And Webster thundered: "I pronounce my rebuke as solemnly and as decisively as I can upon this first instance in which an American minister has been sent abroad as the representative of his party and not as the representative of his country."To these and other challenges, Senator Marcy of New York made his well-remembered retort that "the politicians of the United States are not so fastidious....They see nothing wrong in the rule that to the victor belong the spoils of the enemy."Jackson, with all his bluster and the noise of his followers, made his proscriptions relatively fewer than those of Jefferson.
He removed only 252 of about 612 presidential appointees.* It should, however, be remembered that those who were not removed had assured Jackson's agents of their loyalty to the new Democracy.
* This does not include deputy postmasters, who numbered about 8000 and were not placed in the presidential list until 1836.
If Jackson did not inaugurate the spoils system, he at least gave it a mission.It was to save the country from the curse of officialdom.His successor , Van Buren, brought the system to a perfection that only the experienced politician could achieve.
Van Buren required of all appointees partizan service; and his own nomination, at Baltimore, was made a foregone conclusion by the host of federal job-holders who were delegates.Van Buren simply introduced at Washington the methods of the Albany Regency.
The Whigs blustered bravely against this proscription.But their own President, General Harrison, "Old Tippecanoe," was helpless against the saturnalia of office-seekers that engulfed him.
Harrison, when he came to power, removed about one-half of the officials in the service.And, although the partizan color of the President changed with Harrison's death, after a few weeks in office,--Tyler was merely a Whig of convenience--there was no change in the President's attitude towards the spoils system.
Presidential inaugurations became orgies of office-seekers, and the first weeks of every new term were given over to distributing the jobs, ordinary business having to wait.President Polk, who removed the usual quota, is complimented by Webster for making "rather good selections from his own friends." The practice, now firmly established, was continued by Taylor, Pierce, and Buchanan.
Lincoln found himself surrounded by circumstances that made caution necessary in every appointment.His party was new and composed of many diverse elements.He had to transform their jealousies into enthusiasm, for the approach of civil war demanded supreme loyalty and unity of action.To this greater cause of saving the Union he bent every effort and used every instrumentality at his command.No one before him had made so complete a change in the official personnel of the capital as the change which he was constrained to make.No one before him or since used the appointing power with such consummate skill or displayed such rare tact and knowledge of human nature in seeking the advice of those who deemed their advice valuable.The war greatly increased the number of appointments, and it also imposed obligations that made merit sometimes a secondary consideration.
With the statesman's vision, Lincoln recognized both the use and the abuse of the patronage system.He declined to gratify the office-seekers who thronged the capital at the beginning of his second term; and they returned home disappointed.The twenty years following the Civil War were years of agitation for reform.
