登陆注册
4705400000457

第457章

Again, on our principles, all civil disabilities on account of religious opinions are indefensible. For all such disabilities make Government less efficient for its main end: they limit its choice of able men for the administration and defence of the State; they alienate from it the hearts of the sufferers; they deprive it of a part of its effective strength in all contests with foreign nations. Such a course is as absurd as it would be in the governors of a hospital to reject an able surgeon because he is an Universal Restitutionist, and to send a bungler to operate because he is perfectly orthodox.

Again, on our principles, no Government ought to press on the people religious instruction, however sound, in such a manner as to excite among them discontents dangerous to public order. For here again Government would sacrifice its primary end to an end intrinsically indeed of the highest importance, but still only a secondary end of Government, as Government. This rule at once disposes of the difficulty about India, a difficulty of which Mr. Gladstone can get rid only by putting in an imaginary discharge in order to set aside an imaginary obligation. There is assuredly no country where it is more desirable that Christianity should be propagated. But there is no country in which the Government is so completely disqualified for the task. By using our power in order to make proselytes, we should produce the dissolution of society, and bring utter ruin on all those interests for the protection of which Government exists. Here the secondary end is, at present, inconsistent with the primary end, and must therefore be abandoned. Christian instruction given by individuals and voluntary societies may do much good. Given by the Government it would do unmixed harm. At the same time, we quite agree with Mr. Gladstone in thinking that the English authorities in India ought not to participate in any idolatrous rite; and indeed we are fully satisfied that all such participation is not only unchristian, but also unwise and most undignified.

Supposing the circumstances of a country to be such, that the Government may with propriety, on our principles, give religious instruction to a people; we have next to inquire, what religion shall be taught. Bishop Warburton answers, the religion of the majority. And we so far agree with him, that we can scarcely conceive any circumstances in which it would be proper to establish, as the one exclusive religion of the State, the religion of the minority. Such a preference could hardly be given without exciting most serious discontent, and endangering those interests, the protection of which is the first object of Government. But we never can admit that a ruler can be justified in helping to spread a system of opinions solely because that system is pleasing to the majority. On the other hand, we cannot agree with Mr. Gladstone, who would of course answer that the only religion which a ruler ought to propagate is the religion of his own conscience. In truth, this is an impossibility. And as we have shown, Mr. Gladstone himself, whenever he supports a grant of money to the Church of England, is really assisting to propagate not the precise religion of his own conscience, but some one or more, he knows not how many or which, of the innumerable religions which lie between the confines of Pelagianism and those of Antinomianism, and between the confines of Popery and those of Presbyterianism. In our opinion, that religious instruction which the ruler ought, in his public capacity, to patronise, is the instruction from which he, in his conscience, believes that the people will learn most good with the smallest mixture of evil. And thus it is not necessarily his own religion that he will select. He will, of course, believe that his own religion is unmixedly good. But the question which he has to consider is, not how much good his religion contains, but how much good the people will learn, if instruction is given them in that religion. He may prefer the doctrines and government of the Church of England to those of the Church of Scotland. But if he knows that a Scotch congregation will listen with deep attention and respect while an Erskine or a Chalmers sets before them the fundamental doctrines of Christianity, and that a glimpse of a surplice or a single line of a liturgy would be the signal for hooting and riot and would probably bring stools and brickbats about the ears of the minister, he acts wisely if he conveys religious knowledge to the Scotch rather by means of that imperfect Church, as he may think it, from which they will learn much, than by means of that perfect Church from which they will learn nothing. The only end of teaching is, that men may learn; and it is idle to talk of the duty of teaching truth in ways which only cause men to cling more firmly to falsehood.

On these principles we conceive that a statesman, who might be far indeed from regarding the Church of England with the reverence which Mr. Gladstone feels for her, might yet firmly oppose all attempts to destroy her. Such a statesman may be too well acquainted with her origin to look upon her with superstitious awe. He may know that she sprang from a compromise huddled up between the eager zeal of reformers and the selfishness of greedy, ambitious, and time-serving politicians.

He may find in every page of her annals ample cause for censure.

同类推荐
  • 佛说如来兴显经卷第一

    佛说如来兴显经卷第一

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 外科精要

    外科精要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 寄李輈侍郎

    寄李輈侍郎

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 元始天王欢乐经

    元始天王欢乐经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金刚药叉嗔怒王息灾大威神验念诵仪轨

    金刚药叉嗔怒王息灾大威神验念诵仪轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 怀孕40周这样吃

    怀孕40周这样吃

    怀孕了,吃什么?怎么吃?是每个准妈妈都关心的大事。本书以孕期饮食为主题,介绍了如何在孕前做好营养储备、怎样在孕40周进行合理膳食,以及面对孕期的不适与疾病应该如何用饮食调理等,从多个方面进行了翔实的解答。书中丰富实用的内容将伴随准妈妈快乐健康地度过幸福的孕产期。
  • 他好像在想我

    他好像在想我

    新书《Hello,傲娇男神》已发~【甜宠文,男女主身心健康】“你不许骗我,骗人你是小狗。”那位可信度实在太低,不让他保证怎能行。“骗人你是小狗。”某一日。“颜圣翼...你要干嘛?”某恶魔勾唇笑了笑,为何有不祥的预感?他给她两个选择:一辈子待我身边,或者离开我,你自己选。这还用考虑吗?是人都会选择后者,在她离开时,一双大手把她拉进怀抱。见鬼了,不是让她自己选择,她惹不起还躲不起吗?
  • 重生之佞妃有毒

    重生之佞妃有毒

    前世,她被钉上不守妇道、与人私通的罪名,五马分尸活活痛死!重生,她不要善名甘做毒妇!惩继母,斗继妹,虐渣男!不守妇道?好!万千美男等她来挑!心肠歹毒?她只爱值得爱之人,渣男恶女,毒死活该!权倾天下,美男相随,痛痛快快过一生!
  • 石评梅作品集(中国现代文学名家作品集)

    石评梅作品集(中国现代文学名家作品集)

    深夜梦回的枕上,我常闻到一种飘浮的清香,不是冷艳的梅香,不是清馨的兰香,不是金炉里的檀香,更不是野外雨后的草香。不知它来自何处,去至何方?它们伴着皎月游云而来,随着冷风凄雨而来,无可比拟,凄迷辗转之中,认它为一缕愁丝,认它为几束恋感,是这般悲壮而缠绵。世界既这般空寂,何必追求物象的因果。
  • 万历二十年:抗日援朝

    万历二十年:抗日援朝

    万历二十年(公元1592),日本悍然发动针对朝鲜和中国明朝的侵略战争。应朝鲜国王的请求,大明万历皇帝朱翊钧毅然派名将李如松出师东征,抗日援朝,血沃朝鲜半岛。万历抗日援朝的胜利,对亚洲格局的发展产生了决定性的影响。作者以如椽之笔,拨开历史迷雾,条分缕析,直击万历战争“命门”,并对其前后中日朝三国的历史走向等提出了诸多真知灼见,深邃而富有新意。整部作品气势磅礴,壮怀激烈,带领读者领略历史风云变幻,并蕴含对于历史的精细解读和理性成因剖析,还原历史的真相,深刻的现实关照更是令人感慨深思,颔首称道!
  • 万古主宰

    万古主宰

    一代剑神萧锋头顶造化玉碟,脚踏混沌青莲,携开天神剑临异界,从此一人一剑纵横九州无敌手。一剑西来神鬼惊,一剑寒锋万古寒。吾之道,主宰大道。吾之剑,万剑至尊,吾乃万古主宰!
  • 战国策(中国古代经典集粹)

    战国策(中国古代经典集粹)

    中国古典文学是中国文学史上闪烁着灿烂光辉的经典性作品或优秀作品,它是世界文学宝库中令人瞩目的瑰宝。几千年来,中国传统文化养育了中国古典文学,中国古典文学又大大丰富了中国传统文化,使传统文化更具有深刻的影响力。
  • 快穿殿下想上天

    快穿殿下想上天

    生活终于对身处星际精神病院的时昭下手了被妹子坑进三千小世界时昭表示我要浪浪浪吃饭饭系统:殿下,为了维护您在星际的权威,您应该快点回去啊!时昭:小乌啊,你看我还有权威吗?系统:......
  • 伊江集载

    伊江集载

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 管人语录

    管人语录

    对人的管理,如果不是最复杂、最困难的事情,那么也肯定是世界上最复杂、最困难的事情之一。既然说管理是科学与艺术的高度结合,那么,是什么人将这种结合运用到了炉火纯青的艺术境界呢?毫无疑问,正是那些在管理实践中做出杰出贡献的过来人。