登陆注册
4705400000014

第14章

Mr. Hallam is of opinion that a bill of pains and penalties ought to have been passed; but he draws a distinction less just, we think, than his distinctions usually are. His opinion, so far as we can collect it, is this, that there are almost insurmountable objections to retrospective laws for capital punishment, but that, where the punishment stops short of death, the objections are comparatively trifling. Now the practice of taking the severity of the penalty into consideration, when the question is about the mode of procedure and the rules of evidence, is no doubt sufficiently common. We often see a man convicted of a simple larceny on evidence on which he would not be convicted of a burglary. It sometimes happens that a jury, when there is strong suspicion, but not absolute demonstration, that an act, unquestionably amounting to murder, was committed by the prisoner before them, will find him guilty of manslaughter. But this is surely very irrational. The rules of evidence no more depend on the magnitude of the interests at stake than the rules of arithmetic. We might as well say that we have a greater chance of throwing a size when we are playing for a penny than when we are playing for a thousand pounds, as that a form of trial which is sufficient for the purposes of justice, in a matter affecting liberty and property, is insufficient in a matter affecting life.

Nay, if a mode of proceeding be too lax for capital cases, it is, a fortiori, too lax for all others; for in capital cases, the principles of human nature will always afford considerable security. No judge is so cruel as he who indemnifies himself for scrupulosity in cases of blood, by licence in affairs of smaller importance. The difference in tale on the one side far more than makes up for the difference in weight on the other.

If there be any universal objection to retrospective punishment, there is no more to be said. But such is not the opinion of Mr. Hallam. He approves of the mode of proceeding. He thinks that a punishment, not previously affixed by law to the offences of Strafford, should have been inflicted; that Strafford should have been, by act of Parliament, degraded from his rank, and condemned to perpetual banishment. Our difficulty would have been at the first step, and there only. Indeed we can scarcely conceive that any case which does not call for capital punishment can call for punishment by a retrospective act. We can scarcely conceive a man so wicked and so dangerous that the whole course of law must be disturbed in order to reach him, yet not so wicked as to deserve the severest sentence, nor so dangerous as to require the last and surest custody, that of the grave. If we had thought that Strafford might be safely suffered to live in France, we should have thought it better that he should continue to live in England, than that he should be exiled by a special act. As to degradation, it was not the Earl, but the general and the statesman, whom the people had to fear. Essex said, on that occasion, with more truth than elegance, "Stone dead hath no fellow." And often during the civil wars the Parliament had reason to rejoice that an irreversible law and an impassable barrier protected them from the valour and capacity of Wentworth.

It is remarkable that neither Hyde nor Falkland voted against the bill of attainder. There is, indeed, reason to believe that Falkland spoke in favour of it. In one respect, as Mr. Hallam has observed, the proceeding was honourably distinguished from others of the same kind. An act was passed to relieve the children of Strafford from the forfeiture and corruption of blood which were the legal consequences of the sentence. The Crown had never shown equal generosity in a case of treason. The liberal conduct of the Commons has been fully and most appropriately repaid. The House of Wentworth has since that time been as much distinguished by public spirit as by power and splendour, and may at the present moment boast of members with whom Say and Hampden would have been proud to act.

It is somewhat curious that the admirers of Strafford should also be, without a single exception, the admirers of Charles; for, whatever we may think of the conduct of the Parliament towards the unhappy favourite, there can be no doubt that the treatment which he received from his master was disgraceful. Faithless alike to his people and to his tools, the King did not scruple to play the part of the cowardly approver, who hangs his accomplice.

同类推荐
  • 脉症治方

    脉症治方

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Reprinted Pieces

    Reprinted Pieces

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • History of the Catholic Church

    History of the Catholic Church

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • THE TRAGICAL HISTORY OF DOCTOR FAUSTUS

    THE TRAGICAL HISTORY OF DOCTOR FAUSTUS

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Incognita

    Incognita

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 四肢门

    四肢门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 枕边人

    枕边人

    深夜,一间坐落在幽静海边的别墅突然灯光通亮,别墅台阶上出现纷乱的人影。“救伤车来了吗?快去催呀,去打电话!”“已经催过几次了!”宽敞豪华的睡房中铺着厚地毯,郭颖怡在昏迷中,还没有醒来。颖怡苍白的脸上没有血色,在轻软阔大的粉红色睡床中,尖削的脸显得特别瘦小。她双目紧闭,失去知觉。看护和女仆围在床前看着她。这是他们度过新婚初夜的睡床。
  • 快穿:恶毒女配前来报道

    快穿:恶毒女配前来报道

    #快穿有风险,攻略需谨慎#陈无一脸懵逼的被绑定了系统。“宿主,你的任务是拯救世界……”陈无点了点头“这个任务好。”于是她开始了拯救世界之旅。结果……“宿主,目标就在前方100米处,请去攻略他。”陈无:喵喵喵?不是拯救世界吗?某统:我什么时候说过要拯救世界?
  • 四人三途

    四人三途

    青春时的爱恋,有时候很无理。我们感性,执着,也疼痛。我要说的不是那些轰轰烈烈的事,只是很平凡很人性的生活。
  • 第三种传说

    第三种传说

    第八个月头上,王红问了我一个问题。我并不意外。前妻不止一次问过,有时甚至带着点儿咆哮。之前那个女人也问过。她有点儿口吃,我和她初遇时还很轻微,我俩分开的时候,她的口吃已经相当严重,一句话停顿五六次。我很难过,从某种程度上说,我与罪犯无异。但我有什么办法呢?我不是故意的。她们问话的形式不同,但主题不变,自然与我有关。这样的询问,预示她们和我分手的日子已经不远。
  • 足球之球探系统

    足球之球探系统

    当华夏球迷们羡慕着日韩有大量的留欧球员的时候。而华夏只有一个没有上场机会的张雨宁,大家有没有些许的遗憾和无奈呢!而主角余天就是其中之一,在机缘巧合之下爱上了FM足球经理游戏,开始在游戏里培养了一个又一个的华夏天才,然后卖给了欧洲俱乐部过干瘾。但是突然余天一觉醒来竟然从2018年穿越到了2009年,而且成为了京城八喜俱乐部预备队的主教练,并且觉醒了球探系统。余天决定用球探系统在现实中培养华夏足球的天才,然后输送到欧洲,填补华夏留洋的空白期。看余天如何向欧洲输送人才!如何创造华夏足坛的新局面!如何让华夏足球崛起!
  • 袁督师诗集

    袁督师诗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 愿你的孤独 不负走过的路

    愿你的孤独 不负走过的路

    当你跨越孤独这座山丘,才会发现之前所受的苦,终将成为一种人生力量。初心客厅专栏作者、张德芬空间签约作者、读者公号专栏作者蔡尖尖,始终认为“尖尖而立,孤独自行,不负时光”,用41篇暖心的故事,讲述每个人所遇到的孤独而美好的人生故事。蔡尖尖曾是新媒体大潮下的一员,社会的喧嚣,生活的压力,职场的无奈,爱情的美好,梦想的憧憬……好比战场,你亲自去经过,征战过,才能赢过。她在自媒体平台受到很多读者的热捧,原创了多篇10万的文章。
  • 李嘉诚给年轻人的财富管理课

    李嘉诚给年轻人的财富管理课

    李嘉诚从商数十年,从未在一年之中亏损过,尽管其间经历过两次石油危机和亚洲金融风暴,甚至是全球金融危机,他的企业都能稳立不倒。成功不是一蹴而就的,财富也不是一天就能积累起来的。也许成功的模式是不能复制的,但我们可以学习成功者的思维方式和商业智慧。未来是属于年轻人的,若想成为李嘉诚那样的大商人,开创一番大事业,必须认真聆听他的财富管理课,在任何事情上发现创造财富的潜在机会,你会在财富的路上越走越远。
  • 热血异能高校:学院拽姐

    热血异能高校:学院拽姐

    皇洛异能学院的校长决定从全校的异能学员中筛选出一位最优秀的学员,将他打造成全异能者。谁知考核结束出选当天,圣物【神知】却选中了一位毫无异能的普通人类。当她进入皇洛异能学院,质疑她的异能学员们不断地来挑衅她。但谁都不知道的是,她的体内实际藏有着汪洋般的力量,即使是最强的异能者也只配让她踩在脚下……