登陆注册
4811800000028

第28章 (1)

THE METHOD

H ere we are, right in Germany! We shall now have to talk metaphysics while talking political economy. And in this again we shall but follow M. Proudhon's "contradictions". Just now he forced us to speak English, to become pretty well English ourselves. Now the scene is changing. M. Proudhon is transporting us to our dear fatherland and is forcing us, whether we like it or not, to become German again.

If the Englishman transforms men into hats, the German transforms hats into ideas. The englishman is Ricardo, rich banker and distinguished economist; the German is Hegel, simple professor at the University of Berlin.

Louis XV, the last absolute monarch and representative of the decadence of French royalty, had attached to his person a physician who was himself France's first economist. This doctor, this economist, represented the imminent and certain triumph of the French bourgeoisie. Doctor Quesnay made a science out of political economy; he summarized it in his famous Tablueau economique . Besides the thousand and one commentaries on this table which have appeared, we possess one by the doctor himself. It is the "analysis of the economic table", followed by "seven important observations".

M. Proudhon is another Dr. Quesnay. He is the Quesnay of the metaphysics of political economy.

Now metaphysics -- indeed all philosophy -- can be summed up, according to Hegel, in method. We must, therefore, try to elucidate the method of M. Proudhon, which is at least as foggy as the Economic Table.

It is for this reason that we are making seven more or less important observations.

If Dr. Proudhon is not pleased with our observations, well, then, he will have to become an Abbe Baydeau and give the "explanation of the economico-metaphysical method" himself.

First Observation "We are not giving a history according to the order in time, but according to the sequence of ideas. Economic phases or categories are in their manifestation sometimes contemporary, sometimes inverted.... Economic theories have nonetheless their logical sequence and their serial relation in the understanding:

it is this order that we flatter our- selves to have discovered."(Proudhon, Vol.I, p.146)

M. Proudhon most certainly wanted to frighten the French by flinging quasi-Hegelian phrases at theM. So we have to deal with two men: firstly with M. Proudhon, and then with Hegel. How does M. Proudhon distinguish himself from other economists? And what part does Hegel play in M. Proudhon's political economy?

Economists express the relations of bourgeois production, the division of labor, credit, money, etc., as fixed, immutable, eternal categories.

M. Proudhon, who has these ready-made categories before him, wants to explain to us the act of formation, the genesis of these categories, principles, laws, ideas, thoughts.

Economists explain how production takes place in the above-mentioned relations themselves are produced, but what they do not explain is how these relations themselves are produced, that is, the historical movement which gave them birth. M. Proudhon, taking these relations for principles, categories, abstract thoughts, has merely to put into order these thoughts, which are to be found alphabetically arranged at the end of every treatise on political economy. The economists' material is the active, energetic life of man; M. Proudhon's material is the dogmas of the economists. But the moment we cease to pursue the historical movement of production relations, of which the categories are but the theoretical expression, the moment we want to see in these categories no more than ideas, spontaneous thoughts, independent of real relations, we are forced to attribute the origin of these thoughts to the movement of pure reason. How does pure, eternal, impersonal reason give rise to these thoughts? How does it proceed in order to produce them?

If we had M. Proudhon's intrepidity in the matter of Hegelianism we should say: it is distinguished in itself from itself. What does this mean? Impersonal reason, having outside itself neither a base on which it can pose itself, nor an object to which it can oppose itself, nor a subject with which it can compose itself, is forced to turn head over heels, in posing itself, opposing itself and composing itself -- position, opposition, composition. Or, to speak Greek -- we have thesis, antithesis, and synthesis.

For those who do not know the Hegelian formula: affirmation, negation and negation of the negation. That is what language means. It is certainly not Hebrew (with due apologies M. Proudhon); but it is the language of this pure reason, separate from the individual. Instead of the ordinary individual with his ordinary manner of speaking and thinking we have nothing but this ordinary manner in itself -- without the individual.

同类推荐
  • 周子全书

    周子全书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 钱氏私志

    钱氏私志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 分隶偶存

    分隶偶存

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘六情忏悔

    大乘六情忏悔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 靖难功臣录

    靖难功臣录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 锦晓甚微

    锦晓甚微

    15岁的张晓,涅槃重生。青春阳光,永远带着笑,对生活充满热爱对父母充满关心对仇人........呵呵.....绝不以德报怨总之,这辈子要肆意洒脱要弥补遗憾
  • 幸福其实很简单

    幸福其实很简单

    本书通过时下最流行的百度引擎搜索,整理出了人们感触颇深的50个幸福关键词,同时配备了二百多则精练动人的故事美文,内容涉及心态、心理、淡泊、宽容、尊重、爱、友谊、善良等诸多方面。行文旋律优美流畅,语言细腻清新,为各方的人们搭建一个心与心交流的平台。
  • 宝重《弟子规》

    宝重《弟子规》

    今天这个时代,依然可用狄更斯《双城记》刚刚开始的几句话来描述:“这是最好的时代,这是最坏的时代;这是最聪明的时代,这是最愚蠢的时代;这是信任的时代,这是欺骗的时代……”
  • 三秦记

    三秦记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明实录宪宗实录

    明实录宪宗实录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 一山文集

    一山文集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 噬君心之浮生惊梦

    噬君心之浮生惊梦

    前世债怨,今世情还。只一眼,便是万年。君子清,帝泽,有缘,来世再见…一场梦,一场空,人间浮华,也好过千万年的寂寞…这里容我说一句:这是我的第一本小说,种种原因,一直未能将它实现,在发布文字之前,没人能想到我经历了什么坎坷。账号丢失、重申新的账号、新的账号莫名被禁、这个账号又突然回归,中间的过程真是让人又恼又喜。不管怎样,回来就好,以后我会好好坚持的。浸淫网文这么多年,终于能写自己的小说了,本来我是没有写小说的念头的,但是在朋友的鼓励下,我终于做出了决定,从小就喜欢做梦,总不能因为长大了就不做了吧。我的文笔可能不是太好,不过我会认真锻炼的,本文前期比较苦比较涩,后期苦尽甘来,希望可以给你们带来良好体验吧
  • 浙江人的创新思路

    浙江人的创新思路

    1912年经济学家荀彼特在《经济发展理论》中,首次提出了创新的概念。创新行为在历史上长期是一种企业家的个人行为,后来人们越来越认识到创新是一个多主体、多机构参与的系统行为,因此,20世纪80年代,人们提出了创新系统的概念和理论。由于创新的系统性以及创新系统的复杂性,人们越来越注意从社会、政治和科技、文化的角度来理解企业、企业之外的其他机构在创新系统中的行为和作用。这是非常必要的,因为如果把企业之外的不同机构或者不同社会角色在创新系统中的作用孤立起来,特别是撇开与企业创新活动的联系,就往往容易把创新这个概念单纯理解为“创造新东西”。
  • 快穿之仙气玖玖

    快穿之仙气玖玖

    一个平平凡凡的高一学生林玖,因为在路上捡到了一个小巧精致的戒指从而获得了机遇,小酒系统可以带他穿越到每个小说里面体验生活,并且每次都可以把在小说里学到的东西保存从而变成现代自己的能力,从此他便开始了白天上课晚上穿越的生活。
  • 我的天堂

    我的天堂

    来自现实的苏州的文学报告,它密集而动情地传递报告了苏州改革开放以来的深刻变化,文学地表现了苏州人在现代生活中勇于革新创造的精神和聪明务实的性格力量,是现实苏州的很好文学读本。