登陆注册
4615700000061

第61章 LAPLACE.(2)

With an armament of mathematical methods which had been perfected since the days of Newton by the labours of two or three generations of consummate mathematical inventors, Laplace essayed in the "Mecanique Celeste" to unravel the mysteries of the heavens. It will hardly be disputed that the book which he has produced is one of the most difficult books to understand that has ever been written. In great part, of course, this difficulty arises from the very nature of the subject, and is so far unavoidable. No one need attempt to read the "Mecanique Celeste" who has not been naturally endowed with considerable mathematical aptitude which he has cultivated by years of assiduous study. The critic will also note that there are grave defects in Laplace's method of treatment. The style is often extremely obscure, and the author frequently leaves great gaps in his argument, to the sad discomfiture of his reader. Nor does it mend matters to say, as Laplace often does say, that it is "easy to see"how one step follows from another. Such inferences often present great difficulties even to excellent mathematicians. Tradition indeed tells us that when Laplace had occasion to refer to his own book, it sometimes happened that an argument which he had dismissed with his usual formula, "Il est facile a voir," cost the illustrious author himself an hour or two of hard thinking before he could recover the train of reasoning which had been omitted. But there are certain parts of this great work which have always received the enthusiastic admiration of mathematicians. Laplace has, in fact, created whole tracts of science, some of which have been subsequently developed with much advantage in the prosecution of the study of Nature.

Judged by a modern code the gravest defect of Laplace's great work is rather of a moral than of a mathematical nature. Lagrange and he advanced together in their study of the mechanics of the heavens, at one time perhaps along parallel lines, while at other times they pursued the same problem by almost identical methods. Sometimes the important result was first reached by Lagrange, sometimes it was Laplace who had the good fortune to make the discovery. It would doubtless be a difficult matter to draw the line which should exactly separate the contributions to astronomy made by one of these illustrious mathematicians, and the contributions made by the other.

But in his great work Laplace in the loftiest manner disdained to accord more than the very barest recognition to Lagrange, or to any of the other mathematicians, Newton alone excepted, who had advanced our knowledge of the mechanism of the heavens. It would be quite impossible for a student who confined his reading to the "Mecanique Celeste" to gather from any indications that it contains whether the discoveries about which he was reading had been really made by Laplace himself or whether they had not been made by Lagrange, or by Euler, or by Clairaut. With our present standard of morality in such matters, any scientific man who now brought forth a work in which he presumed to ignore in this wholesale fashion the contributions of others to the subject on which he was writing, would be justly censured and bitter controversies would undoubtedly arise. Perhaps we ought not to judge Laplace by the standard of our own time, and in any case I do not doubt that Laplace might have made a plausible defence. It is well known that when two investigators are working at the same subjects, and constantly publishing their results, it sometimes becomes difficult for each investigator himself to distinguish exactly between what he has accomplished and that which must be credited to his rival. Laplace may probably have said to himself that he was going to devote his energies to a great work on the interpretation of Nature, that it would take all his time and all his faculties, and all the resources of knowledge that he could command, to deal justly with the mighty problems before him. He would not allow himself to be distracted by any side issue. He could not tolerate that pages should be wasted in merely discussing to whom we owe each formula, and to whom each deduction from such formula is due. He would rather endeavour to produce as complete a picture as he possibly could of the celestial mechanics, and whether it were by means of his mathematics alone, or whether the discoveries of others may have contributed in any degree to the result, is a matter so infinitesimally insignificant in comparison with the grandeur of his subject that he would altogether neglect it. "If Lagrange should think," Laplace might say, "that his discoveries had been unduly appropriated, the proper course would be for him to do exactly what Ihave done. Let him also write a "Mecanique Celeste," let him employ those consummate talents which he possesses in developing his noble subject to the utmost. Let him utilise every result that I or any other mathematician have arrived at, but not trouble himself unduly with unimportant historical details as to who discovered this, and who discovered that; let him produce such a work as he could write, and I shall heartily welcome it as a splendid contribution to our science." Certain it is that Laplace and Lagrange continued the best of friends, and on the death of the latter it was Laplace who was summoned to deliver the funeral oration at the grave of his great rival.

同类推荐
  • 西清诗话

    西清诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Rosary

    The Rosary

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 台湾私法债权编

    台湾私法债权编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 高上玉皇本行集经

    高上玉皇本行集经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 甚希有经

    甚希有经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 五言排律

    五言排律

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 盘古大神

    盘古大神

    散修出身的九天玄仙赵琼,在仙界为了更好的丹药和功法,得罪了不少仙人,终于有天惹火了仙帝,被整个仙界的人追杀,被逼无奈只能自曝,自曝居然都没有死去,在疗伤无望的情况下转世成为了一个普通大学生,但是做为大学生在快毕业的时候又因为喝醉酒了,被公交车撞飞,到了一个魔法大陆,在这魔法大陆上,赵琼又会遇到什么呢……
  • 爱情像一场博弈

    爱情像一场博弈

    这是一个关于抉择的故事。一个都市青年,面对着感情,面对着生存,面对着人生变故而艰难抉择的故事。阴差阳错之际,沉沦在三个女人的情感漩涡里,爱恨纠缠,孽缘丛生,也纠结其中;事业上,变故突生,左右掣肘,该如何抉择?借东风,图创业,他将计就计,围魏救赵,瞒天过海,凭借着专业的布局和一份笃定的坚持,三十六计殆尽,九死一生还魂,终于杀出了一条血路。却不料祸起萧墙,他又面临怎么的抉择?……
  • 丐神王妃不好当

    丐神王妃不好当

    倪晚,特案组成员,擅长催眠,可谁料一次任务中发生意外被卷入架空时代。穿越就罢了,人家穿公主,后妃,再不济也是个小姐,而她呢——直接穿去丐帮!丐帮也就算了,出场方式还是脸着地,不过幸好因祸得福,被一众乞丐尊为了丐神。丐神不好当,降龙掌法要狠,打狗棒法要溜,还得带领一众帮众深化改革,肃清丐帮,谋福利谋商机,追求幸福人生。破个案子声名鹊起,朝廷官差上门合作,白银大批来袭,邂逅皇家美男,桃花开了满脸。破迷案,斗白莲,撩美男,处兄弟,可以,生活够精彩。就是好像还缺点什么。“缺什么?”某美男突然出现,风流倜傥,引人注目。倪晚微笑,投入那人怀抱:“缺你。”
  • 末世之空间在手吃喝不愁

    末世之空间在手吃喝不愁

    她,燕芸居然重生了?!重生在末世降临前的一个月前,而且更重要的是,她似乎有了一个挺大的储存空间。前世被抛弃之仇,燕芸发誓要报仇。同时,暗下决心要保护亲人朋友在末世里生存下去。不过光兽?那又是什么?新书求支持~喜欢点亮小星星噢~么么踹~
  • 大秦战魂

    大秦战魂

    战者,生命不息,战斗不止。一生杀伐,只为了君王的兄弟之情,君臣之义。蒙家,秦始皇麾下忠信之家;蒙恬,大秦之战魂,为秦始皇打下天下,随后驻守秦国北疆,长城外镇压匈奴不敢来犯。一生无敌,最后却败在了一个宦官之手……
  • 重生之必然幸福

    重生之必然幸福

    给新书《重生之八零攻略》求个支持。这是由一株人参引发的血案!重生七八年,没有空间,没有钱,唯一挖到的一株野山参也被某个满脸正气的人要求见面分一半。林微脖子一梗,要钱没有,要命一条!谁知某人给了钱,要了命,管了她的后半生……
  • 婚姻决定女人的一生

    婚姻决定女人的一生

    婚姻决定女人的一生,女人怎样选择和经营自己的婚姻,将决定她后半生的人生和命运。虽然你拥有卓越的才华,美丽的外表,但不一定拥有幸福的婚姻,因此要学会为自己的幸福做主。无论在婚姻中发生了什么事,只要我们正视婚姻,用心规划婚姻,了解婚姻的真相,学习经营婚姻的技巧……我们就可以做幸福人生所光顾的那个有准备的女人。本书中所讨论和解析的婚恋中的问题,也许正是现在困扰着你的问题,希望我们的解析能给婚姻迷茫中的女性带来帮助,让她们早日到达幸福的彼岸。
  • 九州·刺客王朝·葵

    九州·刺客王朝·葵

    内心单纯而孤独的少年杀手在潜伏的过程中爱上了身世复杂的花魁,而花魁却徘徊在利用她作棋子的丈夫和杀手之间不能确定心意。乱世中的三人被不同的势力牵引,在利益与爱恨中艰难地抉择着。
  • 2010年中国精短美文精选

    2010年中国精短美文精选

    这套丛书的选本包括:中篇小说选、短篇小说选、报告文学选、散文选、诗歌选、微型小说选和随笔选七种。力求选出该年度最有代表性的作品,力求选出精品和力作,力求能够反映该年度某个文体领域最主要的创作流派、题材热点、艺术形式上的微妙变化。同时,坚持风格、手法、形式、语言的充分多样化,注重作品的创新价值,注重满足广大读者的阅读期待,多选雅俗共赏的佳作。