主打下了天下,但是,公主永远的消失了……
  • 紫星大帝

    紫星大帝

    修真界巅峰强者飞升通道被神秘黑手击杀,重生低等位面修武界,卷土重来,斩荆披棘,重返巅峰!紫星神体降临,天下唯我独尊!
  • 时光煮酒

    时光煮酒

    短篇幅的小故事,比较适合闲暇的时候看。作者君文笔不好,请笑纳。每一篇都是独立性滴。
  • 实用政务文书写作大全(现代常用文体写作全书)

    实用政务文书写作大全(现代常用文体写作全书)

    本书从九个方面介绍了制定策划方案写作、广告文案策划写作、企业内部管理策划写作、经营目标及方针策划的写作、市场调查策划的写作、经营战略策划的写作等内容
  • Letters to Dead Authors

    Letters to Dead Authors

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中国大学生体育协会发展研究

    中国大学生体育协会发展研究

    随着我国建设体育强国战略目标的确立,中国体育踏上了新的征程。科学发展体育事业对全面提高中华民族健康素质和生活质量,促进人的全面发展,促进经济社会发展和社会体育文化发展有着重要的意义,而且肩负着振奋民族精神、提高我国综合实力的历史使命。中国大学生体育协会作为我国唯一的高等学校体育社会团体,在大学生综合素质培养中的作用日益彰显。在国际体育日新月异发展的背景下,随着我国教育体制、体育体制的不断更新完善,中国大学生体育管理改革势在必行。
  • 反派又又又重生了

    反派又又又重生了

    (1V1,双洁。)腹黑竹马:我从来不把你当兄弟,而把你当成老婆。傲娇皇帝:太傅犯了欺君之罪,就罚你成为朕的皇后。霸道校草:我允许你喜欢我。病娇少爷:我的世界一片黑暗,你是唯一的光明。闷骚弟弟:姐姐看过我摸过我,就要负责。容柒:这个我要解释一下,你一个两岁的毛都没长齐的小屁孩,摸你一下怎么了?MMP,总有那么一个智障对本宝宝心怀不轨!系统:MD,这样的傻屌写出来的小说不扑街,我就是个狗!容柒:你说什么,再说一遍?系统:汪!
  • 生活中的处世禁忌:中国式处世潜规则

    生活中的处世禁忌:中国式处世潜规则

    什么是禁忌?简单地讲禁忌是普通人必须避讳的人、物或事。许多人一生的弱点就是不懂得如何把生活和禁忌联系起来。不懂得怎样去精于处世、巧于做人、名誉做事情。因此做同样的事情,有的人就能事事顺通,而有的人却受到百般阻挠。生活需要有正确的原则指导。每一个事物都有其自身的规律,每一种游戏都有其独特地玩法,这就是规则。掌握了这种规则也就掌握了人脉,而人脉往往会决定你在生活中的状态。 本书,立足于生活中细节,思路清晰,事例详细明了,从做人、做事、职场、家庭、社交等多方面多角度地论述了生活中的禁忌,让你在轻松愉快的阅读之中窥探到做人生活的真谛。
  • 春日游苑喜雨应诏

    春日游苑喜雨应诏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 卸妆后我依然很美

    卸妆后我依然很美

    爱美,是女人的天性,也是女人的专属权利。新时代的女性不仅仅追求美,还要追求完美。俗话说,没有最美只有更美。完美情结在女性心里的极度膨胀,让爱美的女人们在自己身上下足了功夫和血本。但是别忘了,时间是女人最大的敌人,无论是貌美的明星,还是姿色上等的职业白领。与职业、社会地位、收入无关,每个人都逃脱不了岁月的蹉跎。