登陆注册
5214200000209

第209章

If the further question be asked, What was the efficient cause of their evil will? there is none.For what is it which makes the will bad, when it is the will itself which makes the action bad? And consequently the bad will is the cause of the bad action, but nothing is the efficient cause of the bad will.For if anything is the cause, this thing either has or has not a will.If it has, the will is either good or bad.If good, who is so left to himself as to say that a good will makes a will bad ? For in this case a good will would be the cause of sin; a most absurd supposition.On the other hand, if this hypothetical thing has a bad will, I wish to know what made it so; and that we may not go on forever, I ask at once, what made the first evil will bad? For that is not the first which was itself corrupted by an evil will, but that is the first which was made evil by no other will.For if it were preceded by that which made it evil, that will was first which made the other evil.But if it is replied, "Nothing made it evil; it always was evil," I ask if it has been existing in some nature.For if not, then it did not exist at all; and if it did exist in some nature, then it vitiated and corrupted it, and injured it, and consequently deprived it of good.And therefore the evil will could not exist in an evil nature, but in a nature at once good and mutable, which this vice could injure.For if it did no injury, it was no vice; and consequently the will in which it was, could not be called evil.But if it did injury, it did it by taking away or diminishing good.

And therefore there could not be from eternity, as was suggested, an evil will in that thing in which there had been previously a natural good, which the evil will was able to diminish by corrupting it.If, then, it was not from eternity, who, I ask, made it? The only thing that can be suggested in reply is, that something which itself had no will, made the will evil.I ask, then, whether this thing was superior, inferior, or equal to it? If superior, then it is better.How, then, has it no will, and not rather a good will? The same reasoning applies if it was equal; for so long as two things have equally a good will, the one cannot produce in the other an evil will.Then remains the supposition that that which corrupted the will of the angelic nature which first sinned, was itself an inferior thing without a will.But that thing, be it of the lowest and most earthly kind, is certainly itself good, since it is a nature and being, with a form and rank of its own in its own kind and order.

How, then, can a good thing be the efficient cause of an evil will? How, I say, can good be the cause of evil? For when the will abandons what is above itself, and turns to what is lower, it becomes evil--not because that is evil to which it turns, but because the turning itself is wicked.Therefore it is not an inferior thing which has made the will evil, but it is itself which has become so by wickedly and inordinately desiring an inferior thing.For if two men, alike in physical and moral constitution, see the same corporal beauty, and one of them is excited by the sight to desire an illicit enjoyment while the other steadfastly maintains a modest restraint of his will, what do we suppose brings it about, that there is an evil will in the one and not in the other?

What produces it in the man in whom it exists? Not the bodily beauty, for that was presented equally to the gaze of both, and vet did not produce in both an evil will.Did the flesh of the one cause the desire as he looked? But why did not the flesh of the other?

Or was it the disposition? But why not the disposition of both? For we are supposing that both were of a like temperament of body and soul.Must we, then, say that the one was tempted by a secret suggestion of the evil spirit? As if it was not by Iris own will that he consented to this suggestion and to any inducement whatever! This consent, then, this evil will which he presented to the evil suasive influence,--what was the cause of it, we ask? For, not to delay on such a difficulty as this, if both are tempted equally and one yields and consents to the temptation while the other remains unmoved by it, what other account can we give of the matter than this, that the one is willing, the other unwilling, to fall away from chastity? And what causes this but their own wills, in cases at least such as we are supposing, where the temperament is identical? The same beauty was equally obvious to the eyes of both; the same secret temptation pressed on both with equal violence.However minutely we examine the case, therefore, we can discern nothing which caused the will of the one to be evil.For if we say that the man himself made his will evil, what was the man himself before his will was evil but a good nature created by God, the unchangeable good? Here are two men who, before the temptation, were alike in body and soul, and of whom one yielded to the tempter who persuaded him, while the other could not be persuaded to desire that lovely body which was equally before the eyes of both.Shall we say of the successfully tempted man that he corrupted his own will, since he was certainly good before his will became bad? Then, why did he do so? Was it because his will was a nature, or because it was made of nothing? We shall find that the latter is the case.For if a nature is the cause of an evil will, what else can we say than that evil arises from good or that good is the cause of evil? And how can it come to pass that a nature, good though mutable, should produce any evil--that is to say, should make the will itself wicked?

CHAP.7.--THAT WE OUGHT NOT TO EXPECT TO FIND ANY EFFICIENT CAUSE OFTHE EVIL WILL.

同类推荐
  • 外科枢要

    外科枢要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 医经国小

    医经国小

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 永嘉禅宗集注

    永嘉禅宗集注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上修真体元妙道经

    太上修真体元妙道经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 林外野言

    林外野言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 赢在态度

    赢在态度

    世界五百强金牌员工的成长法则,阿里巴巴、百度等知名企业的优秀员工吐血推荐。卓越的态度塑造卓越的员工,一流的员工缔造一流的企业。态度决定一切。赶紧用优秀来武装自己,缔造个人卓越职业精神,你也能成为金牌员工。
  • 避戎夜话

    避戎夜话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 美人榜:尊王的爱人

    美人榜:尊王的爱人

    前世之仇,今世之争,天云涅槃重生,涅槃到更强大,毁灭得更汹涌!---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------推荐自己的文文:《帝邪》---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------◆◆——兽血沸腾——◆◆一场天地异变,君临天下间。万里长空一片紫金,风云呼啸,威压骇天!天地玄兽仰天齐鸣,灵兽四动,神兽俱惊。◇君王灵魂的继承者◇某猪很郁闷地签订和某女人签订了主仆契约,还得来了一个让它心中抓狂却装出一副无视模样的名字:小粉!蠢女人,你究竟知道不知道,本圣压根不是一只普通的猪?哦不对,本圣压根不是一只猪!妖娆的男人勾起一抹妩媚的笑意,嘴角轻挑出一抹邪恶:主人,您这么快,就忘记小粉了?◇◇◇天云◇◇◇一场让苍界举世震惊的大战——以一己之力共战百名初劫期渡劫期强者、几十名散仙、数十名虚魂期强者、三名大成期强者,并令几十名初劫期、渡劫期强者生死,三名散仙、五名虚魂期强者以及一名大成期强者形神俱灭!正在此时,九道惊天紫雷接连劈天而下!——一位绝世至尊强者渡劫失败,陨落于苍界!天云最后的意识是:靠,老子就这样被你给弄得玩完了!◇◇◇重生◇◇◇玄炫大陆上,天双皇朝五大世家之一幻家长孙,沉睡十年,在众人惊讶的目光中,迷茫醒来!皇城之内,暗潮涌动,重生的某位绝世至尊坐观上客,看各大世家一皇族斗得鸡鸣狗叫,看得不亦乐乎。当亲情涌入心头,幻族之姓被甘愿冠上,看客踏入局中,顿时风云变幻,扭转乾坤!震惊皇城!幻家长孙幻天云,从此——一飞冲天!◇苍界两大君王:紫之君王和勿之君王◇当昔日两大水火不容的异世君王同时恋上一人,是否又是一场惊天动地的战斗?◇◇◇玄炫大陆◇◇◇凤凰城,封印解除,再现于世,参与一场覆世之争!凤凰城,凤凰现,天下惊!前世之仇,今世之争,天云涅槃重生,涅槃到更强大,毁灭得更汹涌!◇久违的欧阳世家啊,看我将你连根拔起......◇
  • 跨越

    跨越

    三跨青年Lydia的一线奋斗笔记,38篇有世界观,有方法论的故事,为你打开上升通道。三跨青年Lydia的一线奋斗笔记,抛却艰深理论,用亲身经验为你打通任督二脉:揭开思维认知盲区,剖析成长潜在技巧,探知进阶背后逻辑,在拐点到来的时刻,推动人生加速上行。
  • 皇后与王冠

    皇后与王冠

    狄尔苏,一个可以说绝对愚笨的学法者。“哦,你看她,她就是狄尔苏。”那边来了一堆同是学法者的。“天呐,她又在念那些别人听不懂的咒语了。”“哦,好吧,亲爱的,也许她就是那样的一个人。”对于这样的话,不要奇怪,因为很平常。而狄尔苏呢?她会走自己的,一直在坚持。她相信她能成功。(通篇虚构,无可考究)
  • 许你情深天下

    许你情深天下

    许多年以后,他才终于读懂她的爱:许你情深天下。
  • 时代正在改变:民主、市场与想象的权力

    时代正在改变:民主、市场与想象的权力

    从蒋经国到奥巴马,从俄罗斯的严冬到阿拉伯的春天,在这个改变的时代,张铁志的写作为所有期待改变的人们带去希望。在本书中,来自台湾的多面手评论家张铁志,以一贯的睿智理性的批判笔调,挑战既成的政治、商业与文化权力,强调个人抗争和参与对时代改变的作用与意义。本书前半部分是有关台湾民主化历程及其当代问题的回顾与评论,尤其关注台湾公民社会成长的曲折与艰难,以参与者与研究者的视角厘清大陆对台湾转型的部分误读;后半部分将视野推向世界,既反思民主与市场的政治经济结构,也关注反叛文化与社会运动的结合,无处不在探问时代正怎样改变,以及我们如何可以改变这个时代。
  • 美国女画师的清宫回忆

    美国女画师的清宫回忆

    美国女画家凯瑟琳·卡尔在20世纪初曾创了两项世界性纪录:她是惟一在中国宫廷之内一连待了很长时间的外国人,又是惟一替尚健在的中国后妃画过肖像的人。她于1903年到达中国,花了九个月的时间为慈禧太后作画,并在圣路易斯博览会上展出。她返回美国后,把她的经历写成With the Empress Dowager出版,中文译为《慈禧写照记》。
  • 重生西游之最强天兵

    重生西游之最强天兵

    万人追读新书【从重生西游开始打卡】西游暴爽文,喜欢的去加个收藏!【爆火西游】一代凡人穿越西游世界,成为一介天兵。只是一个普通的天兵,却遇到各种无节操的神仙下绊子。不成功便成仁!为了避免成为炮灰,沦为三界尘埃,郭青要努力修炼,拜菩提为师,与降龙称兄道弟,破如来掌中佛国。三界六道,九霄寰宇,终成一代神主,手握百万天兵,凌天绝地,战天魔!封神之战还没结束,西游也不简单……
  • 文青是不是种病

    文青是不是种病

    二十六岁的李唯七看了十年网文,仍然忠爱小白和升级,对于文艺风深恶痛绝。然而在书评区讽刺文青病作者后的第二日,李维七车祸死亡,一个自称为“文青系统0号”的系统带他重生平行世界。从此,更名白安的李维七过上了幸(苦)运(逼)重(改)生(造)、冶(致)愈(郁)心灵的生活,并逐渐走(重)上(组)人(个)生(人)巅(三)峰(观)。