登陆注册
4705400000583

第583章

How it chanced that a man who reasoned on his premises so ably, should assume his premises so foolishly, is one of the great mysteries of human nature. The same inconsistency may be observed in the schoolmen of the middle ages. Those writers show so much acuteness and force of mind in arguing on their wretched data, that a modern reader is perpetually at a loss to comprehend how such minds came by such data. Not a flaw in the superstructure of the theory which they are rearing escapes their vigilance. Yet they are blind to the obvious unsoundness of the foundation. It is the same with some eminent lawyers. Their legal arguments are intellectual prodigies, abounding with the happiest analogies and the most refined distinctions. The principles of their arbitrary science being once admitted, the statute-book and the reports being once assumed as the foundations of reasoning, these men must be allowed to be perfect masters of logic. But if a question arises as to the postulates on which their whole system rests, if they are called upon to vindicate the fundamental maxims of that system which they have passed their lives in studying, these very men often talk the language of savages or of children. Those who have listened to a man of this class in his own court, and who have witnessed the skill with which he analyses and digests a vast mass of evidence, or reconciles a crowd of precedents which at first sight seem contradictory, scarcely know him again when, a few hours later, they hear him speaking on the other side of Westminster Hall in his capacity of legislator. They can scarcely believe that the paltry quirks which are faintly heard through a storm of coughing, and which do not impose on the plainest country gentleman, can proceed from the same sharp and vigorous intellect which had excited their admiration under the same roof, and on the same day.

Johnson decided literary questions like a lawyer, not like a legislator. He never examined foundations where a point was already ruled. His whole code of criticism rested on pure assumption, for which he sometimes quoted a precedent or an authority, but rarely troubled himself to give a reason drawn from the nature of things. He took it for granted that the kind of poetry which flourished in his own time, which he had been accustomed to hear praised from his childhood, and which he had himself written with success, was the best kind of poetry. In his biographical work he has repeatedly laid it down as an undeniable proposition that during the latter part of the seventeenth century, and the earlier part of the eighteenth, English poetry had been in a constant progress of improvement. Waller, Denham, Dryden, and Pope, had been, according to him, the great reformers. He judged of all works of the imagination by the standard established among his own contemporaries. Though he allowed Homer to have been a greater man than Virgil, he seems to have thought the Aeneid a greater poem than the Iliad. Indeed, he well might have thought so; for he preferred Pope's Iliad to Homer's. He pronounced that, after Hoole's translation of Tasso, Fairfax's would hardly be reprinted. He could see no merit in our fine old English ballads, and always spoke with the most provoking contempt of Percy's fondness for them. Of the great original works of imagination which appeared during his time, Richardson's novels alone excited his admiration. He could see little or no merit in Tom Jones, in Gulliver's Travels, or in Tristram Shandy. To Thomson's Castle of Indolence he vouchsafed only a line of cold commendation, of commendation much colder than what he has bestowed on the Creation of that portentous bore, Sir Richard Blackmore. Gray was, in his dialect, a barren rascal. Churchill was a blockhead. The contempt which he felt for the trash of Macpherson was indeed just; but it was, we suspect, just by chance. He despised the Fingal for the very reason which led many men of genius to admire it. He despised it, not because it was essentially commonplace, but because it had a superficial air of originality.

He was undoubtedly an excellent judge of compositions fashioned on his own principles. But when a deeper philosophy was required, when he undertook to pronounce judgment on the works of those great minds which "yield homage only to eternal laws," his failure was ignominious. He criticised Pope's Epitaphs excellently. But his observations on Shakspeare's plays and Milton's poems seem to us for the most part as wretched as if they had been written by Rymer himself, whom we take to have been the worst critic that ever lived.

Some of Johnson's whims on literary subjects can be compared only to that strange nervous feeling which made him uneasy if he had not touched every post between the Mitre tavern and his own lodgings. His preference of Latin epitaphs to English epitaphs is an instance. An English epitaph, he said, would disgrace Smollett. He declared that he would not pollute the walls of Westminster Abbey with an English epitaph on Goldsmith. What reason there can be for celebrating a British writer in Latin, which there was not for covering the Roman arches of triumph with Greek inscriptions, or for commemorating the deeds of the heroes of Thermopylae in Egyptian hieroglyphics, we are utterly unable to imagine.

同类推荐
  • 任法

    任法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 上清高上玉晨凤台曲素上经

    上清高上玉晨凤台曲素上经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 九转灵砂大丹资圣玄经

    九转灵砂大丹资圣玄经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 与舍弟书十六通

    与舍弟书十六通

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 医品庶女

    医品庶女

    梅宜轩从在古代醒来的那一刻起就面临着生死危机,她一路救姨娘、护幼弟,在梅府一波又一波的风波中好不容易有了一个立足之地。可是,却在无意中得知自己的亲人要面临着生命危险。于是,她将计就计,离开了那座人人称羡的高门大院,踏上了逃亡之路。外面的世界虽然跌宕起伏、险象环生,却也自由自在,神秘空间更是让她如鱼得水。可是,正当她建立了自己的商业王国之时,却被某人连哄带骗的又回到了京城。重新回来,改变的不仅是梅府所有人的命运,就连国运也随之改变了。不一样的庶女,不一样的人生。
  • 缘起仙魔

    缘起仙魔

    一个是被师傅捡回来的婴儿,因为在一片桃花林中发现了她,当时漫天飘落着桃花的花瓣,漂亮的就如九天之上飘下了桃花雪一样。当时师傅着她一脸欢笑的看着天上飘下的花朵,师傅为了应景就为他取名花落雪,并把她带回门派教她修仙法,教她便是非细心抚养她长大,对她更是慈爱有加,是她为如掌上明珠。一个是魔门魔主之子,在魔门里他是一人之下,万人之上,魔主为他取名萧莫寒。只是奈何他对权力和修炼跟本不感兴趣,虽有天资之身,整日确不呆在魔门修炼,却出魔门到俗世之中抚琴作画,对外也从来不说自己是魔门少主,以至于除了魔门上下,外界竟无人知道他就是魔门少主。一位是修仙门派资质奇佳的女弟子,一位是喜欢抚琴作画的魔门少主,可是就因为他们二人引起了一场仙魔两派的纷争,到底结果如何,且看缘起仙魔。
  • 心理健康自护手册

    心理健康自护手册

    《青少年安全健康自我保护丛书:心理健康自护手册》从学生的视角出发,以科学的知识、理念和方法,给予我们的学生贴近生活和学习的支持和引导,从而正确认识“心理健康”,进而学会“心理自护”,快乐生活、高效学习、健康成长。所以,我们从观念入手,使学生能够对心理健康形成正确的认识,针对青少年时期突出的心理表现和问题,从人际交往、学习、性的成熟几个方面,进行了阐述和解读,并就中学生常见的几种心理障碍谈到了一些相关的知识和方法。
  • 江北

    江北

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 德国精神

    德国精神

    在当今世界主要大国中,说起别的国家,国人或许总是很容易说出这样那样的批评,但说到德国的时候,国人却几乎是众口一词的褒扬。在我们的意识中,德国精神是和严谨、忠诚、顽强、毅力等词语联系在一起的,因此也就有了“真的很德国”这样的广告词。作为当今世界的一个主要国家,德国无疑有其伟大优秀的一面,就这一点来说,国人对德国的褒扬是有根据的。
  • 和尚皇帝:朱元璋

    和尚皇帝:朱元璋

    “中国文化知识读本”丛书是由吉林文史出版社和吉林出版集团有限责任公司组织国内知名专家学者编写的一套旨在传播中华五千年优秀传统文化,提高全民文化修养的大型知识读本。《和尚皇帝:朱元璋》为丛书之一,介绍了早年生活、投军从戎、建立明朝、身葬孝陵、历史评价。《和尚皇帝:朱元璋》中优美生动的文字、简明通俗的语言、图文并茂的形式,把中国文化中的物态文化、制度文化、行为文化、精神文化等知识要点全面展示给读者。
  • 弃妇翻身:腹黑狼君俏佳人

    弃妇翻身:腹黑狼君俏佳人

    那一年,她笑看夫君提笔写下一纸休书。那一年,她听到自己的妹妹对她说:你若被休,我必要你性命。世人都说,世家繁华,可是谁看到了锦绣满地的背后,那些无奈和悲苦身为世家的女儿,她身不由己,婚姻大事,全凭父母之命,媒妁之言。身为世家的男儿,他遵从父命,任凭声名斐然,也无法决定自己的命运。小小的一方宅院,埋葬了多少世家辛秘。“独孤云梦,为什么你要我写下一纸休书?”“因为,你的心中,从未有我的一席之地……”
  • 重生之巨星暖妻不复婚

    重生之巨星暖妻不复婚

    一觉醒来,她从名媛千金继承人变成了已婚贵妇,接下来还得变成豪门弃妇。秋浅夏觉得自己应该算是所有经历穿越人中最不幸一位,因为别人是穿越,她是被穿越。身体却被所谓的穿越女占用三年,让其用尽心机成为白富美,嫁给高富帅,走上了人生巅峰。可穿越女没有如书上幸福美满大结局,偏偏作的一手好死,游走于向往已久的娱乐圈里,却臭名昭著,最后苦肉计使用过度,身为原主的她又回来了。却发现等待她的是:一个因‘她’变本加厉假怀孕而忍无可忍要离婚的男人,娱乐圈一堆被‘她’的自以为是而得罪的乱摊子,身在异乡没有一个可以信任的人。在以为没有比这个更乱的时候,雪上加霜的发现肚子里还有一个‘后患’!片段一“如果我说,从此以后不会在打扰你工作,不会再任性,不会歇斯底里,走在路上也不会和你打招呼,不会让你进入我的生活……我的所有一切都将与你无关。”秋浅夏看着同为苦主却毫不知情的男人。男人轻轻的瞥了她一眼。“这样的话,你还要离婚吗?”她眨眨眼睛,眸底升起浅浅的水雾,楚楚动人中带着一眼能教人看穿的虚伪和做作。果然……“我会加一条离婚协议,不管发生什么,都没人会去打扰你,签字吧!”男人的厌恶压抑在眼底。虽然有些抱歉了,不过她要的就是这句话!片段二“我们来商量一下婚期吧!”高冷前夫抓准时机十分狂拽的道。“什……么婚期?”某女傻眼。“复婚的日期?”“那个,要慎重啊,要知道你可是刚刚跳出我这个火坑不久,可不能栽倒的那么快。”某人在高冷前夫的阴测测视线下,努力说道。“反正迟早都要跳的。”某前夫一副恩赐的嘴脸让某人手痒的想拍上去。“那个……我觉得我们不合适,当然主要是我配不上你。”“没错。”很不客气的自恋,“我屈尊降贵配得上你就行了。”“……”关键她不稀罕好吧。【本文一对一,女主被人穿越,男女主都是豪门,专情、幸福、无虐。】
  • 阎典史传

    阎典史传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 饮酒江湖,醉里挑灯看剑

    饮酒江湖,醉里挑灯看剑

    一朝锦绣山庄灭,为复仇,却掉入一系列的阴谋之中。无论在江湖,还是古武宗,都在被人牵着鼻子走。待他历经沉浮,一切,由他主宰!本书不爽,没有无敌,一切因主角经历慢慢变化,谢谢观赏